September 2005

9/11 Panel Says U.S. Hasn't Enacted Crucial Reforms

Four years after the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks, the federal government has failed to enact crucial homeland security reforms that could have saved lives and improved the sluggish response to Hurricane Katrina, according to a report to be issued today by former members of the Sept. 11 commission. Local emergency officials are still unable to reliably communicate with one another during disasters, the federal government has no clear system of command and control for responding to a crisis. Thomas H.

A Katrina Lesson: Need for Unified Emergency Radio System

After surviving Hurricane Katrina's initial blow, the radio communications system for the New Orleans police and fire departments dissolved as its radio towers lost their backup power generators in the ensuing flood. Some of the equipment could have been brought back up quickly, except that technicians were blocked from entering the submerged city for three days by state troopers who were themselves struggling with an overwhelmed radio system from a different manufacturer. Four years after the 2001 terror attacks exposed the need for more robust, interconnected communications during such calamities, with nearly a billion dollars appropriated by Congress for the task last year, the United States still lacks uniform systems that can keep all emergency responders in touch. Since 2001, the federal government has given $8.6 billion to states for equipment, first responder training and disaster exercises. Last year, the Department of Homeland Security gave the states $2.1 billion, of which $925 million was spent on or earmarked for communications equipment upgrades. The department, however, does not tell states what to buy, though it stresses that any system deployed in the field should be able talk to another agency's system, known as "interoperability" in industry parlance.

Benton's Communications-related Headlines For Wednesday September 14, 2005

For upcoming media policy events, see http://www.benton.org/calendar.htm

EMERGENCY COMMUNICATIONS
A Katrina Lesson: Need for Unified Emergency Radio System
9/11 Panel Says U.S. Hasn't Enacted Crucial Reforms (reliable communicatio=
ns
for emergency officials)
Congress Urged to Make Public Safety Communications a Priority
Stabenow, Biden Push Emergency Communications Funding
McCain Wants Analog Spectrum By 2007
Wireless Experts Aid Hurricane Victims
Health Records Of Evacuees Go Online
America's Second Harvest

TELEVISION
DTV Bill Gets New Life with Oct. 26 Reconciliation Deadline
Viacom, Comcast Study Venture for New Channels

PEOPLE
Pat Mitchell Elected to Sun Microsystems Board of Directors
Leslie Harris to Head CDT

QUICKLY -- Katrina's Silver Lining?; Roberts Recognizes Lesser Protection=
=20
For Porn; Diversity: Industry Still Taking Baby Steps; Telus Fires 14 Union=
=20
Members

EMERGENCY COMMUNICATIONS

A KATRINA LESSON: NEED FOR UNIFIED EMERGENCY RADIO SYSTEM
After surviving Hurricane Katrina's initial blow, the radio communications=
=20
system for the New Orleans police and fire departments dissolved as its=20
radio towers lost their backup power generators in the ensuing flood. Some=
=20
of the equipment could have been brought back up quickly, except that=20
technicians were blocked from entering the submerged city for three days by=
=20
state troopers who were themselves struggling with an overwhelmed radio=20
system from a different manufacturer. Four years after the 2001 terror=20
attacks exposed the need for more robust, interconnected communications=20
during such calamities, with nearly a billion dollars appropriated by=20
Congress for the task last year, the United States still lacks uniform=20
systems that can keep all emergency responders in touch. Since 2001, the=20
federal government has given $8.6 billion to states for equipment, first=20
responder training and disaster exercises. Last year, the Department of=20
Homeland Security gave the states $2.1 billion, of which $925 million was=
=20
spent on or earmarked for communications equipment upgrades. The=20
department, however, does not tell states what to buy, though it stresses=
=20
that any system deployed in the field should be able talk to another=20
agency's system, known as "interoperability" in industry parlance.
[SOURCE: Associated Press, AUTHOR: Matthew Fordahl & Bruce Meyerson]
http://www.mercurynews.com/mld/mercurynews/business/technology/12637104.htm

