November 1, 2013 (Modest Surveillance Reforms)
BENTON'S COMMUNICATIONS-RELATED HEADLINES for FRIDAY, NOVEMBER 1, 2013
Wireless 2020: Spectrum Crisis or Broadband Abundance? http://benton.org/calendar/2013-11-01/
GOVERNMENT & COMMUNICATIONS
Senate panel OKs modest surveillance reforms
Tech companies urge lawmakers to reform NSA programs [links to web]
Report says US tapped cardinals’ phones ahead of conclave
US admits surveillance on foreign governments ‘reached too far’ [links to web]
Angry Over US Surveillance, Tech Giants Bolster Defenses
Open Government Progress - press release [links to web]
INTERNET/BROADBAND
Over $32 Million Authorized To Expand Broadband Access In Rural Puerto Rico, Hawaii and Alaska From Connect America Fund - press release
The Slowest Draw in the West
New America Foundation Report Finds Municipal Broadband Providers Gouging Consumers - analysis
Gigabit Desert beginning to look more lush - speech
Cable Industry Preps Broadband Answer to Gigabit FTTH [links to web]
Net neutrality RIP? - analysis
WIRELESS
FAA to Allow Airlines to Expand Use of Personal Electronics - press release
In a First, Police Ticket a Driver Wearing Google Glass
TELECOM
Verizon Responds To Public Records Request With More Than Three Hundred Totally Blacked-Out Pages
Telecoms Selling TV Have Bigger Impact on Cable Firms
AT&T Said to Explore Vodafone Takeover as Soon as Next Year
RADIO
Radio Isn’t Going Away - op-ed
ELECTIONS AND MEDIA
Comcast is donating heavily to defeat the mayor who is bringing gigabit fiber to Seattle
HEALTH
Why Go To The Doctor When You Can Talk To A Doctor In Your Phone? [links to web]
The State Department Partners with Coursera to Support Free Education in Over 30 Countries [links to web]
GOVERNMENT PERFORMANCE
Can Silicon Valley save the Obamacare site?
White House Plans A Single FOIA Portal Across Government
POLICYMAKERS
Chairman Rockefeller Welcomes Sen Booker to the Senate Commerce Committee - press release [links to web]
COMPANY NEWS
Google Aims for the Next Billion Users With Android KitKat [links to web]
Facebook Tests Software to Track Your Cursor on Screen [links to web]
The Stakes Are High for Facebook’s Next Big Ad Product [links to web]
Comcast could license tech to other US cable operators: executive [links to web]
Time Warner Cable Reports Record Quarterly Loss of TV Subscribers [links to web]
Newspapers Reordered in New Count [links to web]
STORIES FROM ABROAD
Microsoft seeks EU approval for $7.5 billion Nokia deal [links to web]
AT&T Said to Explore Vodafone Takeover as Soon as Next Year
MORE ONLINE
On Cyber Trick-or-T(h)reats - press release [links to web]
IRS warns of telephone tax scam involving fake caller IDs [links to web]
GOVERNMENT & COMMUNICATIONS
MODEST SURVEILLANCE REFORMS
[SOURCE: Politico, AUTHOR: Josh Gerstein]
The Senate Intelligence Committee approved a set of modest surveillance reforms in an effort supporters of the measure hope will head off other bids to effectively shut down the telephone call-tracking program revealed by National Security Agency contractor Edward Snowden. The intelligence panel voted 11-4 to approve its reform package at a closed meeting that followed two other closed markup sessions earlier this week. The text of the committee bill was not immediately released, nor were the identities of those who voted for and against the measure. However, a summary released by the panel largely tracks with the outlines Committee Chairman Dianne Feinstein (D-CA) had given previously of her proposed reforms. Feinstein’s measure would largely convert court-imposed limits on the call-tracking program into statutory requirements. Some new limits would be added, like a requirement that the justification for every query of the database be provided after the fact to the federal court which oversees the program. In addition, a five-year limit on the retention of data would be imposed by law, with records older than three years accessible only with the approval of the attorney general.
