Daily Digest 10/5/2022 (Loretta Webb)

Benton Institute for Broadband & Society
Table of Contents

Digital Equity

Benton Foundation
What's Our Vision of Digital Equity?  |  Read below  |  Adrianne Furniss, Andrew Coy  |  Editorial  |  Benton Institute for Broadband & Society
Audio: How the FCC and local libraries are addressing "digital redlining"  |  Connecticut Public Radio

Broadband Funding

More Than 235 Applications Submitted to the Biden-Harris Administration’s “Internet for All” Middle Mile Grant Program  |  Read below  |  Press Release  |  National Telecommunications and Information Administration
     Deputy Secretary of Commerce Don Graves Regarding Extending “Internet for All” Middle Mile Program in Puerto Rico  |  Department of Commerce
Major Federal Funding to Close the Digital Divide Won’t Succeed Without Philanthropic Support  |  Read below  |  Lynette Bell, Larry Irving  |  Op-Ed  |  Chronicle of Philanthropy
Tracking the Funds: Specific Fiscal Year 2022 Provisions for U.S. Department of Agriculture  |  Government Accountability Office

MDU Broadband

Bulk Internet Services Take Hold in Multifamily Broadband  |  Read below  |  Sean Buckley  |  Broadband Communities
MDUs: The Numbers Look Good, But It’s Too Soon to Tell  |  Read below  |  Steven Ross  |  Analysis  |  Broadband Communities
Op-Ed: Everything Is Coming Up Bulk  |  Broadband Communities

FCC Reform

Resounding Silence: The Need for Local Insights in Federal Broadband Policymaking  |  Read below  |  Ryan Johnston  |  Analysis  |  Next Century Cities

Twitter & Musk

Elon Musk offers to buy Twitter for original price, weeks before trial  |  Washington Post
Elon Musk is buying Twitter: Twitter accepts offer for $54.20 a share before court battle  |  USA Today
Who is Elon Musk? What to know about the Tesla CEO who appears poised to buy Twitter.  |  USA Today
Elon Musk may soon own Twitter. What will it look like if he does?  |  Washington Post
How Twitter employees are reacting to today’s Elon Musk news  |  Vox
Everything we know about Elon Musk’s messy new Twitter offer  |  Vox
Everything we don’t know about Elon Musk’s latest about-face on Twitter  |  Los Angeles Times
Kevin Roose: Elon Musk’s Twitter Will Be a Wild Ride  |  New York Times
Holman Jenkins: Twitter’s Odd Victory Over Elon Musk  |  Wall Street Journal

Labor

The NLRB alleges that Apple “discriminated against employees” trying to unionize  |  Vox

Privacy

Google to Pay $85 Million to End Arizona Consumer-Privacy Suit  |  Bloomberg

Content

Rights holders got Google to remove 6 billion links from Search over 10 years  |  Ars Technica

Company/Industry News

AT&T Launching Campaign to Help Close the Digital Divide  |  Read below  |  Press Release  |  AT&T
Fast Forward: What makes our network different?  |  Read below  |  Thomas Feilmeier  |  Press Release  |  Google
Here’s how MetroNet is winning over mayors as fiber competition intensifies  |  Read below  |  Diana Goovaerts  |  Fierce
Nextlink Adds 10 Gbps Fiber to Its Arsenal  |  Read below  |  Joan Engebretson  |  telecompetitor
Committing to Sustainability Through Fiber  |  Read below  |  Deborah Kish  |  Op-Ed  |  Broadband Communities
Brightspeed becomes 5th largest US ILEC through Lumen deal  |  Read below  |  Diana Goovaerts  |  Fierce
Micron’s investing $100 billion to bring the country’s ‘largest semiconductor fabrication facility’ to New York  |  Verge, The
TikTok reports $1 Billion turnover across international markets  |  Guardian, The

Stories From Abroad

Reviewing case related to Iran  |  Facebook Oversight Board
Long-awaited common charger for mobile devices will be a reality in 2024  |  European Parliament
Development of the ICT sector and the determinants of Internet use in the Southern Caucasus  |  Telecommunications Policy
Today's Top Stories

Digital Equity

What's Our Vision of Digital Equity?

Adrianne Furniss, Andrew Coy  |  Editorial  |  Benton Institute for Broadband & Society

This is Digital Inclusion Week 2022, a time to raise awareness of solutions addressing home internet access, personal devices, and local technology training and support programs. The theme this year, Turning Our Moment into Movement, is so apt because, as expansive as our efforts are, it will take a sustained effort to close our digital divides. The Benton Institute for Broadband & Society is committed to working alongside the hundreds of other organizations across the United States that are advancing digital equity. As states, tribes and territories begin planning to use Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act support to connect everyone via high-speed internet access, one overarching requirement is that they each write their vision of digital equity. The exercise is a powerful opportunity to think some years down the line and envision how our lives, communities, economy, and society can be transformed through successful implementation of the Act. In recognition of the work states, tribes and territories have before them—as well as the role communities must play to inform their plans—the Benton Institute is launching a national dialogue to engage our community of advocates to contribute to a publication that outlines a collective vision of digital equity.