9/11 PANEL SAYS US HASN'T ENACTED CRUCIAL REFORMS
Four years after the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks, the federal government has=20
failed to enact crucial homeland security reforms that could have saved=20
lives and improved the sluggish response to Hurricane Katrina, according to=
=20
a report to be issued today by former members of the Sept. 11 commission.=
=20
Local emergency officials are still unable to reliably communicate with one=
=20
another during disasters, the federal government has no clear system of=20
command and control for responding to a crisis. Thomas H. Kean (R), the=20
former New Jersey governor who headed the panel that investigated the=20
terrorist attacks, and other commission officials said the most serious=20
oversights are those that might have helped in the response to Hurricane=20
Katrina. The commission's report will note that lawmakers, facing=20
opposition from the broadcast industry, have not established a unified=20
emergency communications system by dedicating a portion of the broadcast=20
spectrum to medical and disaster responders. As on Sept. 11, when=20
malfunctioning radios contributed to deaths in the World Trade Center,=20
public safety officials in New Orleans have reported widespread=20
communications problems. "The fact that Congress has chosen not to do=20
something about this is a national scandal that has cost lives," Kean said.
[SOURCE: Washington Post, AUTHOR: Dan Eggen]
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2005/09/13/AR200509...
1677.html
(requires registration)

CONGRESS URGED TO MAKE PUBLIC SAFETY COMMUNICATIONS A PRIORITY
The Association for Public-Safety Communications Officials (APCO) is urging=
=20
Congress to make first responder communications a priority during the last=
=20
months of this session. =93The Katrina disaster demonstrates once again the=
=20
critical need for robust, interoperable radio communications for public=20
safety personnel,=94 the organization wrote in a letter to Members. APCO=20
urged Congress to pass legislation this year that would: (1) Set a hard=20
date to clear TV stations from 700 MHz band radio spectrum already=20
allocated for public safety. (2) Boost federal grants supporting=20
interoperable communications planning, staffing and equipment. (3) =93Impro=
ve=20
the way funds are allocated to
local governments to be used for upgrading or purchasing interoperable=20
communications systems.=94 (4) =93Provide federal grants to PSAPs to upgrad=
e=20
their 911 systems.=94 (public safety answering point, a physical location=
=20
where 911 emergency telephone calls are received and then routed to the=20
proper emergency services) (5) =93Consider the need for additional spectrum=
=20
for broadband public safety communications applications.=94
[SOURCE: Communications Daily, AUTHOR: Susan Polyakova]
(Not available online)

STABENOW, BIDEN PUSH EMERGENCY COMMUNICATION FUNDING
Sens. Stabenow (D-Mich.) and Biden (D-Del.) Tuesday introduced amendments=
=20
to the Commerce-State-Justice appropriations bill that would add money for=
=20
emergency communications equipment. Sen Stabenow=92s amendment called for $=
15=20
billion to go to the Homeland Security Dept. over 3 years to buy equipment=
=20
that fire, police and rescue units could use to talk to one another in=20
crises. Biden=92s amendment, which failed 56-41, included $300 million for=
=20
local agencies for interoperable communications to be handled through the=
=20
Justice Dept. Community Oriented Policing Services (COPS) program. At=20
CommDaily's deadline, the Stabenow amendment was on the floor awaiting a=20
vote. Sen Stabenow cited a U.S. Conference of Mayors 2004 survey showing=20
94% of cities lack interoperability among rail facilities, police, fire and=
=20
emergency medical service. =93There is no excuse for that,=94 Stabenow said=
at=20
a news conference introducing her amendment: =93The government's response t=
o=20
Katrina shows how little has been learned.=94 She said only $280 million ha=
s=20
been spent on equipment despite a Congressional Budget Office estimate that=
=20
nearly $15 billion is needed to assure safety.
[SOURCE: Communications Daily, AUTHOR: Anne Veigle]
(Not available online)
* Congressional Democrats Seek Funds For First Responder Communications
http://www.njtelecomupdate.com/lenya/telco/live/tb-KJKM1126642210423.html

