Daily Digest 10/15/2024 (Lilly McDaniel; Timothy Peter Johnson)

Benton Institute for Broadband & Society
Table of Contents

Broadband Funding

FCC announces six-month waiver to provide discounted phone and broadband service support for Hurricane Milton survivors and future storms  |  Read below  |  Marlene Dortch  |  Public Notice  |  Federal Communications Commission
Benton Foundation
Milton's Four Horses Ride Through Florida  |  Read below  |  Kevin Taglang  |  Analysis  |  Benton Institute for Broadband & Society
We're building more middle mile but it's not affordable enough  |  Read below  |  Masha Abarinova  |  Fierce
Beware these common pitfalls that can bedevil BEAD projects  |  Read below  |  Diana Goovaerts  |  Fierce
‘Last yard’ or ‘10-year slog’? Here's how BEAD is progressing in 4 states  |  Read below  |  Diana Goovaerts, Masha Abarinova  |  Fierce
Biden-Harris Administration Approves Alaska and Ohio’s "Internet for All" Initial Proposals  |  Read below  |  Press Release  |  National Telecommunications and Information Administration
Utah, Arizona broadband directors estimate BEAD high cost thresholds  |  Read below  |  Linda Hardesty  |  Fierce
Where's the broadband workforce? Waiting for the money  |  Read below  |  Diana Goovaerts  |  Fierce
Pennsylvania public spaces are getting $45 Million to boost internet access and close the digital divide  |  Read below  |  Sarah Huffman  |  Technical.ly
Governor Lamont Announces $28 Million To Increase Broadband Access in 88 Towns and Cities in Connecticut’  |  Read below  |  Press Release  |  Connecticut Department of Energy and Environmental Protection
Round 11 Awards in Indiana Connectivity Program  |  Read below  |  Press Release  |  Indiana Office of Community and Rural Affairs
Electric co-ops, USF, and rural broadband  |  Read below  |  Shirley Bloomfield  |  Editorial  |  NTCA-The Rural Broadband Association
With BEAD looming, workforce safety remains a big problem  |  Read below  |  Masha Abarinova  |  Fierce
To avoid fraud, NTIA will publish a list of certified Buy America compliant companies  |  Fierce
Kamala Harris’s Rural Broadband Flop  |  Read below  |  FCC Commissioner Brendan Carr  |  Op-Ed  |  Wall Street Journal

Wireless

FWA: Long-term play or short-term stopgap? Depends who you ask.  |  Read below  |  Diana Goovaerts  |  Fierce
AT&T proposes moving CBRS users via incentive auction  |  Read below  |  Mike Dano  |  Light Reading
Wireless Internet Providers Reap High Satisfaction Ratings in J.D. Power Study  |  telecompetitor

Security

It’s time to rethink how wiretaps work after Chinese hack, experts say  |  Read below  |  David DiMolfetta  |  nextgov

Copyright

Court Sides Against Grande Communications In Battle With Record Companies  |  Read below  |  Wendy Davis  |  MediaPost

Elections & Media

Inside Elon Musk’s plan to trigger a ‘red wave’ for Trump  |  Washington Post
Elon Musk Is Going All In to Elect Trump  |  New York Times

Energy

Google Backs New Nuclear Plants to Power AI  |  Wall Street Journal

Ownership

TPG Telecom Sells Fixed-Fiber Network to Vocus for A$5.25 Billion  |  Wall Street Journal

Kids & Media

Most Americans back cellphone bans during class, but fewer support all-day restrictions  |  Pew Research Center

Platforms/Social Media

TikTok knew app posed mental health risks for children, lawsuit alleges  |  Washington Post
Google Used Influence, Ultimatum to Cut California News Deal  |  Bloomberg
Social Media Tells You Who You Are. What if It's Totally Wrong?  |  Wired

A.I.

