August 31, 2010 (Net Neutrality Deal? White Spaces Order?)
BENTON'S COMMUNICATIONS-RELATED HEADLINES for TUESDAY, AUGUST 31, 2010
INTERNET/BROADBAND
Companies reach "general agreement" on network neutrality
FCC Adjusts Final Rules On Use of Vacant TV Band
2010 International Broadband Data Report
Input Sought on Improving the International Broadband Data Report
$4 Billion Cut in Verizon, AT&T Fiber+ DSL Spending
NCTA Asks FCC to Reconsider Broadband Data Report
Without fast broadband, towns and schools find selves withering
TECHNOLOGY
Obama poised to loosen rules on export of technology
Advances Offer Path to Shrink Computer Chips Again
TELEVISION
Fox v. FCC: FCC Concentrates And Asks Again
Samsung Joins Field Seeking to Bring 'Apps' to TVs
GOVERNMENT & COMMUNICATIONS
Report says Congress needs lots of help with Web sites
STORIES FROM ABROAD
These headlines presented in partnership with:
BlackBerry Gets a 2-Month Reprieve in India
RIM's Agreement With India Is Likely to Foreshadow Wider Government Access
Waiting on a missed connection
Tensions between media and ANC on display in South Africa
New cables tie West Africa closer to Internet
Free Cuba Telecommunications Market Urged on Obama by AT&T, Nokia, Verizon
German Court Turns Down Injunction Against YouTube
Canada regulator enforces Internet "speed-matching"
Yahoo Japan, Google expanding video offerings
MORE ONLINE
Elections, Katrina and Economy Split the News Agenda
The New Now: How Real Time Redefines the Now
INTERNET/BROADBAND
NETWORK NEUTRALITY DEAL?
[SOURCE: The Hill, AUTHOR: Sara Jerome, Gautham Nagesh]
Apparently, companies negotiating a network neutrality compromise at the Information Technology Industry Council (ITI) have reached a general agreement. The agreement reportedly includes concessions on some of the most divisive topics in the debate, including the questions of wireless Internet, Federal Communications Commission authority, and managed services. The ITI talks include Verizon, AT&T, Skype, Microsoft, NCTA, and others. New concessions from wireless companies could mean the agreement is stricter than the Google-Verizon proposal issued this month, which exempts wireless traffic from the toughest rules. Still, it's unlikely that the companies would submit to a full non-discrimination rule for wireless services, which they see as the future of their businesses and say are technically too different from wireline services to be subject to the same rule. Various scenarios are possible for regulating wireless without applying the full weight of a non-discrimination rule and without entirely exempting them, either; the companies, for instance, could be prohibited from blocking websites but not applications, among other possible variations.
benton.org/node/41212 | Hill, The
Recommend this Headline
back to top
WHITE SPACES DECISION SOON?
[SOURCE: Wall Street Journal, AUTHOR: Amy Schatz]
Technology and telecommunications companies could soon get access to unused TV airwaves, allowing them to introduce new wireless gadgets and services, under rules that Federal Communications Commission officials are close to putting into final form.
Some of FCC Chairman Julius Genachowski's top aides have met with broadcasters and other interested parties in recent weeks to discuss the remaining obstacles to freeing up the vacant spectrum between television channels, known in the industry as "white spaces." The issue could come to a vote as soon as the agency's September meeting. Chairman Genachowski said earlier this year that he wanted the matter resolved by the end of September.
benton.org/node/41211 | Wall Street Journal
Recommend this Headline
back to top
2010 INTERNATIONAL BROADBAND DATA REPORT
[SOURCE: Federal Communications Commission, AUTHOR: ]
On August 27, the Federal Communications Commission released its first International Broadband Data Report as required by the Broadband Data Improvement Act (BDIA). The report presents data and information on international broadband service capability. The BDIA requires the FCC to, among other things, include in its annual
broadband deployment report "information comparing the extent of broadband service capability (including data transmission speeds and price for broadband service capability) in a total of 75 communities in at least 25 countries abroad for each of the data rate benchmarks for broadband service utilized by the FCC to reflect different speed tiers." For this comparison, the BDIA directs the FCC to choose international communities comparable to U.S. communities with respect to population size, population density, topography, and demographic profile. The FCC is also directed to include "a geographically diverse selection of countries" and "communities including the capital cities of such countries." The FCC must also identify a number of specific similarities and differences in each community, including "their market structures, the number of competitors, the number of facilities-based providers, the types of technologies deployed by such providers, the applications and services those technologies enable, the regulatory model under which broadband service capability is provided, the types of applications and services used, business and residential use of such services, and other media available to consumers."
