Daily Digest 12/5/2018 (National Day of Mourning for President George Bush)

Benton Foundation
Table of Contents

Broadband/Internet/Telecom

Digital Divide Is Wider Than We Think, Study Says  |  Read below  |  Steve Lohr  |  New York Times
Microsoft increases commitment to eliminate the US rural broadband gap  |  Read below  |  Press Release  |  Microsoft
How the 116th Congress Could Close the Digital Divide  |  Read below  |  John Windhausen Jr  |  Analysis  |  Schools Health and Libraries Broadband Coalition
The Sneaky Fight to Give Cable Lines Free Speech Rights  |  Read below  |  Susan Crawford  |  Op-Ed  |  Wired
FCC Releases The Smoke & Mirrors Internet-Broadband Connections Report  |  Bruce Kushnick
Your landline might not be there for you when the power goes out  |  Marketplace

Wireless/Spectrum

The first ‘real world’ 5G test was a dud  |  Read below  |  Sean Hollister  |  Vox
Chairman Pai Remarks at International Telecom & Media Forum  |  Read below  |  FCC Chairman Ajit Pai  |  Speech  |  Federal Communications Commission
Free Marketers Want to Free TV White Spaces for Broadband  |  Broadcasting&Cable
Daniel Lyons -- The future of text messaging and the Federal Communications Commission: Why consumers should care  |  American Enterprise Institute
Harold Feld: Chairman Pai Isn’t Stopping Robocalls—He’s Empowering Carriers to Block Your Text Messages  |  Public Knowledge

Security

Defense Information Systems Agency outlines plans to wall off agency from public internet  |  Read below  |  Jack Corrigan  |  nextgov
Emails of top National Republican Congressional Committee officials stolen in major 2018 hack  |  Read below  |  Alex Isenstadt, John Bresnahan  |  Politico
Senate Commerce Committee Leaders Seek Answers on Marriott Data Breach  |  Senate Commerce Committee
FTC Seeks Comment on Identity Theft Detection Rules  |  Federal Trade Commission
Nokia Threat Intelligence Report 2019: IoT Botnet Activity Poses Significant Malware Threats to Service Provider Networks  |  Nokia

Broadcasting

Nexstar Makes Regulatory Case for Tribune Acquisition, Drawing Contrast With Sinclair  |  Variety
Nexstar, Tribune TV deal poses test for Trump regulators  |  Hill, The
Rep David Cicilline (D-RI) Warns of Mass Newsroom Layoffs With Nexstar’s Tribune Acquisition  |  Variety
Nexstar's Plan To Be The Top TV Station Owner Concerns Some  |  Forbes
Retransmission Fees Will Rise in Wake of Nexstar-Tribune Deal  |  Multichannel News
American Cable Association: Without Conditions, Nexstar-Tribune Should Be Nixed  |  Broadcasting&Cable
Future of WGN Radio and WGN America uncertain after Tribune Media agrees to $4.1 billion sale to Nexstar  |  Chicago Tribune

Content

Why Tumblr’s adult content ban is about so much more than p0^n  |  Vox
The story behind Netflix’s $100 million ‘Friends’ deal  |  Vox
Op-Ed: Chatbots Are a Danger to Democracy  |  New York Times

Education

White House Releases STEM Education Plan  |  Read below  |  Press Release  |  White House

Journalism

Margaret Sullivan: The digital-media bubble is bursting. That’s hurting a generation of promising young journalists.  |  Washington Post
Opinion: Journalists are rightly suspicious of ad tech. They also depend on it.  |  Columbia Journalism Review
Thomson Reuters to Slash 3,200 Jobs by 2020  |  Wrap, The
Holman Jenkins: Press Is the Enemy of Climate  |  Wall Street Journal

Open Government/Oversight

Democrats Hit Back at FCC IG Report  |  Read below  |  Cristiano Lima  |  Politico
Inside House Democrats’ Plans to Investigate the FCC and Net Neutrality  |  Read below  |  Tonya Riley  |  Mother Jones
“Big [expletive] problem”: a battle over open records in Atlanta  |  University of Florida