Readout of the Justice Department’s Interagency Convening on Advancing Equity in AI  |  US Department of Justice
Research | Generative AI, the American worker, and the future of work  |  Brookings

Stories From Abroad

Westminster’s reliance on Elon Musk’s X is ‘totally wrong’, says Labour MP  |  Guardian, The
Return of the landline: why gen Z – and scam artists – love old-fashioned phones  |  Guardian, The
‘I felt I had no choice’: why Deborah did her schoolwork using the shopping centre wifi  |  Guardian, The
Today's Top Stories

FCC announces six-month waiver to provide discounted phone and broadband service support for Hurricane Milton survivors and future storms

Marlene Dortch  |  Public Notice  |  Federal Communications Commission

The Federal Communications Commission took action to assist those affected by Hurricane Milton and future hurricanes, typhoons, tropical storms, and tropical cyclones (together, “tropical weather systems”) by temporarily waiving certain Lifeline program eligibility rules to ensure that consumers receiving federal disaster assistance can easily apply for and enroll in the Lifeline program. Hurricane Milton caused significant power and infrastructure disruptions, in addition to property damage in homes, schools, libraries, businesses, and healthcare facilities in impacted areas. Because of the exigent circumstances that arose from Hurricane Milton, the FCC finds that there is good cause for further action to expeditiously ensure that households receive critical assistance for their communications needs in the aftermath of hurricanes and other tropical weather systems in the near term. The FCC temporarily waived the Lifeline eligibility requirements to permit households not already enrolled in the Lifeline program to enter the program if they are receiving individual assistance from the Federal Emergency Management Agency’s (FEMA) Individuals and Households Program (IHP) as a result of the impacts of Hurricane Milton or other hurricanes or other tropical weather systems that result in a Presidential declaration of emergency or major disaster that occur during the next six months.  Such waiver will run for at least six months from the date of the declaration. 

Milton's Four Horses Ride Through Florida

Kevin Taglang  |  Analysis  |  Benton Institute for Broadband & Society

Tornadoes, heavy rain, hurricane-force wind, and storm surge. Any of these could devastate a community. Hurricane Milton delivered them all to Florida earlier this month. Milton made landfall on October 9 in Siesta Key, south of Sarasota, as a Category 3 hurricane and continued out to the Atlantic as a Category 1 the next morning. The storm dropped nearly two feet of rain in some areas, causing flooding inland and adding more water onto the storm surge that was hitting parts of both coasts. Sustained winds were 120 miles per hour, toppling trees and ripping the roof off of Tropicana Field, where first responders were staging operations and thousands of people were taking shelter. More than 3 million people lost power across the state. The National Weather Service counted 45 reports of tornadoes across the southern half of the state. According to network outage data submitted by communications providers to the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) Disaster Information Reporting System (DIRS), as of 9 a.m. (EDT) October 10 over twelve percent of cell sites in areas impacted by Hurricane Milton were out of service, mostly due to a lack of power. The counties impacted most were Sarasota and Polk, where nearly half of all cell sites were down, along with Hardee, Highlands, Manatee, and Pinellas where at least a third of cell sites were down. Cable and wireline companies reported 1,273,354 subscribers out of service in the disaster area, including the loss of telephone, television, and/or internet services. Florida, of course, knows firsthand how extreme weather can have an adverse effect on infrastructure. Due to its location and unique geographical ecosystems, the state faces unique weather risks and hazards that can cause damage to broadband infrastructure or delay its deployment. Florida has always been more vulnerable to hurricanes and tropical storms than any other U.S. state because its exposed, southern location is surrounded by warm waters. There are almost twice as many hurricanes that hit Florida as Texas, the second most impacted state. But shifting atmosphere and ocean conditions are making hurricane season even worse for Floridians. As Milton illustrates, natural disasters can severely damage broadband infrastructure, causing network failures that interrupt the continuity of many commercial, governmental, and social activities. The Broadband Equity, Access, and Deployment (BEAD) Program requires states and territories to plan for how BEAD-funded networks will withstand climate-related disasters.

We're building more middle mile but it's not affordable enough

Masha Abarinova  |  Fierce

The federal government has set aside $42 billion to connect last-mile communities and just under $1 billion for the middle mile networks that will provide the backbone to reach those unserved homes. But that's not enough money to cover the cost of building middle mile infrastructure, some say. The business case for building rural fiber, especially middle mile, “is not fantastic.” The problem is that in order for last-mile deployments to be successful, you need that reliable middle-mile backbone plus the additional circuits and fiber paths that come with it, said Nate Walowitz, regional broadband program director at the Northwest Colorado Council of Governments. Regional governments could lend a helping hand in making the middle-mile more affordable, he went on to say. Say two companies want to build a middle-mile network in the same region, “why can’t they work together?” That way, these middle-mile providers “each have a fair shot” and can gain access to each of the markets on the network’s path, thus being able to connect more unserved folks.

