Daily Digest 3/12/2020 (Barbara Neely)

Benton Institute for Broadband & Society
Table of Contents

Broadband/Internet

Coronavirus exposes the digital divide's toll  |  Read below  |  Margaret Harding McGill  |  Axios
Senate Commerce Approves ACCESS BROADBAND Act  |  Read below  |  John Eggerton  |  Multichannel News
FCC Chairman Pai: FCC Lacks Resources to Implement BRODBAND DATA Act  |  Read below  |  John Eggerton  |  Multichannel News
FCC Commissioner O'Rielly on Final Passage of Broadband Data Act  |  Federal Communications Commission
FCC Chairman Pai Defends Mozilla Decision Comment Release  |  Read below  |  John Eggerton  |  Broadcasting&Cable
Coronavirus Cited In Request for Net Neutrality Comment Extension  |  Read below  |  John Eggerton  |  Multichannel News
Musk's SpaceX Looking to Compete for $16 Billion in Federal Broadband Subsidies  |  Read below  |  Ryan Tracy, Brody Mullins  |  Wall Street Journal
CenturyLink rings up more fiber in Tennessee  |  Fierce

Health

Coronavirus Prompts Hospitals to Fast-Track Telemedicine Projects  |  Read below  |  Agam Shah  |  Wall Street Journal
Doctors and Patients Turn to Telemedicine in the Coronavirus Outbreak  |  Read below  |  Reed Abelson  |  New York Times
White House Talks Coronavirus with Tech Giants  |  Multichannel News
Sen Mark Warner Calls on Vice President Pence to Combat Online Coronavirus Misinformation  |  US Senate
Coronavirus: The dawning of a new IT spending era  |  Fierce
MSNBC public editor: Chris Hayes on how to cover COVID-19 responsibly  |  Columbia Journalism Review
Google Scrubs Coronavirus Misinformation on Search, YouTube  |  Bloomberg
How Covid-19 led to a nationwide work-from-home experiment  |  BBC
How Right-Wing Pundits Are Covering Coronavirus  |  New York Times
A remote White House? Trump team weighs teleworking  |  Politico
FCC Commissioner Starks and FTC Commissioner Slaughter Postpone Detroit Field Hearing  |  Federal Communications Commission
How the coronavirus outbreak is roiling the film and entertainment industries  |  Vox
Twitter requires all employees work from home  |  Hill, The
TV Talk Shows Throw Out the Audience  |  New York Times
See what working from home has done to San Francisco  |  Washington Post
Sorry, but Working From Home Is Overrated  |  New York Times

Education

Coronavirus School Closings Expose Digital Divide  |  Read below  |  Lauren Camera  |  US News and World Report
Educational Opportunities Spread with Broadband Expansion in Rural America  |  Read below  |  Hilda Legg  |  Press Release  |  US Department of Agriculture

Wireless

House passes Secure 5G Act, which mandates Trump Administration 5G strategy  |  Read below  |  John Eggerton  |  Multichannel News
California to drop fight against T-Mobile's merger with Sprint  |  C|Net

Surveillance

House passes compromise bill on surveillance reform  |  Read below  |  Ellen Nakashima, Mike DeBonis  |  Washington Post

Platforms

Techlash? America's Growing Concern With Major Tech Companies  |  Read below  |  Research  |  Knight Foundation, Gallup

TV/Radio

Byron Allen makes $8.5-billion bid for TV station owner Tegna  |  Los Angeles Times
FCC Commissioner O'Rielly Letter to Sen Kennedy Re: Pirate Radio  |  Federal Communications Commission
How Google kneecapped Amazon’s smart TV efforts  |  Protocol
Digital entertainment spending passes global box office as streaming transforms Hollywood  |  Los Angeles Times

Privacy

Why your privacy could be threatened by the EARN IT Act  |  C|Net
Apple, Samsung, Google get letter from lawmakers to protect data from period tracker apps  |  USA Today
The not-so-hidden skeletons in our smartphones  |  Financial Times
How to stop your smart home spying on you  |  Guardian, The
Comcast accidentally published 200,000 “unlisted” phone numbers  |  Ars Technica

Lobbying

Ben Scott seeks to rewrite anti-tech lobbying rulebook  |  Read below  |  Mark Scott  |  Politico

Elections & Media

Biden to hold 'virtual' campaign events amid coronavirus outbreak  |  Hill, The
Bloomberg Team Says It Spent $275 Million on Anti-Trump Ads  |  Wall Street Journal