Government & Communications

Postal Service Review Proposes Sweeping Changes Likely to Hit Amazon  |  Read below  |  John McKinnon, Paul Ziobro  |  Wall Street Journal, Washington Post, New York Times
‘Enough was enough’: How CNN boss Jeff Zucker reached the boiling point with White House Press Secretary Sarah Sanders  |  Washington Post
Sen Grassley offers President Trump some advice on his tweets: Show them to your wife first  |  Washington Post

Elections

Incoming-House Intel Committee Chairman Schiff (D-CA): President Trump's tweets are 'evidence' of obstruction of justice  |  Washington Post
Wary of repeating 2016 mistakes, Democrats prepare to shake up 2020 presidential debate plan  |  Washington Post

Lobbying

Tech giants sought early inroads with President Trump's FTC  |  Read below  |  Margaret Harding McGill  |  Politico

Policymakers

More Than 60 National Civil Rights Organizations and Stakeholders Call on Congress to Seize Opportunity to Diversify Top Staff  |  Joint Center for Political and Economic Studies
NPR President Jarl Mohn to Become President Emeritus and Co-Chair 50th Anniversary Campaign  |  National Public Radio

FCC Reform

Mark Jamison: The welcome return of economics at the Federal Communications Commission  |  American Enterprise Institute

Agenda

FCC Confirms Agenda for December 2018 Meeting  |  Federal Communications Commission
Slowing economy could increase pressure on Big Tech  |  Axios

Company News

Mark Cuban’s Landmark Theatres Sold to Cohen Media Group  |  Wrap, The

Stories From Abroad

China Announces Punishments for Intellectual-Property Theft  |  Bloomberg
Today's Top Stories

Broadband/Internet

Digital Divide Is Wider Than We Think, Study Says

Steve Lohr  |  New York Times

A new study by Microsoft researchers casts a light on the actual use of high-speed internet across the country, and the picture it presents is very different from Federal Communications Commission numbers. Their analysis suggests that the speedy access is much more limited than the FCC data shows. Over all, Microsoft concluded that 162.8 million people do not use the internet at broadband speeds, while the FCC says broadband is not available to 24.7 million Americans. The discrepancy is particularly stark in rural areas. 

The issue with the current FCC statistics, experts say, is that they rely on simplistic surveys of internet service providers that inherently overstate coverage. For example, if one business in an area has broadband service, then the entire area is typically considered to have broadband service available. The Microsoft researchers instead looked at the internet speeds of people using the company’s software and services, like Office software, Windows updates, Bing searches and maps, and Xbox game play. The Microsoft data is much more detailed than the official government statistics, said John Kahan, Microsoft’s chief data analytics officer for external affairs. Microsoft plans to release the national comparisons, as well as state and county data in 2018.

Microsoft increases commitment to eliminate the US rural broadband gap

Press Release  |  Microsoft

More than 19 million people living in rural America do not have access to broadband, a service as necessary as electricity in today’s digital economy. Microsoft President Brad Smith reiterated his call for a national strategy to close the rural broadband gap and highlighted that this is a problem the country can solve. The Microsoft Airband Initiative launched in July 2017 with the goal of working with partners to make broadband available to 2 million Americans in rural communities who lack access today and to help catalyze an ecosystem to connect millions more. After the success of the initiative’s first year, Smith announced that Microsoft is raising its goal for the program and increasing the company’s commitment. The program will reach 3 million Americans in rural communities by July 4, 2022, and is adding additional states, bringing the total to 25 states served by this time in 2019. The new states include CA, IN, MS, OK, and WV. The Microsoft Airband Initiative partners with internet service providers that are using a mix of technologies to close the rural broadband gap. This includes TV white spaces, which provides an economical wireless solution for rural areas. 

