Daily Digest 10/10/2018

Benton Foundation
Table of Contents

Broadband

Chairman Pai Remarks at International Regulators Forum in Mexico City  |  Read below  |  FCC Chairman Ajit Pai  |  Speech  |  Federal Communications Commission
FCC Announces Availability of Interactive Connect America Fund Map  |  Federal Communications Commission
Broadband 'Disconnect' Has Big Consequences for Midwest Farmers  |  Read below  |  Whitelaw Reid  |  University of Virginia
VT Democratic Gov Candidate Hallquist's plan to bring fiber-optic cable to VT: How would it work?  |  Read below  |  April McCullum  |  Burlington Free Press
Groups providing high-speed internet, low-cost computers to bridge Cleveland's 'Digital Divide'  |  Read below  |  Homa Bash  |  News 5 Cleveland
South Carolina Public-Private Partnership Makes Economic Case for Broadband  |  Read below  |  Colin Demarest  |  Aiken Standard
Erie Charts Course for Citywide Internet  |  Read below  |  Jim Martin  |  Erie Times-News
Here Comes the Third Wave of Cord Cutting: Home Internet Service  |  Read below  |  Aaron Pressman  |  Fortune

Wireless

Why the race to 5G is a bet on a multi-trillion dollar economic impact  |  Read below  |  Molly Wood, Scott Tong  |  Marketplace
Senate Commerce Committee Chairman John Thune (R-SD) Announces Field Hearing to Examine 5G in Sioux Falls, South Dakota  |  Read below  |  Press Release  |  US Senate Commerce Committee
Commissioner Carr Set to Visit Dakotas and Minnesota to Discuss 5G and Rural Broadband  |  Federal Communications Commission
How to deploy 5G: Best practices for infrastructure, regulation and business models  |  Strand Consulting
Global Economic Value of Wi-Fi Reaches $1.96 Trillion in 2018  |  Wi-Fi Alliance

Ownership

Why the Consumer Welfare Standard Should Remain the Bedrock of Antitrust Policy  |  Read below  |  Joe Kennedy  |  Analysis  |  Information Technology and Innovation Foundation
Comcast Closes Deal for Fox’s Sky Stake, Owns Over 75% of European Pay-TV Giant  |  Variety

Privacy/Security

US, Europe threaten tech industry's cherished legal 'shield'  |  Read below  |  Ashley Gold, Joanna Plucinska  |  Politico
Privacy: It’s time for Congress to do right by consumers  |  Read below  |  Kathy Grillo  |  Press Release  |  Verizon
FTC-DOJ Signal Privacy Is a New Antitrust Risk for Google Facebook  |  Scott Cleland
New Evidence of Hacked Supermicro Hardware Found in US Telecom  |  Read below  |  Jordan Robertson, Michael Riley  |  Bloomberg
Bloomberg's fraying "secret chips" story  |  Axios
Weapon Systems Cybersecurity: Department of Defense Just Beginning to Grapple with Scale of Vulnerabilities  |  Government Accountability Office
From Inside The NSA, A Call For More Whistleblowers  |  National Public Radio

Media Literacy

Developing Media Literacy in Public Libraries: Learning from Community Media Centers  |  Read below  |  Colin Rhinesmith, Christiana Lynne Urbano Stanton  |  Research  |  Public Library Quarterly

Journalism

Trump media frenzy grows: Politics on steroids, 24/7  |  Read below  |  Sara Fischer  |  Axios
How do you know what’s ‘fake news’?  |  Read below  |  Press Release  |  Politico

Research

Comparing Survey Sampling Strategies: Random-Digit Dial vs. Voter Files  |  Pew Research Center

Government & Communications

Microsoft to Host the Government’s Classified Data  |  Read below  |  Frank Konkel  |  nextgov

Emergency Communications

FCC Activates Disaster Information Reporting for Hurricane Michael  |  Federal Communications Commission
AT&T FirstNet, Verizon Now Support First Responder Body Cameras  |  telecompetitor

Accessibility

21st-Century Communications and Video Accessibility Act Biennial Report for 2018  |  Federal Communications Commission

Broadcasting

Narrow Satellite Legislation Should Expire as Congress Intended  |  National Association of Broadcasters