Policymakers

Claire McCaskill transitions from Senate to television  |  Associated Press

Company News

AT&T Chief’s Pay Jumped to $32 Million After Hedge Fund Battle  |  Wall Street Journal

Stories From Abroad

Why the web needs to work for women and girls  |  Read below  |  Tim Berners-Lee  |  Editorial  |  World Wide Web Foundation
BT lines up 1-Gig home broadband service across the UK  |  Fierce
UK Online Revenues Tax Troubles Big Tech  |  Multichannel News
Today's Top Stories

Broadband

Coronavirus exposes the digital divide's toll

Margaret Harding McGill  |  Axios

As the coronavirus pushes more human activities online, it's forcing a reckoning with the often-invisible digital divide. Both the government and private sector are moving to online systems and operations, but not everyone in the US can easily follow. "Coronavirus, without some immediate changes being made, is certainly going to exacerbate the haves and have nots for who's digitally connected," said Federal Communications Commissioner Geoffrey Starks. He wants the FCC to direct funds toward helping serve connectivity needs laid bare by coronavirus. "We need to think creatively on how we're going to help the American people through a time of crisis," said Commissioner Starks. "I firmly believe that families are going to rely on connectivity in a way that they've never done before. And the FCC has to lead."

Senate Commerce Approves ACCESS BROADBAND Act

John Eggerton  |  Multichannel News

The Senate Commerce Committee approved the Advancing Critical Connectivity Expands Service, Small Business Resources, Opportunities, Access, and Data Based on Assessed Need and Demand (ACCESS BROADBAND) Act (S. 1046), as well as two-other communications-related bills. The bill creates the Office of Internet Connectivity and Growth within the National Telecommunications & Information Administration, the White House's chief communications policy adviser. The office will track the construction, use and access to broadband infrastructure built with federal subsidies. Those include USDA-funded rural deployment programs and the FCC's Universal Service Fund.  

FCC Chairman Pai: FCC Lacks Resources to Implement BRODBAND DATA Act

John Eggerton  |  Multichannel News

Federal Communications Commission Chairman Ajit Pai told a House Financial Services Subcommittee budget hearing that he could not provide a timeline for when the FCC could improve its broadband availability maps, in part because of a bill Congress just passed to require better mapping. Asked for a best-guess for when better maps could be produced, FCC Commissioner Jessica Rosenworcel (who was also testifying) said she thought the FCC could improve its maps within 3-6 months and again argued the FCC should hold off on handing new rural broadband buildout subsidies — $16 billion worth and the majority of that 10-year Rural Digital Opportunity Fund — until it improved those maps. Chairman Pai shot back that that was "flatly incorrect." He said having consulted the career staff at the FCC, it would take all of those six months just to analyze the underlying data before they could be translated into verifiable maps. He added that the was before the recent legislation that was passed that "doesn't give us the resources." Pressed for a time estimate, Chairman Pai said it would be a lot longer than 3-6 months, but could not provide an estimate "because the recently passed legislation imposes new mandates the FCC does not have the funding to be able to fulfill."  Chairman Pai was referring to the Senate's unanimous passage of the Broadband Deployment Accuracy and Technological Availability (DATA) Act March 10, which requires the FCC to issue new rules "to require the collection and dissemination of granular broadband availability data and to establish a process to verify the accuracy of such data, and more."   

FCC Chairman Pai Defends Mozilla Decision Comment Release

John Eggerton  |  Broadcasting&Cable

Federal Communications Commission Chairman Ajit Pai pushed back hard against suggestions by fellow-FCC Commissioner Jessica Rosenworcel that he was playing "hide the ball" with the way the FCC issues its request for comment on the remand of some of its net neutrality dereg order. Rep. Sanford Bishop (D-GA), citing a 2010 law requiring federal agencies to communicate in "plain language" the public can understand, pointed to the headline on the FCC's request for comment on a federal court's directive to better address the FCC net neutrality deregulation on public safety, the regulation of pole attachments, and its Lifeline broadband/phone subsidy program. That headline: "WCB6 Comment on Discreet Issues Arising from Mozilla Decision." Rep Bishop said the headline didn't seem to be plain language and he didn't have any idea what the FCC was requesting comment on, while Commissioner Rosenworcel called it "hiding the ball" from the American public. 

