Benton's Communications-related Headlines For Wednesday September 14, 2005
For upcoming media policy events, see http://www.benton.org/calendar.htm
EMERGENCY COMMUNICATIONS
A Katrina Lesson: Need for Unified Emergency Radio System
9/11 Panel Says U.S. Hasn't Enacted Crucial Reforms (reliable communicatio=
ns
for emergency officials)
Congress Urged to Make Public Safety Communications a Priority
Stabenow, Biden Push Emergency Communications Funding
McCain Wants Analog Spectrum By 2007
Wireless Experts Aid Hurricane Victims
Health Records Of Evacuees Go Online
America's Second Harvest
TELEVISION
DTV Bill Gets New Life with Oct. 26 Reconciliation Deadline
Viacom, Comcast Study Venture for New Channels
PEOPLE
Pat Mitchell Elected to Sun Microsystems Board of Directors
Leslie Harris to Head CDT
QUICKLY -- Katrina's Silver Lining?; Roberts Recognizes Lesser Protection=
=20
For Porn; Diversity: Industry Still Taking Baby Steps; Telus Fires 14 Union=
=20
Members
EMERGENCY COMMUNICATIONS
A KATRINA LESSON: NEED FOR UNIFIED EMERGENCY RADIO SYSTEM
After surviving Hurricane Katrina's initial blow, the radio communications=
=20
system for the New Orleans police and fire departments dissolved as its=20
radio towers lost their backup power generators in the ensuing flood. Some=
=20
of the equipment could have been brought back up quickly, except that=20
technicians were blocked from entering the submerged city for three days by=
=20
state troopers who were themselves struggling with an overwhelmed radio=20
system from a different manufacturer. Four years after the 2001 terror=20
attacks exposed the need for more robust, interconnected communications=20
during such calamities, with nearly a billion dollars appropriated by=20
Congress for the task last year, the United States still lacks uniform=20
systems that can keep all emergency responders in touch. Since 2001, the=20
federal government has given $8.6 billion to states for equipment, first=20
responder training and disaster exercises. Last year, the Department of=20
Homeland Security gave the states $2.1 billion, of which $925 million was=
=20
spent on or earmarked for communications equipment upgrades. The=20
department, however, does not tell states what to buy, though it stresses=
=20
that any system deployed in the field should be able talk to another=20
agency's system, known as "interoperability" in industry parlance.
[SOURCE: Associated Press, AUTHOR: Matthew Fordahl & Bruce Meyerson]
http://www.mercurynews.com/mld/mercurynews/business/technology/12637104.htm
9/11 PANEL SAYS US HASN'T ENACTED CRUCIAL REFORMS
Four years after the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks, the federal government has=20
failed to enact crucial homeland security reforms that could have saved=20
lives and improved the sluggish response to Hurricane Katrina, according to=
=20
a report to be issued today by former members of the Sept. 11 commission.=
=20
Local emergency officials are still unable to reliably communicate with one=
=20
another during disasters, the federal government has no clear system of=20
command and control for responding to a crisis. Thomas H. Kean (R), the=20
former New Jersey governor who headed the panel that investigated the=20
terrorist attacks, and other commission officials said the most serious=20
oversights are those that might have helped in the response to Hurricane=20
Katrina. The commission's report will note that lawmakers, facing=20
opposition from the broadcast industry, have not established a unified=20
emergency communications system by dedicating a portion of the broadcast=20
spectrum to medical and disaster responders. As on Sept. 11, when=20
malfunctioning radios contributed to deaths in the World Trade Center,=20
public safety officials in New Orleans have reported widespread=20
communications problems. "The fact that Congress has chosen not to do=20
something about this is a national scandal that has cost lives," Kean said.
[SOURCE: Washington Post, AUTHOR: Dan Eggen]
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2005/09/13/AR200509...