As a first phase of this process, we are inviting the digital equity community to join us on October 11th at 11am ET (REGISTRATION LINK) for a conversation and to provide input in a short, 10-question survey: https://www.menti.com/qj1oj3dij4

[Adrianne B. Furniss is the Executive Director of the Benton Institute for Broadband & Society. David Coy is the founder of Initial Velocity and executive director of the Digital Harbor Foundation in Baltimore, Maryland.]

Broadband Funding

More Than 235 Applications Submitted to the Biden-Harris Administration’s “Internet for All” Middle Mile Grant Program

The Department of Commerce’s National Telecommunications and Information Administration (NTIA) released preliminary data that shows over 235 applications were submitted totaling more than $5.5 billion in funding requests for the Enabling Middle Mile Infrastructure Grant Program. Included in President Biden’s “Internet for All” initiative, the Middle Mile grant program provides $1 billion in funding to projects that connect high-speed Internet networks to each other and reduce the cost of bringing Internet service to communities that lack it. Applications for the Middle Mile program were due by September 30, 2022. NTIA will evaluate the applications and make awards on a rolling basis no earlier than March 2023.  Additionally, NTIA has temporarily waived the application deadline for eligible entities that submit Middle Mile Grant Program applications for projects that would deploy middle mile infrastructure in Puerto Rico as well as parts of Florida, South Carolina, and Alaska impacted by natural disasters. The deadline for such applications is 11:59 p.m. EDT, November 1, 2022. More information can be found here

Major Federal Funding to Close the Digital Divide Won’t Succeed Without Philanthropic Support

Lynette Bell, Larry Irving  |  Op-Ed  |  Chronicle of Philanthropy

If the Broadband Equity, Access, and Deployment, or BEAD, program is to be a game changer for digital equity, grant makers must ensure government dollars go where they’re needed most. They should start by looking at the growing movement of community connectivity providers whose primary purpose is to help people meet their digital needs at affordable prices. These municipal and community networks and social enterprises are demonstrating that they can deliver low-cost, high-speed internet for all households. All but one of the 10 fastest internet service providers in the United States run on municipal or community-owned broadband infrastructure. While such providers are in a far better position than big telecom companies to reach America’s least connected communities, they have historically lacked access to the necessary financial capital. BEAD is an opportunity to inject billions of dollars to overcome those funding challenges. But these community connectivity providers need far greater support to stand a chance of competing for government dollars against big telecom. A new study from the nonprofit Connect Humanity, on whose board we both serve, found that just 0.05 percent of overall giving from large U.S. foundations went to digital-equity programs from 2010 to 2019. Now is exactly the moment for grant makers to step up their support for these efforts.

[Lynette Bell is president of the Truist Foundation and serves on the board of Connect Humanity. Larry Irving served as assistant secretary of commerce and head of the agency’s National Telecommunications and Information Administration under President Clinton. He is a board member of Connect Humanity.]

MDU Broadband

Bulk Internet Services Take Hold in Multifamily Broadband

Sean Buckley  |  Broadband Communities

Multifamily property owners want to make broadband an amenity available to residents as part of their rental agreements. They’re working hard to enter into bulk service agreements with service providers. Commonplace for cable television, these deals are between a homeowners association or condominium association and a company to deliver internet services to everyone who is a community member. Bulk internet services provide several benefits for multifamily owners/operators and residents:

  • Lower Costs: Bulk broadband services are provided to residents at a lower price than they would be if customers purchased them from a provider on a retail basis. Though savings vary, bulk internet costs up to 50 percent less than a homeowner would pay for the same services individually.
  • Association Budgets Revenue: A provider usually recompenses an owner a one-time payment based on an agreed amount per unit. The property owner can use those funds to upgrade the property.
  • Service Quality: With a bulk service model, every resident gets guaranteed service performance.
  • Dedicated Customer Service: A bulk broadband provider can provide a “white glove” customer service experience.
  • Consistent Pricing, Service: Every resident served by a bulk internet agreement gets the same service and price. Moreover, the monthly rate is locked in for several years.

Service providers are taking charge of this opportunity as broadband becomes the critical amenity residents desire when they look at a property.

