July 2010

Subcommittee on Health
House Commerce Committee
Tuesday, July 27, 2010
1:00 pm

Witnesses:

Panel 1:

  • David Blumenthal, M.D., National Coordinator, Health Information Technology, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services
  • Anthony Trenkle, Director, Office of E-Health Standards and Services, Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services

Panel 2:

  • Frank J. Vozos, M.D., FACS , Executive Director, Monmouth Medical Center, New Jersey Hospital Association
  • Gregory D. Starnes, CEO, Fayette County Hospital
  • Christine Bechtel, Vice President, National Partnership for Women & Families
  • Roland A. Goertz, M.D., M. B.A., President-Elect, American Academy of Family Physicians, Heart of Texas Community Health Center
  • Dr. Matthew Winkleman, M.D., Physician, Primary Care Group,
  • Glen E. Tullman, CEO, Allscripts
  • Peggy C. Evans, Ph.D., CPHIT, Director, Washington and Idaho Regional Extension Center, Qualis Health


ESPN's Internal Watchdog Slams Network's LeBron James Special

ESPN's internal journalism watchdog sharply criticized the cable-sports network for what he said were ethical missteps in its recent broadcast of a TV program devoted to basketball star LeBron James.

In a column on ESPN's website, the ombudsman harshly criticized ESPN for over-hyping its coverage of James, for failing to explicitly disclose to viewers the ties between James and ESPN, and for what he said was an effective payment for a news story - which is typically considered improper for journalists. "ESPN made some major mistakes handling the entire affair," said Don Ohlmeyer, the journalism watchdog, or ombudsman. "ESPN should never have traded [advertising] inventory for access or allowed a subject to select his inquisitor."

FTC, OECD Announce New Policymaking Guide To Help Consumer and Regulatory Authorities Around the World

The Federal Trade Commission hosted a roundtable presentation of the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development's just-published Consumer Policy Toolkit at FTC headquarters.

This publication will help government policy makers around the world who strive to protect and empower consumers in an increasingly complex global marketplace. The Consumer Policy Toolkit provides advice for consumer protection authorities and other regulators to help them determine where markets may be failing consumers, and what steps they can take in response. This guide outlines a comprehensive six-step process for choosing the best consumer protection policies, and describes a range of policy options that government officials can use to address consumer problems. Included in the publication are examples drawn from the experiences of more than 20 countries. Today's consumers face unique opportunities - and challenges -from a broader range of increasingly complex products, more global trade, and the development of the Internet. "The Toolkit will help consumer protection authorities make well-informed policies to protect consumers from unfair practices in the modern marketplace," said FTC Chairman Jon Leibowitz. "It will also be a valuable resource for those setting policy for finance, telecommunications, food, drug, and product safety matters."

The Rest Of The World Rules Broadband While America Drools

[Commentary] While there's nothing new about lamenting over America's falling in the standings relative to broadband in the rest of the world, Daily continues to be amazed at how that gap seems to be widening, not just in the capacity and cost of bandwidth customers have access to, but in how quickly other countries are moving forward with real plans to achieve real progress relative to the US.

Here in the US we barely have our first broadband plan. We're still caught up in debates over whether or not we're setting the standard for broadband too high, whether or not government should play any role in the deployment of broadband, and whether or not the agency charged with overseeing our country's communications infrastructure even has the authority to regulate broadband.

After comparing that to the rest of the world, Daily concludes: If we feel any pride as a nation, if we have any sense about what our economic future can and should look like, then we need to make sure these stories about where the rest of the world's heading aren't swept underneath the carpet. The time to act is now. The rest of the world realizes this and is moving forward full steam ahead. The question is when will America wake up and start getting serious about our international competitiveness as a whole rather than focusing almost all of our attention on how do we get every American connected to yesterday's networks.

Report Advocates Tax Relief in Telecommunications Sector

According to a report released by the Global System for Mobile communications Association (GSMA), the key to spurring broadband adoption in previously under-covered areas is targeted tax relief. According to the group's summary of the study, "The study indicates how a reduction in special taxes applied to the telecommunications sectors in countries with different taxation approaches like Brazil, Mexico, Bangladesh and South Africa will translate into higher Mobile Broadband service adoption and more wealth creation reflected in additional GDP growth." The study's methodology analyzed the relationship between mobile broadband adoption and tax rates in the four countries outlined above. Despite disparities in other areas, the study notes that every dollar reduced in taxes across Brazil, Mexico, Bangladesh and South Africa will generate additional GDP ranging between US$1.4 to US$12.6 through enhanced broadband uptake.