benton.org/node/41183 | Federal Communications Commission | Attachment A | Attachment B
Recommend this Headline
back to top
INPUT SOUGHT ON INTERNATIONAL BROADBAND REPORT
[SOURCE: Federal Communications Commission, AUTHOR: ]
The Federal Communications Commission's International Bureau recently released the first International Broadband Data Report (2010 IBDR). The 2010 IBDR presented basic data in three main categories for communities in 37 countries: 1) publicly-available pricing information on broadband Internet access services available from Internet service providers (ISPs); 2) population, education, and other demographic information; and 3) descriptive information on regulatory structures, market conditions, and other media. Now the FCC seeks public comment regarding the preparation of next year's IBDR, and how best to build on the foundation of the 2010 IBDR. What improvements can be made to the data and analysis used in the 2010 IBDR to make next year's IBDR more useful, particularly for policymakers, including for the Commission's overall assessment regarding the reasonable and timely deployment of broadband services to all Americans? Are there additional data and analysis that could better illuminate similarities and differences between broadband technologies, markets, and policies in U.S. and comparable foreign communities? Should the FCC provide side-by-side comparisons of the price and performance of popular broadband offerings in U.S. and foreign communities? The FCC invites interested parties to submit comments to assist this effort to improve upon the 2010 IBDR, including with respect to analytic techniques or approaches to estimate the effects of competition on the availability, capability, and adoption of broadband in foreign communities. The public notice seeks specific comment on improving several data collections pertaining to the IBDR. Comments Due: 09/27/2010. Reply Comments Due: 10/12/2010. Contact: Arthur Lechtman at (202) 418-1465, email: Arthur.Lechtman@fcc.gov (Dkt No 10-171)
benton.org/node/41184 | Federal Communications Commission
Recommend this Headline
back to top
TELECOS CUTTING BROADBAND SPENDING
[SOURCE: Fast Net News, AUTHOR: Dave Burstein]
Verizon's wireline capital spending in the first six months of 2010 was $3.35 billion, down nearly $1 billion from last year. For the full year that is nearly a $2 billion drop, which corresponds to their plan to cut the FiOS build in 2010 by 2/3rds. Since they've also cut the post 2010 FiOS build by 2-4 million homes, this is probably a permanent drop. Spread over 4 years, the total cut in Verizon wireline/FiOS spending would be about $7 billion, about the same as the total government money spent on the broadband stimulus. The numbers at AT&T are similar but not broken out. AT&T cut U-Verse by 1/3rd last year, one reason they went 92K negative on broadband this quarter. These multi-billion dollar cuts came after the U.S. enacted a stimulus program and now is talking about huge subsidies supposedly for broadband. Verizon CEO Ivan Seidenberg is a smart guy who told investors that he thinks the government will pay up if he doesn't invest. The stimulus, as Tom Hazlett predicted, resulted in fewer new broadband connections as company after company reduced spending hoping the government will pay instead. Verizon is claiming 20-30% of their lines require a subsidy and asking for billions or they might discontinue voice service. Ironically, Verizon and AT&T just reassured Wall Street their wireline margins are staying up.
benton.org/node/41182 | Fast Net News
Recommend this Headline
back to top
NCTA ASKS FCC TO RECONSIDER BROADBAND REPORT
[SOURCE: National Cable and Telecommunications Association, AUTHOR: Neal Goldberg, Steven Morris, Jennifer McKee]
The National Cable and Telecommunications Association is urging the Federal Communications Commission reconsider its Sixth 706 Report issued on July 20, 2010. NCTA requests that the FCC reconsider both the appropriateness of the dataset relied on in the Sixth 706 Report and its conclusion that deployment of broadband networks is not proceeding in a "reasonable and timely" manner. NCTA argues that the FCC erred in failing to consider current information and reasonably anticipated developments in reaching its conclusion that the "reasonable and timely" standard was not being met. NCTA notes that the FCC relied on Form 477 data reflecting deployment as of June 2009 and December 2009 and claims that if the FCC had considered the more recent data in its possession, some of the largest counties identified as unserved would not have been on the list.
