AT&T wants to settle with FTC to avoid unlimited data throttling lawsuit
AT&T has given up its years-long quest to cripple the Federal Trade Commission's authority to regulate broadband providers. Just weeks ago, AT&T said it intended to appeal its loss in the case to the US Supreme Court before a deadline of May 29. But May 31, AT&T informed court officials that it has decided not to file a petition to the Supreme Court and did not ask for a deadline extension.
AT&T had been trying to limit the FTC's authority since October 2014, when the FTC sued AT&T for promising unlimited data to wireless customers and then throttling their speeds by as much as 90 percent. With AT&T having ruled out a Supreme Court appeal, the FTC can finally pursue its case against AT&T and try to secure refunds for affected customers. AT&T said it will try to settle the case with the FTC instead of going to trial. AT&T's decision might indicate that it is already having settlement talks with the agency.
AT&T's decision also means that traditional phone companies will have to face some network neutrality oversight from the FTC after the Federal Communications Commission finalizes its net neutrality repeal on June 11. The FTC is barred from regulating common carriers, and AT&T has long been a common carrier for its mobile voice and landline phone services. AT&T previously argued that the FTC can't regulate any product offered by AT&T, whether it is or isn't a common carrier service. Though ultimately unsuccessful, AT&T's attempt to deny the FTC's authority to regulate any aspect of its business has delayed the throttling case for years.
FCC To Hold Open Commission Meeting Thursday, June 7, 2018
The Federal Communications Commission will hold an Open Meeting on the subjects listed below on Thursday, June 7, 2018:
Use of Spectrum Bands Above 24 GHz For Mobile Radio Services (GN Docket No. 14-177); Amendment of Parts 1, 22, 24, 27, 74, 80, 90, 95, and 101 To Establish Uniform License Renewal, Discontinuance of Operation, and Geographic Partitioning and Spectrum Disaggregation Rules and Policies for Certain Wireless Radio Services (WT Docket No. 10-112): The Commission will consider a Third Report and Order, Memorandum Opinion and Order, and Third Further Notice of Proposed Rulemaking that would continue efforts to make available millimeter wave spectrum, in bands at or above 24 GHz, for fifth-generation wireless, Internet of Things, and other advanced spectrumbased services. It would finalize rules for certain of these bands and seek comment on making additional spectrum available in the 26 GHz and 42 GHz bands for flexible terrestrial wireless use, sharing mechanisms in the Lower 37 GHz band, and earth station siting criteria for the 50 GHz band.
Accelerating Wireline Broadband Deployment by Removing Barriers to Infrastructure Investment (WC Docket No. 17-84): The Commission will consider a Second Report and Order that will revise the Commission’s section 214(a) discontinuance processes, network change disclosure processes, and Part 68 customer notification process to remove barriers to infrastructure investment and promote broadband deployment.
Petition of NTCA—The Rural Broadband Association and the United States Telecom Association for Forbearance Pursuant to 47 U.S.C. § 160(c) from Application of Contribution Obligations on Broadband Internet Access Transmission Services (WC Docket No. 17-206): The Commission will consider an Order granting forbearance from applying Universal Service Fund contribution requirements to rural carriers’ broadband Internet access transmission services.
Audacy Corporation Application for Authority to Launch and Operate a NonGeostationary Medium Earth Orbit Satellite System in the Fixed-and Inter-Satellite Services (IBFS File No. SAT-LOA-20161115-00117): The Commission will consider an Order and Authorization that recommends granting Audacy’s request to construct, deploy, and operate a proposed non-geostationary satellite (NGSO) constellation to provide continuous, high-speed, low-latency relay services to other NGSO spacecraft operators through Audacy’s proposed satellites and gateway earth stations.
O3b Limited Request for Modification of U.S. Market Access for O3b Limited’s NonGeostationary Satellite Orbit System in the FixedSatellite Service and in the Mobile-Satellite Service (IBFS File Nos. SAT-MOD-20160624-00060, SAT-AMD-20161115-00116, SAT-AMD20170301-00026, SAT-AMD-20171109-00154): The Commission will consider an Order and Declaratory Ruling that recommends granting a request to modify O3b’s existing U.S. market access grant by adding new nongeostationary satellites and new frequency bands in order to provide broadband communication services in the United States.
Updating the Intercarrier Compensation Regime to Eliminate Access Arbitrage (WC Docket No. 18-155): The Commission will consider a Notice of Proposed Rulemaking that proposes measures to eliminate access arbitrage in the intercarrier compensation regime.