MCCAIN WANTS ANALOG SPECTRUM BY 2007
Senator John McCain (R-Ariz.) took aim at broadcasters from the Senate=20
floor Tuesday over the issue of Katrina Communications failures, saying=20
they should be forced to give their analog spectrum back by the end of next=
=20
year. "Let=92s remember that Congress provided additional spectrum for firs=
t=20
responders in the Telecommunications Act of 1996," said McCain. "So, after=
=20
spending millions of dollars in funding and additional spectrum for our=20
nation=92s first responders why aren't we better off than we were on 9/11=
=20
when it comes to interoperable communications? Because the spectrum=20
Congress provided to first responders in 1996 is being held hostage by=20
television broadcasters even though broadcasters have been given new=20
spectrum." Former Commerce Committee Chairman McCain argued for action on=
=20
the SAVE Lives Act, a bill he introduced with Senator Joe Lieberman that=20
would return analog spectrum by Jan. 1, 2009, But he said that given the=20
hurricane problems, he wanted to amend that to Jan. 1, 2007.
[SOURCE: Broadcasting&Cable, AUTHOR: John Eggerton]
http://www.broadcastingcable.com/article/CA6256609?display=3DBreaking+Ne...
referral=3DSUPP
(free access for Benton's Headlines subscribers)

WIRELESS EXPERTS AID HURRICANE VICTIMS
Technology professionals proficient in wireless Internet access have=20
established high-speed connections in at least 15 relief centers in=20
northern Louisiana -- prompting many to argue for stronger policy=20
incentives to create community and municipal broadband networks. Wireless=
=20
Internet connections are proving to be a significant means of communication=
=20
in and out of the disaster area, and some people are using the occasion to=
=20
argue that more spectrum should be allocated for unlicensed devices, such=
=20
as those using the Wi-Fi standard. Others note that disaster relief and=20
homeland security become important additional reasons to establish=20
municipal broadband networks. "There has been a lot of publicity on the=20
Philadelphia" municipal broadband network but "less on Oklahoma City and=20
Corpus Christi, Texas, which were primarily designed for public safety,"=20
said Reed Hundt, a former FCC chairman and now an advocate and board member=
=20
of several wireless companies. "Oklahoma City had its own experience with=
=20
tragedy, and Corpus Christi, which is certainly not unaware of hurricanes,=
=20
wanted networks that would help with first responders," Hundt added. Both=
=20
cities have established Wi-Fi networks as a way for police and firefighters=
=20
to communicate in emergencies.
[SOURCE: Technology Daily, AUTHOR: Drew Clark]
http://www.njtelecomupdate.com/lenya/telco/live/tb-DJGQ1126642636199.html

HEALTH RECORDS OF EVACUEES GO ONLINE
The federal government is making medical information on Hurricane Katrina=
=20
evacuees available online to doctors, the first time private records from=
=20
various pharmacies and other health care providers have been compiled into=
=20
centralized databases. Electronic health records are controversial among=20
many privacy advocates, who fear the data could be exploited by hackers,=20
companies or the government.
[SOURCE: Washington Post, AUTHOR: Jonathan Krim]
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2005/09/13/AR200509...
2128.html
(requires registration)

AMERICA'S SECOND HARVEST
America's Second Harvest -- "The Nation's Food Bank Network" and a=20
recipient of a 1999 award from NTIA's Technology Opportunities Program=20
-- has obtained and distributed more than 16 million pounds of food, water=
=20
and essential grocery supplies to the victims of Hurricane Katrina. By the=
=20
beginning of this week, the Network had secured and dispatched 487 trucks,=
=20
carrying 16.5 million pounds of supplies (about 12.9 million meals) to the=
=20
affected areas. The award Second Harvest received from TOP in 1999 helped=
=20
create a model demonstrating that connectivity and data sharing can result=
=20
in a better supply chain for relief products. The Network secures supplies=
=20
and then moves them to local food banks that pack 25 pound relief boxes to=
=20
go to the more than 200 emergency shelters in Louisiana, Alabama,=20
Mississippi, Florida, and the surrounding states where hundreds of=20
thousands of evacuees are moving. Second Harvest is the nation's largest=
=20
charitable hunger-relief organization with a Network of more than 200=20
regional member food banks and food - rescue programs serving all 50=20
states, the District of Columbia, and Puerto Rico. The America's Second=20
Harvest Network secures and distributes nearly two billion pounds of=20
donated food and grocery products annually. The America's Second Harvest=
=20
Network supports approximately 50,000 local charitable agencies operating=
=20
more than 94,000 programs including food pantries, soup kitchens, emergency=
=20
shelters, after-school programs, and Kids Cafes. Last year, the America's=
=20
Second Harvest Network provided food assistance to more than 23 million=20
low-income hungry people in the United States, including more than nine=20
million children and nearly three million seniors.
[SOURCE: Don Druker, National Telecommunications and Information=20
Administration]
http://www.ntia.doc.gov/top/

