June 2015

COMPTEL Seeks Senate Video Hearing

Competitive telecommunication carriers, including NTCA–The Rural Broadband Association and COMPTEL, have asked Senate Commerce Committee Chairman John Thune (R-SD) to hold a hearing looking into the video marketplace, specifically what they say are failures that need addressing, including a revamp of the retransmission consent regime that allows broadcasters a programming "stranglehold." The groups argue that access to video is directly related to the issue of broadband deployment, which is the prime directive of communications policy these days.

"[T]he retransmission consent regime is more than twenty years old and reflects an era with very different marketplace realities," they said in a letter to Chairman Thune. "This regime gives broadcast stations a stranglehold over access to programming and prevents providers from negotiating market-based rates for programming. As a result, consumers face blackouts of channels and ever escalating video costs." They also want the committee to look at program tying and bundling, which they have long argued "impede the ability of consumers to avail themselves of alternative choices."

Cable Ops to FCC: Dish, DirecTV Should Pay More

Cable operators want satellite operators to pay more in Federal Communications Commission regulatory fees. In a joint filing with the FCC, the American Cable Association and National Cable & Telecommunications Association said 12 cents per sub for 2015 is not enough, given that cable operators will have to pay eight times that, or about 95 cents per year. The operators want the FCC to double satellite's portion to 24 cents per year for 2015 and add another 24 cents over the next three years with fee parity between satellite and cable starting in 2018.

The comments came in response to the FCC's Notice of Proposed Rulemaking and order issued by the FCC in May to correct what FCC Commissioner Ajit Pai called a long-time imbalance in the treatment of multichannel video programming distributor (MVPD) programming distributors. NCTA and ACA had pushed for putting DBS in the same fee category, and to pay per-sub, rather than per satellite license. But they want the FCC to raise the rate by more, and faster, than the commission proposed. The FCC ordered that DBS be added to the fee category that included cable and IP services, then asked for comment on its proposed fee, including whether the proposal to start low -- 1 cent per month -- and phase in the increase would address satellite operators argument that that would avoid consumer bill shock.

Inside Cablevision’s War With Big Labor

On June 23, James Dolan’s cable company, Cablevision, finally answers allegations that it strong-armed employees during a bruising, three-year tangle with the communication workers’ union. James L. Dolan is not a man to dodge a fight. When the billionaire owner of the New York Knicks and Rangers received an emotional e-mail from a lifelong fan begging him to sell his hapless basketball team, for example, Dolan told 72-year-old Irving Bierman that he was a “hateful mess” and an “alcoholic maybe.” But tiffs like these are nothing compared to the bruising three-year war of attrition that Dolan and Cablevision, the multibillion-dollar cable company he runs, have fought with the Communications Workers of America (CWA) union that some employees voted to join in 2012.

Allegations of misconduct have been hurled at both sides. In recent months, regional offices of the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB), the federal agency that supervises union elections and investigates unfair labor practices, has accused Dolan and Cablevision of violating federal labor law by allegedly threatening employees, bargaining in bad faith, unfairly firing employees, and raising the salaries only of non-union workers. In a statement, a Cablevision spokesman responded: “This is a ridiculous and false attack which is not worthy of either a response or any attention from readers.” A contract between CWA was finally signed, only hours before tipoff at the February 13 NBA All-Star Game, hosted at Dolan’s Madison Square Garden. But the scars from the long, expensive fight remain raw.

Nearly Half of US Households are Now Wireless Only Households, But 60 Percent May be More Accurate Number

The latest data from the Centers for Disease Control paints the picture of a growing mobile first society in the US, with nearly half (45.4 percent) of US households wireless only. The data comes from the CDC’s July -- December 2014 National Health Interview Survey (NHIS). The NHIS captures this data twice per year and provides some of the best data available regarding wireless substitution in the US. Wireless only households is not an issue for just the very young anymore.

According to the CDC data, more than two-thirds of adults aged 25–29 (69.2 percent) and aged 30-34 (67.4 percent) lived in wireless only households. That exceeds those in the 18 – 24 demographic, where 57.8 percent were wireless only. For those beyond age 35 – 53.7 percent for those 35–44 were wireless only; 36.8 percent for those 45–64; and 17.1 percent for those 65 and over. Renters (66.2 percent) and adults living with unrelated roommates (81.3 percent) far exceeded the national average of 45.4 percent. Household income is a factor as well. Nearly sixty percent (59.4 percent) of adults living under the poverty line were wireless only, compared to 42.5 percent of higher income adults.

Nation’s poor to the FCC: ‘We’re way ahead of you’

[Commentary] The Federal Communications Commission adopted a proposal that, according to the agency, takes “significant steps to modernize its Lifeline program.” Lifeline is a 30 year-old telecommunications subsidy program for low-income households. After 30 years, you would think that the program has made a demonstrable impact on making “phone service affordable for low-income Americans,” as the FCC put it. You would be wrong.

As I think most American’s would agree, the FCC is right for caring about the poor, but the agency’s plan doesn’t put that care into action. Despite FCC Chairman Tom Wheeler’s statements to the contrary, this isn’t a partisan issue. It’s an evidence issue. Why does Lifeline make no impact? The poor purchase service without the subsidy. In my home state of Florida, for example, in 2005, under the original program, about 90 percent of low-income households had telephone service, but less than 20 percent participated in Lifeline. One study found that people signing up for the subsidy almost always already had phone service. Why were poor households abandoning landlines and ignoring Lifeline? People participating in the study said they moved often, which meant costly connection fees. They also said cellular phones are more convenient and that it is easier to control access to cellular phones. What should the FCC do? Devote more radio spectrum resources to broadband. Poor customers have shown themselves to be just as talented as others in determining what communications services best fit their needs, and they are taking advantage of dynamic competitive markets just like everyone else. The primary need of these markets is more radio spectrum. This is particularly true for the poor since they have demonstrated a preference for mobile devices.