benton.org/node/165524 | Politico
Share: Twitter | Facebook
back to top
REPORT SAYS US TAPPED CARDINALS’ PHONES AHEAD OF CONCLAVE
[SOURCE: Religion News Service, AUTHOR: Eric Lyman]
The National Security Agency spied on cardinals as they prepared to select the new pope -- perhaps including even Cardinal Jorge Bergoglio, who emerged from last spring’s conclave as Pope Francis, news magazine Panorama reported. The same NSA eavesdropping program that angered leaders in Germany, France, Spain and Mexico also listened in on calls to and from the Vatican, including the phones in the Santa Marta guesthouse that housed Bergoglio and the rest of the College of Cardinals.
benton.org/node/165513 | Religion News Service
Share: Twitter | Facebook
back to top
TECH GIANTS BOLSTER DEFENSES
[SOURCE: New York Times, AUTHOR: Claire Cain Miller]
Google has spent months and millions of dollars encrypting email, search queries and other information flowing among its data centers worldwide. Facebook’s chief executive said at a conference this fall that the government “blew it.” And though it has not been announced publicly, Twitter plans to set up new types of encryption to protect messages from snoops. It is all reaction to reports of how far the government has gone in spying on Internet users, sneaking around tech companies to tap into their systems without their knowledge or cooperation. What began as a public relations predicament for America’s technology companies has evolved into a moral and business crisis that threatens the foundation of their businesses, which rests on consumers and companies trusting them with their digital lives. So they are pushing back in various ways -- from cosmetic tactics like publishing the numbers of government requests they receive to political ones including tense conversations with officials behind closed doors. And companies are building technical fortresses intended to make the private information in which they trade inaccessible to the government and other suspected spies. Yet even as they take measures against government collection of personal information, their business models rely on collecting that same data, largely to sell personalized ads. So no matter the steps they take, as long as they remain ad companies, they will be gathering a trove of information that will prove tempting to law enforcement and spies.
benton.org/node/165552 | New York Times | Wall Street Journal
Share: Twitter | Facebook
back to top
INTERNET/BROADBAND
OVER $32 MILLION AUTHORIZED TO EXPAND BROADBAND ACCESS IN RURAL AREAS FROM CONNECT AMERICA FUND
[SOURCE: Federal Communications Commission, AUTHOR: Press release]
Over $32 million in funding to provide new broadband access to over 42,000 unserved homes and businesses in Puerto Rico, Hawaii and Alaska has been authorized from the Federal Communications Commission’s Connect America Fund, connecting over 100,000 people who lack service. Currently about 15 million U.S. residents, mostly rural, lack access to fixed broadband. Specifics about this authorization are as follows:
Puerto Rico (territory-wide): $31.6 million to reach 40,736 homes and businesses
Hawaii (Hawaii County): $1 million to reach 1,317 homes and businesses
Alaska (Yukon-Koyukuk Borough): $174,000 to reach 316 homes and businesses
benton.org/node/165473 | Federal Communications Commission | FCC Public Notice
Share: Twitter | Facebook
back to top
SLOWEST DRAW IN THE WEST
[SOURCE: New America Foundation, AUTHOR: Danielle Kehl]
Once upon a time, America had the fastest Internet in the world. But today, according to our new report, American cities are trailing with vastly slower -- and costlier -- Internet speeds: average speeds around the world are increasing as America falls behind, and the price per megabit (aka the cost of bandwidth) is much higher in the U.S. than in most other countries in the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD). To put it simply: prices are high, speeds are slower, and there doesn’t seem to be much that consumers can do about it. The Open Technology Institute’s new data gathers the cost of high-speed Internet from 24 cities around the world. What distinguishes our data from many of the other rankings out there is that we focus on the cost of connectivity in big cities -- a way to account for the difficulty of comparing the United States as a whole when it is much larger and more sparsely populated than many countries in Europe or Asia. We present the actual broadband packages that a consumer in New York, Seoul, or Paris might consider subscribing to at home. And we found that in general, American consumers pay higher prices for lower speeds than their international peers.
benton.org/node/165477 | New America Foundation
Share: Twitter | Facebook
back to top
ITIF ON NEW AMERICA REPORT
[SOURCE: Information Technology and Innovation Foundation, AUTHOR: Rob Atkinson]
[Commentary] In its second annual report assessing broadband speeds and prices in various nations, the New America Foundation reports some disturbing findings. But my reason for pointing this out is to show the absurdity of the New America report, for it purports to make the case that US private sector broadband providers charge too much relative to providers in other nations. But if US private sector providers are fat, lazy monopolists earning fat profits, why don’t these municipal providers who charge much higher prices than foreign providers not charge much less? Perhaps they are run by lazy incredibly inefficient government bureaucrats? Perhaps they are paying for welfare for the poor on the backs of the excessive revenues they are extracting from their captive broadband customers? Or perhaps their prices, and the prices of comparable US private sector providers, are in fact, not out of line at all. Of course, the last explanation is the right one.
