Thursday, December 13, 2018
Headlines Daily Digest
Consolidated Communications Marketplace Report
Don't Miss:
2018 Quadrennial Review of Media Ownership Rules
News from the FCC Meeting
- FCC Communications Marketplace Report Finds High Cable Prices, Uncompetitive Broadband Markets | Public Knowledge
- AT&T Statement on 39 GHz Spectrum Auction and the Rollout of 5G | AT&T
FCC Acts on Spam Robotext Messages | Read below | Press Release | Federal Communications Commission
- FCC Approves Flawed ‘Robotext’ Order Enabling Wireless Carriers to Block Your Text Messages | Public Knowledge
- AT&T Statement on FCC Action to Protect Consumers from Spam and Robotexts | AT&T
FCC Creates Reassigned Numbers Database to Combat Unwanted Robocalls | Read below | Press Release | Federal Communications Commission
Commissioner Rosenworcel Calls for Free Robocall Blocking Tools for Consumers | Federal Communications Commission
- AT&T Commends FCC Efforts to Combat Robocalling | AT&T
At AT&T’s urging, FCC panel proposes tax on businesses that use the Internet | Read below | Jon Brodkin | Ars Technica
FCC 28 GHz Auction Gets Shout-Out From Commissioner Carr | Multichannel News
FCC Enforcement Bureau Applauds Westchester County District Attorney For Pirate Radio Case | Federal Communications Commission
Broadband
House Passes Farm Bill, Sends It to President Trump’s Desk for Signature | Wall Street Journal
Small Broadband Wary On Farm Bill | Read below | Cristiano Lima | Politico, McClatchy, telecompetitor
Study on Rapid Fiber Growth in North America | Read below | Press Release | Fiber Broadband Association
Fixed Broadband Speedtest Data Q2-Q3 2018 in US | Read below | Ookla
AT&T Fiber Expansion Adds 12 More Markets, Now Reaches 10M Locations | telecompetitor
Wireless
California considers text messaging tax to fund cell service for low-income residents | Read below | John Woolfolk | San Jose Mercury News
FTC Reform
The FTC should match tech company innovation with oversight innovation | Read below | Tom Wheeler | Analysis | Brookings
Platforms
Journalists paid to help fix Facebook’s fake news problem say they have lost trust in the platform | Guardian, The
Op-ed: Each time you click on a Facebook ad, Facebook sells data on you to that advertiser. | New York Times
House Google Hearing Confirms Bipartisanship on Internet Platform Issues | Scott Cleland
What Google’s CEO told Congress about China — and what he didn’t | Vox
Friction: Could some of our biggest technological challenges be solved by making things slightly less simple? | New York Times
Privacy/Security
Sen Schatz Leads Group of 15 Senators In Introducing New Bill To Help Protect People’s Personal Data Online | US Senate
Tribune, Tronc And Beyond: A Slur, A Secret Payout And A Looming Sale | National Public Radio
Analysis: President Trump is getting tough on Chinese hacking. Will it work? | Washington Post
Journalism
The Future of Print Journalism in the Age of Digital Media | New York Times
Government Communications
Troubled by Lapses, Voice of America Braces for New Trump Management | New York Times
Senate passes 21st Century Idea Act, giving agencies a year to improve government websites, digital services | nextgov
Department of Homeland Security Office of Emergency Communications Should Take Steps to Help Improve External Communications | Government Accountability Office
Elections
Publisher of the National Enquirer admits to hush-money payments made on Trump’s behalf | Washington Post
Senate votes to overturn Trump administration donor disclosure rule for ‘dark money’ groups | Washington Post
Q2 2018 Report: TV still the dominant media, but more young adults are connecting via Internet | Nielsen
Stories From Abroad
In France, School Lessons Ask: Which Twitter Post Should You Trust? | New York Times
Opinion: Washington must wake up to the abuse of software that kills -- Dictators are using spyware to persecute journalists | Washington Post
How Whatsapp Fuels Fake News and Violence in India | Wired
Today's Top Stories
New From The FCC
The Federal Communications Commission adopted its first Communications Marketplace Report, which provides a comprehensive evaluation of the state of the communications marketplace. As required by Title IV of RAY BAUM’S Act of 2018, the report consolidates several separate reports to address the state of the broader communications marketplace in one place. And as mandated by Congress, this report will be issued every two years. In total, 10 separate regularly recurring FCC reports were eliminated or materially modified, and relevant data has now been consolidated into a single, comprehensive report. The report provides:
- Increased transparency. By consolidating numerous Commission reports, which had been issued separately and posted separately, data is now easier to find, review, and use.
- A holistic overview of competition across all communications marketplaces: mobile wireless, fixed broadband, audio, video, and satellite communications markets.
