July 2008

Broadcasting Board of Governors Nomination and Withdrawal

In January 2007, President Bush nominated Mark McKinnon to be a member of the Broadcasting Board of Governors for a term expiring August 13, 2009, a position he had already obtained in a recess appointment. On July 10, McKinnon's nomination was withdrawn and the President instead nominated Clifford D. May for the BBG slot. May is the President of the Foundation for Defense of Democracies, a policy institute focusing on terrorism created two days following the 9/11 attacks on the United States. A veteran news reporter, foreign correspondent and editor (at The New York Times and other publications), he has covered stories in more than two dozen countries, including Iran, Pakistan, Sudan, Ethiopia, China, Uzbekistan, Northern Ireland and Russia. He is a frequent guest on national and international television and radio news programs, providing analysis and participating in debates on national security issues. He writes a weekly column that is nationally distributed by Scripps Howard News Service and he is a regular contributor for National Review Online, The American Spectator and other publications. From 1997 to 2001, he served as the Director of Communications for the Republican National Committee. holds masters degrees from both Columbia University's School of Public and International Affairs and its School of Journalism. He earned his BA from Sarah Lawrence College in Bronxville, N.Y. In addition, he holds a certificate in Russian language and literature from Leningrad University.
(Sources linked below)

Network Neutrality Debate Goes Online (of course)

On July 8, Comcast's Joe Waz wrote that Free Press wants to "punish Comcast for engaging in network management that Free Press believes violates the Federal Communications Commission’s Internet Policy Statement." But, he argued, FCC Commissioners have said the Internet Policy Statement is not enforceable, and the law is very clear on that basic point. The Policy Statement is not a set of rules. It doesn't have any binding effect. And the FCC has never adopted rules in this area. On July 9, Free Press' Marvin Ammori responded saying, "We want to ensure that all Americans, not just big corporations and their lobbying gangs, have a seat at the table in policy debates. We also want to protect the free and open Internet that we have always enjoyed. And finally, we want to make sure that lawmakers punish any company that tries to illegally insert itself as gatekeeper between consumers and online content. Unfortunately for the cable giant, what Free Press and the public want is the exact opposite of what Comcast wants. Comcast wants to monopolize your Internet connection, block online competitors, and control what consumers do online. Comcast wants to turn the Internet into cable TV, where every Web site has to cut a special deal with them to get carried or else get blocked. And Comcast wants to be above the law while doing this." Ammori identifies what he calls Comcast's "two main lies": 1) Congress never gave the FCC authority to enforce Net Neutrality. Free Press argues Congress gave the FCC more than enough authority to enforce Net Neutrality and to punish Comcast for its violation. 2) The FCC can't punish Comcast because the agency didn't issue a “rule” about Net Neutrality -- only a “policy statement.” Free Press says the Supreme Court and Congress have made it clear that a federal agency like the FCC can act either through rules or a complaint processes. Nate Anderson asks "Who knew that arcane telecom policy battles at the FCC could 1) be this important and 2) simultaneously be this entertaining?"
(Sources linked below)

Who Killed the Online Journalism Review and Will It Live Again?

For more than 10 years, the Online Journalism Review was published by the Annenberg School for Communications at the University of Southern California as a place to follow the struggles and triumphs in the nascent field of online journalism. But on June 16, editor Robert Niles posted a note to the site titled, Goodbye, explaining that USC was suspending publication of OJR and that he would be leaving the school. Why? The short answer is that the Annenberg School is going through a major transition, with a new dean, Ernest Wilson, and a new director of the journalism school (which lives within the overall school of communications), Geneva Overholser. They are reconsidering many programs, and want to rethink the way that OJR operates at the school. But there’s a larger story behind the rise and fall (and possible rebirth) of OJR, relating to academia and its own struggles putting online journalism into curriculum in a meaningful way.
http://www.pbs.org/mediashift/2008/07/digging_deeperwho_killed_the_o.html

Connecticut Judge Stands Pat On AT&T U-verse Service

AT&T has failed to convince a federal judge in Connecticut to vacate a legal precedent declaring that its U-verse service is a cable service. The telecommunications company petitioned the U.S. District Court for the District of Connecticut to declare as moot that court's July 26, 2007 ruling striking down a finding by the Connecticut Department of Public Utility Control from 2006. The most recent AT&T motion asked the judge to amend her final judgment, arguing that the whole dispute became moot in October of last year when the Connecticut legislature approved its state franchising bill. The new legislation created video franchise regulation. That regulation did not rely on a legally defining U-verse in order for AT&T to qualify to deliver video in the state. But the court, in a ruling issued July 10, decided that while the state franchising law resolved the issue of franchising, there are “live issues” that will remain until the Federal Communications Commission or a court decides that elements of the Cable Act do or don't apply to AT&T's video service. Therefore, Judge Arterton refused to amend her previous rulings.
http://www.multichannel.com/article/CA6577558.html?nid=4262

Best Buy Adds Common Sense Media DVD Reviews

Best Buy decided to add Common Sense Media reviews of TV shows and movies to the DVD section of BestBuy.com beginning this week. Best Buy already features Common Sense reviews of video games on the site. The DVD reviews will include information on violence, sex and profanity. Common Sense, the nonprofit group that advocates for parental oversight of children's media consumption, has also been pushing for a government- and industry-funded, broad-based media-education initiative.

It’s All Over Now, Violet Blue

What happens when a bog suddenly decides to remove all reference to someone and all the posts said person ever made on a site?
http://www.cjr.org/behind_the_news/its_all_over_now_violet_blue.php

When Is An Ad Starring A Candidate Not About The Candidate?

A new series of ads by the Oregon Democrats raises an interesting question: Is the state party trying to evade campaign finance rules by running so-called "issue ads" -- which ostensibly aren't supposed to be about the candidates -- that just so happen to star their nominee for Senate?
http://tpmelectioncentral.talkingpointsmemo.com/2008/07/when_is_an_ad_st...

TWC Sells 80,000 Subscribers

Time Warner Cable said late Thursday that it has reached an agreement to sell systems in several non-strategic markets with about 80,000 subscribers to Windjammer Communications for an undisclosed sum. Windjammer was created specifically for the deal and consists of Boston private equity concern MAST Capital Management and Jupiter, Fla.-based small cable operator Communications Construction Services.
http://www.multichannel.com/article/CA6577553.html?nid=4262

Tuesday July 22, 2008

House Subcommittee on Telecommunications and the Internet Hearing
2:00 p.m. in room 2123 Rayburn House Office Building

This hearing will serve as a legislative hearing on H.R. 3914, the
“Protecting Consumers through Proper Forbearance Procedures Act." HR 3914 amends the Communications Act of 1934 to require the Federal Communications Commission to grant or deny, within one year, a petition by one or more telecommunications carriers or classes of carriers requesting that the FCC forbear from applying any regulation or provision under the Act. (Current law deems such a petition granted if not denied within one year.)

The bill is sponsored by House Commerce Committee Chairman John Dingell (D-MI) and has 11 co-sponsors including Subcommittee Chairman Ed Markey (D-MA) and Vice Chairman Mike Doyle (D-PA).



Today's Quote 07.10.08

This bill will "will ensure that those companies whose assistance is necessary to protect the country will, themselves, be protected from lawsuits for past or future cooperation."
-- President George Bush