The FCC is holding a symposium today on the educational potential of
broadband and the US Chamber of Commerce will release a report calling for
telecom regulation certainty. For upcoming media policy events, see
http://www.benton.org/calendar.htm
TODAY'S QUESTION: This wonk's ears perked when Sen Edwards ended the debate
with the image of his father learning math on TV. Is instructional
programming something we should expect of broadcasting today and in the
digital future?
MEDIA POLICY
Ensign Announces Deal to Raise Cap on Indecency Violations, Includes
Penalties for Performers
The New Language of NASCAR
Peacock Proudly Defends WRC
Comcast: Multicasting's Hurdles 'Insurmountable'
FCC Takes Flak Over Flag
News Corp. Might Buy All of Fox
Viacom Gets Stake in Spanish Broadcasting
Radio Goes Digital
TELECOM POLICY
Accounting Issues Emerge as Latest E-Rate Crisis
Phone Group Head Resigns After Uproar
Seventh Circuit: Modem-Fee Case to State Court
QUICKLY
Political Groups Are Big Spenders
Is the PC a Political Machine?
House Approves Spyware Legislation
Federal Court to Rehear Email Privacy Case
USTA Lays Out Key Principles for Telecom Industry Wholesale Rules
Taxation of Online Sales
Position Available: FAIR
Congrats to APC's Karen Banks
MEDIA POLICY
ENSIGN ANNOUNCES DEAL TO RAISE CAP ON INDECENCY VIOLATIONS, INCLUDES
PENALTIES FOR PERFORMERS
On Tuesday, Sen John Ensign (R-NV) announced that he and other leading
lawmakers had cut a major legislative deal to raise the cap on indecency
fines to $500,000 -- and clear the way for the FCC to force on-air
performers to pay the penalties for their off-color utterances. The bill
would also sets timelines for FCC action on indecency complaints, require
the FCC to report annually to Congress on its indecency efforts and calls
for the National Association of Broadcasters to establish a family-viewing
policy. These provisions will be part of the defense spending authorization
bill in conference committee now. Sen Ensign's announcement is a turnaround
from efforts earlier in the day to strip any non-defense-related provisions
from the bill (see story below). In theory, he is responding to quick
pressure applied by the Parents Television Council which has been pushing
for the indecency legislation. Stripped from the bill were provisions to
extend indecency prohibitions to violent broadcast and cable programming
and end FCC efforts to relax agency media ownership rules.
[SOURCE: Current, AUTHOR: Doug Halonen]
http://www.tvweek.com/news.cms?newsId=6455
FCC Indecency-Fine Boost in Jeopardy
Nevada Republican Senator John Ensign has sent a letter to Armed Services
Committee Chairman John Warner (R-VA) and ranking member Carl Levin (D-MI)
saying that extraneous and controversial provisions regarding media
ownership limits and cable indecency could jeopardize agreement on a
defense spending authorization bill tied up in a House-Senate conference.
The bill includes an amendment, offered by Sen Sam Brownback (R-KS), that
would increase fines for indecent broadcast content. That provision has
bi-partisan support. But additional provisions would permanently throw out
the FCC's June 2, 2003 ownership revamp and creating a violence safe harbor
on broadcast outlets. Sen Ensign believes these provisions jeopardize a
compromise on the defense bill before the current Congressional session
ends Oct. 8.
[SOURCE: Broadcasting&Cable, AUTHOR: John Eggerton]
http://www.broadcastingcable.com/article/CA468484.html?display=Breaking+...