Beware these common pitfalls that can bedevil BEAD projects

Diana Goovaerts  |  Fierce

Procurement, permitting and people. Those are the three Ps to remember if you want to ensure a smooth broadband build. Steven Greene, Technical Program Manager at the Utah Broadband Center, said broadband builders often assume they can readily get the supplies they need for their projects. But without a solid procurement plan in place, shortages can quickly become problematic. That’s especially true of upcoming Broadband Equity, Access, and Deployment (BEAD) projects. Steve Kristan, Lumos Fiber’s Director of Market Development for the state of Ohio, pointed to permitting as another key hurdle. Kristan also said builders should use lidar technology to assess the lay of the land underground rather than relying on municipal records, which are often inaccurate. And when builders inevitably hit a buried gas or power line, that’s when relationships with the people in local markets will really matter.

‘Last yard’ or ‘10-year slog’? Here's how BEAD is progressing in 4 states

Diana Goovaerts, Masha Abarinova  |  Fierce

The good news about the Broadband Equity, Access, and Deployment (BEAD) program? Shovels could be in the ground in some states as soon as next summer. The bad news? One state official said it likely won’t be able to finish its subgrantee selection process until 2026 and dubbed BEAD a “10-year slog.” Here’s everything you need to know about what officials from Nevada, New York, Massachusetts and North Dakota said about the program:

  • Nevada is using a combination of “13 or 14 different funding sources” to construct a 2,500-mile middle-mile network that will be deployed “within 10 miles of 80% of our unserved locations in the state.”
  • New York: Joshua Brietbart, SVP of ConnectALL at Empire State Development, said New York is still going through its challenge process results but so far it’s identified about 95,000 locations for BEAD.
  • Massachusetts: While it waits for the gears of government to turn on the BEAD front, Baldino said the state decided to allocate a portion of the $175 million it received in Capital Projects Fund money from the federal government to preemptively start closing that gap via the aptly-named Gap Networks Grant Program.
  • North Dakota has about 5,000 locations it needs to reach with BEAD money. But unlike Nevada and Massachusetts, it hasn’t yet decided how to set its project sizes. That’s in part because the state isn’t really sure who—if anyone—will bid.

Biden-Harris Administration Approves Alaska and Ohio’s "Internet for All" Initial Proposals

The Department of Commerce’s National Telecommunications and Information Administration (NTIA) has approved Alaska and Ohio’s Initial Proposals for the Broadband Equity, Access, and Deployment (BEAD) program. The approval enables Alaska and Ohio to request access to funding and begin implementation of the BEAD program. This action allows states to request:  

  • Alaska: Over $1 billion
  • Ohio: Over $793 million

Utah, Arizona broadband directors estimate BEAD high cost thresholds

Linda Hardesty  |  Fierce

At what point is it too expensive to deploy fiber? That's a key question for Broadband Equity, Access, and Deployment (BEAD) Program participants looking to deploy alternative technologies in hard to reach areas of the country. To hear state broadband officials for Utah and Arizona tell it, the magic number will likely be between $10,000 and $15,000 per passing. Rebecca Dilg, director of Utah’s Broadband Center, said the state’s high-cost threshold for fiber would probably be $13,000 to $15,000 although this is just an estimate until the state starts seeing “results from proposals.” Sandip Bhowmick, Arizona’s state broadband director, said, “Anything less than $10,000, we will probably go with fiber. Anything over that we’ll probably switch over to alternate technology.” He said any passing costing more than $15,000, which he described as a very high-cost level, will “definitely be satellite.” Dilg noted that the National Telecommunications and Information Administration (NTIA) has a preference for fiber, so anything that is fiber will get higher points in Utah’s BEAD scoring process. She said the broadband office would be “promoting and wanting to get fiber as far and as much as we can.” But the state is not likely to have sufficient funding to deploy fiber everywhere. In Arizona, the broadband office wants to make sure that whatever technology is deployed will be sustainable to operate. Bhowmick said it wouldn’t make sense to deploy fiber in very sparsely populated areas. For instance, he said areas where it would require 10 miles of fiber to serve two households wouldn’t make sense because “no one would be managing that” in the future. “We’re seeing things more from a sustainably perspective,” he said.