1677.html
(requires registration)
CONGRESS URGED TO MAKE PUBLIC SAFETY COMMUNICATIONS A PRIORITY
The Association for Public-Safety Communications Officials (APCO) is urging=
=20
Congress to make first responder communications a priority during the last=
=20
months of this session. =93The Katrina disaster demonstrates once again the=
=20
critical need for robust, interoperable radio communications for public=20
safety personnel,=94 the organization wrote in a letter to Members. APCO=20
urged Congress to pass legislation this year that would: (1) Set a hard=20
date to clear TV stations from 700 MHz band radio spectrum already=20
allocated for public safety. (2) Boost federal grants supporting=20
interoperable communications planning, staffing and equipment. (3) =93Impro=
ve=20
the way funds are allocated to
local governments to be used for upgrading or purchasing interoperable=20
communications systems.=94 (4) =93Provide federal grants to PSAPs to upgrad=
e=20
their 911 systems.=94 (public safety answering point, a physical location=
=20
where 911 emergency telephone calls are received and then routed to the=20
proper emergency services) (5) =93Consider the need for additional spectrum=
=20
for broadband public safety communications applications.=94
[SOURCE: Communications Daily, AUTHOR: Susan Polyakova]
(Not available online)
STABENOW, BIDEN PUSH EMERGENCY COMMUNICATION FUNDING
Sens. Stabenow (D-Mich.) and Biden (D-Del.) Tuesday introduced amendments=
=20
to the Commerce-State-Justice appropriations bill that would add money for=
=20
emergency communications equipment. Sen Stabenow=92s amendment called for $=
15=20
billion to go to the Homeland Security Dept. over 3 years to buy equipment=
=20
that fire, police and rescue units could use to talk to one another in=20
crises. Biden=92s amendment, which failed 56-41, included $300 million for=
=20
local agencies for interoperable communications to be handled through the=
=20
Justice Dept. Community Oriented Policing Services (COPS) program. At=20
CommDaily's deadline, the Stabenow amendment was on the floor awaiting a=20
vote. Sen Stabenow cited a U.S. Conference of Mayors 2004 survey showing=20
94% of cities lack interoperability among rail facilities, police, fire and=
=20
emergency medical service. =93There is no excuse for that,=94 Stabenow said=
at=20
a news conference introducing her amendment: =93The government's response t=
o=20
Katrina shows how little has been learned.=94 She said only $280 million ha=
s=20
been spent on equipment despite a Congressional Budget Office estimate that=
=20
nearly $15 billion is needed to assure safety.
[SOURCE: Communications Daily, AUTHOR: Anne Veigle]
(Not available online)
* Congressional Democrats Seek Funds For First Responder Communications
http://www.njtelecomupdate.com/lenya/telco/live/tb-KJKM1126642210423.html
MCCAIN WANTS ANALOG SPECTRUM BY 2007
Senator John McCain (R-Ariz.) took aim at broadcasters from the Senate=20
floor Tuesday over the issue of Katrina Communications failures, saying=20
they should be forced to give their analog spectrum back by the end of next=
=20
year. "Let=92s remember that Congress provided additional spectrum for firs=
t=20
responders in the Telecommunications Act of 1996," said McCain. "So, after=
=20
spending millions of dollars in funding and additional spectrum for our=20
nation=92s first responders why aren't we better off than we were on 9/11=
=20
when it comes to interoperable communications? Because the spectrum=20
Congress provided to first responders in 1996 is being held hostage by=20
television broadcasters even though broadcasters have been given new=20
spectrum." Former Commerce Committee Chairman McCain argued for action on=
=20
the SAVE Lives Act, a bill he introduced with Senator Joe Lieberman that=20
would return analog spectrum by Jan. 1, 2009, But he said that given the=20
hurricane problems, he wanted to amend that to Jan. 1, 2007.