(free access for Benton's Headlines subscribers)
THE NEW LANGUAGE OF NASCAR
Moments after he won Sunday's race at Talladega Superspeedway in Alabama,
Dale Earnhardt Jr was asked by an NBC reporter about the significance of
the victory. In a fit of self-deprecating glee, Earnhardt recalled the
memory of his legendary father, Dale Earnhardt, who was killed in the 2001
Daytona 500, declaring, "It don't mean [expletive] right now. Daddy's won
here 10 times." NASCAR officials countered yesterday by slapping Earnhardt
with a $10,000 fine and docking him 25 points toward the season's
championship, dropping him from first to second in the standings with seven
races to go. NASCAR's response illuminates the lingering effects of Janet
Jackson's breast-baring halftime show during the National Football League's
Super Bowl, which resulted in more than a half-million complaints and a
record $550,000 FCC fine against 20 CBS-owned stations.
[SOURCE: Washington Post, AUTHOR: Liz Clarke and Dan Steinberg]
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/articles/A8141-2004Oct5.html
(requires registration)
PEACOCK PROUDLY DEFENDS WRC
NBC has asked the Federal Communications Commission to reject the Parent's
Television Council's petition to deny the license renewal of its WRC-TV
Washington, D.C., arguing that the station's record of service to the
community should not be trumped by "a series of unadjudicated (or
dismissed) allegations that certain dialogue within a few of the station's
programs was actionably indecent." NBC argues that it was unaware of
"virtually all" of the referenced complaints, and takes that lack of FCC
notification as evidence that none made a prima facie case for indecency,
"never mind any sort of claim sufficient to raise a material and
substantial question as to the station's extensive and outstanding record
of broadcasting in the public interest." On a broader point, says NBC, "a
single individual should not be able to deny millions of satisfied viewers
a continuation of the station's long-standing and exemplary service because
of that person's complaints about a handful of episodes during more than a
half-decade of television programming. Among that service NBC sites helping
lead the transition to digital TV, Equal Employment Opportunity community
outreach, local news and other locally produced programming, educational
kids shows, Public Service Announcements and top-quality entertainment.
[SOURCE: Broadcasting&Cable, AUTHOR: John Eggerton]
http://www.broadcastingcable.com/article/CA468478.html?display=Breaking+...
(free access for Benton's Headlines subscribers)
COMCAST: MULTICASTING'S HURDLES 'INSURMOUNTABLE'
In a meeting last week with several FCC officials, including Media Bureau
Chief Kenneth Ferree, Comcast reiterated the cable giant's position that
requiring cable systems to carry every digital service beamed by local TV
stations -- know as multicast must-carry -- would face "insurmountable"
legal hurdles because of constitutional issues. Chief Ferree has said his
staff has concluded that the FCC's ruling that TV stations were entitled to
carriage of a single programming service was incorrect and that law permits
an interpretation of the 1992 Cable Act that would support a
multicast-carriage mandate. The FCC is moving to resolve the issue by the
end of this year. Comcast argues that a multicast mandate would frustrate
its ability to select programming services most desired by subscribers and
also noted that it is seeking technology that would allow it to reallocate
surplus bandwidth that becomes available when digital-TV stations alternate
between HDTV and less-bit-intensive standard-definition formats. "Thus, to
be denied this flexibility by the [FCC], through a rule that requires the
carriage of multiple program streams for a single broadcaster, would
represent an even greater intrusion on the editorial discretion and the
reasonable investment-backed expectations of the cable operator than a rule
that requires the carriage of a single HDTV programming stream per
broadcaster," Comcast said.
[SOURCE: Multichannel News, AUTHOR: Ted Hearn]
http://www.multichannel.com/article/CA469126.html?display=Breaking+News
(requires subscription)
FCC TAKES FLAK OVER FLAG
Public Knowledge, Consumer's Union, Consumer Federation of America, and a
number of library associations have filed a petition with the DC Court of
Appeals arguing that the FCC had no authority to adopted the broadcast-flag
digital-distribution protection regime for over-the-air digital TV.
Although they concede the FCC has authority over the DTV transmissions,
they argue that the flag does not come into play until after the
transmission is received. "The Broadcast Flag resembles an assertion of FCC
jurisdiction over an entire automobile simply because the car contains a
satellite radio receiver," they argued in the brief. The groups fear the
flag will put undue limitations on copying devices including TiVos, digital
VCRs, iPods, and cell phones. "This is a crucial case that will determine
how much control the government and Hollywood will have over current and
future digital media devices," said Public Knowledge President Gigi Sohn.