8YY Access Charge Reform (WC Docket No. 18-156): The Commission will consider a Further Notice of Proposed Rulemaking that proposes taking further steps in reforming intercarrier compensation by transitioning interstate and intrastate originating 8YY end office and tandem switching and transport charges to bill-and keep and capping and limiting 8YY database query rates.
Text-Enabled Toll-Free Numbers (WC Docket No. 18-28); Toll Free Service Access Codes (CC Docket No. 95-155): The Commission will consider a Declaratory Ruling and Notice of Proposed Rulemaking that will clarify the Commission’s rules regarding the authorization required to text-enable a toll-free number, and propose further safeguards to promote the innovative use of tollfree numbers while protecting the integrity of the toll-free numbering system.
Protecting Consumers from Unauthorized Carrier Changes and Related Unauthorized Charges (CG Docket No. 17-169): The Commission will consider a Report and Order to protect consumers from slamming (the unauthorized change of a consumer’s telephone provider) and cramming (the placement of unauthorized charges on a consumer’s telephone bill), including rules to address sales call misrepresentations and abuses of the third-party verification procedures.
Misuse of Internet Protocol (IP) Captioned Telephone Service (CG Docket No. 13- 24); Telecommunications Relay Services and Speech-to-Speech Services for Individuals with Hearing and Speech Disabilities (CG Docket No. 03-123): The Commission will consider a Report and Order, Declaratory Ruling, Further Notice of Proposed Rulemaking, and Notice of Inquiry to adopt measures, and seek comment on others, to ensure that Internet Protocol Captioned Telephone Service (IP CTS) remains sustainable for people with hearing loss who need it.
Leased Commercial Access (MB Docket No. 07-42); Modernization of Media Regulation Initiative (MB Docket No. 17-105): The Commission will consider a Further Notice of Proposed Rulemaking that tentatively concludes that the Commission should vacate its 2008 Leased Access Order, and invites comment on ways to modernize the existing leased access rules.
Enforcement Bureau Action: The Commission will consider an enforcement action.
Senators demand Bolton reconsider eliminating top cyber post
A group of 19 Democratic Sens wrote to national security adviser John Bolton urging him to reconsider the move to elminate a top cybersecurity position at the White House, calling it a “step in the wrong direction” and worrying that it would “lead to a lack of unified focus against cyber threats.” The role of White House cybersecurity coordinator was established under the Obama administration to coordinate cybersecurity policymaking efforts across the federal government. In mid-May, National Security Council officials disclosed that they would eliminate the position in order to streamline operations across the two senior directors who work on cybersecurity. "Cyberattacks to our nation have increased in frequency and sophistication," the Sens wrote, led by Sen Amy Klobuchar (D-MN). “Our country’s cybersecurity should be a top priority; therefore, it is critically important that the US government present a unified front in defending against cyberattacks.
The Emerging Delrahim Doctrine
Washington and Silicon Valley are united at the moment in trying to get a better handle on how, exactly, Justice Department antitrust chief Makan Delrahim will handle the American tech industry and its iconic companies, from Amazon to Google. May 31 they'll have another chance, with a DOJ roundtable meant to shed light on the relationship between regulation and competition.
Whether regulation meant to foster competition might have the opposite effect, and if so, how to avoid that if government decides to regulate anyway. It’s a topic of particular interest as politicians on both the right and left float — let’s admit it — vague notions of somehow checking the power of Silicon Valley. Chief Delrahim is scheduled to give opening remarks.
Sinclair Responds to FCC Data Request
Sinclair provided the Federal Communications Commission with information in response to the commission's request for information following Sinclair's latest, and expected to be last, variation on its Tribune merger proposal. The FCC was apparently looking for historical data on retransmission consent and ad revenue. Sinclair's submission came in response to a May 21 request from Michele Carey, chief of the Media Bureau, which is overseeing the merger review. Specifically, Sinclair provided data--redacted in the public version--on two markets--Indianapolis and St.Louis--where Sinclair argues it should be allowed to keep two of the top four stations.
Sinclair Finds Backdoor to Push Conservative Message
Sinclair Broadcast Group is selling off nearly two dozen TV stations to comply with federal ownership rules — but that may not stop the company from reaching millions of those stations' viewers with its conservative programming. Four of the sales include provisions that would leave the giant broadcaster with a role in the stations' programming, finances and operations, even when it no longer owns them. Sinclair has made these kinds of arrangements before as it has sold off some of its outlets. But the conditions attached to the station sales are attracting new scrutiny as the company pursues a $3.9 billion merger with Tribune Media that would expand Sinclair's access to households across the country. "This is a technique that was developed by slick lawyers for the purpose of getting around the rules," said former Federal Communications Commission Chairman Tom Wheeler. "It borders on a regulatory fraud."