[SOURCE: Broadcasting&Cable, AUTHOR: John Eggerton]
http://www.broadcastingcable.com/article/CA6256609?display=3DBreaking+Ne...
referral=3DSUPP
(free access for Benton's Headlines subscribers)
WIRELESS EXPERTS AID HURRICANE VICTIMS
Technology professionals proficient in wireless Internet access have=20
established high-speed connections in at least 15 relief centers in=20
northern Louisiana -- prompting many to argue for stronger policy=20
incentives to create community and municipal broadband networks. Wireless=
=20
Internet connections are proving to be a significant means of communication=
=20
in and out of the disaster area, and some people are using the occasion to=
=20
argue that more spectrum should be allocated for unlicensed devices, such=
=20
as those using the Wi-Fi standard. Others note that disaster relief and=20
homeland security become important additional reasons to establish=20
municipal broadband networks. "There has been a lot of publicity on the=20
Philadelphia" municipal broadband network but "less on Oklahoma City and=20
Corpus Christi, Texas, which were primarily designed for public safety,"=20
said Reed Hundt, a former FCC chairman and now an advocate and board member=
=20
of several wireless companies. "Oklahoma City had its own experience with=
=20
tragedy, and Corpus Christi, which is certainly not unaware of hurricanes,=
=20
wanted networks that would help with first responders," Hundt added. Both=
=20
cities have established Wi-Fi networks as a way for police and firefighters=
=20
to communicate in emergencies.
[SOURCE: Technology Daily, AUTHOR: Drew Clark]
http://www.njtelecomupdate.com/lenya/telco/live/tb-DJGQ1126642636199.html
HEALTH RECORDS OF EVACUEES GO ONLINE
The federal government is making medical information on Hurricane Katrina=
=20
evacuees available online to doctors, the first time private records from=
=20
various pharmacies and other health care providers have been compiled into=
=20
centralized databases. Electronic health records are controversial among=20
many privacy advocates, who fear the data could be exploited by hackers,=20
companies or the government.
[SOURCE: Washington Post, AUTHOR: Jonathan Krim]
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2005/09/13/AR200509...
2128.html
(requires registration)
AMERICA'S SECOND HARVEST
America's Second Harvest -- "The Nation's Food Bank Network" and a=20
recipient of a 1999 award from NTIA's Technology Opportunities Program=20
-- has obtained and distributed more than 16 million pounds of food, water=
=20
and essential grocery supplies to the victims of Hurricane Katrina. By the=
=20
beginning of this week, the Network had secured and dispatched 487 trucks,=
=20
carrying 16.5 million pounds of supplies (about 12.9 million meals) to the=
=20
affected areas. The award Second Harvest received from TOP in 1999 helped=
=20
create a model demonstrating that connectivity and data sharing can result=
=20
in a better supply chain for relief products. The Network secures supplies=
=20
and then moves them to local food banks that pack 25 pound relief boxes to=
=20
go to the more than 200 emergency shelters in Louisiana, Alabama,=20
Mississippi, Florida, and the surrounding states where hundreds of=20
thousands of evacuees are moving. Second Harvest is the nation's largest=
=20
charitable hunger-relief organization with a Network of more than 200=20
regional member food banks and food - rescue programs serving all 50=20
states, the District of Columbia, and Puerto Rico. The America's Second=20
Harvest Network secures and distributes nearly two billion pounds of=20
donated food and grocery products annually. The America's Second Harvest=
=20
Network supports approximately 50,000 local charitable agencies operating=
=20
more than 94,000 programs including food pantries, soup kitchens, emergency=
=20
shelters, after-school programs, and Kids Cafes. Last year, the America's=
=20
Second Harvest Network provided food assistance to more than 23 million=20
low-income hungry people in the United States, including more than nine=20
million children and nearly three million seniors.