[SOURCE: Broadcasting&Cable, AUTHOR: John Eggerton]
http://www.broadcastingcable.com/article/CA468967.html?display=Breaking+...
(free access for Benton's Headlines subscribers)
See a Press Release from Public Knowledge at:
http://www.publicknowledge.org/content/press-releases/press_release.2004...
See a Press Release from the Electronic Frontier Foundation:
http://www.eff.org/news/archives/2004_10.php#001968
NEWS CORP MAY BUY ALL OF FOX
News Corp may buy out the 18% of its Fox Entertainment Group unit it
doesn't already own, News Chairman Rupert Murdoch told an investors
conference. Fox owns some of News Corp's most valuable US businesses and
the move to buy Fox may be a major reason for the proposed shift in News
Corp.'s corporate domicile from Australia to the US. Murdoch believes the
deal could be done for about $5 billion. News Corp isn't likely to buy full
ownership of either DirecTV Group, its 34%-owned satellite-TV arm in the
US, or its 35%-owned UK satellite arm, British Sky Broadcasting Group,
Murdoch said. BSkyB would be too expensive, while a DirecTV buyout isn't
possible because of a tax-related agreement with DirecTV's former
controlling shareholder, General Motors.
[SOURCE: Wall Street Journal, AUTHOR: Martin Peers martin.peers( at )wsj.com]
http://online.wsj.com/article/0,,SB109701720828337204,00.html?mod=todays...
(requires subscription)
VIACOM GETS STAKE IN SPANISH BROADCASTING
Viacom has purchased a 10% stake in Spanish Broadcasting System (SBS) in
exchange for in exchange for Viacom's Infinity Broadcasting unit merging an
FM station in San Francisco with SBS, creating what Viacom and SBS describe
as the single most powerful Spanish-language radio station in the market.
Beyond the station deal, the two companies also agreed to join forces to
target Hispanic consumers through television, radio and outdoor advertising
throughout the United States. Analyst David Joyce viewed the transaction as
a positive for Viacom, providing the company with an entry into a "highly
coveted broadcasting subsector."
[SOURCE: TVWeek, AUTHOR: Jay Sherman]
http://www.tvweek.com/news.cms?newsId=6448
Coverage also in --
Wall Street Journal
http://online.wsj.com/article/0,,SB109699936181036705,00.html?mod=todays...
(requires subscription)
RADIO GOES DIGITAL
Like TV, radio is going digital. Nearly 140 stations in the U.S. are
broadcasting digital radio, and an additional 70 are expected to convert by
year's end. A digital FM station has a crisper, cleaner sound approaching
that of a compact disc. When digitized, even AM radio, which is prone to
signal interference, sounds as good as a conventional FM station does
today. Because digital transmission is more efficient than analog, stations
that convert to digital can squeeze two digital channels and an analog
channel on the same frequency. That means a station could have two digital
channels broadcasting different music in the same frequency. National
Public Radio, for instance, is considering a jazz channel that could reside
on an alternative channel. Stations also could use the additional channels
to send messages to listeners, says Robert Struble, chief executive of
iBiquity Digital, which developed the official U.S. standard for digital
radio in 2002. Mr. Struble predicts many stations will beam breaking news
or traffic information in text scrolling across a car radio's LCD screen.
[SOURCE: Wall Street Journal, AUTHOR: Gary McWilliams
gary.mcwilliams( at )wsj.com]
http://online.wsj.com/article/0,,SB109702174476337406,00.html?mod=todays...
(requires subscription)
'TiVo' for Your Radio
Walt Mossberg reviews a new device that aims to do for radio what TiVo did
for television.
http://online.wsj.com/article/0,,SB109701902050037291,00.html?mod=todays...