[Mark Jamison is the Director and Gunter Professor of the Public Utility Research Center at the University of Florida]

Five Ways the Department of Commerce Supports a Data-Enabled Economy

Through its 12 bureaus, the Department of Commerce creates the conditions for economic growth and opportunity on both a domestic and global scale. As the voice of business in the President’s Cabinet, Secretary Pritzker has spearheaded the Department of Commerce’s “Open for Business Agenda” Strategic Plan and focused on five strategic goals: trade and investment, innovation, environment, data and operational excellence. Secretary Pritzker’s two-year anniversary is June 26, and we are highlighting one of our strategic pillars by recognizing recent achievements. Here are five important accomplishments in Data since Secretary Pritzker joined the Commerce Department:

  1. ESA assembled 19 technology leaders and established the Commerce Data Advisory Council to provide guidance and insight into how the Department of Commerce should analyze, promote, and disseminate its trove of data.
  2. Commerce engaged with data users and launched a new Developer Outreach Program, which led to the launch of the Trade Developer Portal and a “City Software Development Kit” at the National Day of Civic Hacking.
  3. Commerce recruited a new data team, led by the Department’s first-ever Chief Data Officer Ian Kalin, to improve the operations of the Department. The team is focused on the distribution and use of open data.
  4. NOAA established Cooperative Research and Development Agreements to handle their Big Data initiative.
  5. NYU’s GovLab worked with the Commerce Department, specifically USPTO, to shape the bureau’s open data roadmap. Govlab also outlined private sector recommendations for improving Commerce Department data management, which led to more data jams with data users.

The progress that the US Department of Commerce has made reflects both the dedication of Secretary Pritzker as well as the commitment of our 47,000 Commerce employees, to keeping America Open for Business.

Video visitations gain popularity in prison system

As part of a series about technology in prisons called "Jailbreak," we're talking about the growing use of video visitation in prisons. It's being used already in over 500 institutions around the country. Most of them are county jails, but a few are state prisons. And while we know a lot about the impact of in-person visits between inmates and their families while incarcerated, we don't know much about the impact of video visitation.

Bernadette Rabuy, a policy and communications associate at the Prison Policy Initiative, says the growth in popularity of video visitation technology has a lot to do with cutting costs. Prisons are also attracted to the fact that it eliminates the opportunity for the smuggling of contraband items to prisoners. But Rabuy cautions that the benefits may not outweigh the emotional costs: "We don't know that these videos are equivalent to in-person visits, which have been shown by a lot of research to be one of the only ways we know for sure reduces the likelihood of future crimes."

Google introduces News Lab, a resource for journalists

In addition to its mission of “organizing the world’s information,” Google is now trying to help newsrooms around the world make sense of that information. News Lab features interactive tutorials on how to get the most out of tools like Maps, YouTube and Fusion Tables, as well as an update to the Google Trends platform, which lets journalists track trends in Google searches.

As part of the initiative, the company announced partnerships with media start-ups such as Matter and Hacks/Hackers, which involves financial support from Google and mentorship from Google engineers to help them build their businesses. The company also announced three projects that will support citizen reporting, each making use of platforms like YouTube, Medium and the Witness Media Lab.

Medicare Slow To Adopt Telemedicine Due To Cost Concerns

Nearly 20 years after such videoconferencing technology has been available for health services, fewer than 1 percent of Medicare beneficiaries use it. Anthem and a University of Pittsburgh Medical Center health plan in western Pennsylvania are the only two Medicare Advantage insurers offering the virtual visits, and the traditional Medicare program has tightly limited telemedicine payments to certain rural areas. And even there, the beneficiary must already be at a clinic, a rule that often defeats the goal of making care more convenient. Congress has maintained such restrictions out of concern that the service might increase Medicare expenses.

The Congressional Budget Office and other analysts have said giving seniors access to doctors online will encourage them to use more services, not replace costly visits to emergency rooms and urgent care centers. In 2012, the latest year for which data are available, Medicare paid about $5 million for telemedicine services -- barely a blip compared with the program’s total spending of $466 billion, according to a study in the journal Telemedicine. But the telemedicine industry says letting more beneficiaries get care online would reduce doctor visits and emergency care. Industry officials as well as the American Medical Association, the American Hospital Association and other health experts say it’s time for Congress to expand use of telemedicine in Medicare.

NATO working with South Dakota telemedicine hub

NATO leaders are working with a telemedicine hub in southeast South Dakota to develop a multinational system that could deliver medical services remotely during natural or manmade disasters. Representatives from NATO nations, including Romania, the United Kingdom and the US, are visiting Avera Health's telemedicine center in Sioux Falls to look at the technology and equipment options available to provide health care services from distant locations. The goal of the NATO-funded research project is to increase survival rates in emergency situations, when immediate access to medical specialists is not always possible.

"This project is aiming at the creation of the multinational capacity in responding to major situations, disasters, civil emergencies, in countries where we would send our teams and they may need to consult experienced physicians at the distant from where they are," said Romanian interior ministry official Dr. Raed Arafat, who is the NATO director for the project. The team working on the project has been gathering for more than a year, and their visit to South Dakota marks their first meeting in the US.