Content

Soldiers in Facebook’s War on Fake News Are Feeling Overrun  |  New York Times
Dozens of new initiatives have launched to address fake news and the erosion of faith in the media; here's a partial list  |  Axios
Hindered thought and negative emotions linked to unintended social exclusion on Facebook and other social media sites  |  University of Buffalo
Music Piracy Remains a Problem in the Spotify Era  |  Wall Street Journal
Celebrity advocates use social media to influence which California bills become law  |  Los Angeles Times

Company News

Facebook will soon rely on Instagram for the majority of its ad revenue growth  |  Vox
Disney’s Big Bet on Streaming Relies on Little-Known Tech Company BamTech  |  New York Times
Forbes becomes first major media company to experiment with publishing stories to blockchain  |  Axios
Digital’s hard truths: Want to better understand what digital is doing to your business? Look to the underlying economics.  |  McKinsey

Stories From Abroad

Google Appeals $5 Billion European Union Fine in Android Case  |  Wall Street Journal
How the world views the US and its president in 9 charts  |  Pew Research Center

Policymakers

Deputy Attorney General Rosenstein faces congressional confrontation amid new claim he seriously suggested wiretapping President  |  Washington Post
Statement of FTC Chairman Joe Simons on the Death of former FTC Chairman Robert Pitofsky  |  Federal Trade Commission

Agenda

 
Democrats eye ambitious agenda if House flips  |  Hill, The
Today's Top Stories

Broadband

Chairman Pai Remarks at International Regulators Forum in Mexico City

FCC Chairman Ajit Pai  |  Speech  |  Federal Communications Commission

Closing the digital divide is the Federal Communications Commission’s top priority. The best way to make sure every American has better, faster, cheaper Internet access is to set a market-based regulatory framework that promotes competition and increases network investment. We also want to promote competition and innovation that could transform the marketplace.  The FCC has made facilitating the rollout of 5G a major priority. One economic analysis of our [5G] reforms projects that they will cut about $2 billion in costs, unleashing $2.4 billion in extra investment. But here’s the key point: 97% of that new deployment will be in rural and suburban communities. That’s because when we reduce the cost of deployment, it has the biggest impact in those areas where the investment case is the most marginal. Here’s the bottom line. Whether you’re from the United States, Mexico, Mongolia, Jamaica, Costa Rica, or Nicaragua, bridging the digital divide is an imperative in the 21st century. 

Broadband 'Disconnect' Has Big Consequences for Midwest Farmers

Whitelaw Reid  |  University of Virginia

The vast majority of farmers in the Midwest aren’t able to utilize “precision agriculture” GPS technology because they don’t get high-speed internet, according to Christopher Ali, assistant media studies professor at the University of Virginia. He said companies don’t want to put in fiber optic cable – considered the gold standard – because of its great expense. “There’s not enough customers on a farm, because there’s technically one customer on the farm – the farmer,” he said. “That doesn’t merit any of these companies coming out. The per-mile cost of laying the wires is the problem.” Ali said the US offers $6 billion in subsidies to telecommunications companies for the purpose of installing rural broadband, but the funds aren’t making their way out to the farms. To try to get to the bottom of the public policy issue that he believes has far-reaching consequences, Ali and his dog, Tuna, loaded up “Lima Bean” – Ali’s bright green Kia Soul – and drove to small farm towns in Kentucky, Iowa, Minnesota, Missouri and Indiana. “Co-ops are the unsung heroes of rural broadband,” Ali said. “They don’t need the return on investment that the giant companies need because they don’t have shareholders to satisfy. They have community members to service. And I think because they don’t need a 20 percent profit margin, they’re able to take a few more risks. Wouldn’t it be great if public policy could help these co-ops leverage or mitigate some of the risk?”

VT Democratic Gov Candidate Hallquist's plan to bring fiber-optic cable to VT: How would it work?

April McCullum  |  Burlington Free Press

If Christine Hallquist is elected governor of Vermont, her plan is to pass legislation that would require electric utilities to hang fiber-optic cable in their service areas. The power companies could make money by leasing the fiber to internet service providers. Utilities would not be allowed to compete with traditional telecommunication companies by selling internet service directly to customers. "When I talk about doing fiber, I'm not saying that the electric companies are going to provide the services, because that would be unfair," Hallquist said. There would be no state funding to go along with the mandate. Hallquist believes that neither utilities nor telecom companies would put up a fight if the legislation is done correctly.  "I think the electric utility providers are going to want to do it anyway," said Hallquist, who was the CEO of Vermont Electric Cooperative until she resigned in 2018 to run for governor. "So we'll make it a requirement, but you’re not going to get resistance from the electric utilities."