TELECOM POLICY
ACCOUNTING ISSUES EMERGE AS LATEST E-RATE CRISIS
The Senate Commerce Committee held a hearing on the E-rate Tuesday and an
accounting convention broke out. The Universal Service Administrative
Corporation explained to Senators that it had lost $4.6 million due to an
accounting change that required the company to have more cash on hand --
USAC needed to sell some assets and paid significant penalties. The changes
may also force the FCC to raise the contribution factors for telecos from
8.7% to 10% -- which could help trigger Congressional reform of how
universal service funds are collected as constituents may start complaining
about higher phone bills. [Unfortunately for Republicans, they don't have
Al Gore to kick around for this anymore.] USAC also confirmed that it froze
the E-rate program in August and does not plan to make new funding
commitments until late November at the earliest. Committee Chairman John
McCain (R-AZ) proposed an additional hearing after the election.
[SOURCE: Communications Daily, AUTHOR: Howard Buskirk]
(Not available online)
See additional coverage:
Internet Grants Cut, and F.C.C. Scolded
[SOURCE: New York Times, AUTHOR: Stephen Labaton]
http://www.nytimes.com/2004/10/06/technology/06net.html
(requires registration)
PHONE GROUP HEAD RESIGNS AFTER UPROAR
John D. Windhausen Jr., president of the Association for Local
Telecommunication Services (know as ALTS which represents competitors of
the large regional telephone companies), resigned yesterday after an
internal memo was accidentally filed at the FCC and made available over the
Internet. The document starkly characterized the policy positions of FCC
members and lawmakers and described the need for the association to hire,
for $120,000 a year, a "heavyweight Republican [lobbyist] that can navigate
between the FCC chairman and the White House." The document, written by
Windhausen and presented recently to chief executives of his member
companies, was posted on the FCC Web site only briefly last week but was
there long enough to have been downloaded by communications lobbyists and
lawyers. It is now the talk of telecom insiders. Details of a lobbying
strategy -- and lobbyists' assessments of the officials they lobby -- are
usually top secret. Lawmakers and regulators exhibit a strong distaste for
any hint that interest groups are working to manipulate them, even though
that is precisely what lobbyists regularly do.
[SOURCE: Washington Post, AUTHOR: Jeffrey H. Birnbaum and Christopher Stern]
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/articles/A9726-2004Oct5.html
(requires registration)
SEVENTH CIRCUIT: MODEM-FEE CASE TO STATE COURT
The U.S Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit in Chicago on Friday ruled
that cable-modem litigation between the city of Chicago, Comcast Corp. and
other cable companies belongs in state court as a contract dispute. By
returning the case to state court, the Seventh Circuit panel did not give
Chicago the green light to collect cable-modem franchise fees. The city
still has to persuade a state court that its cable-franchise agreement
requires Comcast to pay the fees despite the FCC's classification of
cable-modem service as an interstate information service. After the FCC's
cable-modem-classification ruling in March 2002, cable operators stopping
paying cable-modem franchise fees. Some MSOs said they had to cease
payments because they feared class-action suits brought by subscribers.
[SOURCE: Multichannel News, AUTHOR: Ted Hearn]
http://www.multichannel.com/article/CA468474.html?display=Breaking+News
(requires subscription)
QUICKLY
POLITICAL GROUPS ARE BIG SPENDERS
Political parties, political action committees and independent groups spent
more than $60 million in September on advertising to influence the
presidential race. The unprecedented level of spending comes in a campaign
in which every fundraising record has been broken. See who's spending how
much at the URL below.
[SOURCE: Los Angeles Times, AUTHOR:Lisa Getter]
http://www.latimes.com/news/printedition/asection/la-na-money6oct06,1,64...
(requires registration)
IS THE PC A POLITICAL MACHINE?
As the presidential race turns red hot in the weeks leading up to Nov. 2,
political Web sites are popping up faster than political leaflets rolling
off the presses. Read about some examples at the URL below.
