Verizon Wireless Acquisition of SpectrumCo (cable company) Spectrum
On December 19, 2011, Verizon Wireless and SpectrumCo filed an application for the consent of the Federal Communications Commission to the assignment of 122 Advanced Wireless Services (“AWS” -- the 1710-1755/2110-2155 MHz bands) licenses from SpectrumCo to Verizon Wireless. The 122 licenses cover 120 markets.
On December 19, 2011, Verizon Wireless and SpectrumCo filed an application for the consent of the Federal Communications Commission to the assignment of 122 Advanced Wireless Services (“AWS” -- the 1710-1755/2110-2155 MHz bands) licenses from SpectrumCo to Verizon Wireless. The 122 licenses cover 120 markets because in two markets, SpectrumCo holds two AWS licenses. In each market, SpectrumCo has 20 MHz of spectrum, except in Houston, where it has 30 MHz of spectrum.
SpectrumCo was created in 2006 as a joint venture among subsidiaries of Comcast, Time Warner Cable, Cox Communications, Bright House Networks, and Sprint Nextel. SpectrumCo was the successful bidder for 137 wireless spectrum licenses in the FCC’s AWS auction, which concluded in September 2006. In 2007, Sprint withdrew from SpectrumCo, and the SpectrumCo members purchased Sprint’s interests for an amount equal to Sprint’s capital contribution to the joint venture. In 2009, Cox also withdrew from SpectrumCo, taking with it the share of the AWS spectrum to which it was entitled under the SpectrumCo agreement. Today, SpectrumCo is owned by Comcast (63.6 percent), Time Warner Cable (31.2 percent), and Bright House (5.3 percent).
SpectrumCo has determined as a business matter, based on a variety of marketplace factors in combination, that constructing and operating a standalone facilities-based wireless network with that spectrum would not provide a return that would warrant incurring the substantial costs and risks involved.
- the financial resources required to build a wireless network are enormous – SpectrumCo estimated that “the capital expenditures and cumulative negative net operating costs would be approximately $10 - $11 billion.”
- SpectrumCo assessed the possibility of market entry with the 20 MHz of spectrum it had won at auction, SpectrumCo concluded that this might be sufficient to initially deploy an LTE wireless network. SpectrumCo concluded that, if it were successful in attracting a significant number of customers (including from its owners’ base of cable customers), it ultimately would have to incur further costs to acquire additional spectrum to serve those customers and their rapidly expanding demand for mobile services in a sustainable way
- SpectrumCo concluded that entering as a facilities-based provider would involve other costs and complexities. For example, to be competitive with other providers, SpectrumCo would need to purchase from manufacturers the devices most attractive to consumers at cost-effective prices, and would need to incur the cost of providing a sufficient subsidy for any such devices.
- In addition, SpectrumCo would need to secure nationwide roaming agreements.
The parties emphasize that the transaction involves transferring only spectrum and no other assets, facilities, or customers. The transaction will move spectrum that is not currently being used to serve consumers to a provider that will make efficient use of that spectrum to serve the public. The transaction will not reduce the number of choices for wireless services that consumers have in each of the licensed areas. The applicants, then, assume that there will be no anti-competitive effects of the transaction and, therefore, the Federal Communications Commission’s review should be limited.
Verizon Wireless also argues that the transaction will not exceed FCC spectrum screens:
- because the transaction would affect no change in market share, two of the three screens the FCC uses to identify markets where there may be potential competitive harm –which both pertain to changes to the post-transaction Herfindahl-Herschman Index (“HHI”) – simply do not apply
- the remain spectrum screen is not triggered in 105 of the 120 markets included in the transaction. The screen is 145 MHz in nearly all markets nationally, and Verizon Wireless would remain below this level in 2,230 of the 2,276 of the counties covered by the SpectrumCo licenses – or in 97.7 percent of the covered counties.
- In remaining markets, Verizon Wireless argues, screen overages are minor
For Verizon Wireless, the transaction will enable the company to add network capacity to meet growing demand.
Although not mentioned in the application, when the transaction was announced, the parties also said that they have entered into several agreements, providing for the sale of various products and services. Through these agreements, the cable companies, on the one hand, and Verizon Wireless, on the other, will become agents to sell one another's products and, over time, the cable companies will have the option of selling Verizon Wireless’ service on a wholesale basis. Additionally, the cable companies and Verizon Wireless have formed an innovation technology joint venture for the development of technology to better integrate wireline and wireless products and services. That would allow, for example, a consumer to walk into a Comcast store and get a Verizon Wireless plan tacked on to his television, Internet and landline phone service.
