Information Technology: Continued Improvements in Investment Oversight and Management Can Yield Billions in Savings
Originally published: April 12, 2011
Last updated: April 12, 2011 - 9:20pm
The Office of Management and Budget (OMB) has improved the oversight and management of information technology (IT) investments through multiple initiatives.
By establishing the IT Dashboard, OMB has drawn additional attention to over 300 troubled IT investments at federal agencies, totaling $20 billion, which is an improvement from the previously used oversight mechanisms. The Federal Chief Information Officer (CIO) recognized that the Dashboard has increased the accountability of agency CIOs and established much-needed visibility into investment performance.
However, GAO has found that the data on the Dashboard are not always accurate. Specifically, in reviews of selected investments from 10 agencies, GAO found that the Dashboard ratings were not always consistent with agency cost and schedule performance data. In these reports GAO made a number of recommendations to OMB and federal agencies to improve the accuracy of Dashboard ratings. Agencies agreed with these recommendations, while OMB agreed with all but one. Specifically, OMB disagreed with the recommendation to change how it reflects current investment performance in its ratings because Dashboard data are updated on a monthly basis.
However, GAO maintained that current investment performance may not always be as apparent as it should be; while data are updated monthly, ratings include historical data, which can mask more recent performance. In addition to the Dashboard, beginning in January 2010 the Federal CIO began leading reviews -- known as "TechStat" sessions -- of selected IT investments involving OMB and agency leadership to increase accountability and transparency and improve performance. OMB officials stated that, as of December 2010, 58 sessions had been held and resulted in improvements to or termination of IT investments with performance problems. For example, the June 2010 TechStat session for a National Archives and Records Administration investment resulted in the halting of development funding pending the completion of a strategic plan.
In addition, OMB identified 26 additional high-priority IT projects and plans to develop corrective action plans with agencies at future TechStat sessions. According to the Federal CIO, OMB's efforts to improve management and oversight of IT investments have already resulted in $3 billion in savings. Additionally, in December 2010, OMB issued an 18-month plan for reforming federal IT management that has five major goals, including strengthening program management, streamlining governance and improving accountability, and using shared solutions, among others. These goals and the plans in place to support them are consistent with GAO's work highlighting IT management and governance weaknesses, as well as work to identify duplicative activities in the government. As part of this plan, OMB has initiatives under way to strengthen agencies' investment review boards and to consolidate federal data centers. GAO has ongoing work to review the Dashboard and other OMB initiatives. Continued OMB oversight and the implementation of its 18-month plan along with outstanding GAO recommendations, could result in further significant savings and increased efficiency.
- IT Dashboard: Accuracy Has Improved, and Additional Efforts Are Under Way to Better Inform Decision Making
- Immediate Review of Information Technology Projects
- Open Sourcing the IT Dashboard & the TechStat Process
- Federal IT dashboard not winning manager hearts
- OMB: It takes money to save money in IT operations
- Sunshine, Savings, and Service
- Expect IT Consolidation, Cost Cutting During Obama’s Second Term
- Report: IT dashboard plagued by outdated data
- GAO: Management and Oversight of Information Technology Projects Need Attention
- Federal Chief Information Officers: Opportunities Exist to Improve Role in Information Technology Management
- Information Technology Reform: Progress Made but Future Cloud Computing Efforts Should be Better Planned
- Commission on Government Technology Opportunity in the 21st Century Releases Action Plan for Improving Federal IT
- Saving Billions in IT Spending
- Federal CIO: Budget request includes funds for IT oversight
- The Updated IT Dashboard