Chairman Pai countered that the language came from career staffers. He said "one could always take a shot from the peanut gallery along those lines," apparently putting Commissioner Rosenworcel rather than Rep Bishop in that gallery. He suggested that the headline was something that had been delegated. He said when you have the responsibility of running an agency, when responding to a remand on particular, discreet issues, "I rely not on political judgments but on the judgment of our career staff in the office of general counsel and the Wireline Competition Bureau." He said it had been drafted to respond to those particular issues that was what they had approved and he wasn't going to second guess them. 

Coronavirus Cited In Request for Net Neutrality Comment Extension

John Eggerton  |  Multichannel News

A group of interested stakeholders has cited the coronavirus in asking the Federal Communications Commission to extend the comment deadline on a court's remand of portions of its Restoring Internet Freedom order. In a motion for extension of time, the groups said that "the staff, officials and line level first responders who possess the knowledge necessary to respond to these questions are preoccupied with preparing for, and conducting, emergency responses to a public safety crisis of unprecedented magnitude brought on by the rapid spread of COVID-19." They also pointed out that since the court did not vacate the pole-attachment rules and Lifeline program, there is less urgency to get comments in, and cited the complexity and importance of the issues, the latter indicated by the number of comments in the FCC docket--currently the busiest docket at the commission. 

Filing the motion were The Benton Institute for Broadband & Society, California Public Utilities Commission, County of Santa Clara, City of Los Angeles, Access Now, Center for Democracy and Technology, Common Cause, Electronic Frontier Foundation, INCOMPAS, National Hispanic Media Coalition, Next Century Cities, Open Technology Institute and Public Knowledge.

Musk's SpaceX Looking to Compete for $16 Billion in Federal Broadband Subsidies

Ryan Tracy, Brody Mullins  |  Wall Street Journal

Elon Musk’s SpaceX is seeking to qualify for federal subsidies to provide broadband service to rural areas, over the objections of competitors who say its satellite-based technology is unproven. The company, formally known as Space Exploration Technologies Corp., has convinced the Federal Communications Commission to propose a policy change that would improve its chances of winning federal funds to expand internet service in far-flung parts of the US, records show. In meetings with FCC staff, representatives of SpaceX said it should qualify for the money alongside companies that already provide broadband in remote areas through fiber-optic cable, according to a lobbying disclosure filed by SpaceX with the FCC. The FCC has yet to decide whether the company will be awarded funding. 

Health

Coronavirus Prompts Hospitals to Fast-Track Telemedicine Projects

Agam Shah  |  Wall Street Journal

Hospital chief information officers, no strangers to emergencies, are putting in place new systems and workflows to get ahead of a growing coronavirus epidemic that threatens to tax limited resources and staff. Their tasks include greenlighting telemedicine projects to reduce expected patient gridlock, developing digital dashboards to speed triage, and testing and retesting systems expected to allow staff to work remotely. Some health systems are fast-tracking planned technology projects such as telemedicine, aimed at screening patients without requiring them to visit a hospital.

Doctors and Patients Turn to Telemedicine in the Coronavirus Outbreak

Reed Abelson  |  New York Times

Rush University Medical Center in Chicago and other large hospitals across the country are quickly expanding the use of telemedicine to safely screen and treat patients for coronavirus, and to try to contain the spread of infection while offering remote services. While the notion of seeing a doctor via your computer or cellphone is hardly new, telemedicine has yet to take off widely in the United States. Health insurance plans do typically offer people the option of talking to a nurse or doctor online as an alternative to heading to an emergency room or urgent care center, but most people don’t make use of it. Now doctors, hospital networks and clinics are rethinking how the technology can be used, to keep the worried well calm and away from clinical care while steering the most at risk to the proper treatment.

Education

Coronavirus School Closings Expose Digital Divide

Lauren Camera  |  US News and World Report

The mounting school closures amid the coronavirus outbreak in the US are exposing major equity gaps in access to technology and the internet, and the Federal Communications Commission needs to step in, according to FCC commissioners. "Now is absolutely the time to talk about the coronavirus disruption and how technology can help," FCC Commissioner Jessica Rosenworcel told a Senate hearing. "Nationwide we are going to explore the expansion of tele-work, tele-health and tele-education, and in the process we are going to expose some really hard truths about the scope of the digital divide." Those hard truths are playing out in real-time in Washington state, where 34 schools and three school districts have closed, some for as long as a month. And while a handful of them are taking their classes online, many others aren't due to the students varying levels of access to technology. "The FCC should be convening broadband providers right now to prepare," Commissioner Rosenworcel said. "It should be identifying how it can use universal service powers to support connective care for quarantined patients and how wifi hotspots can be available for loan for students who have schools that have shut and classes that have migrated online."