The transaction will transfer unused spectrum to meet Verizon Wireless' growing demand for mobile broadband
Transaction announced: December 2, 2011
Application filed: December 19, 2011
- FCC Stops Clock on Verizon-SpectrumCo and Verizon-Cox | Federal Communications Commission | public notice | 06/26/2012
- FCC favorably views Verizon, T-Mobile deal | Washington Post | reporting | 06/26/2012
- T-Mobile drops opposition to Verizon-cable deal | Hill, The | reporting | 06/26/2012
- Verizon, T-Mobile agree on wireless sale | Associated Press | reporting | 06/25/2012
- Verizon Wireless Expands Marketing Rollouts With Comcast, TWC | Multichannel News | reporting | 06/21/2012
- House Dems Want Verizon-SpectrumCo Hearing | Broadcasting&Cable | reporting | 06/21/2012
- House Democrats Urge Scrutiny of Verizon-Cable Deals | National Journal | reporting | 06/14/2012
- Chairman Kohl: Verizon-Cable Deals Raise 'Serious' Concerns | National Journal | reporting | 05/24/2012
- Antitrust chairman raises new questions about Verizon spectrum deal | Hill, The | reporting | 05/17/2012
- FCC Asks Verizon for More Info on Proposed Spectrum Sale | Federal Communications Commission | public notice | 05/15/2012
Federal Communications Commission (FCC)Approved with Modification
Department of JusticeApproved with Modification
Verizon Wireless (owned by Verizon Communications and Vodafone Group)
SpectrumCo (owned by Comcast, Time Warner Cable, and Bright House)
Supporters in the news
- Verizon CFO Denies Wireless Carrier Has 'Hoarded' Spectrum | Multichannel News | reporting | 04/19/2012
- Verizon: In the game of 4G, spectrum trumps technology | GigaOm | reporting | 03/06/2012
- Verizon urges FCC to approve deal with cable companies | Hill, The | reporting | 03/05/2012
- Spectrum - Crunching the Numbers | Verizon | press release | 02/26/2012
- 2 of 2
Detractors in the news
- Verizon's Cable Deal Would Widen Digital Divide, Lawmakers Say | Huffington Post, The | reporting | 07/11/2012
- Verizon's competitors look to restrict cable deal | Hill, The | reporting | 07/11/2012
- Free Press Asks FCC to Deny Verizon/T-Mobile Spectrum Swap | Broadcasting&Cable | reporting | 07/11/2012
- VZ/SpectrumCo Update: Actually Pretty Good, Except For That ‘Cartel’ Thing | Tales of the Sausage Factory | analysis | 07/11/2012
- Hoodwinked | Benton Foundation | op-ed | 07/09/2012
- Consumer Federation of America Brands SpectrumCo Deal End of 96 Act's Competitive Promise | Broadcasting&Cable | reporting | 07/09/2012
- House Democrats Urge Scrutiny of Verizon-Cable Deals | National Journal | reporting | 06/14/2012
- Consumer group blasts cable operators’ Wi-Fi roaming deal | Hill, The | reporting | 05/22/2012
- Mayors question Verizon-cable deal | Hill, The | reporting | 05/17/2012
- Verizon Deal Critics To Launch Coalition | National Journal | reporting | 05/13/2012
- Verizon CFO: Our 700 MHz spectrum sale is not a 'fire sale'
- Mobile Services and Cable TV Are Unexpected Allies
- Verizon's Shammo: We have enough spectrum for 4-5 years
- FCC Authority In VZ/SpectrumCo, or “Real Lawyers Read The Footnotes.”
- Why Verizon Was Allowed to Buy Wireless Spectrum and AT&T Wasn't
- Verizon-SpectrumCo: How Do Ya Like Me Now?
- FCC Concludes Review of Verizon Wireless-SpectrumCo Deal and Approves Related Spectrum Transactions
- FCC Establishes Docket for Monitoring the Recent Verizon Wireless Transaction
- DOJ Releases Confidential Information; Verizon/Cable Deal As Bad As We Thought
- Sources: Votes Are In, and Its 5-0 for Verizon/SpectrumCo
- Three FCC Votes In for Verizon/SpectrumCo
- The Sprint Is On for New Wireless Bids
- Full Speed Ahead for Verizon and Cable
- Could Verizon/SpectrumCo Create Gaping New Loophole In Media Ownership Rules?
- The Spectrum Gap Keeps Growing
- Verizon learned from AT&T’s mistakes to push spectrum deal with cable operators
- Keeping Verizon Wireless from being too cozy with cable
- Barack Obama, trustbuster?
- Verizon/Cable Settlement with DOJ: A Closer Look
- When Competition Is Cooked, Consumers Are Toast
- Critics Slam SpectrumCo Approval
- Sen Franken: DOJ should have been tougher on Verizon
- Justice Department Requires Changes to Verizon-Cable Company Transactions to Protect Consumers, Allows Procompetitive Spectrum Acquisitions to Go Forward
- FCC’s Genachowski: Commission Should Now Approve Verizon-SpectrumCo Deal
- Verizon-Cable Agreement Is Said To Win Antitrust Approval Today
- Verizon Deal Nears Regulatory Approval
- Verizon Wireless spectrum deal in for tough remedy
- FCC Consolidates Verizon Spectrum Deals Reviews
- Boston Mayor Pitches Attorneys General on Opposing Verizon/SpectrumCo
- Maryland senators concerned about Verizon-cable deal
- T-Mobile defends Verizon spectrum swap as way to enhance LTE network
- Why is Verizon in bed with Time Warner and Comcast?
- Comcast, TWC Extend Verizon Wireless Bundle Promos
- Competition Worries Snag Verizon Deal on Airwaves
- Sen Rockefeller To FCC, Justice On SpectrumCo: Keep Close Eye on Marketing Agreements
- So, How Are We Doing?
- The Great Spectrum Swap
- Rosenworcel and Pai Head Back to the FCC
- Keeping Low-Income Consumers in Mind While Reviewing the Verizon Spectrum Buy
- Harmless Collaboration or a Threat to Competition and Consumers?
- Critics Get Their Say on Verizon/Cable Spectrum Sale
- The Facebook and More