benton.org/node/165475 | Information Technology and Innovation Foundation
Share: Twitter | Facebook
back to top
GIGABIT DESERT
[SOURCE: Gig.U, AUTHOR: Blair Levin]
Blair Levin spoke at the Web Summit in Dublin, Ireland on the topic of Gigabit Networks. In his remarks he noted:
“A few years ago, gigabit America was a desert. Now, with a dozen Gig.U communities moving forward, Google Fiber capturing the imagination of many, cities like Chattanooga and Lafayette providing gigabit service, and incumbents like CenturyLink, AT&T and Time-Warner Cable now looking favorably upon upgraded networks, that desert is beginning to look more like a garden.”
“The key to activity in the United States has been enlightened local leadership that recognizes how the quality of the network their community has 10 years from now will affect everything they do and everything they do today affects the quality of the network they will have 10 years from now.”
“It is still early in the transition to the digital economy but the presence of such networks will accelerate innovations in how we solve society’s problems with smarter use of chips, bits and bandwidth.”
benton.org/node/165469 | Gig.U
Share: Twitter | Facebook
back to top
NET NEUTRALITY RIP?
[SOURCE: American Enterprise Institute, AUTHOR: Jeffrey Eisenach]
[Commentary] The Washington Post’s Brian Fung recently argued that a Netflix-Time Warner Cable collaboration would be bad news for net neutrality because it would take one of its strongest advocates off the playing field. I agree that Netflix’s evolution is bad news for net neutrality, but on economic rather than political grounds. It is becoming increasingly apparent that Netflix isn’t, and perhaps never was, a likely victim of anticompetitive discrimination by Internet service providers. That’s important, because if there was ever a plausible scenario for discriminatory conduct by infrastructure owners against “edge” firms -- the heart of the case for the Federal Communication Commission’s net neutrality rules -- Netflix was the poster child. But in its July 2013 Fifteenth Report on Competition in the Market for Video Delivery, released just six months after its brief to the DC Circuit defending Open Internet rules, Netflix went from being a substitute for cable service to a complement. We now know that one of the central arguments for net neutrality regulation was based on a faulty assumption. One could make a pretty good argument that the rule ought to be withdrawn and reconsidered. At a minimum, though, if the rule is overturned by the Court as many believe likely, it surely should be allowed to RIP.
benton.org/node/165481 | American Enterprise Institute
Share: Twitter | Facebook
back to top
WIRELESS
FAA OKs USE OF DEVICES
[SOURCE: Federal Aviation Administration, AUTHOR: Press release]
The Department of Transportation’s Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) has determined that airlines can safely expand passenger use of Portable Electronic Devices (PEDs) during all phases of flight, and is immediately providing the airlines with implementation guidance. Due to differences among fleets and operations, the implementation will vary among airlines, but the agency expects many carriers will prove to the FAA that their planes allow passengers to safely use their devices in airplane mode, gate-to-gate, by the end of the year. The FAA based its decision on input from a group of experts that included representatives from the airlines, aviation manufacturers, passengers, pilots, flight attendants, and the mobile technology industry. Passengers will eventually be able to read e-books, play games, and watch videos on their devices during all phases of flight, with very limited exceptions. Electronic items, books and magazines, must be held or put in the seat back pocket during the actual takeoff and landing roll. Cell phones should be in airplane mode or with cellular service disabled -- i.e., no signal bars displayed -- and cannot be used for voice communications based on FCC regulations that prohibit any airborne calls using cell phones. If your air carrier provides Wi-Fi service during flight, you may use those services. You can also continue to use short-range Bluetooth accessories, like wireless keyboards.