TELEVISION

DTV BILL GETS NEW LIFE WITH OCT 26 RECONCILIATION DEADLINE
Senate leadership set Oct. 26 as the new deadline for budget=20
reconciliation, which puts DTV legislation back on track for consideration=
=20
while giving lawmakers time to deal with funding for Hurricane Katrina.=20
Senate Commerce Committee Chmn. Stevens told reporters Tues. he plans to=20
meet with members the next day or 2 to brief them on DTV matters. In the=20
House, Commerce Committee Chmn. Barton is still working on his bill.=20
Sources said progress is being made on controversial provisions. The=20
anticipated $10 billion proceeds from auctioning analog spectrum is an=20
important revenue consideration for the reconciliation package. Under=20
budget resolution instructions, the Senate Commerce Committee must raise=20
$4.8 billion and the House Commerce Committee must cut -- or raise -- $14.7=
=20
billion, much of which is expected to come from cuts in Medicaid program=20
growth (CD July 8 p1). The House and Senate reconciliation bills will=20
include DTV provisions that will be submitted separately to the Senate=20
Budget Committee and worked out in conference. The House has taken the lead=
=20
on DTV and is making progress on divisive provisions. One sticking point=20
that may be getting resolved is the amount of the subsidy to allocate for=
=20
converter boxes to allow consumers with analog TVs to receive digital=20
signals. Apparently, Republicans and Democrats are nearing a compromise on=
=20
the subsidy: $800 million total, $40 vouchers for consumers who buy=20
convertors boxes.
[SOURCE: Communications Daily, AUTHOR: Anne Veigle]
(Not available online)

VIACOM, COMCAST STUDY VENTURE FOR NEW CHANNELS
Viacom, looking to start cable channels aimed at people ages 25 to 54, is=
=20
in talks with cable giant Comcast about forming a joint venture to launch=
=20
new channels. The talks are part of an effort under way at MTV Networks to=
=20
broaden the reach of its channels, which include VH-1, Comedy Central and=
=20
Nickelodeon. For years, MTV Networks has focused its programming on=20
children, teenagers and young adults. Now, it wants to create lifestyle=20
channels for an older audience, focusing on areas such as food, cars and=20
homes, the people said. In addition to new channels, MTV Networks plans to=
=20
create programming for video-on-demand services and the Internet.=20
Partnering with Comcast, which has more than 21 million cable subscribers,=
=20
would guarantee MTV that its new channels would get off the ground. An=20
alliance also could help MTV in future negotiations about carriage of its=
=20
cable channels on Comcast systems, often a contentious discussion. For=20
Comcast, a deal with Viacom would add another dimension to the programming=
=20
business it has been expanding since last year when it made an unsuccessful=
=20
effort to take over Walt Disney Co.
[SOURCE: Wall Street Journal, AUTHOR: Joe Flint joe.flint( at )wsj.com and Peter=
=20
Grant peter.grant( at )wsj.com]
http://online.wsj.com/article/0,,SB112665400686739805,00.html?mod=3Dtoda...
us_marketplace
(requires subscription)
* Viacom Exec Denies Reports of a Joint Viacom/Comcast Net
"I am not in bed with that 500 lb gorilla. Yuck. Just the thought of it..."
http://www.mediaweek.com/mw/news/recent_display.jsp?vnu_content_id=3D100...
7586