Groups providing high-speed internet, low-cost computers to bridge Cleveland's 'Digital Divide'

Homa Bash  |  News 5 Cleveland

The Cleveland Foundation just announced $488,000 in grants that encourage digital inclusion — a multi-faceted initiative to get everyone connected, “until we get to a point that the internet access is treated more like a utility, no different than electricity. Until it’s in every home,” said Leon Wilson, chief of digital innovation at the Cleveland Foundation. The first part of the initiative is a partnership with the Cleveland Public Library and Cuyahoga County Library systems. All 28 Cleveland Library branches and four Cuyahoga County Library branches will have 4G unlimited data hotspots available for free checkout for 21-day periods. The second part of the initiative is the arrival of PCs for People, a nonprofit based out of Minnesota with a second location in Denver (CO).

South Carolina Public-Private Partnership Makes Economic Case for Broadband

Colin Demarest  |  Aiken Standard

Access to serviceable Internet is of serious importance in Aiken County (SC) and surrounding areas, said Economic Development Partnership President and CEO Will Williams.  "Many of our areas don't have broadband capabilities because of where they are," Williams said. "And so we're trying to come up with alternative solutions so as many homes as possible will have access to broadband." The EDP — a nonprofit, public-private business development group — works throughout Aiken, Edgefield, Saluda and McCormick counties. Nearly 12,000 Aiken County residents lack access to even the most basic Internet service.

Erie Charts Course for Citywide Internet

Jim Martin  |  Erie Times-News

Erie's (PA) status as a smart city is poised to take on new meaning thanks to the National League of Cities, the Erie Innovation District and Velocity Network. The Innovation District, which now provides free Wi-Fi in Perry Square, is expected to develop a plan during 2019 to roll out free wireless internet that could eventually blanket the city of Erie, said Karl Sanchack, the organization's CEO. Sanchack said the impetus for that initiative came from a call from the National League of Cities, which represents 19,000 cities and towns across the United States. In partnership with the philanthropic organization Schmidt Futures, the league announced in June that it was creating a new program, City Innovation Ecosystems, which is dedicated to helping cities thrive in the modern economy.

Here Comes the Third Wave of Cord Cutting: Home Internet Service

Aaron Pressman  |  Fortune

The trend of people cutting their home Internet connections in favor of wireless online connectivity is accelerating, according to the latest survey from Pew Research. No doubt fed by falling prices for wireless service and the spread of unlimited data plans, Internet cord cutting has now reached one in five Americans, almost double the level of two years ago. The percentage of people who say they depend solely on their smartphones to connect to the Internet has risen steadily from 8% in 2013, to 12% in 2016, to 20% in 2018. The trend marks the third wave of cord cutting over the past few decades, following the cutting of landline phones and then cable TV. The latest wave of cutting home Internet could thwart the cable industry’s response to cord cutting of cable TV subscriptions. Analysts expected that most customers who fled cable TV would still buy home Internet service from cable companies. Higher prices for broadband could offset the loss of TV subscription revenue. That assumption may have to be revisited.

Wireless

Why the race to 5G is a bet on a multi-trillion dollar economic impact

Molly Wood, Scott Tong  |  Marketplace

The next generation of wireless technology, 5G, could be a huge deal. The speed — and the number of devices that can be connected — could spawn new businesses we haven't even thought of yet. It could mean $12 trillion in economic output across the world by 2035. And add some 22 million jobs. A  whiff  of that potential is why there's a race to get to 5G first between companies and countries. 