One buyer of Sinclair stations, conservative commentator Armstrong Williams, pushed back on the notion that Sinclair would control the stations he's purchasing in Seattle (WA), Salt Lake City (UT), and Oklahoma City (OK). "I get to reject something that I don't want to run," he said. But the deals present a major test for Republican FCC Chairman Ajit Pai, who faces scrutiny over a number of agency actions that critics say have benefited Sinclair.
Sprint says merger with “fiercest rival” will “create robust competition”
Sprint Executive Chairman Marcelo Claure tweeted that Sprint will build "one of the best networks in the world" even if it isn't allowed to merge with rival T-Mobile USA. "Merger or no merger, Sprint presses ahead with KC network buildout. Kansas City will have one of the best networks in the world," Claure tweeted. So why does Sprint need to merge with T-Mobile? In another tweet that could be read as contradicting itself, Claure wrote as well, "we announced a mega-merger with our fiercest rival T-Mobile to create robust competition in the 5G era." Claure deleted the original version of his "Merger or no merger" tweet. Claure's statement about Sprint's network-building ability may undercut the T-Mobile/Sprint argument that they can't effectively compete against AT&T and Verizon Wireless as separate companies.
Forget about broad-based pay hikes, AT&T and other executives say
Very few Americans have enjoyed steadily rising pay beyond inflation over the last couple of decades, a shift from prior years in which the working and middle classes enjoyed broad-based wage gains as the economy expanded. Now, executives of big US companies suggest that the days of most people getting a pay raise are over, and that they also plan to reduce their work forces further. John Stephens, chief financial officer at AT&T, said 20% of the company's employees are call-center workers. He said he doesn't need that many. In addition, he added, "I don't need that many guys to install coaxial cables." Because of the changes coming, AT&T is pushing employees to take nano-degree programs to prepare them for other jobs — either at AT&T or elsewhere.
Lifeline 'Flaw' Could Hurt Online Enrollment, FCC Told
The Federal Communications Commission needs to fix a “flaw” in the online enrollment system for the Lifeline subsidy program that could hurt rural and other customers signing up for discounted phone service offered to low-income consumers, Q Link Wireless LLC recently told senior agency staffers. Q Link executives, including President Paul Turner, met with FCC representatives on May 23 to argue for including “application programming interfaces” in the national Lifeline verifier. The verifier is being added to online enrollment as part of an FCC effort to shift responsibility for determining eligibility from phone service providers to the independent, FCC-designated, not-for-profit Universal Service Administrative Co. Without APIs, the national verifier “could disconnect millions of rural Americans from the enrollment process,” Q Link said. “If left uncorrected, this flaw will effectively deny access to mobile wireless broadband Lifeline services to millions of low-income Americans in rural areas,” the company said, pointing to states where it “provides a substantial number of rural households” with data and calling services under the subsidy.
“[A]s USAC’s plans currently stand, the National Verifier would permit consumer online eligibility verification if the consumer can navigate that process without the carrier, and it would permit carriers using agents to have the agents assist consumers with eligibility verification and enrollment,” Q Link continued, “but it will not support both online eligibility verification and carrier assistance to consumers at the same time.” That means, according to the filing, that customers who want to sign up online must navigate the national verifier by themselves and repeat that “cumbersome process” again with the carrier, which would also have to collect the consumers’ information and verify it, a step that would be unneeded with an API link. What is left is only in-person assistance provided by the carriers, according to Q Link, but this is not enough for rural customers who may be a considerable drive from the nearest in-person assistance, which is too expensive to distribute further.
NAB Says C-Band Sharing Isn't a Given
Broadcasters are warning the Federal Communications Commission not to weaken protections for current spectrum users, like broadcasters, in its race to free up more spectrum for wireless broadband. While that sounds like it could be a 2014 advisory on the potential impact of the broadcast incentive auction, it was actually the National Association of Broadcasters calling on the commission to require "detailed" technical proposals for sharing C-band spectrum rather than simply "assume that technical solutions will appear that will allow incompatible services to share spectrum."
The FCC is preparing a report--Mandated by the MOBILE NOW Act--on the feasibility of current C-band satellite spectrum users sharing their 3.7-4.2 GHZ spectrum band with terrestrial wireless broadband users. That report needs to be in the hands of the appropriate committees by Sept. 23, 2019, so there is still time to hash out the issue. Broadcast networks use the C-band to deliver their content to over 1,000 affiliates, as do cable networks to their MVPDs, as does NPR to get its programming to public radio stations. NAB told the FCC that before it allows the band to be shared with unlicensed devices or licensed wireless broadband services, it needs to do its due diligence to make sure incumbents are not subject to harmful interference.
