April 2012

Verizon/SpectrumCo: The Spectrum Concentration Gap v. The Spectrum Crunch

[Commentary] Verizon has clearly studied everything AT&T did wrong last year when it tried to acquire T-Mobile. That includes staying alert for early signs of trouble and taking preemptive moves to keep the course of approval running smoothly. It also includes showing grace under fire rather than trying to browbeat the Federal Communications Commission into submission.

To head off concerns about the growing “spectrum gap” between Verizon (and AT&T) and its competitors, Verizon has offered to sell its Lower 700 MHz A&B block licenses in a private auction if the FCC grants the application to transfer the AWS-1 spectrum to it from SpectrumCo. At the same time, Verizon also insists that it is doing this of its own free will and not because the FCC is making it do so or because it has run into any trouble. As I will explain, I believe Verizon is telling the truth. The 700 MHz A&B block licenses Verizon promises to auction to competitors is not nearly as useful to it as the AWS-1 spectrum it will get from SpectrumCo and Cox. Given that everyone has extolled the virtues of the 700 MHz spectrum as the most important, game changing super-duper useful for mobile broadband spectrum in the entire universe, and since the licenses in question do cover some major markets, that no doubt comes as a surprise to many. Indeed, rather like the stereotypical used car salesman offering to swap your beat up lemon for his hardly ever driven luxury cream puff, this offer looks too good to be true.

Why would Verizon want to swap Magic Elixir 700 MHz spectrum for Totally Awesome But Not Magic AWS-1 spectrum?

Health records lost, stolen or revealed online

Almost a decade after a new law went into effect to strengthen health privacy protections, the number of breaches of patient records and databases across the US suggests that personal health information is not as private or secure as many consumers might want or expect. Since fall 2009, more than 400 large health care breaches affecting at least 500 people and more than 50,000 smaller breaches have been reported to the federal government.

Universities as Hubs for Next-Generation Networks

Based on a request for information (RFI) submitted to The University Community Next Generation Innovation Project (Gig.U), the paper describes a model for universities to develop next generation broadband infrastructure in their communities. In our view universities can play a critical role in spurring next generation networks into their communities through use of their physical infrastructure to extend high-speed Internet access and sharing their expertise and resources to support engagement and participation by community members, businesses, and institutions.

We propose a network model that integrates both high-capacity fiber deployments to community anchor institutions along with community-driven wireless mesh deployments, a device-as-infrastructure network architecture that operates using commonly available Wi-Fi equipment, to create connectivity for local neighborhoods. The model enables universities and communities to 1) provide affordable, scalable broadband access to end-users; 2) empower and engage community members through a collaborative deployment process; and 3) create a sustainable ecosystem of connectivity to further drive community development. In addition to expanding next-generation high-speed Internet access, the model allows for the creation of a community-wide intranet to develop local applications and serve as a platform for community data collection and research to better understand challenges relating to mobility, health, safety, urban management, and education. The paper also provides recommendations for universities to engage and identify local stakeholders and needs, build and finance network infrastructure, and for engaging community members in the build-out of wireless mesh networks.

Who's teleworking? Government doesn't really know.

In 2010, the Office of Personnel Management set an aggressive goal of increasing the level of telework among federal employees by 50 percent, but officials don’t know how well they’re doing with it because of shortcomings in the way data about telework is collected, according to a recent report. OPM plans to test an automated system to gather telework data from agencies this year to get more complete and consistent data, rather than relying on agency estimates as in the past. But these changes also will make it difficult to compare the data with that from previous years, as required by the Telework Enhancement Act, according to the Government Accountability Office. “OPM officials have noted that this could limit OPM’s ability to report agency progress in its first report to Congress,” GAO said. It likely will be several years before there can be meaningful measurements of progress in moving federal workers out of the office.

Measuring the Broadband Bonus in Thirty OECD Countries

This paper provides estimates of the economic value created by broadband Internet using measures of new gross domestic product and consumer surplus. The study finds that the economic value created in 30 OECD countries correlates roughly with the overall size of their broadband economies. In addition, price and quality data from the United States suggest that widespread adoption of broadband Internet has occurred without a dramatic decline in prices, which reflects an unobserved increase in broadband quality that conventional government statistics do not capture.

Why Internet/GDP Ratios Make No Sense

[Commentary] The Economist reprinted a chart from a BCG report, which purported to show the contribution of “the internet” to the total GDP of various different countries. Britain comes out on top, with an internet-to-GDP ratio of 8.3%; it’s followed by Korea, China, Japan, USA, India, and Australia. After the UK, the highest-ranking European country is Germany, on just 3.3%, while Canada lags far behind the US.