Senate Commerce Committee Chairman John Thune (R-SD) Announces Field Hearing to Examine 5G in Sioux Falls, South Dakota

Press Release  |  US Senate Commerce Committee

Senate Commerce Committee Chairman John Thune (R-SD) will convene a hearing titled “The Race to 5G: A View from the Field,” on Oct 12, 2018 at Carnegie Town Hall in Sioux Falls (SD). This hearing will focus on identifying existing barriers to broadband deployment of next generation wireless technology deployment and ways to streamline broadband infrastructure siting and encourage investment in next generation communications services. Witnesses (subject to change):

  • Brendan Carr, Commissioner, Federal Communications Commission
  • Paul TenHaken, Mayor, City of Sioux Falls
  • Dr. José-Marie Griffiths, President, Dakota State University
  • Robert Fisher, Senior Vice President, Federal Government Affairs, Verizon
  • Justin Forde, Senior Director, Government Relations, Midcontinent Communications
  • Mark Shlanta, Chief Executive Officer, SDN Communications

Ownership

Why the Consumer Welfare Standard Should Remain the Bedrock of Antitrust Policy

Joe Kennedy  |  Analysis  |  Information Technology and Innovation Foundation

The application of antitrust policy, through which the government seeks to shape the general rules of competition, has always been contentious. But for roughly 40 years there has been a consensus that its ultimate goal should be the welfare of consumers, broadly defined to mean maximizing overall economic growth. Yet a small, but growing group of activists and scholars now argues we should abandon the consumer welfare standard and add in a host of new factors for antitrust policy to address, while also attacking “bigness” per se. A careful review, however, shows the consumer welfare standard is able to handle some of its critics’ legitimate concerns.

Privacy/Security

US, Europe threaten tech industry's cherished legal 'shield'

Ashley Gold, Joanna Plucinska  |  Politico

In the US and European Union, a series of two-decade-old legal provisions dating to the web’s early days allow internet companies to host content posted by users without being legally responsible for it. Thanks to that immunity, US companies have built massive profit engines around material such as Facebook posts, Instagram photos and YouTube videos, without having to screen them ahead of time. But now lawmakers and regulators in the US and European Union are starting to chip away at those protections, driven by growing concern about hoaxes, hate speech and other online bad behavior.

In April, President Donald Trump signed a law holding online companies liable for "knowingly" hosting content that enables sex trafficking. Both Democratic and Republican Reps are talking about carving out a similar exception for illegal opioid sales. In Brussels, meanwhile, the European Commission recently introduced a bill that would require sites like Facebook to take down terrorist content — Islamic State videos, for example — within an hour of being flagged by authorities, or face still-unspecified penalties. The move follows updates to EU copyright and audiovisual media laws that require platforms like YouTube and Amazon to more actively monitor for violations, including online copyright infringements and inappropriate ad placements.

Privacy: It’s time for Congress to do right by consumers

Kathy Grillo  |  Press Release  |  Verizon

What should a new consumer privacy framework look like? Legislation must be simple to understand, targeted to consumers’ needs and today's digital reality, and national in scope so all Americans are equally protected. Verizon believes a consumer privacy bill should be bipartisan and focus on the following key principles:

  1. Consistency. All entities, regardless of industry sector, that collect information about consumers should be subject to the same requirements. One set of rules, primarily enforced by a single Federal regulator – the Federal Trade Commission – will ensure consistent protections for consumers.
  2. Flexibility. Statutory requirements governing ever-evolving technology need to be flexible so that they don’t become quickly outdated. The overall framework should be informed by the principle that the level of sensitivity of the personal information will dictate the corresponding protections. The FTC could have a role in providing guidance on statutory requirements, such as defining “personal information” and “sensitive personal information.”
  3. Transparency. Companies must provide clear and easy to understand information about their practices with respect to the collection, use, and sharing of personal information. As part of transparency, companies should have a mechanism that provides consumers with reasonable access to what information the company has about that consumer.
  4. Choice. Companies must provide consumers with the opportunity to opt in to the collection, use, and sharing of sensitive personal information and to opt out of the collection, use, and sharing of other personal information. Exceptions should be in place for the collection, use, and sharing of personal information for operational and other purposes (e.g., legal process).
  5. Data Security and Breach Notification. Companies must put in place reasonable security measures to protect information and should notify consumers in appropriate circumstances when breaches occur.
  6. Safe Harbor Programs. There should be a Safe Harbor program that companies can follow and know that they are meeting the requirements of the law.
  7. Enforcement. The enforcement regime for privacy should be two-fold: (a) FTC enforcement with civil penalties (subject to a cap); and (b) State attorneys general enforcement of Federal law.