[SOURCE: C-Net|News.com, AUTHOR: Dawn Kawamoto]
http://news.com.com/Is+the+PC+a+political+machine/2100-1028_3-5397598.ht...
HOUSE APPROVES SPYWARE LEGISLATION
By a 399-1 vote, House members approved legislation prohibiting "taking
control" of a computer, surreptitiously modifying a Web browser's home
page, or disabling antivirus software without proper authorization. The Spy
Act would also create a complicated set of rules governing software capable
of transmitting information across the Internet. It would give the Federal
Trade Commission authority to police violations of the law and to levy
fines of up to $3 million in the most pernicious cases. A similar bill is
pending in the Senate. The lone "Nay" was cast by Rep Ron Paul (R-TX) a
vocal libertarian who frequently says the federal government should not be
policing the Internet.
[SOURCE: C|Net/News.com, AUTHOR: Declan McCullagh]
http://news.com.com/House+approves+spyware+legislation/2100-1028_3-53978...
FEDERAL COURT TO REHEAR EMAIL PRIVACY CASE
A federal court of appeals has announced it will rehear its earlier
decision that the wiretap laws do not apply to real-time interception of
email. CDT and three other organizations had urged the court to reconsider
its ruling in an amicus brief arguing that the original appeals court
decision potentially created a loophole for law enforcement and ISP access
to email.
[SOURCE: Center for Democracy and Technology]
http://www.cdt.org
There's more at the Electronic Privacy Information Center
http://www.epic.org/
USTA LAYS OUT KEY PRINCIPLES FOR TELECOM INDUSTRY WHOLESALE RULES
USTA filed comments with the FCC laying out three key principles for the
Commission to follow it its proceeding on wholesale rules: 1) the rules
must advance facilities-based competition; 2) the rules must be narrowly
tailored to avoid harming competition; and the new rules should provide
certainty and be effective immediately. USTA said, "The courts have
invalidated the FCC's approach three times in the past eight years. Yet,
each of these court rulings has provided the FCC with clear guidance
regarding what would constitute lawful unbundling rules. As a whole, these
decisions require the FCC to take into account real competition in various
markets and to compel unbundling only where competitors cannot compete
without access to certain incumbent local exchange carrier ("ILEC")
facilities. It should be absolutely clear now that the Commission is
required to follow the guidance of the courts in order to create lawful
unbundling rules."
[SOURCE: United States Telecom Association Press Release]
http://www.usta.org/news_releases.php?urh=home.news.nr2004_1005
TAXATION OF ONLINE SALES: COMPETING WITH THE STREAMLINED SALES TAX PROJECT
The Progress and Freedom Foundation released a new report Monday on the
Streamlined Sales Tax Project (SSTP), multi-state compact to harmonize
elements of state taxation. With the growth of e-commerce, state
governments have become increasingly concerned about the potential loss of
sales and use tax remissions on remote purchases by their residents.
[SOURCE: Progress and Freedom Foundation]
http://www.pff.org/news/news/2004/100404sstp.html
The Progress & Freedom Foundation is a market-oriented think tank that
studies the digital revolution and its implications for public policy.
FAIR is looking for a Development Director.
http://www.fair.org/posting.html
The Association for Progressive Communication's Karen Banks Wins Anita Borg
Award for Social Impact
The award recognizes significant and sustained contributions in technology.
http://www.apc.org/english/news/index.shtml?x=26581
CORRECTION: The Technology Opportunities Program can now be found online at
http://www.ntia.doc.gov/top/
--------------------------------------------------------------
Communications-related Headlines is a free online news summary service
provided by the Benton Foundation (www.benton.org). Posted Monday through
Friday, this service provides updates on important industry developments,
policy issues, and other related news events. While the summaries are
factually accurate, their often informal tone does not always represent the
tone of the original articles. Headlines are compiled by Kevin Taglang
(headlines( at )benton.org) -- we welcome your comments.
--------------------------------------------------------------