Smith also called attention to the need for better broadband maps. "We can’t solve a problem that we don’t understand. There is strong evidence that the percentage of Americans without broadband access is much higher than the FCC’s numbers indicate." Smith also wrote he was, “encouraged by the recent strides taken by the FCC toward collecting better data."

How the 116th Congress Could Close the Digital Divide

John Windhausen Jr  |  Analysis  |  Schools Health and Libraries Broadband Coalition

The 116th Congress has a golden opportunity to solve the digital divide, by including broadband funding in upcoming infrastructure legislation. President Trump, Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell, and prospective Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi have all said that investment in infrastructure is an area that they can agree on in 2019. 

Here are a few principles that should guide Congress’ broadband policies:

  • Technology-neutral: Local communities should make the decisions about what services, providers, and technologies best suit their unique situation, whether it be a traditional fiber build or high-speed wireless technology.

  • Balance Upfront Capital Investment and Ongoing Funding: While some areas can be sustainably funded with upfront capital investment, the most remote regions will require a mix of upfront capital and ongoing funding to support network operations.

  • Encourage Network Sharing: Congress should only fund network providers who agree to make their networks open to interconnection and shared use at affordable prices, so that they can serve as platforms for extending wired or wireless service to unserved areas.

  • Community Support, Training and Devices: Closing the digital divide entails more than simply building networks. Legislation should plan for community outreach, provide resources to promote digital literacy training, lower the monthly costs of broadband to affordable levels and make devices affordable for low-income people. Public libraries and other community-based organizations can facilitate digital literacy training and low-cost wireless services.

  • Forward-looking and Scalable: However Congress chooses to invest, it should avoid technologies that will quickly become obsolete. Funding should focus on building “future-proof” networks that are scalable and will provide the foundation for telemedicine and educational needs for decades to come.

  • Mapping: Congress should provide funding to improve broadband mapping practices, so that they produce granular maps showing both wireless and wireline availability. Such maps could be used to target investment to areas that need it most.

The Sneaky Fight to Give Cable Lines Free Speech Rights

Susan Crawford  |  Op-Ed  |  Wired

It seems counterintuitive that a phone line could be a "speaker." But the cable industry very much wants to ensure that the act of transmitting speech from Point A to Point B is protected by the First Amendment, so that making a cable connection carry any speech it isn’t interested in amounts to unconstitutional “forced speech.” The addition of Justice Brett Kavanaugh to the Supreme Court roster gives the industry a significant boost. In a 2017 DC Circuit dissenting opinion, Justice Kavanaugh made it clear that he supports giving internet access providers "speaker" privileges, saying that "the First Amendment bars the Government from restricting the editorial discretion of Internet service providers." Right now, the cable industry is unquestionably operating a service that customers view as a utility. But it is subject to vanishingly few obligations. And now it wants to ensure that it will be wrapped in the Constitution if the government ever tries to change this situation. This should be intolerable.

[Susan Crawford is a professor at Harvard Law School]

Spectrum/Wireless

The first ‘real world’ 5G test was a dud

Sean Hollister  |  Vox

The Qualcomm Snapdragon Technology Summit was the first time that journalists were able to see real, consumer 5G devices running on real 5G networks from Verizon and AT&T. On the island of Maui, a handful of 5G devices are available, but  journalists aren’t being allowed to try 5G in any meaningful way. And while Qualcomm’s newly announced Snapdragon 855 processor will theoretically be capable of multi-gigabit speeds, and even today’s most LTE networks can cross 400Mbps in some areas, the single 39GHz millimeter wave 5G network here in Maui is currently running at a measly 130-140Mbps.

Chairman Pai Remarks at International Telecom & Media Forum

FCC Chairman Ajit Pai  |  Speech  |  Federal Communications Commission

I’m pleased to note that the Americas region continues to work hard and steadily advance regional proposals for the 2019 International Telecommunication Union World Radio Conference. We are deeply focused on the WRC-19. We’ll need to work together to set the course for the future of 5G, as we seek to promote a dynamic, global communications marketplace. And speaking of working together, in Nov the Federal Communications Commission took a big step towards increased international cooperation by letting American consumers use Galileo, the European Union’s radionavigation satellite service. 