benton.org/node/165479 | Federal Aviation Administration | White House
Share: Twitter | Facebook
back to top
IN A FIRST, POLICE TICKET A DRIVER WEARING GOOGLE GLASS
[SOURCE: Wired, AUTHOR: Damon Lavrinc]
And so it begins… California-based Glass Explorer Cecilia Adabie is the first person to get a ticket while wearing Google’s head-mounted computer. And she won’t be the last. Abadie was driving in San Diego when an officer pulled her over for speeding. The primary infraction was for going 15 mph over the speed limit, but there was a secondary offense scrawled on the ticket: “driving w/ monitor visible to driver (Google Glass).” The arresting officer issued the citation to Abadie for violating California’s Vehicle Code Section 27602, which states that “A person shall not drive a motor vehicle if a television receiver, a video monitor, or a television or video screen, or any other similar means of visually displaying a television broadcast or video signal that produces entertainment or business applications, is operating and is located in the motor vehicle at a point forward of the back of the driver’s seat, or is operating and the monitor, screen, or display is visible to the driver while driving the motor vehicle.”
benton.org/node/165483 | Wired
Share: Twitter | Facebook
back to top
TELECOM
VERIZON RESPONDS TO PUBLIC RECORDS REQUEST WITH MORE THAN THREE HUNDRED TOTALLY BLACKED-OUT PAGES
[SOURCE: Forbes, AUTHOR: Elise Ackerman]
In September 2013, a group of consumer advocates interceded in a proceeding Verizon had initiated with the New York Public Service Commission to shut down its traditional network, known as the “wireline” network. The advocates were interested in reviewing documents Verizon had filed with the commission about its wireline and wireless build-outs. Under the state Freedom of Information Law, advocates requested that Verizon provide information about the actual costs and expenses associated with the repair, upkeep and maintenance of the traditional wireline network on the resort community of Fire Island. Verizon responded to the advocate’s Freedom of Information request with more than 300 fully redacted pages. Among other documents, Verizon claimed as a “trade secret” a list of Voice Link deployments, a Voice Link leader’s guide and a document about overcoming customers’ objections to Voice Link and responding to requests to return to copper.
benton.org/node/165485 | Forbes
Share: Twitter | Facebook
back to top
TELECOM TV
[SOURCE: Wall Street Journal, AUTHOR: Shalini Ramachandran, Thomas Gryta]
Nearly a decade after Verizon Communications and AT&T began building pipelines to carry TV service to US homes, they are nearing the market share of cable operators in areas where they operate, according to third-quarter results released by cable and phone companies in recent days. The top two cable providers, Comcast and Time Warner Cable, shed 435,000 video customers in the quarter, while AT&T and Verizon added 400,000. The growth of telecom's share of the TV business could have a significant impact on the television industry. Both phone companies have shown a greater willingness than their cable rivals to experiment with delivering movies and TV programming over the Internet outside the traditional pay-TV bundle. AT&T and Verizon are now the fifth and sixth biggest pay-TV providers in the U.S. after Comcast and Time Warner Cable and the two satellite-TV companies, DirecTV and Dish Network Corp. The phone companies account for only about 10% of the pay-TV market, compared with 55% for cable, according to MoffettNathanson LLC, but that is largely because phone companies don't offer service everywhere cable does. In the markets where they do operate, Verizon isn't far behind cable: FiOS has signed up 35% of the households where it offers its service, compared with 40.3% for Comcast and 38.9% for Time Warner Cable. AT&T's average is much lower, but it has become much more aggressive lately, launching a $6 billion investment in its wireline operations last year that includes extending the reach of its TV service.
benton.org/node/165550 | Wall Street Journal
Share: Twitter | Facebook
back to top
AT&T SAID TO EXPLORE VODAFONE TAKEOVER AS SOON AS NEXT YEAR
[SOURCE: Bloomberg, AUTHOR: Matthew Campbell, Jeffrey McCracken]
AT&T executives are laying the groundwork internally for a potential takeover of Vodafone Group next year, mapping out a strategy for a complex deal with Europe’s largest mobile carrier, people familiar with the situation said. While the companies haven’t entered formal negotiations, AT&T, the largest US phone company, is intensifying work on which Vodafone assets it would retain after a deal and who could buy others, the people said, declining to be identified discussing private deliberations. AT&T, which remains interested in UK carrier EE as an alternative target, is also formulating a strategy for Vodafone’s operations in Europe, where mobile broadband adoption has lagged the US, the people said. Combined, Vodafone and AT&T would be a globe-spanning telecommunications player with a market capitalization exceeding $250 billion and large-scale operations in the US and across Europe. With more than 500 million wireless subscribers worldwide, the company would be able to challenge Google and Apple when negotiating handset subsidies and wringing profit out of nascent technologies such as mobile advertising.
