Originally published: June 21, 2011
Last updated: June 21, 2011 - 6:03pm
A federal judge ruled that publishing an entire article without the rights holder’s authorization was a fair use of the work, in yet another blow to newspaper copyright troll Righthaven.
It’s not often that republishing an entire work without permission is deemed fair use. Fair use is an infringement defense when the defendant reproduced a copyrighted work for purposes such as criticism, commentary, teaching and research. The defense is analyzed on a case-by-case basis. The ruling dismissed a lawsuit brought by Righthaven, a Las Vegas-based copyright litigation factory jointly owned with newspaper publisher Stephens Media. The venture’s litigation tactics and ethics are being questioned by several judges and attorneys, a factor that also weighed in on U.S. District Judge Philip Pro’s decision. Righthaven has sued more than 200 websites, bloggers and commenters for copyright infringement. More than 100 have settled out of court. The lawsuit decided Monday targeted Wayne Hoehn, a Vietnam veteran who posted all 19 paragraphs of November editorial from the Las Vegas Review-Journal, which is owned by Stephens Media. Hoehn posted the article, and its headline, “Public Employee Pensions: We Can't Afford Them” on medjacksports.com to prompt discussion about the financial affairs of the nation’s states. Hoehn was a user of the site, not an employee.
- Court: Posting Entire News Article Was Fair Use
- Have Media Companies Destroyed Their Copyrights With The ‘Share’ Button?
- Las Vegas's copyright crapshoot could maim social media
- Enforcing Copyrights Online, for a Profit
- Copyright on Imported Works
- Google-itis: Beware of Class Action Settlements
- Online piracy: As a mere host, YouTube is protected from liability
- Google and the Copyright Wars
- Pulling Prince from YouTube
- Newspapers go all-in for copyright fight against clipping service
- New Zealand judge: FBI must release more evidence to Kim Dotcom
- The limits of copyright law
- Judge suggests DMCA allows DVD ripping if you own the DVD
- Copyrights That No One Knows About Don't Help Anyone
- Judge Sotomayor Has IP Background