PEOPLE... PEOPLE WHO DO TELECOM POLICY... ARE THE LUCKIEST PEOPLE IN THE WO=
RLD

PAT MITCHELL ELECTED TO SUN MICROSYSTEMS BOARD OF DIRECTORS
The board of directors of Sun Microsystems announced that Pat Mitchell,=20
president and chief executive officer of the Public Broadcasting Service=20
(PBS), has been elected to the company's board of directors, effective=20
immediately. Ms. Mitchell becomes the tenth member of Sun's board and one=
=20
of eight independent directors. Ms. Mitchell has headed PBS since March=20
2000, the first woman and first producer to lead the operations of the=20
nation's only non-commercial media organization. As a result of her success=
=20
in energizing programming and increasing partnerships, and her commitment=
=20
to public service initiatives, Forbes magazine recognized PBS as one of the=
=20
"Magnetic 40" companies in America. Additionally, the Hollywood Reporter=20
recognized Ms. Mitchell as one of the "most influential female executives=
=20
in the entertainment industry." Prior to PBS, Ms. Mitchell served as=20
president of CNN Productions and Time Inc. Television, a division of Time=
=20
Warner, Inc. Previously, she helped found VU Productions, an independent=20
production company based at Paramount Studios. She also worked at all three=
=20
of the major broadcast networks and as a producer, has been awarded more=20
than 100 major industry awards. Ms. Mitchell is a member of the Council on=
=20
Foreign Relations and is a Trustee of the Mayo Clinic Foundation. Her other=
=20
non profit work includes vice chair, the Sundance Institute and the=20
advisory council of the Kennedy School of Public Leadership at Harvard=20
University. She is also on the boards of the Bank of America Corporation=20
and Knight-Ridder, Inc. She is a magna cum laude graduate of the University=
=20
of Georgia with a master's degree in English literature.
[SOURCE: Sun Microsystems press release]
http://www.sun.com/smi/Press/sunflash/2005-09/sunflash.20050912.5.html

LESLIE HARRIS TO HEAD CDT
Consultant Leslie Harris takes over at Center for Democracy & Technology as=
=20
Executive Director, replacing Jim
Dempsey, moving to San Francisco as Policy Director; Ari Schwartz promoted=
=20
to Deputy Director. [SOURCE: Communications Daily]
(Not available online)

QUICKLY

KATRINA'S SILVER LINING?
[Commentary] Before all the media mavens break their arms patting their=20
peers and themselves on the back, let=92s call them on their latest lie =AD=
the=20
one claiming some great journalistic =91silver lining=92 is emerging from=
=20
behind Hurricane Katrina=92s dark clouds. Weren't all these newly invigorat=
ed=20
journalists just doing their job, anyway?
[SOURCE: Media Is Plural, AUTHOR: Rory O'Connor]
http://www.roryoconnor.org/blog/index.php?p=3D137

ROBERTS RECOGNIZES LESSER PROTECTION FOR PORN
U.S. Supreme Court Chief Justice nominee John Roberts agrees that court=20
precedent has established a lesser protection for pornographic speech than=
=20
for political or "core" speech, but that, in a judicial sense, he won't=20
know porn until he sees it.
[SOURCE: Broadcasting&Cable, AUTHOR: John Eggerton]
http://www.broadcastingcable.com/article/CA6256605?display=3DBreaking+Ne...
referral=3DSUPP
(free access for Benton's Headlines subscribers)

DIVERSITY: INDUSTRY STILL TAKING BABY STEPS
The cable industry continues to make small strides in its diversity=20
efforts, but industry complacency and challenges from competing=20
technologies could very easily derail its progress, according to executives=
=20
speaking at the opening panel of the National Association for=20
Multi-Ethnicity in Communications=92 19th annual conference.
[SOURCE: Multichannel News, AUTHOR: R. Thomas Umstead]
http://www.multichannel.com/article/CA6256365.html?display=3DBreaking+News
(requires subscription)