MDUs: The Numbers Look Good, But It’s Too Soon to Tell

Steven Ross  |  Analysis  |  Broadband Communities

Construction of apartments in large, multiple-dwelling-unit (MDU) buildings by nongovernmental builders could set another record this year. Builders received more than 18,000 permits for MDUs with five dwelling units or more in 2021. The properties would contain 552,000 dwelling units, up from 532,000 in 2020. That’s great news for broadband deployers – MDUs are now almost always designed for fiber, and connecting an apartment is far less expensive than stringing fiber along streets and tying it to single-family homes through individual drops. New MDU construction has been the sweet spot for broadband deployments since the 1990s, specifically for fiber deployments. But only about half of new construction has used fiber since the technology became widely available 15 years ago. Now that is quickly changing. COVID-19 is the main reason. It directly brought more work, education, and even health care to many households. It also got federal subsidies, lower-cost deployment technology, cheap financing, and new municipal concern: resilience against future pandemics. Thus, even the least-technologically savvy developers have prioritized broadband since mid-2020. However, incomplete Census data and other related factors that may affect reporting on new MDU construction numbers clouds an accurate picture of broadband needs for MDU owners and managers. The best advice is for existing MDU owners and managers to survey the needs of their tenants and prospective tenants.

FCC Reform

Resounding Silence: The Need for Local Insights in Federal Broadband Policymaking

Ryan Johnston  |  Analysis  |  Next Century Cities

In the past, the Federal Communication Commission has made sweeping changes that have impacted communities without local input. The federal government is now poised to do the same again. This paper examines the public comment process at the FCC and whether municipal filers ultimately influence the Commission’s decisions. This paper suggests that the FCC must improve its community outreach efforts, specifically through the following suggestions: 

  • Fully Staff the Office of Intergovernmental Affairs: Appointing a permanent chief and the necessary associate and deputy chiefs will give the OIA the leadership to plan and execute the outreach programs needed to spread awareness of FCC programs.
  • Appoint More Local Officials to Commission Advisory Committees: Ensuring that there are a designated number of seats available for industry, state, local, Tribal, and other potential stakeholders could increase the likelihood that all opinions can be heard and considered fairly.
  • Provide Direction on the Substantive and Procedural Requirements for Filing Comments: Many communities unfamiliar with the process may struggle to understand whether the letter they intend to submit will be considered due to improper formatting. A brief explanation of what is expected could help ameliorate those potential concerns.

Ultimately, the paper posits that these recommendations combined help to ensure that the FCC uses its administrative resources to conduct necessary outreach and fulfills its promise to collaborate with communities nationwide

Company News

AT&T Launching Campaign to Help Close the Digital Divide

Press Release  |  AT&T

As part of our $2 billion commitment from 2021 to 2023 to help close the digital divide, AT&T is launching the Bridge to Possibility: Closing the digital divide, together campaign. It is a month-long, company-wide initiative to drive awareness of the digital divide and the collective response needed to address it. We must demonstrate how broadband connectivity tangibly improves lives. We’ll share stories of how we’re continuously tackling the challenges of access, affordability, and adoption. Additionally, thousands of AT&T employees and our Employee Groups (EGs) will mobilize to give back to their communities. We’ll recognize their commitment to social good with city celebrations where employees will assemble 10,000 connected learning kits for students in need and host device distributions across the nation, along with additional volunteer activities.

Fast Forward: What makes our network different?

Thomas Feilmeier  |  Press Release  |  Google

From the start, Google Fiber was designed to bring you Internet - fiber optic Internet. One of the benefits of fiber is that the material withstands the challenges of time, distance, and natural elements, and it can be upgraded (at higher speeds) quickly by changing the optical equipment at the endpoints. What makes Google Fiber different from other fiber internet providers lies not in the types of fiber we use, but in the way we design our core network and the operational disciplines we use that focus on the Customer Experience. First, we design a core backbone architecture (think city to city) that has multiple layers of redundancy to provide a high level of network reliability. Google Fiber’s network offers 99.9%* reliable connection, which is in large part due to the way our backbone network is built and managed.  Our core backbone network is designed with multiple layers of resiliency. Another way that we ensure our Customers get the speed and content they need is by large-scale peering and localized caching within our network.  We peer directly with the largest media and content providers (in fact, we’ll peer with anyone who is willing to peer with us, and we don’t use peering for revenue generation); this allows us to obtain and deliver content very quickly. Finally, we place the utmost importance on Customer Experience. We have a highly disciplined change management process and we continually measure, study and improve to drive higher reliability.

Here’s how MetroNet is winning over mayors as fiber competition intensifies

Diana Goovaerts  |  Fierce

MetroNet's focus on building quickly and considerately is helping it win over mayors and other local officials in an increasingly competitive fiber market. The operator currently has construction underway in all 14 of the states where it operates, with work covering more than 90 cities. States with the most projects include North Carolina, Minnesota, and Iowa. But MetroNet isn’t just focused on building contiguous markets; it is increasingly targeting underserved tier 2 cities across the country, with its market identification team already in conversations with officials in states outside of its current territory. Over the next year and beyond, MetroNet expects to add several new states to its construction list. As it works to lock in new build targets, it is having conversations with city officials behind the scenes that have changed. While there was a time when MetroNet was entering cities as the only fiber provider, it’s increasingly going into markets where smaller regional fiber players are making inroads and city officials have more fiber options to choose from. MetroNet proactively invites residents to mark out underground systems with flags the company provides and allows citizens to submit questions and concerns via an online ticketing system. It also pays for any restoration work itself, he said. The idea of all of this, he said, is to make construction as painless as possible for both municipal officials and residents alike.