New Evidence of Hacked Supermicro Hardware Found in US Telecom

Jordan Robertson, Michael Riley  |  Bloomberg

A major US telecommunications company discovered manipulated hardware from Super Micro Computer Inc. in its network and removed it in Aug, fresh evidence of tampering in China of critical technology components bound for the US, according to Yossi Appleboum, a security expert working for the telecom company. The security expert provided documents, analysis and other evidence of the discovery following the publication of an investigative report that detailed how China’s intelligence services had ordered subcontractors to plant malicious chips in Supermicro server motherboards over a two-year period ending in 2015. Appleboum previously worked in the technology unit of the Israeli Army Intelligence Corps and is now co-chief executive officer of Sepio Systems in Gaithersburg (MD). His firm specializes in hardware security and was hired to scan several large data centers belonging to the telecommunications company. Bloomberg is not identifying the company due to Appleboum’s nondisclosure agreement with the client. Unusual communications from a Supermicro server and a subsequent physical inspection revealed an implant built into the server’s Ethernet connector, a component that's used to attach network cables to the computer, Appleboum said.

Media Literacy

Developing Media Literacy in Public Libraries: Learning from Community Media Centers

Colin Rhinesmith, Christiana Lynne Urbano Stanton  |  Research  |  Public Library Quarterly

The rise of digital media labs and spaces for content creation in public libraries has been documented in the scholarly literature. However, fewer studies have investigated the outcomes of media literacy initiatives in community media centers (CMCs) and how they might inform similar programs and services in public libraries. This article reports findings from a study that used qualitative research to investigate the current goals and activities of CMCs across the United States. The findings show that the educational, social, and community benefits of these programs could be useful for public libraries to consider in developing or augmenting their own media literacy initiatives.

Journalism

Trump media frenzy grows: Politics on steroids, 24/7

Sara Fischer  |  Axios

You think the insane flow of politics in your newsfeed, on your TV and lighting up your iPhone will slow when the Trump Show ends? Think again: Media companies are doubling down on even more politics, to generate even higher ratings and more clicks, as audiences seem to crave all politics, all the time. This is your life on politics. National newspapers and magazines are already staffing up for 2020 with some of their biggest field teams yet. 

How do you know what’s ‘fake news’?

Press Release  |  Politico

The term “fake news” has become a cudgel for political leaders trying to discredit reporting, but disinformation – false content created explicitly to deceive or misinform – runs rampant online. Politico is trying to identify and trace the origins of political disinformation and debunk it.

Government & Communications

Microsoft to Host the Government’s Classified Data

Frank Konkel  |  nextgov

Microsoft is making moves to target a growing multibillion market: hosting, storing and running the US government’s most sensitive classified secrets and data. The company announced it will join rival Amazon as the only commercial cloud providers with the security capabilities to host secret classified data by the end of the first quarter of 2019. Microsoft’s announcement comes days before the Pentagon will accept bids on its $10 billion Joint Enterprise Defense Infrastructure contract, which it will award to a single cloud service provider. The announcement doubles as a public declaration of Microsoft’s intent to bid on the contract one day after Google pulled out of the competition in part because the company couldn't meet the Pentagon’s security requirements stipulated for JEDI quickly enough. 

Submit a Story

Benton (www.benton.org) provides the only free, reliable, and non-partisan daily digest that curates and distributes news related to universal broadband, while connecting communications, democracy, and public interest issues. Posted Monday through Friday, this service provides updates on important industry developments, policy issues, and other related news events. While the summaries are factually accurate, their sometimes informal tone may not always represent the tone of the original articles. Headlines are compiled by Kevin Taglang (headlines AT benton DOT org) and Robbie McBeath (rmcbeath AT benton DOT org) — we welcome your comments.


© Benton Foundation 2018. Redistribution of this email publication — both internally and externally — is encouraged if it includes this message. For subscribe/unsubscribe info email: headlines AT benton DOT org


Kevin Taglang

Kevin Taglang
Executive Editor, Communications-related Headlines
Benton Foundation
727 Chicago Avenue
Evanston, IL 60202
847-328-3049
headlines AT benton DOT org

Share this edition:

Benton Foundation Benton Foundation Benton Foundation

Benton Foundation

The Benton Foundation All Rights Reserved © 2018