How Michael Cohen Protects Trump By Making Legal Threats Against Journalists
President Donald Trump's lawyer Michael Cohen is facing legal peril, including an FBI raid of his home and office — and involvement in a civil lawsuit with porn star Stormy Daniels. But in the past, it was Cohen who has sought to put legal pressure on others to solve problems for his boss. For the first time, audio recordings of Cohen's legal threats, from a 2015 Daily Beast interview, are being published. The audio, taken from a 2015 interview with Cohen and then-Daily Beast reporter Tim Mak and published by NPR — Mak's current employer — reveal Cohen making legal threats to Mak over a piece he was writing about a 1993 Trump biography. The biography, written by former Newsweek reporter Harry Hurt III and titled "The Lost Tycoon," details a sworn deposition from Trump's first wife, Ivana, who alleged during her divorce proceedings that Trump had raped her.
Samantha Bee apologizes for calling Ivanka Trump a vulgar word after White House condemnation
Ivanka Trump sparked online outrage recently when she tweeted a photo of herself with her younger son around the same time as reports circulated that the US government had lost track of nearly 1,500 migrant children in 2017. During a segment May 30 criticizing the administration’s immigration practices, “Full Frontal” host Samantha Bee directed choice words at the first daughter. “You know, Ivanka, that’s a beautiful photo of you and your child,” Bee said. “Let me just say, one mother to another, do something about your dad’s immigration practices, you feckless c—. He listens to you.”
The comment elicited a passionate response from the White House. “The language used by Samantha Bee last night is vile and vicious,” White House press secretary Sarah Huckabee Sanders said. “The collective silence by the left and its media allies is appalling. Her disgusting comments and show are not fit for broadcast, and executives at Time Warner and TBS must demonstrate that such explicit profanity about female members of this administration will not be condoned on its network.” Bee later apologized.
President Trump again asks for apology from Disney chief after ‘Roseanne’ cancellation
President Donald Trump is continuing to react to the controversy over the cancellation of “Roseanne,” which was taken off the air May 29 after lead actress Roseanne Barr posted offensive and racist tweets. President Trump on May 31 repeated his complaint that Disney chief Bob Iger has not apologized to him for anti-Trump comments made by ABC personalities, something he believes is a double standard since Iger got in touch with Valerie Jarrett, the former top aide to President Barack Obama who was the target of Barr’s racist comments. Jarrett said Iger called her before announcing that ABC, which is owned by Disney, was pulling the plug on “Roseanne.” “Iger, where is my call of apology?” Presidnet Trump tweeted. “You and ABC have offended millions of people, and they demand a response. How is Brian Ross doing? He tanked the market with an ABC lie, yet no apology. Double Standard!” President Trump is referring to ABC News reporter Brian Ross, who was suspended after making an error in a report last year when he said President Trump had directed his national security adviser, Michael Flynn, to make contact with the Russians during the 2016 presidential campaign.
House Majority Leader McCarthy blasts Google over 'Nazism' association
House Majority Leader Kevin McCarthy (R-CA) went after Google for displaying “Nazism” as one of the ideologies of the California Republican Party. A search on the site for “California Republican Party” apparently returned with a sidebar result listing Nazism as an ideology alongside “conservativism” and “market liberalism.” Majority Leader McCarthy noted the sidebar in a tweet at the company. “Dear @Google, This is a disgrace #StopTheBias,” McCarthy tweeted, accompanied by a screenshot showing Nazism listed among the California Republican party’s ideologies alongside values like “conservatism” and “market liberalism.”
Never Mind the News Media: Politicians Test Direct-to-Voter Messaging
From Washington to Texas to California, politicians are road-testing their political messaging strategies, searching for the best way to reach voters in ways that often bypass the traditional media gatekeepers. These media methods have obvious appeal: Politicians can appear accessible but remain insulated from the press. They are also not altogether new. President Donald Trump eschewed traditional television advertising during the 2016 campaign and can now overshadow even his own party’s message at the drop of a tweet. And many politicians have long made a practice of ducking reporters.
Yet several factors have converged to elevate the practice: Fake news and false information about politics have proliferated; the public’s trust in the mainstream media is low; and social media platforms make unfiltered messaging easier than ever. As a result, there is a new urgency among politicians to deliver talking points directly. Many politicians blame the news media for the shift, claiming dishonest coverage has left them no other choice. “For those of you who want to truly see what is happening, follow along through social media,” Gov Matt Bevin (R-KY), a prolific purveyor of Facebook videos, told voters during his state of the commonwealth address in 2017. “With all due respect to what now passes for traditional media, it’s dying for a reason.”