benton.org/node/165528 | Bloomberg
Share: Twitter | Facebook
back to top
ELECTIONS AND MEDIA
COMCAST IS DONATING HEAVILY TO DEFEAT THE MAYOR WHO IS BRINGING GIGABIT FIBER TO SEATTLE
[SOURCE: Washington Post, AUTHOR: Andrea Peterson]
One of Seattle Mayor Mike McGinn's big policy initiatives has been expanding the quality and quantity of high-speed Internet access throughout the city. A public-private partnership plans to offer higher speeds at lower prices than most broadband providers currently offer. And incumbent providers, particularly Comcast, have invested heavily in defeating Mayor McGinn in his mayoral election. While Comcast denies there is any connection between Mayor McGinn's broadband policies and their donations, the company has given thousands of dollars to political action committees that have, in turn, given heavily to anti-McGinn groups. Mayor McGinn's major opponent, state Sen. Ed Murray (D-Seattle), has committed to honoring the city's existing contracts for a 14-neighborhood pilot project, but has shown limited enthusiasm about Mayor McGinn's plans to expand the network in the future. So the election could determine whether Seattle residents have new options for high-speed broadband service, or will have to make do with the slower services already offered by incumbents like Comcast.
benton.org/node/165533 | Washington Post
Share: Twitter | Facebook
back to top
RADIO
RADIO ISN’T GOING AWAY
[SOURCE: Wall Street Journal, AUTHOR: Mary Beth Garber]
[Commentary] Scarborough USA Plus data shows radio has actually increased its reach of adults 18-54, 25-54 and 18-34 over the past five years. Radio accounts for more than 90 percent of almost any demographic segment of the consumer market every week. And many are surprised to discover that radio is the leading source of reach among media entertainment. More than 95 percent of the people who used Pandora in the past month also listened to broadcast radio in the past week. USA Touchpoints also shows that while consumers have shifted some of their audio entertainment time, it has been away from CDs and iPods, not radio. The number of radio listeners has continued to grow as digital audio has grown.
[Mary Beth Garber is Head of Radio Analysis and Insights, Katz Radio Group]
benton.org/node/165530 | Wall Street Journal
Share: Twitter | Facebook
back to top
GOVERNMENT PERFORMANCE
CAN SILICON VALLEY SAVE THE OBAMACARE SITE?
[SOURCE: Washington Post, AUTHOR: Brian Fung]
High-profile companies like Google, Oracle and Red Hat are donating their engineering talent to the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services in response to the Administration's call for a "tech surge" that would fix the embattled HealthCare.gov website. A spokesperson for the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services said that Google's Michael Dickerson, a site reliability engineer who's on temporary leave, will be aiding QSSI, one of the initial contractors for HealthCare.gov. Meanwhile, a former Presidential Innovation Fellow named Greg Gershman has signed on with CGI, the Canadian company widely said to be responsible for the botched project. Fixing HealthCare.gov could be these engineers' biggest project yet.
benton.org/node/165536 | Washington Post | USA Today | Bloomberg
Share: Twitter | Facebook
back to top
WHITE HOUSE PLANS A SINGLE FOIA PORTAL ACROSS GOVERNMENT
[SOURCE: nextgov, AUTHOR: Joseph Marks]
The White House plans to launch a single online portal where journalists, researchers and other citizens can file Freedom of Information Act requests, according to an early draft of commitments to the international Open Government Partnership. A single FOIA portal could significantly reduce the time FOIA requesters spend managing requests that cross multiple agencies. It may also make it easier for agencies to forward requests within the government and to publicize responsive documents so FOIA officers don’t lose time digging for the same document twice. The government-wide portal could be based on FOIA Online, a year-old system that tracks FOIA requests for the Commerce Department and the Environmental Protection Agency, though the White House doesn’t mention the system by name. FOIA Online is the only multi-agency online FOIA portal in government so far.
benton.org/node/165532 | nextgov
Share: Twitter | Facebook
back to top