FCC Commissioner Geoffrey Starks also emphasized the important role the FCC could play in stemming the coronavirus outbreaks and keeping communities forced to quarantine connected to the outside world. "The FCC and communication networks have an integral role to play in responding to coronavirus. With quarantines being required, as it may be soon in many communities, broadband connections will become ever more vital. Everyone in the telecommunication sector must step up and the time is now. Americans are going to need broadband in their homes to help telework to keep the economy strong, to help understand medical information and potentially connect with medical care via telemedicine to help our youngest learners continue to grow. The FCC must join immediately with efforts that bring broadband into homes impacted with COVID-19."

Educational Opportunities Spread with Broadband Expansion in Rural America

Hilda Legg  |  Press Release  |  US Department of Agriculture

As a former teacher, education and its long-reaching benefits are dear to my heart. While joining Deputy Under Secretary Donald “DJ” LaVoy at Lindsey Wilson College in Columbia (KY) to announce over $55.3 million in ReConnect funding, I thought of the impact this funding would have on the education of our fellow Kentuckians. While it is true that rural communities stand to benefit from broadband expansion in a number of ways, its ability to help close the very real digital divide between rural and urban America is a shining promise to the future for all Americans.

Online or distance education at accredited higher learning institutions is gaining ground across the country as well, and I can’t help but think a large part of that growth is rural students who can get degrees and certifications without leaving the communities where they’ve been raised. But they need true broadband to take advantage of those education opportunities. Nearly one quarter of the rural population across the country still lacks access to broadband service, but thanks to the four latest ReConnect projects in Kentucky, we are driving that number down in rural Kentucky. As broadband spreads in rural communities, so too does education, opportunity and prosperity, and when rural America prospers, so too does the rest of America.

[Hilda Legg, Kentucky State Director, USDA Rural Development]

Wireless

House passes Secure 5G Act, which mandates Trump Administration 5G strategy

John Eggerton  |  Multichannel News

The House has passed the Secure 5G and Beyond Act of 2020 (S 893). The legislation passed on unanimous consent, which is a way to pass noncontroversial bills, but only if there are no "no" votes. The bill directs the President to develop a "Secure Next Generation Mobile Communications Strategy” in consultation with the heads of the Federal Communications Commission, National Telecommunications and Information Administration, and the Department of Homeland Security, as well as the Director of National Intelligence and Secretary of Defense. The bill is the Senate version of an already-passed House version. 

Surveillance

House passes compromise bill on surveillance reform

Ellen Nakashima, Mike DeBonis  |  Washington Post

The US House of Representatives approved legislation that would institute some reforms of the government’s surveillance authority while also imposing new requirements on the way the FBI obtains wiretapping warrants in national security investigations following criticism of its monitoring of a Trump campaign adviser in 2016. The bill also permanently bans a controversial but dormant program that allowed the government to obtain Americans’ phone records in terrorism investigations.

The bipartisan bill — an attempt to satisfy Republican lawmakers angry at the FBI’s handling of its Trump campaign investigation and Democratic lawmakers seeking broader surveillance reform — passed on a 278-to-136 vote just two days before lawmakers leave town. Democratic Reps wanted surveillance reforms to enhance privacy, and President Donald Trump’s Republican Reps wanted measures to curb what they saw as abuses of the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act (FISA), the 1978 law governing surveillance used in terrorism and espionage investigations. The result — packaged in legislation to reauthorize what is known as the USA Freedom Act, which in turn amends FISA — assuaged moderates, but disappointed libertarians on the right and privacy advocates on the left. The legislation now moves to the GOP-controlled Senate, where passage is expected the week of March 9. 

Platforms

Techlash? America's Growing Concern With Major Tech Companies

Research  |  Knight Foundation, Gallup

A new Knight Foundation and Gallup study confirms that, for Americans, the techlash is real, widespread, and bipartisan. From concerns about the spread of misinformation to election interference and data privacy, we’ve documented the deep pessimism of folks across the political spectrum who believe tech companies have too much power — and that they do more harm than good. Some findings:

  1. Americans have largely negative views of major internet and technology companies' impact on society. 74% of Americans are very concerned about the spread of misinformation on the internet. Despite a partisan gap, majorities of both Democrats (84%) and Republicans (65%) are very concerned about this issue.
  2. The public (77%) believes internet and technology companies have too much power — a sentiment held across all demographic and political groups
  3. Americans distrust social media companies to make the right decisions about their content but are divided on the role of government to regulate them
  4. Americans across the political and demographic spectrum say political leaders are not paying enough attention to technology issues. 59% of Americans believe elected officials and political candidates are paying “too little” attention to issues dealing with technology and technology companies.