Nextlink Adds 10 Gbps Fiber to Its Arsenal

Joan Engebretson  |  telecompetitor

Nextlink, one of the biggest winners in the Rural Digital Opportunity Fund (RDOF) auction, will be using 10 Gbps XGS-PON fiber broadband infrastructure from Nokia to connect 200,000 homes in 12 states; including 6 states that it already serves and 6 new states. XGS-PON fiber technology can be easily upgraded to 25 Gbps in the future. In winning the most recent RDOF auction, Nextlink is being called on to use a combination of fiber broadband and fixed wireless to provide service at speeds as high as 1 Gbps. The 12 states where Nextlink will be deploying the Nokia XGS-PON equipment are Texas, Indiana, Wisconsin, Minnesota, Wyoming, Louisiana, Oklahoma, Kansas, Nebraska, Illinois, Iowa, and South Dakota.

Committing to Sustainability Through Fiber

Deborah Kish  |  Op-Ed  |  Broadband Communities

Fiber internet service providers and manufacturers across the US have been building their strategies toward sustainability since as early as 2015. The evolution from hardware-based to software-based networks began in the early 2000s. That was a step toward energy efficiency, lower carbon emissions, a smaller eco-footprint, and the use of more environmentally friendly materials. As the technology evolved, so did environmental, social, and governance (ESG) strategies. However, one type of network infrastructure has always been sustainable: fiber optics. And it’s not just about clean energy. Fiber’s contribution to global sustainability goes above and beyond other broadband technologies because of its unlimited capacity, reliability, and societal benefits. Fiber optics has aided in the sustainable operation of precision farming, wastewater treatment plants, telemedicine, and more. Additionally, the low latency and unlimited capacity of fiber broadband mean it has the power and speed needed to transmit data that informs the communications systems of the required action; which has accelerated the efficiency and effectiveness of educational institutions, thus positively affecting innovation. Ultimately, the societal benefits of fiber – health, safety, education, etc. – are clear.

[Deborah Kish is the vice president of research and workforce development for the Fiber Broadband Association.]

Brightspeed becomes 5th largest US ILEC through Lumen deal

Diana Goovaerts  |  Fierce

After more than a year of waiting, Brightspeed finally closed on a $7.5 billion deal to acquire Lumen Technologies’ telecommunications assets in 20 states via its parent company Apollo Global Management. The operator is looking to make a name for itself as a new, better broadband provider through a laser focus on simplicity and customer service as it steps out into the world as the newly-minted fifth largest incumbent local exchange carrier (ILEC) in the US. The company’s acquired territory includes 6.5 million locations spread across the Midwest and Southeast as well as parts of Pennsylvania and New Jersey in the Northeast. The vast majority of its footprint is currently served with copper, but Brightspeed unveiled a plan to spend $2 billion to deploy fiber to at least 3 million locations over the course of several years. In recent months, it has detailed build plans spanning more than 1 million locations across 17 states. Once fiber is up and running in each market, Brightspeed plans to offer service tiers providing symmetrical speeds of 200 Mbps, 500 Mbps, 1 Gbps or 2 Gbps. Brightspeed will be starting out with around 1.2 million copper customers, around half of which it plans to cover with fiber.

Submit a Story

Benton (www.benton.org) provides the only free, reliable, and non-partisan daily digest that curates and distributes news related to universal broadband, while connecting communications, democracy, and public interest issues. Posted Monday through Friday, this service provides updates on important industry developments, policy issues, and other related news events. While the summaries are factually accurate, their sometimes informal tone may not always represent the tone of the original articles. Headlines are compiled by Kevin Taglang (headlines AT benton DOT org) and Grace Tepper (grace AT benton DOT org) — we welcome your comments.


© Benton Institute for Broadband & Society 2022. Redistribution of this email publication — both internally and externally — is encouraged if it includes this message. For subscribe/unsubscribe info email: headlines AT benton DOT org


Kevin Taglang

Kevin Taglang
Executive Editor, Communications-related Headlines
Benton Institute
for Broadband & Society
1041 Ridge Rd, Unit 214
Wilmette, IL 60091
847-328-3040
headlines AT benton DOT org

Share this edition:

Benton Institute for Broadband & Society Benton Institute for Broadband & Society Benton Institute for Broadband & Society

Benton Institute for Broadband & Society

The Benton Institute for Broadband & Society All Rights Reserved © 2022