All of this was rather puzzling to me, so I spoke to BCG’s Paul Zwillenberg, one of the authors of the report. And the main thing I wanted to know, of course, was how on earth you could turn “the internet” into an annual dollar amount divisible by national GDP. “It’s like electricity. It’s part and parcel of the fabric of daily life,” Zwillenberg said, almost before I could ask my question. “It’s touching every part of the economy.” I’m inclined to agree — but you’d never dream of measuring different countries’ electricity-to-GDP ratios. So what’s he doing here? Zwillenberg did say that in ten years or so, “you won’t need to measure the internet economy because it will be totally pervasive.” But for the time being, he’s determined to measure the internet. And the way he’s doing it is very web 1.0. It seems to me that BCG’s not really measuring the internet here — it’s not measuring the hours spent watching YouTube, or interacting with friends on Facebook and Tumblr, or spreading news on Twitter, or even checking your stock portfolio or updating your billing information somewhere. It’s measuring e-commerce, primarily, which is an interesting subset of the internet, and one of the oldest, but ultimately just a fraction of what it can be. And when you’re measuring e-commerce, you’re measuring lots of things which aren’t really internet-related at all.

Mobile Ad Firms Seek New Ways to Track You

Few smart-phone users realize it, but mobile ad companies track them as they use many free apps. They do this in order to fine-tune the ads the users see. But now that Apple has started to restrict a common way of tracking users, ad companies are scrambling for alternatives, and hoping to "teach" consumers to appreciate the targeted ads that support free apps. Alarge consortium of mobile ad firms launched a new technical approach to tracking users of free apps. The consortium says the new method protects users' privacy, and will allow people to opt out if they prefer not to have their behavior logged. That opt-out mechanism would be modeled on those offered by online-ad companies for people who do not want their browsing history used to tailor ads.

Broadband Investment Continues to Hold Steady in 2011

The broadband industry invested nearly $66 billion in the nation’s information infrastructure in 2011, with wireline providing the largest portion of capital, according to USTelecom.

Data from this 2011 research updates a data series published last year which documents the amount of capital broadband providers have invested since 1996. Through 2011, broadband providers have invested approximately $1.2 trillion. In 2011 wireline broadband providers invested nearly $27 billion, according to the study. From 1996 through 2011, wireline broadband providers invested approximately $640 billion in broadband infrastructure. Also, wireline contributed the largest portion of industry capital in 2011: 41 percent, compared to 40 percent for wireless and 19 percent for cable. High-speed fixed access and fiber core networks are essential to carry the large volume of data traffic, which has grown from the equivalent of 8.3 million DVDs per month in 2000 to more than 1.4 billion DVDs per month in 2010, and is expected to triple again over the next five years.

Subcommittee on Oversight, Investigations, and Management
House Committee on Homeland Security
April 24, 2012
2:00pm
http://homeland.house.gov/hearing/subcommittee-hearing-america-under-cyb...

Witnesses
Mr. Shawn Henry
Former Executive Assistant Director
Criminal, Cyber, Response, and Services Branch
Federal Bureau of Investigation

Mr. James Lewis
Director and Senior Fellow
Technology and Public Policy Program
Center for Strategic and International Studies

Mr. Gregory C. Wilshusen
Director
Information Security Issues
Government Accountability Office

Mr. Stuart McClure
Chief Technology Officer
McAfee

Dr. Stephen E. FLynn
Founding Co-Director
George J. Kostas Research Institute for Homeland Security
Northeastern University



National Urban League Policy Institute and Time Warner Cable Research Program on Digital Communications
Wednesday, May 2, 2012
3:00 to 4:30 p.m. (EDT)

The report concludes that after unprecedented effort to bridge the digital divide, the broadband access gap between African Americans and white Americans has started to narrow. Now is the time to leverage what has been achieved and what is yet to be achieved to trigger entrepreneurship, initiative and participation by African Americans in broadband jobs and businesses.

The panel will explore how private enterprise, community organizations and governments can work together to do this in underserved communities. Panelists will include those actively engaged in this from Time Warner Cable, Inc., the Federal Communications Commission and the Central Florida Urban League, whose Center for Workforce Innovation was featured as a success story in the report.

Who:

  • Marc H. Morial, President & CEO, National Urban League
  • The Honorable Julius Genachowski, Chairman, Federal Communications Commission
  • The Honorable Mignon Clyburn, Commissioner, Federal Communications Commission
  • The Honorable Robert McDowell, Commissioner, Federal Communications Commission
  • The Honorable Michael Powell, President/CEO, National Cable and Telecommunications Association/ Former Chairman, Federal Communications Commission
  • Chanelle P. Hardy, Senior Vice-President/Executive Director, National Urban League Policy Institute
  • Josh Gottheimer, Senior Counselor to the Chairman, Federal Communications Commission
  • Fernando Laguarda, Vice President, External Affairs/Policy Counselor, Time Warner Cable, Inc.
  • Allie Braswell, CEO, Central Florida Urban League