benton.org/node/41180 | National Cable and Telecommunications Association
Recommend this Headline
back to top
WITHOUT BROADBAND, TOWNS WITHERING
[SOURCE: San Antonio Express-News, AUTHOR: Roy Bragg]
It's the 21st century, and the Information Age has revolutionized business, culture and life -- unless you're any of the 415 people in the East Texas town of Chireno who find themselves off the grid. About 45 percent of Texas has no access to high-speed Internet service, but most of that land is sparsely populated. Chireno, however, is an incorporated city within a half-hour's drive of three larger ones, and it's still on the outside of the Web looking in. Make no mistake: This is a one stop-light town. It's also a five-business town, with a gas station, a grocery/cafe, air conditioning repair service, an acoustical ceiling tile factory and a chain bank. And, according to residents and government officials, this is as good as it's going to get unless broadband Internet service in made available here.
benton.org/node/41179 | San Antonio Express-News
Recommend this Headline
back to top
TECHNOLOGY
NEW TECH EXPORT RULES
[SOURCE: Washington Post, AUTHOR: Howard Schneider]
The Obama administration is overhauling the decades-old rules for the export of sensitive military and other technology, jettisoning what industry groups criticize as an antiquated Cold War set of regulations for a more streamlined approach. After a year-long review by officials at the State, Defense and Commerce departments, President Obama is scheduled to announce plans Tuesday to consolidate some enforcement activities in a single agency and develop a clearer list of products whose sale is restricted. U.S. export controls cover tens of thousands of products and services and are overseen by three agencies. It is a system U.S. businesses say often leaves them hamstrung, even when it comes to selling less-sensitive items that are readily available in other industrialized countries.
benton.org/node/41209 | Washington Post
Recommend this Headline
back to top
SMALLER COMPUTER CHIPS
[SOURCE: New York Times, AUTHOR: John Markoff]
Scientists at Rice University and Hewlett-Packard are reporting this week that they can overcome a fundamental barrier to the continued rapid miniaturization of computer memory that has been the basis for the consumer electronics revolution. In recent years the limits of physics and finance faced by chip makers had loomed so large that experts feared a slowdown in the pace of miniaturization that would act like a brake on the ability to pack ever more power into ever smaller devices like laptops, smartphones and digital cameras. But the new announcements, along with competing technologies being pursued by companies like IBM and Intel, offer hope that the brake will not be applied any time soon. In one of the two new developments, Rice researchers are reporting in Nano Letters, a journal of the American Chemical Society, that they have succeeded in building reliable small digital switches -- an essential part of computer memory -- that could shrink to a significantly smaller scale than is possible using conventional methods. More important, the advance is based on silicon oxide, one of the basic building blocks of today's chip industry, thus easing a move toward commercialization. The scientists said that PrivaTran, a Texas startup company, has made experimental chips using the technique that can store and retrieve information. Separately, H.P. is to announce on Tuesday that it will enter into a commercial partnership with a major semiconductor company to produce a related technology that also has the potential of pushing computer data storage to astronomical densities in the next decade. H.P. and the Rice scientists are making what are called memristors, or memory resistors, switches that retain information without a source of power.
benton.org/node/41208 | New York Times
Recommend this Headline
back to top
TELEVISION
FCC APPEALS INDECENCY RULING
[SOURCE: CommLawBlog, AUTHOR: Dan Kirkpatrick]
In July, the US Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit overturned the Federal Communications Commission's indecency enforcement regime as unconstitutional. After considering its options, the FCC has chosen to go back to the three judges who rejected the policy, trying to convince them that they got it wrong and ask the entire en banc Second Circuit to reverse the three-judge panel's decision. According to the FCC's petition for rehearing, the Second Circuit panel's Fox decision went too far in overturning the entire indecency enforcement regime. The Commission asserts that the panel's conclusion that the FCC's overall indecency policy is unconstitutionally vague is inconsistent with earlier decisions by the Supreme Court, the D.C. Circuit, and even the Second Circuit itself. The Commission argues that the Fox decision rejects the "contextual approach" to indecency analysis the FCC has used in the past and that, by so doing, leaves the Commission with no way to enforce the federal laws prohibiting indecent broadcasts. The Second Circuit now must decide whether or not to grant rehearing, either by the original panel or en banc. While that may sound simple, it's not. In particular, the en banc rehearing process in the federal courts ranks up there with papal elections when it comes to procedural quirks. The FCC's petition will first be circulated to all ten active judges on the Circuit as well as Senior Judge Pierre Leval, who sat on the original panel. Any of those 11 can ask that his/her colleagues be polled as to whether or not to consider the petition. If nobody asks for such a polling, the petition is denied. If polling is requested, then the ten active judges but no senior judges (i.e., Judge Leval doesn't participate) are polled. Unless a majority of those polled vote for rehearing, the petition is denied. If a majority of the poll votes to grant rehearing, then the case is re-briefed and re-argued in front of all ten active judges and Senior Judge Leval. There is no guarantee that, even if the case gets that far, the FCC would prevail. A majority of the en banc court could just as easily affirm the panel's decision. In other words, the FCC has a long row to hoe. Meanwhile, a couple of other indecency cases also continue to wend their way through the Courts.