[SOURCE: Don Druker, National Telecommunications and Information=20
Administration]
http://www.ntia.doc.gov/top/
TELEVISION
DTV BILL GETS NEW LIFE WITH OCT 26 RECONCILIATION DEADLINE
Senate leadership set Oct. 26 as the new deadline for budget=20
reconciliation, which puts DTV legislation back on track for consideration=
=20
while giving lawmakers time to deal with funding for Hurricane Katrina.=20
Senate Commerce Committee Chmn. Stevens told reporters Tues. he plans to=20
meet with members the next day or 2 to brief them on DTV matters. In the=20
House, Commerce Committee Chmn. Barton is still working on his bill.=20
Sources said progress is being made on controversial provisions. The=20
anticipated $10 billion proceeds from auctioning analog spectrum is an=20
important revenue consideration for the reconciliation package. Under=20
budget resolution instructions, the Senate Commerce Committee must raise=20
$4.8 billion and the House Commerce Committee must cut -- or raise -- $14.7=
=20
billion, much of which is expected to come from cuts in Medicaid program=20
growth (CD July 8 p1). The House and Senate reconciliation bills will=20
include DTV provisions that will be submitted separately to the Senate=20
Budget Committee and worked out in conference. The House has taken the lead=
=20
on DTV and is making progress on divisive provisions. One sticking point=20
that may be getting resolved is the amount of the subsidy to allocate for=
=20
converter boxes to allow consumers with analog TVs to receive digital=20
signals. Apparently, Republicans and Democrats are nearing a compromise on=
=20
the subsidy: $800 million total, $40 vouchers for consumers who buy=20
convertors boxes.
[SOURCE: Communications Daily, AUTHOR: Anne Veigle]
(Not available online)
VIACOM, COMCAST STUDY VENTURE FOR NEW CHANNELS
Viacom, looking to start cable channels aimed at people ages 25 to 54, is=
=20
in talks with cable giant Comcast about forming a joint venture to launch=
=20
new channels. The talks are part of an effort under way at MTV Networks to=
=20
broaden the reach of its channels, which include VH-1, Comedy Central and=
=20
Nickelodeon. For years, MTV Networks has focused its programming on=20
children, teenagers and young adults. Now, it wants to create lifestyle=20
channels for an older audience, focusing on areas such as food, cars and=20
homes, the people said. In addition to new channels, MTV Networks plans to=
=20
create programming for video-on-demand services and the Internet.=20
Partnering with Comcast, which has more than 21 million cable subscribers,=
=20
would guarantee MTV that its new channels would get off the ground. An=20
alliance also could help MTV in future negotiations about carriage of its=
=20
cable channels on Comcast systems, often a contentious discussion. For=20
Comcast, a deal with Viacom would add another dimension to the programming=
=20
business it has been expanding since last year when it made an unsuccessful=
=20
effort to take over Walt Disney Co.
[SOURCE: Wall Street Journal, AUTHOR: Joe Flint joe.flint( at )wsj.com and Peter=
=20
Grant peter.grant( at )wsj.com]
http://online.wsj.com/article/0,,SB112665400686739805,00.html?mod=3Dtoda...
us_marketplace
(requires subscription)
* Viacom Exec Denies Reports of a Joint Viacom/Comcast Net
"I am not in bed with that 500 lb gorilla. Yuck. Just the thought of it..."
http://www.mediaweek.com/mw/news/recent_display.jsp?vnu_content_id=3D100...
7586
PEOPLE... PEOPLE WHO DO TELECOM POLICY... ARE THE LUCKIEST PEOPLE IN THE WO=
RLD
PAT MITCHELL ELECTED TO SUN MICROSYSTEMS BOARD OF DIRECTORS
The board of directors of Sun Microsystems announced that Pat Mitchell,=20
president and chief executive officer of the Public Broadcasting Service=20
(PBS), has been elected to the company's board of directors, effective=20
immediately. Ms. Mitchell becomes the tenth member of Sun's board and one=
=20
of eight independent directors. Ms. Mitchell has headed PBS since March=20
2000, the first woman and first producer to lead the operations of the=20
nation's only non-commercial media organization. As a result of her success=
=20
in energizing programming and increasing partnerships, and her commitment=
=20
to public service initiatives, Forbes magazine recognized PBS as one of the=
=20
"Magnetic 40" companies in America. Additionally, the Hollywood Reporter=20
recognized Ms. Mitchell as one of the "most influential female executives=
=20
in the entertainment industry." Prior to PBS, Ms. Mitchell served as=20
president of CNN Productions and Time Inc. Television, a division of Time=
=20
Warner, Inc. Previously, she helped found VU Productions, an independent=20
production company based at Paramount Studios. She also worked at all three=
=20
of the major broadcast networks and as a producer, has been awarded more=20
than 100 major industry awards. Ms. Mitchell is a member of the Council on=
=20
Foreign Relations and is a Trustee of the Mayo Clinic Foundation. Her other=
=20
non profit work includes vice chair, the Sundance Institute and the=20
advisory council of the Kennedy School of Public Leadership at Harvard=20
University. She is also on the boards of the Bank of America Corporation=20
and Knight-Ridder, Inc. She is a magna cum laude graduate of the University=
=20
of Georgia with a master's degree in English literature.