Teens, Social Media & Technology 2018
Until recently, Facebook had dominated the social media landscape among America’s youth – but it is no longer the most popular online platform among teens, according to a new Pew Research Center survey. Today, roughly half (51%) of US teens ages 13 to 17 say they use Facebook, notably lower than the shares who use YouTube, Instagram or Snapchat.
This shift in teens’ social media use is just one example of how the technology landscape for young people has evolved since the Center’s last survey of teens and technology use in 2014-2015. Most notably, smartphone ownership has become a nearly ubiquitous element of teen life: 95% of teens now report they have a smartphone or access to one. These mobile connections are in turn fueling more-persistent online activities: 45% of teens now say they are online on a near-constant basis. The survey also finds there is no clear consensus among teens about the effect that social media has on the lives of young people today. Minorities of teens describe that effect as mostly positive (31%) or mostly negative (24%), but the largest share (45%) says that effect has been neither positive nor negative.
President Obama's US Digital Service Survives President Trump -- Quietly
The US Digital Service emerged from the technological and political meltdown of the 2013 launch of healthcare.gov. After a squad of Silicon Valley techies descended to fix the site, President Barack Obama created USDS to get tech workers helping other parts of government. Under President Obama, the group’s missions included speeding immigration processes, and expediting the acceptance of refugees. Under President Donald Trump, the unit’s current leader, Matt Cutts, admits that he’s less likely to highlight those projects. “We might talk more about how we save money,” says Cutts, a former Google executive, who took the helm after USDS’s founding director, a political appointee, departed in 2017. Cutts highlighted wins such as saving the Veterans Administration almost $100 million by convincing the agency to host a new project in Amazon's cloud instead of buying equipment.
Cutts has also had to change his unit’s pitch to potential recruits, many of whom take temporary leaves from tech companies to join USDS for short tours of duty. President Obama was popular in the left-leaning tech industry, and would sometimes invite people into the Roosevelt Room to persuade them to join the group. President Trump’s reputation among tech workers is poor, and he doesn’t offer USDS such direct support. Cutts says USDS has around 175 people, roughly the level it did at the start of the Trump administration. That’s down from the 202 the group had late in the Obama administration. “In this environment it’s very important to make arguments about service and that we’re working for the American people,” says Cutts. It’s a good line, but Cutts’ team works for Trump and his policies, too. The Obama-centric idealism under which USDS was founded has met the political reality of civil service.
Profile of FTC Commissioner Slaughter: ‘I Don’t Feel Superhuman. I Feel Like a Mom Who Has a Career.’
For the next several weeks, until her daughter Pippa goes to day care as a slightly older baby, she will join Federal Trade Commissioner Rebecca Slaughter on the fifth floor, either in a gray bouncy seat behind a desk or nestled in a wrap attached to her mother’s chest. It was the imperfect but best solution for Commissioner Slaughter, whose appointment in March to serve as an FTC commissioner just happened to coincide with the birth of her third child.
The work culture for families has been stubbornly slow to change in Washington. To take a position of leadership in federal agencies, on Capitol Hill or in the White House requires long and unpredictable hours. Modest pay, demanding travel and meager family leave benefits also deter many women from rising in the government ranks. Such considerations have held back female representation in every corner of government. Women comprise 20 percent of Congress. They hold a quarter of the cabinet posts in the Trump administration.
Benton (www.benton.org) provides the only free, reliable, and non-partisan daily digest that curates and distributes news related to universal broadband, while connecting communications, democracy, and public interest issues. Posted Monday through Friday, this service provides updates on important industry developments, policy issues, and other related news events. While the summaries are factually accurate, their sometimes informal tone may not always represent the tone of the original articles. Headlines are compiled by Kevin Taglang (headlines AT benton DOT org) and Robbie McBeath (rmcbeath AT benton DOT org) -- we welcome your comments.
(c)Benton Foundation 2018. Redistribution of this email publication -- both internally and externally -- is encouraged if it includes this message. For subscribe/unsubscribe info email: headlines AT benton DOT org
Benton experts make knowledge and analysis accessible to include more people in communications policymaking.
Kevin Taglang
Executive Editor, Communications-related Headlines
Benton Foundation
727 Chicago Avenue
Evanston, IL 60202
847-328-3049
headlines AT benton DOT org