- An assessment of the state of deployment of communications capabilities.
- An assessment of barriers to competitive entry, including market entry barriers for entrepreneurs and other small businesses.
- A compilation of geographic areas that are not served by any provider of advanced telecommunications capabilities.
- A description of the Commission’s actions to address challenges and opportunities in the communications marketplace during the previous two years.
- A discussion of the Commission’s agenda for continuing to address those challenges and opportunities over the next two years.
Press Release | Federal Communications Commission
The Federal Communications Commission adopted a Notice of Proposed Rulemaking commencing the 2018 Quadrennial Review of the Commission’s media ownership rules. The FCC is legally required to review certain broadcast ownership rules every four years to determine whether they “are necessary in the public interest as the result of competition” and to “repeal or modify any regulation [the Commission] determines to be no longer in the public interest.” The rules subject to this quadrennial review obligation are the Local Radio Ownership Rule, the Local Television Ownership Rule, and the Dual Network Rule. (The statute specifically excludes the national television ownership cap from the quadrennial review.) The Local Radio and Local Television Ownership Rules limit the total number of broadcast radio and television stations, respectively, that may be commonly owned in a media market. The Dual Network Rule prohibits a merger between or among the Big Four broadcast networks (ABC, CBS, Fox, and NBC). In this Notice of Proposed Rulemaking, the FCC seeks comment on whether these three rules continue to serve the public interest or whether they should be modified or eliminated in light of changes to the media marketplace. In addition, the notice seeks comment on three proposals relevant to promoting diversity in the broadcast industry.
Press Release | Federal Communications Commission
The Federal Communications Commission will provide additional funding for the Connect America Fund, the FCC’s program that helps expand broadband deployment and make broadband service more affordable in rural areas. In return for this increased funding, the FCC will require providers to expand the availability of faster service that will better meet the needs of consumers and businesses. The FCC updated the Connect America Fund programs providing support for small, rural providers, known as rate-of-return carriers, to deliver faster broadband speeds and expanded coverage in rural areas. In return for additional funding, the FCC will require providers to expand availability of service offering downloads of at least 25/3 Mbps service, compared to the current 10/1 Mbps standard. Updates include:
Offering up to $67 million a year in additional support for carriers receiving funding through the Connect America Fund’s Alternative Connect America Cost Model, or ACAM. This revised offer alone has the potential to increase by 100,000 the number of rural homes and businesses with access to 25/3 Mbps service.
Opening a new window for carriers receiving support through legacy mechanisms to voluntarily move to model-based support through the A-CAM II offer, which incentivizes deployment while reducing regulatory burdens. In return, these carriers would be required to provide 25/3 Mbps service to all homes and businesses whose costs are fully funded through the A-CAM cost model.
Increasing the $1.4 billion annual budget for carriers that continue to get support from legacy mechanisms by initiating an annual inflation adjustment, eliminating 2018 cuts mandated by budgetary rules established under the prior Administration, and setting a guaranteed floor of minimum support for each carrier. In return, legacy providers would be required to expand deployment of 25/3 Mbps service.
The FCC combats waste by reducing the maximum per-line subsidy in the legacy program from the current $250 to $200 by July of 2021. It also eliminates a burdensome capital expenditures allowance rule, which failed to incentivize investment by companies where it had been lacking or to rein in significant waste. The FCC also determines that a market-based auction can best eliminate wasteful subsidies to legacy providers serving areas that are entirely or almost entirely overlapped by unsubsidized providers. Eliminating unnecessary support in such areas could save the Fund up to $12 million annually. The item includes a Further Notice of Proposed Rulemaking seeking comment on how to structure such an auction, as well as how to address conversions to broadband-only lines and whether to include a Tribal Broadband Factor for legacy carriers
Press Release | Federal Communications Commission
The Federal Communications Commission took a step toward holding a major 5G spectrum auction in 2019 by adopting new rules that will promote the availability of high-band millimeter wave spectrum for the next generation of wireless connectivity. The airwaves in the combined Upper 37 GHz and 39 GHz bands are the largest amount of contiguous spectrum available for wireless service in the millimeter wave bands—2,400 megahertz in total—while the 47 GHz band provides an additional 1,000 megahertz of spectrum. Specifically, the Fourth Report and Order in the Spectrum Frontiers proceeding:
- Modifies the band plans for the Upper 37 GHz, 39 GHz, and 47 GHz bands from 200 megahertz blocks to 100 megahertz blocks to be licensed by Partial Economic Area, which will facilitate the simultaneous auction of licenses in the three bands;
- Adopts an incentive auction mechanism that will offer contiguous blocks of spectrum throughout the Upper 37 GHz, 39 GHz, and 47 GHz bands, while preserving spectrum usage rights for existing licensees; and
- Adopts a pre-auction process that allows incumbent licensees to rationalize their holdings.