The other topic I’d like to briefly highlight is artificial intelligence and machine learning.  AI also holds the potential to help bridge the digital divide, which is the FCC’s top priority. We heard Nov 30 about efforts to use AI to more efficiently build and operate communications networks and manage spectrum, which should result in more access for more people at lower cost. Bridging the digital divide through AI, machine learning, and other emerging technologies will help all Americans benefit from the digital revolution, regardless of who they are or where they live. That is something every citizen can appreciate.

Security

Defense Information Systems Agency outlines plans to wall off agency from public internet

Jack Corrigan  |  nextgov

The Defense Department is giving industry more time to come up with plans to quarantine the agency’s internal networks using the cloud. The Defense Information Systems Agency extended the deadline for vendors to submit white papers on how to build a cloud-based system that cuts off agency networks from the public web while still allowing employees to access the internet. The tech would close many of the digital doorways hackers and other online bad actors use to attack the Department of Defense Information Network, or DODIN, according to the solicitation. Under the proposed system, all internal web browsing would be redirected to remote servers located in federal data centers, essentially creating a digital moat around the agency. The new deadline for proposals is Dec 14. 

Emails of top National Republican Congressional Committee officials stolen in major 2018 hack

Alex Isenstadt, John Bresnahan  |  Politico

The House GOP campaign arm suffered a major hack during the 2018 election, exposing thousands of sensitive emails to an outside intruder, according to three senior party officials. The email accounts of four senior aides at the National Republican Congressional Committee (NRCC) were surveilled for several months, apparently. The intrusion was detected in April by an NRCC vendor, who alerted the committee and its cybersecurity contractor. An internal investigation was initiated and the FBI was alerted to the attack.

However, senior House Republicans — including Speaker Paul Ryan (R-WI), House Majority Leader Kevin McCarthy (R-CA), and Majority Whip Steve Scalise (R-LA) — were not informed of the hack until Politico contacted the NRCC on Dec 3 with questions about the episode. Rank-and-file House Republicans were not told, either. Committee officials said they decided to withhold the information because they were intent on conducting their own investigation, and feared that revealing the hack would compromise efforts to find the culprit. Party officials would not say when the hack began or who was behind it, although they privately believe it was a foreign agent due to the nature of the attack.

Education

White House Releases STEM Education Plan

Press Release  |  White House

The White House is releasing a five-year plan to strengthen education in science, technology, engineering, and mathematics (STEM), developed by the National Science and Technology Council Committee on STEM Education and the White House Office of Science and Technology Policy. The plan seeks to ensure that all Americans have access to quality STEM education and safeguard America’s place as the global leader in STEM innovation and employment. The Administration’s goals include building a strong foundation of STEM literacy, increasing diversity in STEM careers, and preparing the STEM workforce of the future. The plan lays out key pathways to achieve these goals, including:

  • Developing and enriching strategic STEM partnerships
  • Engaging students where disciplines converge
  • Advancing computational thinking as a critical skill for America’s future workforce

Open Government/Oversight

Democrats Hit Back at FCC IG Report

Cristiano Lima  |  Politico

Democrats on the House Commerce Committee are pushing back on a report by the Federal Communications Commission Inspector General finding no evidence of a "concealment or cover-up" by FCC Chairman Ajit Pai in communications with the White House regarding the failed Sinclair-Tribune merger. “While we appreciate the Inspector General’s office looking into this matter, we do not agree with its finding that Pai did not need to disclose this information in the public docket based on his commitment to Ranking Member [Frank] Pallone,” a Democratic panel spokesman said. Rep. Pallone asked Chairman Pai to commit to publicly disclosing White House discussions about the merger at a congressional oversight hearing July 25. Chairman Pai agreed, but didn't mention an earlier July conversation with then-White House counsel Don McGahn until a Senate hearing in August. The report notes commission rules wouldn't require disclosure of the conversation with McGahn in the public docket. Investigators also didn't find evidence of other communications between the White House and FCC staff on the deal. An FCC spokesman said the agency is pleased with the findings by the IG.