Where's the broadband workforce? Waiting for the money

Diana Goovaerts  |  Fierce

State officials have been working hard to suss out what kinds of skills ISPs need and how best to attract and train up new workers, said Edyn Rolls, Chief Strategic Officer for the Oklahoma Broadband Office. For instance, Oklahoma State University conducted a nationwide study to identify what areas of the broadband workforce need the biggest boost, she said. GIS mapping and engineering skills would be most in demand, the study found. But state officials have five years to finish their BEAD projects and an engineering degree takes four years to obtain — meaning it'll take almost as long to finish training the workforce as they have to finish the work according to the Broadband Equity, Access, and Deployment (BEAD) Program timeline. So, figuring out how to align the need with the training required has been a challenge. A total of 174,800 construction workers and 186,900 technicians will be needed to execute BEAD builds, according to a recent study commissioned by the Workforce Development for the Fiber Broadband Association, noted director Todd Jackson. However, there’s expected to be a shortage of 28,000 workers on the construction side and 30,000 on the technician side between 2025 and 2030.

Pennsylvania public spaces are getting $45 Million to boost internet access and close the digital divide

Sarah Huffman  |  Technical.ly

Public spaces across Pennsylvania are about to get an internet upgrade. The Pennsylvania Broadband Development Authority (PBDA) announced $45 million in funding for the Multi-Purpose Community Facilities Program, which provides money to community organizations and local governments to upgrade public facilities. The program will provide grants to 49 projects in 26 counties across the commonwealth. The grants will go toward building and improving public spaces such as schools, libraries, community centers and healthcare facilities for free, high-speed internet. Seven projects in Philadelphia were approved for funding, including two projects from the City of Philadelphia’s Office of Innovation and Technology (OIT), which received $2 million in grants.

Governor Lamont Announces $28 Million To Increase Broadband Access in 88 Towns and Cities in Connecticut’

Governor Ned Lamont (D-CT) and Connecticut Department of Energy and Environmental Protection (DEEP) Commissioner Katie Dykes announced the release of $28 million in grants awarded under the first round of the state’s ConneCTed Communities Grant Program. Administered by DEEP, these grants will support the buildout of broadband infrastructure in more than half of Connecticut’s communities. A total of 88 cities and towns in the state, including 26 on the state’s Distressed Municipalities list, will benefit from the grants under this initial round. The funding comes from Connecticut’s portion of American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) Capital Project Fund dollars, which is designed to support access to high-speed internet by funding infrastructure projects to support the goal of universal access to affordable, resilient, and reliable broadband. A total of $40.8 million is available for this program.

Applicant

Project Area

Number of Locations in Project

Grant Funding

Comcast

Statewide across 75 municipalities

2,099

$21,262,269.00

Verizon

Greenwich

148

$1,815,488.00

GoNetspeed

East Windsor

237

$836,718.75

GoNetspeed

Meriden

46

$206,452.50

Frontier Communications

Sharon-Cornwall

148

$953,909.00

Frontier Communications             

Putnam-Killingly

196

$837,400.00

Frontier Communications

East Lyme

53

$837,734.00

Frontier Communications             

Salem

182

$359,184.00

Frontier Communications

Sterling-Plainfield

138

$434,521.00

Frontier Communications

Torrington

32

$204,030.00

Frontier Communications

Waterford

41

$225,116.00

TOTAL

3,320

$27,972,822.25

Round 11 Awards in Indiana Connectivity Program

The Indiana Connectivity Program announced the 11th round of awards on Oct. 8, 2024. The 11th round of the program awarded $1,489,320 to expand broadband to 326 addresses across 34 counties. Of these addresses, 310 are homes and 16 are businesses. Internet providers carrying out the projects matched $5,286,195 for a total investment of $6,775,515.