The incentive auction of these spectrum bands will have two phases: a clock phase in which bidders may bid on generic license blocks, and an assignment phase in which clock phase winners may bid on specific frequencies. Incentive payments will be offered to incumbents who choose to relinquish their spectrum usage rights to make new licenses available. New entrants and participating incumbents may bid for new licenses. Incumbents that bid for new licenses may use “vouchers” equivalent to their existing holdings for credit toward the amount they bid in the auction. For an incumbent that chooses not to relinquish all its existing rights, the Report and Order provides methods to modify the incumbent’s licenses so that they align with the band plan and service areas adopted by the FCC.
Press Release | Federal Communications Commission
The Federal Communications Commission issued a ruling rejecting requests to make it harder for text messaging providers to protect consumers from spam and scam robotexts. The FCC’s decision makes clear that wireless providers are authorized to continue their efforts to stop unwanted text messaging through robotext-blocking, anti-spoofing measures, and other anti-spam features. In this ruling, the FCC denies requests from mass-texting companies and other parties to classify text messaging services as “telecommunications services” subject to common carrier regulation under the Communications Act—a classification that would limit wireless providers’ efforts to combat spam and scam robotexts effectively. Instead, the FCC finds that two forms of wireless messaging services, Short Message Service (SMS) and Multimedia Messaging Service (MMS), are “information services” under the Communications Act. With this decision, the FCC empowers wireless providers to continue taking action to protect American consumers from unwanted text messages.
Press Release | Federal Communications Commission
The Federal Communications Commission adopted new rules to establish a reassigned numbers database that will reduce the number of unwanted phone calls Americans receive. The new rules establish a single, comprehensive database with information provided by phone companies that callers will be able to use to avoid calling reassigned numbers. Callers using the database will be able to find out if telephone numbers assigned to consumers who want their calls have been disconnected and made eligible for reassignment. Any such numbers can then be purged from their call lists, thereby decreasing the number of unwanted calls to consumers. To further encourage callers to use the database, the Commission is providing callers a safe harbor from liability for any calls to reassigned numbers caused by database error.
Press Release | Federal Communications Commission
The Federal Communications Commission's Broadband Deployment Advisory Committee (BDAC) has proposed a new tax on Netflix, Google, Facebook, and many other businesses that require Internet access to operate. If adopted by states, the recommended tax would apply to subscription-based retail services that require Internet access, such as Netflix, and to advertising-supported services that use the Internet, such as Google and Facebook. The tax would also apply to any small- or medium-sized business that charges subscription fees for online services or uses online advertising. The tax would also apply to any provider of broadband access, such as cable or wireless operators. The collected money would go into state rural broadband deployment funds that would help bring faster Internet access to sparsely populated areas.
BDAC has been criticized by San Jose Mayor Sam Liccardo—who quit the committee—"for advancing the interests of the telecommunications industry over those of the public." An AT&T executive who is on BDAC argued that the recommended tax should apply even more broadly, to any business that benefits financially from broadband access in any way. AT&T stands to be one of the biggest beneficiaries if states assess the new taxes. The proposed tax doesn't seem likely to get support from FCC Chairman Ajit Pai. "Chairman Pai has been clear that he opposes taxes on the Internet," a spokesperson for Chariman Pai said.
Jon Brodkin | Ars Technica
The Senate passed the compromise farm bill, HR 2, notching a win for Democrats who opposed the House’s plan to impose tighter work requirements on food stamp recipients. The bill would raise the annual budget for Department of Agriculture broadband loans, loan guarantees and grants to $350 million from 2019 to 2023 and allows funding to go toward grants as well as loans. Other compromise farm bill broadband provisions include raising the “minimum acceptable level of broadband service for a rural area” to 25 Mbps downstream and 3 Mbps upstream – up from a previous 4/1 Mbps. The bill also includes $50 million annually for Community Connect grants; $10 million annually for grants, loans and loan guarantees for middle mile infrastructure for rural areas; and $10 million annually for what was previously known as the “Rural Gigabit Network Pilot Program” but which would now be known as the “Innovative Broadband Advancement Program.”
The bill could receive a House vote as early as Dec 12. But some House Republicans are still bristling over the bill’s concessions.
Broadband groups are pushing back against the measure. “While the 2018 Farm Bill Conference Report takes some positive steps towards improving rural broadband deployment, ITTA remains troubled that the Report would allow for the use of RUS funds to overbuild existing providers receiving federal support from the Federal Communications Commission’ universal service program,” said ITTA, which represents largely regional broadband providers.