benton.org/node/41181 | CommLawBlog
Recommend this Headline
back to top
GOVERNMENT & COMMUNICATIONS
CONGRESSIONAL WEBSITES
[SOURCE: Federal Computer Week, AUTHOR: Alice Lipowicz]
Although a few congressional Web sites are exemplary, many are "suboptimal," and Congress needs to do more work to improve Web sites and share best practices for Web 2.0 technologies, according to a new report from the Brookings Institution think tank. Brookings has been reviewing congressional Web sites for quality since 2006. In its most recent review with the Congressional Management Foundation in April, it gave the Platinum Mouse Award top honors for Web site excellence to the House Science & Technology Committee, the House Republican Conference, and the individual sites of Sen. Lisa Murkowski (R-Alaska) and Rep. Steve Israel (D-NY) Despite those superior examples, and despite the fact that many lawmakers say their sites are important communication tools, the quality of many of those sites is "suboptimal," according to the Brookings authors Kevin Esterline, David Laser and Michael Nablo in the "Improving Congressional Web Sites" report, dated this August.
benton.org/node/41203 | Federal Computer Week
Recommend this Headline
back to top
STORIES FROM ABROAD
These headlines presented in partnership with:
BLACKBERRY GETS A 2-MONTH REPRIEVE IN INDIA
[SOURCE: New York Times, AUTHOR: Vikas Bajaj]
In a sign that India and the maker of popular BlackBerry devices might be closer to settling a dispute over law enforcement's access to corporate e-mail, the government on Monday said that it would study and test a proposal by the company for two months. The decision ends a waiting game, at least for now, over whether India would ban the popular corporate e-mail and BlackBerry Messenger chatting services on Tuesday, a deadline set this month for access. In a statement, the ministry of home affairs, which is responsible for internal security, said Research in Motion, the Canadian company that makes BlackBerry devices, had made "certain proposals for lawful access by law enforcement agencies and these would be operationalized immediately. The feasibility of the solutions offered would be assessed thereafter."
benton.org/node/41201 | New York Times
Recommend this Headline
back to top
RIM AGREEMENT'S IMPACT
[SOURCE: Bloomberg, AUTHOR: Ketaki Gokhale]
Research In Motion Ltd.'s concession in giving Indian authorities access to BlackBerry e-mail and instant-messenger correspondence means it's likely to do the same for other governments, analysts said. The agreement sets a precedent that will make it difficult for RIM to refuse countries seeking similar conditions, said Romal Shetty, executive director of the telecommunications division at KPMG's Indian unit. RIM spokesman Satchit Gayakwad declined to comment on the government accord or discuss any details of the proposal. RIM's proposal, disclosed by the Indian government yesterday, means the company may be willing to compromise on the privacy of corporate customers to placate regulators.
benton.org/node/41202 | Bloomberg
Recommend this Headline
back to top
WAITING ON A MISSED CONNECTION
[SOURCE: Sydney Morning Herald, AUTHOR: Lucy Battersby]
As Australia's politicians brawl over the election outcome, the telecommunications sector sits in a policy vacuum. The National Broadband Network Company has gone into hibernation -- finishing off existing work but not starting any new contracts. And Telstra has announced it will invest heavily in mobile and marketing, apparently demoting its role as the incumbent national fixed telephone network provider. The single biggest problem for fixed broadband expansion is the cost. Revenue from phone calls and data no longer justify the cost of installation for any telecommunications company anywhere in the world, according to the analyst Paul Budde. "We all know the fiber network can deliver other services -- healthcare, education, smart grids -- but that requires government policies that will actually stimulate other sectors to utilize the broadband network, and that is when you start getting the business model going,'' he says.
benton.org/node/41178 | Sydney Morning Herald
Recommend this Headline
back to top