Smithsonian, FCC and USDA Announce Online Learning Registry

On July 21, more than 150 rural education stakeholders and technology experts from 26 states came together to learn from one another and provide feedback to federal officials. The National Rural Education Technology Summit included the Department of Education, the Department of Agriculture and the Federal Communications Commission.

"Knowledge knows no boundaries and we cannot allow distance to stand between students, education and opportunity," said Secretary of Education Arne Duncan. "We have the hardware, the latest software, and huge investments are being made in the build-out of the national broadband plan to connect us as never before." Secretary Duncan announced the creation of the Online Learning Registry which will provide access to the thousands of documents, photos and other data housed at the Smithsonian. This online registry was one of the many recommendations made by the National Broadband Plan.

"No technological innovation in our lifetime has greater potential to transform education than high-speed Internet," said FCC Chairman Genachowski. "But computers and connections alone are not enough to seize the opportunities of broadband for education. The National Broadband Plan recommended that the federal government increase the pool of high-quality digital resources that educators can easily find, access, and combine with other content to help their students learn. I am very pleased to see this recommendation being adopted. The Learning Registry will put a library of world-class educational content at the fingertips of every American student and teacher."

Senators Raise Caution Flag On Media Ownership Review

Sens Byron Dorgan (D-ND), Olympia Snowe (R-Maine) and Maria Cantwell (D-WA) wrote Federal Communications Commission Chairman Julius Genachowski this week advising him that he did not have to follow in the footsteps of his predecessors when it comes to vetting the FCC's media ownership rules and that they were still concerned about consolidation.

The letter came as the FCC was preparing to defend at least the authority and process by which Martin came to that decision in a brief to the Third Circuit Court of Appeals, which is currently hearing appeals of that 2007 decision by deregulation defenders and opponents alike. The FCC is concurrently reconsidering its ownership rules as part of a quadrennial review mandated by Congress. In the letter, they said they wanted to remind him of "the Senate's interest in public interest limits for media ownership and that the current commission is under no obligation to follow the footsteps of its predecessors." They also point out in the letter that the last two attempts to "weaken" the media ownership rules (in 2003 under Chairman Michael Powell and 2007 under Martin, were met with "considerable congressional opposition," including resolutions of disapproval passed by the Senate in both instances.

Why Does Fox News Have More Power Than Any Progressive in the Country?

[Commentary] As we can all see now, when Fox says jump, the Obama administration asks how high? (Then jumps one inch less and considers it a progressive victory). Is there anyone Obama won't fire or throw under the bus if Fox asks him to? What if they ask Obama to fire himself? Would he do it? Or would he just fire Biden and say he met them halfway? I understand the Obama team is playing the old Washington games and think they're very clever at it. But those games don't work anymore. Bad news cycles are not created by genuine mistakes anymore, they're artificially created by Fox News channel. You can't make them go away by giving into them. You're just feeding the beast. And more importantly, you're starving your own side. It isn't about fighting Fox News to make yourself feel better. It's about ignoring their silly attacks so you can actually bring us the progressive change you promised. Otherwise, we would be retarded to come and vote for you again.

Comcast, GE Boost Spending as U.S. Considers NBC Deal

Comcast, the largest US cable provider, boosted spending on political donations and lobbying as it sought approval to take over the operations of General Electric's NBC Universal. Comcast spent $6.9 million to lobby the federal government during the first half of the year, up from $6.1 million during the same period in 2009, new congressional filings show. GE also increased its lobbying expenditures, to $15.4 million during the first six months of 2010 compared with $11.7 million during the same period a year earlier. Comcast increased its political action committee donations to $2.1 million between Jan. 1, 2009, and June 30, 2010, up from $1.6 million during the same period two years earlier. GE's PAC made $1.7 million in contributions in 2009-10, the same as in the corresponding period in 2007-08.

Why Do We Care About FCC Authority Over Broadband?

"Progressive Era philosophy" means going back to a basic idea over why we care about services like broadband. When we have a service offered to the public, when members of the public depend on accessing this service reliably, and when a failure to have reliable access can have dire consequences, these services are "affected with the public interest."

For these services, we need some basic safeguards to ensure fundamental fairness and, to the extent possible, prevent disasters before they occur - whether that disaster is limited to a subscriber or small business cut off from a vital service or a failure to serve rural areas or a massive failure on order of a BP or Katrina-type disaster. We once took pride in having an electric grid and a telephone network that were the envy of the world because they reached everyone, worked reliably, and treated everyone fairly. We should want the same for our broadband networks in the 21st Century. Those who ignore the quiet role of government in ensuring basic principles of fundamental fairness and standards or reliability in making these previous networks the envy of the world leave us at the mercy of the market. But the market cannot protect either fundamental fairness or impose basic standards of reliability. Without these two principles, our broadband network will not flourish, and we will all pay the price.