Inside House Democrats’ Plans to Investigate the FCC and Net Neutrality

Tonya Riley  |  Mother Jones

Now that Democrats are about to take charge of the House in January, lawmakers plan to force some accountability on Federal Communications Commission Chairman Ajit Pai. FCC oversight is a top priority for the House Commerce Committee in the upcoming session, according to committee members. “We plan to put the consumer first by pushing policies that protect net neutrality, promote public safety, and provide meaningful privacy and data security protections that are seriously lacking today,” said incoming-Committee Chairman Frank Pallone (D-NJ). “It’s also important that the committee get back to conducting real oversight of the FCC, and that means regular oversight hearings with all commissioners.” issues on the agenda: net neutrality, improper communications with industry, Sinclair Broadcasting, 

Government & Communications

Postal Service Review Proposes Sweeping Changes Likely to Hit Amazon

John McKinnon, Paul Ziobro  |  Wall Street Journal, Washington Post, New York Times

A Treasury-led task force is proposing that the US Postal Service charge more for certain package deliveries, going after Amazon and other online retailers that President  Donald Trump has said benefit at the post office’s expense. The task force’s report recommends:

  • USPS be able to charge market-based prices for mail and package items that aren’t deemed essential services
  • raising prices for many types of commercial package deliveries, a growing business for the Postal Service
  • the Postal Service correctly assess the costs it incurs in delivering packages for companies like Amazon because it hasn’t sufficiently updated its formula to reflect the rapid rise in package volumes and the decline in mail volumes
  • rethinking the definition of what qualifies for the Postal Service’s so-called universal-service obligation, a legal requirement that it deliver everywhere in the US

Lobbying

Tech giants sought early inroads with President Trump's FTC

Margaret Harding McGill  |  Politico

Google, Amazon, and Snap wasted little time in 2018 in trying to cultivate the new crop of enforcers at the Federal Trade Commission, an agency that will play a key role in any Washington crackdown on the tech industry. The companies reached out to schmooze the four FTC commissioners appointed by President Donald Trump soon after they they were sworn into office in May, according to 73 pages of email communications obtained through a Freedom of Information Act request. Google was particularly active, inviting commission staff to coffee, setting up a meeting with the new Republican chairman, Joe Simons, and touting a project it said would give users more control of their data. Amazon also requested a sit-down with Simons to discuss the company's "approach to privacy" and its view of the "overall retail competitive landscape including our grocery business," a reference to the Whole Foods chain it acquired in 2017. Amazon's head of policy in Washington (DC) Brian Huseman, who previously worked for two Republican FTC chairs, also offered to assist Simons' new chief of staff, writing, "And if I can help in any way with the job, just holler."

Submit a Story

Benton (www.benton.org) provides the only free, reliable, and non-partisan daily digest that curates and distributes news related to universal broadband, while connecting communications, democracy, and public interest issues. Posted Monday through Friday, this service provides updates on important industry developments, policy issues, and other related news events. While the summaries are factually accurate, their sometimes informal tone may not always represent the tone of the original articles. Headlines are compiled by Kevin Taglang (headlines AT benton DOT org) and Robbie McBeath (rmcbeath AT benton DOT org) — we welcome your comments.


© Benton Foundation 2018. Redistribution of this email publication — both internally and externally — is encouraged if it includes this message. For subscribe/unsubscribe info email: headlines AT benton DOT org


Kevin Taglang

Kevin Taglang
Executive Editor, Communications-related Headlines
Benton Foundation
727 Chicago Avenue
Evanston, IL 60202
847-328-3049
headlines AT benton DOT org

Share this edition:

Benton Foundation Benton Foundation Benton Foundation

Benton Foundation

The Benton Foundation All Rights Reserved © 2018