[SOURCE: Sun Microsystems press release]
http://www.sun.com/smi/Press/sunflash/2005-09/sunflash.20050912.5.html
LESLIE HARRIS TO HEAD CDT
Consultant Leslie Harris takes over at Center for Democracy & Technology as=
=20
Executive Director, replacing Jim
Dempsey, moving to San Francisco as Policy Director; Ari Schwartz promoted=
=20
to Deputy Director. [SOURCE: Communications Daily]
(Not available online)
QUICKLY
KATRINA'S SILVER LINING?
[Commentary] Before all the media mavens break their arms patting their=20
peers and themselves on the back, let=92s call them on their latest lie =AD=
the=20
one claiming some great journalistic =91silver lining=92 is emerging from=
=20
behind Hurricane Katrina=92s dark clouds. Weren't all these newly invigorat=
ed=20
journalists just doing their job, anyway?
[SOURCE: Media Is Plural, AUTHOR: Rory O'Connor]
http://www.roryoconnor.org/blog/index.php?p=3D137
ROBERTS RECOGNIZES LESSER PROTECTION FOR PORN
U.S. Supreme Court Chief Justice nominee John Roberts agrees that court=20
precedent has established a lesser protection for pornographic speech than=
=20
for political or "core" speech, but that, in a judicial sense, he won't=20
know porn until he sees it.
[SOURCE: Broadcasting&Cable, AUTHOR: John Eggerton]
http://www.broadcastingcable.com/article/CA6256605?display=3DBreaking+Ne...
referral=3DSUPP
(free access for Benton's Headlines subscribers)
DIVERSITY: INDUSTRY STILL TAKING BABY STEPS
The cable industry continues to make small strides in its diversity=20
efforts, but industry complacency and challenges from competing=20
technologies could very easily derail its progress, according to executives=
=20
speaking at the opening panel of the National Association for=20
Multi-Ethnicity in Communications=92 19th annual conference.
[SOURCE: Multichannel News, AUTHOR: R. Thomas Umstead]
http://www.multichannel.com/article/CA6256365.html?display=3DBreaking+News
(requires subscription)
TELUS FIRES 14 UNION MEMBERS
Fourteen members of the Telecommunications Workers Union, locked out from=
=20
their work at Telus, have been terminated by the company. The terminations=
=20
are for what the company calls inappropriate behavior by TWU members during=
=20
the labor dispute.
[SOURCE: Edmonton Journal, AUTHOR: Paul Marck]
http://www.canada.com/edmonton/edmontonjournal/news/business/story.html?id=
=3D2e9f3b75-a1ed-4fed-816d-a35f58090dac
--------------------------------------------------------------
Communications-related Headlines is a free online news summary service=20
provided by the Benton Foundation (www.benton.org). Posted Monday through=
=20
Friday, this service provides updates on important industry developments,=
=20
policy issues, and other related news events. While the summaries are=20
factually accurate, their often informal tone does not always represent the=
=20
tone of the original articles. Headlines are compiled by Kevin Taglang=20
(headlines( at )benton.org) -- we welcome your comments.
--------------------------------------------------------------