Last updated: February 21, 2008 - 2:41am
NEW REPORT DISMANTLES INDUSTRY CLAIMS ABOUT NET NEUTRALITY
[SOURCE: Free Press]
The likely harm to consumers and the Internet economy if Congress abandons "Network Neutrality" will be substantial, according to a new economic analysis released today by Consumers Union, Consumer Federation of America and Free Press. The report rebuts the claims of Net Neutrality opponents such as Vanderbilt University Law Professor Christopher S. Yoo and the Phoenix Center for Advanced Legal & Economic Public Policy Studies, finding that the benefits claimed for abandoning the principle of standardized, open communications network are small or non-existent. "Since network neutrality has succeeded so dramatically in producing the vibrant Internet economy and sustaining competitive communications services," said Trevor Roycroft, the economist who authored the report, "critics must show very tangible benefits from changing that policy. These analyses do not even come close to meeting that burden." The report argues that Yoo and the Phoenix Center have reached erroneous conclusions based on biased theoretical perspectives and faulty assumptions that do not fit the economic reality of Internet-related markets. The three groups submitted the report to the Senate Committee on Commerce, Science and Transportation in advance of its latest hearing on major telecommunications legislation. â€œThe proponents of network discrimination get the policy problem exactly backward,â€ said Mark Cooper, director of research for the Consumer Federation of America. â€œThey say we should not risk imposing Network Neutrality for fear of stifling competition and innovation. Yet it is Network Neutrality that has given us vibrant competition and innovation. The question Congress should be asking is why abandon network neutrality and risk destroying the Internet?"
- What Network Neutrality Is REALLY About
- Search neutrality? How Google became a "neutrality" target
- Seven Days to Preserve the Internet
- Consumers Want Congress to Protect Right to Access Information, Services on Internet
- Network Neutrality, Product Differentiation, and Social Welfare
- 'Net Neutrality' Strikes A Chord
- Activist Group Officials Discuss 2006 Telecom Landscape
- Wireless Carriers Resist Open-Internet Stance
- Diller Argues for Strong Network Neutrality Law
- Justice Dept Wary of "Net Neutrality" Proposals
- Do you lose free speech rights if you speak using a computer?
- CDT Paper Calls For Narrowly Tailored Internet Neutrality Legislation
- Dueling Network Buzzwords: 'Neutrality' Versus 'Diversity'
- Electronics group restates case for Net Neutrality
- Net neutrality rules don't go far enough, but going farther wasn't politically possible