Lobbying

Ben Scott seeks to rewrite anti-tech lobbying rulebook

Mark Scott  |  Politico

From an office in London's diamond district, Ben Scott has his eyes set on Big Tech. The former tech policy aide to Hillary Clinton has spent the last three years leapfrogging between elections from Germany to Canada looking for ways to counter the rise of online misinformation and halt the growing dominance of social media giants. Now, the 42-year-old, who worked with Clinton when she was Secretary of State and during her failed 2016 presidential bid, is reentering the fight with a new lobbying shop called Reset. It aims take on the power of Silicon Valley companies just as officials from Brussels to Ottawa look to rewrite the rules for the digital world. With up to $10 million in annual funding from philanthropic organization Luminate and the Sandler Foundation — a US-based donor that also supports the likes of the American Civil Liberties Union and media outlet ProPublica — Reset hopes to level the playing field between Big Tech and lawmakers. It will help officials gain access to data, and insider knowledge, that so far have been largely shielded from public view.

Stories from Abroad

Why the web needs to work for women and girls

Tim Berners-Lee  |  Editorial  |  World Wide Web Foundation

When the world celebrated the web’s 30th birthday a year ago, we were reminded of the incredible things it has enabled — and all that we stand to lose if we don’t fight for it. I asked everyone to join together and do what they can to make sure the next 30 years of the web is even greater than the last. A year later, with the help of activists, academics, policymakers and business people across the world, the Web Foundation has built and published a Contract for the Web— endorsed by companies, institutions and thousands of organisations and individuals — designed to protect and shape a web that is safe, empowering and available to all. It’s becoming increasingly clear that we cannot achieve the aims of this Contract unless we address a dangerous trend we are hearing more and more about from our partners globally and working on the frontline: the web is not working for women and girls. The world has made important progress on gender equality thanks to the unceasing drive of committed champions everywhere. But I am seriously concerned that online harms facing women and girls — especially those of colour, from LGBTQ+ communities and other marginalised groups — threaten that progress. This should concern us all. Women’s rights are human rights and are fundamental to a healthy society, from reducing poverty and disease to improving education and economic growth. 

In 2020, we must channel the ambitious, collaborative spirit behind the Contract for the Web to tackle the digital gender divide and online harms against women and girls: 

  • Prioritise the problem: 2020 must be the year governments and companies tackle online harms against women as a top priority.
  • Provide better data: Companies and governments must tackle the data void around online violence by systematically recording and publishing data on what women experience online.
  • Embed ‘gender equality by design’: Governments and companies must create all products, policies, and services based on data and feedback from women of all backgrounds.
  • Build legal protections: Governments must develop laws that hold perpetrators of online gender-based violence to account, and resource law enforcement to respond and prosecute when those laws are violated.
  • Be active bystanders: We must all speak up when we see harms against women and girls online.

Submit a Story

Benton (www.benton.org) provides the only free, reliable, and non-partisan daily digest that curates and distributes news related to universal broadband, while connecting communications, democracy, and public interest issues. Posted Monday through Friday, this service provides updates on important industry developments, policy issues, and other related news events. While the summaries are factually accurate, their sometimes informal tone may not always represent the tone of the original articles. Headlines are compiled by Kevin Taglang (headlines AT benton DOT org) and Robbie McBeath (rmcbeath AT benton DOT org) — we welcome your comments.


© Benton Institute for Broadband & Society 2019. Redistribution of this email publication — both internally and externally — is encouraged if it includes this message. For subscribe/unsubscribe info email: headlines AT benton DOT org


Kevin Taglang

Kevin Taglang
Executive Editor, Communications-related Headlines
Benton Institute
for Broadband & Society
727 Chicago Avenue
Evanston, IL 60202
847-328-3049
headlines AT benton DOT org

Share this edition:

Benton Institute for Broadband & Society Benton Institute for Broadband & Society Benton Institute for Broadband & Society

Benton Institute for Broadband & Society

The Benton Institute for Broadband & Society All Rights Reserved © 2019