Originally published: March 28, 2012
Last updated: April 5, 2012 - 6:10am
In the view of Poynter Institute expert Craig Silverman, the editorial process that Ira Glass described for “Mr. Daisey and the Apple Factory” wasn’t rigorous enough to meet journalistic standards.
This American Life producer Brian Reed, who worked with Glass to vet Daisey’s monologue, fact-checked the ideas in the story, but not the specific details of each of Daisey’s encounters, said Silverman, author of Regret the Error, a Poynter blog about fact-checking. “The show worked to vet elements of the Daisey story, but I think their approach was different from what is typically defined as ‘fact-checking,’” Silverman said. “At some point, they came to see Daisey as a partner in the verification process, when, in fact, the nature of this story made it important for him to be the subject of verification.”
Links to Sources
- Login or register to post comments
- Email this page
Related
- This American Life Retracts “Mr Daisey and the Apple Factory
- Journalism and the Truth: More Complicated than it has Ever Been
- Ira Glass’s Casablanca Moment with Mike Daisey
- AP editor cites Bachmann fact-checking ‘quota’
- Theater, Disguised as Real Journalism
- Speeding up the factcheck cycle
- Making the Most of Broadband: Think Small
- Bad News
- Court: Janet Jackson's exposure not illegal
- The Agony and the Ecstasy of Steve Jobs
- 2011: The year when it became the norm for the device in your pocket to be the center of your world
- NBC's Silverman: Broadcast to Be Event-Driven
- ComScore Study: A Third of Ad Impressions Are Never Seen
- The future of music is boring – and that’s exciting!
- Apple's Samsung Win Slams Asian Phone Makers
Location
Ratings
Login to rate this headline.