Provider

Addresses

Grant Amount

Airwave Networks, LLC 9 $35,500
Auburn Essential Services 5 $24,000
Berry Communications 1 $4,800
Joink Inc. 17 $61,412
Mulberry Telecommunications 41 $196,800
PSC Fiber 41 $149,208
SEI Communications 4 $19,200
Surf Internet 208 $998,400

Total Awarded

326 $1,489,320

Electric co-ops, USF, and rural broadband

Shirley Bloomfield  |  Editorial  |  NTCA-The Rural Broadband Association

At the Connected Oklahoma – Rural Broadband Summit in Oklahoma City, I shared my thoughts on the future of the Universal Service Fund (USF) and Low Earth Orbit satellites. Here's the homework I asked the audience to do:

  1. Reach out to your anchor institutions and see how you might partner together.
  2. If you are an electric co-op, reach out to an NTCA member to see how you might create some scope and scale and what you can do better together.
  3. If you’re a policymaker, dig deeper to understand how the USF impacts your consumers' rates and deployment plans and plan to join our fight for the preservation and future of the program.
  4. If you are a Smart Rural Community (SRC) provider, engage your community more on the ownership they should take for the successes you help power in the community and fully utilize that platform. For those who aren’t SRC providers, it’s important to still find ways to tell your story. Storytelling is among our most powerful tools, and it’s important to stop being modest about the work you are doing.

[Shirley Bloomfield is chief executive officer of NTCA–The Rural Broadband Association]

With BEAD looming, workforce safety remains a big problem

Masha Abarinova  |  Fierce

The United States needs way more workers to support the upcoming flurry of federal-funded broadband projects. But the broadband industry’s also got catching up to do with its labor standards. In fact, the Broadband Equity, Access, and Deployment (BEAD) program is the first federal broadband grant program with “any type of language” concerning labor practice requirements, according to Marcus Chambers, network telecom technician for CWA and state broadband lead for Maryland. Both broadband work quality and workers’ safety have been on a downswing for years. For CWA’s part, it offers OSHA-10 Construction courses to employers and schools that are training broadband technicians. It also encourages new technicians to “shadow” veteran technicians on-the-job, so workers aren’t just learning from “by-the-book material.”

Kamala Harris’s Rural Broadband Flop

FCC Commissioner Brendan Carr  |  Op-Ed  |  Wall Street Journal

In 2021 Vice President Kamala Harris (D-CA) agreed to lead the administration’s $42 billion plan for expanding high-speed internet to millions of Americans. That year, she tweeted that “we can bring broadband to rural America today.” Today, nearly three years after Congress passed the infrastructure bill that created the program, not one home or business has been connected through it. The Biden-Harris administration recently confirmed that construction projects won’t begin until next year at the earliest, and in many cases not until 2026. Instead of focusing on delivering broadband to unserved areas, the administration has used the program to advance a wish list of political goals. It has adopted regulations that include diversity, equity and inclusion requirements, climate-change rules, price controls, preferences for union labor, and schemes that favor government-run networks. The administration has been handing out wins to favored political groups rather than delivering results. In 2020 Elon Musk’s satellite service, Starlink, won an $885 million award from the Federal Communications Commission to offer high-speed internet to more than 640,000 rural homes and businesses. By a 2023 vote along party lines, the FCC revoked the award. As I noted in my dissent at the time, the FCC’s revocation couldn’t be explained by any objective application of the facts, the law or sound policy. In my view, it amounted to nothing more than regulatory lawfare against one of the left’s top targets: Musk. Rural communities stuck on the wrong side of the digital divide are paying the price.

[Carr is a Republican FCC commissioner.]

FWA: Long-term play or short-term stopgap? Depends who you ask.

Diana Goovaerts  |  Fierce

AT&T is ramping up its efforts around fixed wireless (FWA) access this year, but doesn’t seem to have changed its mind that the tech is fundamentally a bridge to better things. However, not everyone shares the view that FWA should be relegated to a stopgap. AT&T AVP Angela Wilkin highlighted AT&T’s efforts to expand its Internet Air consumer FWA product across the parts of 48 states and the operator's introduction of a business version of the tech earlier this year. However, when asked what the long-term strategy for Internet Air is, she said that “in a lot of cases, it’s a bridge” for customers—particularly those on legacy copper lines—until they gain access to fiber. That said, she acknowledged that, at least in some areas, relief from fiber will never come. And in those few instances, customers could continue to use Internet Air.