Cristiano Lima | Politico, McClatchy, telecompetitor
The Fiber Broadband Association and RVA, LLC released a new report on the rapid growth of the North American fiber broadband industry. Key findings include:
- In 2018, fiber surpassed DSL to become the second most common connection for home internet in North America after cable. In North America, fiber now passes nearly 60 million homes and connects 23.8 million.
- In the US, fiber now passes 41 million unique homes and connects 18.6 million homes. This is a 17% increase in homes passed by fiber since 2017. 1.6 million homes can get fiber broadband from two or more providers.
- In the US in 2018, more than 1,000 smaller providers were responsible for 29% of the fiber build, with four major Tier 1 providers responsible for the other 71%.
- Canada leads North American fiber deployment, with 19% growth in homes marketed in 2018 alone.
Press Release | Fiber Broadband Association
With gigabit expanding across the nation, fixed broadband speeds in the US are rapidly increasing. Speedtest data from Q2-Q3 2018 reveals a 35.8 percent increase in mean download speed during the last year and a 22.0 percent increase in upload speed. As a result, the US ranks 7th in the world for download speed, between Hungary and Switzerland. The US ranks 27th for upload, between Bulgaria and Canada. Though 5G looms on the mobile horizon, fixed broadband speeds in the US continue to outpace those on mobile showing both faster speeds and greater increases in speed.
Kansas City (MO) topped the fixed chart as the fastest city in the US with an average download speed of 159.19 Mbps. Memphis (TN) came in last with an average download of 44.86 Mbps and Laredo (TX) was second to last at 55.37. Xfinity was the fastest provider in the US as a whole, in nine states and in 17 of the country’s largest cities. Cox tied for second fastest at the national level and was fastest in three states and 19 cities. On average, US consumers should have few complaints about recent increases in internet speeds. However, Ookla research shows that those speeds vary widely depending on location and provider.
| Ookla
California state regulators have been ginning up a scheme to charge a fee for text messaging on mobile phones to help support programs that make phone service accessible to the poor. The wireless industry and business groups have been working to defeat the proposal, now scheduled for a vote in January by the California Public Utilities Commission. It’s unclear how much individual consumers would be asked to pay their wireless carrier for texting services under the proposal. But it likely would be billed as a flat surcharge per customer — one of those irksome fees at the bottom of your wireless bill — not a fee per text. The CTIA, which represents the US wireless communications industry, said in legal filings to the commission that texting is an information service like email, not a telecommunications service subject to the commission’s authority.
A dense California Public Utilities Commission report laying out the case for the texting surcharge says the Public Purpose Program budget has climbed from $670 million in 2011 to $998 million in 2017. But the telecommunications industry revenues that fund the program have fallen from $16.5 billion in 2011 to $11.3 billion in 2017. “This is unsustainable over time,” the report says, arguing that adding surcharges on text messaging will increase the revenue base that funds programs that help low-income Californians afford phone service.
John Woolfolk | San Jose Mercury News
FTC Reform
The FTC should match tech company innovation with oversight innovation
The Nov 27 Senate hearing on the activities of the Federal Trade Commission highlighted the shortcomings of applying industrial-era thinking to internet-era challenges. The new digital reality calls for both expansive regulatory oversight as well as legislative action. FTC Chairman Joseph Simons' constrained description of the FTC’s authority highlights the need for creative new responses the the ongoing collision between conservative dogma and the unconstrained activities of Big Tech. A forward-looking FTC could advance this debate by recognizing the convergence of unfair acts with uncompetitive behavior. Shedding its industrial interpretations could provide some short-term amelioration of current issues. Most importantly, it could draw a roadmap laying out the areas that need new legal authority. Protecting consumers and competition in the digital age requires conforming responsibilities established in the industrial era with the new realities established by information technology. The FTC needs to be as innovative in oversight as the companies are in technology.
Tom Wheeler | Analysis | Brookings
Benton (www.benton.org) provides the only free, reliable, and non-partisan daily digest that curates and distributes news related to universal broadband, while connecting communications, democracy, and public interest issues. Posted Monday through Friday, this service provides updates on important industry developments, policy issues, and other related news events. While the summaries are factually accurate, their sometimes informal tone may not always represent the tone of the original articles. Headlines are compiled by Kevin Taglang (headlines AT benton DOT org) and Robbie McBeath (rmcbeath AT benton DOT org) — we welcome your comments.
© Benton Foundation 2018. Redistribution of this email publication — both internally and externally — is encouraged if it includes this message. For subscribe/unsubscribe info email: headlines AT benton DOT org
Kevin Taglang
Executive Editor, Communications-related Headlines
Benton Foundation
727 Chicago Avenue
Evanston, IL 60202
847-328-3049
headlines AT benton DOT org
The Benton Foundation All Rights Reserved © 2018