AT&T proposes moving CBRS users via incentive auction

Mike Dano  |  Light Reading

AT&T is urging the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) to move existing CBRS spectrum users to a different portion of the 3GHz band. The company said the FCC could do so by conducting an incentive auction and using the proceeds from that auction to finance the relocation of current CBRS operations. "We propose an incentive auction that builds upon the success of the FCC's prior incentive auctions in the 600 MHz and 39 GHz bands," AT&T argued on its website, in a post by Rhonda Johnson, AT&T's EVP of Federal Regulatory Relations. AT&T's broad goal is to free up the 3.55GHz-3.7GHz band for high-power, licensed operations—the kind of operations its 5G network currently uses. 

It’s time to rethink how wiretaps work after Chinese hack, experts say

David DiMolfetta  |  nextgov

Cybersecurity experts say a recent Chinese intrusion into major U.S. broadband providers’ systems means that it’s time for regulators to rethink a cornerstone law that, for 30 years, has required communications firms to engineer their systems to allow for law enforcement agencies to intercept targets’ communications through wiretapping. The break-ins, which may have compromised some of the most sensitive national security data on domestic surveillance targets, have raised questions about the security architecture of the backdoor installations enabled by the the Communications Assistance for Law Enforcement Act — or CALEA — which passed in 1994. The break-in should push the U.S. to consider fresh standards for wiretap security protocols, said John Ackerly, a former White House official who managed the George W. Bush administration’s tech policy portfolio. “I don’t think it’s the question of giving government more access, but I think it’s a lot more clarity about what the standards are around the security and where there are back doors — those have to be really tight,” said Ackerly who now heads Virtru, a firm that offers data security services. “The vast majority of these requests are trying to keep us safe.” Apparently, the Federal Communications Commission has requested a briefing from national security officials about the intrusion

Court Sides Against Grande Communications In Battle With Record Companies

Wendy Davis  |  MediaPost

Siding with the record industry, a federal appellate court has upheld a finding that Grande Communications contributed to copyright infringement by failing to disconnect internet subscribers who were accused of unlawfully sharing music. A three-judge panel of the 5th Circuit Court of Appeals said Grande (now owned by Astound Broadband) either knew or was willfully blind to identities of infringing subscribers, yet “made the choice to continue providing services to them anyway, rather than taking simple measures to prevent infringement.” The ruling comes in a battle dating to 2017, when Universal Music Group, Warner Records, and other record companies accused Grande of contributing to piracy by failing to take “meaningful action” against alleged file-sharers. The record companies' complaint, brought in federal court in Austin, alleged that the internet provider allowed “repeat infringers to use the Grande service to continue to infringe plaintiffs’ copyrights without consequence.”

Submit a Story

Benton (www.benton.org) provides the only free, reliable, and non-partisan daily digest that curates and distributes news related to universal broadband, while connecting communications, democracy, and public interest issues. Posted Monday through Friday, this service provides updates on important industry developments, policy issues, and other related news events. While the summaries are factually accurate, their sometimes informal tone may not always represent the tone of the original articles. Headlines are compiled by Kevin Taglang (headlines AT benton DOT org), Grace Tepper (grace AT benton DOT org), and Zoe Walker (zwalker AT benton DOT org) — we welcome your comments.


© Benton Institute for Broadband & Society 2024. Redistribution of this email publication — both internally and externally — is encouraged if it includes this message. For subscribe/unsubscribe info email: headlines AT benton DOT org


Kevin Taglang

Kevin Taglang
Executive Editor, Communications-related Headlines
Benton Institute
for Broadband & Society
1041 Ridge Rd, Unit 214
Wilmette, IL 60091
847-220-4531
headlines AT benton DOT org

Share this edition:

Benton Institute for Broadband & Society Benton Institute for Broadband & Society Benton Institute for Broadband & Society

Benton Institute for Broadband & Society

The Benton Institute for Broadband & Society All Rights Reserved © 2024