TELUS FIRES 14 UNION MEMBERS
Fourteen members of the Telecommunications Workers Union, locked out from=
=20
their work at Telus, have been terminated by the company. The terminations=
=20
are for what the company calls inappropriate behavior by TWU members during=
=20
the labor dispute.
[SOURCE: Edmonton Journal, AUTHOR: Paul Marck]
http://www.canada.com/edmonton/edmontonjournal/news/business/story.html?id=
=3D2e9f3b75-a1ed-4fed-816d-a35f58090dac
--------------------------------------------------------------
Communications-related Headlines is a free online news summary service=20
provided by the Benton Foundation (www.benton.org). Posted Monday through=
=20
Friday, this service provides updates on important industry developments,=
=20
policy issues, and other related news events. While the summaries are=20
factually accurate, their often informal tone does not always represent the=
=20
tone of the original articles. Headlines are compiled by Kevin Taglang=20
(headlines( at )benton.org) -- we welcome your comments.
--------------------------------------------------------------

A Better Communications System for Emergency Workers

[Commentary] Katrina overwhelmed the nation's complex communications system, raising serious questions about whether federal and local governments need new powers to organize a rapid response by the wireless, wire, cable, satellite, and broadcast industries. Moreover, it seems clear that first responders ought to have a resilient, mobile wireless data network that they can share. Fixing this is not difficult. There are some concrete steps the United States can and should take. The important thing to understand is that we know how to do this. The pieces to put together a national emergency response system are well understood. They include WiFi networks, dedicated spectrum for emergency responders, and standard off-the-shelf technology that enables emergency responders to receive pages, talk to each other, do simple text messaging, transmit photographs, and retrieve maps. The basic task is straightforward: every single emergency responder in the United States should be equipped with a simple Emergency Transponder (ET) that can receive pages and allow at least voice and text communications with other workers. We think such a device could be built for as little as $150. It would be a trivial task for the government to offer a rebate on the 3.2 million needed devices.

Big Media + Big Bucks = Big Easy Boost

Amid ever more shocking images and mounting casualties, big media corporations on Wednesday announced millions of dollars in aid to victims of Hurricane Katrina, which has transformed the historic and heavily populated city of New Orleans into a virtual underwater hell and decimated areas of Mississippi and Alabama.
Walt Disney unveiled corporate contributions of $2.5 million: a $1 million donation to the American Red Cross for immediate relief efforts; $1 million for rebuilding efforts targeted at children's charities; and $500,000 for volunteer centers. Viacom is planning a $1 million cash donation to the American Red Cross and a worldwide employee matching gift program directed to the agency. Its divisions CBS, BET, UPN, MTV Networks, Infinity Radio and outdoor will develop special programming and offer ad space and airtime for public service announcements from the Red Cross and other agencies.
Local TV and radio stations will do the same in their communities. Time Warner, the world's biggest media company, said it will start by matching
$1 million in employee contributions made to the American Red Cross.

Benton's Communications-related Headlines For Tuesday September 13, 2005

For upcoming media policy events, see http://www.benton.org/calendar.htm

EMERGENCY COMMUNICATIONS
A Better Communications System for Emergency Workers
Bills Would Boost Emergency Communications Funds
What Are the Lessons of Katrina?
A Paper Without a City
Rebuilt New Orleans Could be Cutting Edge
Keep the Light on Injustice

BROADCASTING/CABLE
Despite Katrina, Industry Expects Action On Digital TV Transition
FCC Urges Multicast Must-Carry =96- Sometimes
94 Cable Nets to Congress: No Multicast
Consumer Groups Criticize Recording Industry=92s New Attempt at=20
Content Controls
PBS Stations Elect Professional and Lay Directors to PBS Board of=
=20
Directors

TELECOM
Muni Nets can Work to Incumbents' Advantage
Phone Firms to Take On Internet Calling Rivals
Survey Explores Rural Youth Telecommunications Preferences
Telstra Stock Sale Could Be in Jeopardy Amid War of Words

QUICKLY -- What Journalism Could Learn from Advertising; Tech Firms Talking=
=20
Up 'Net Neutrality'; DeLay Chief of Staff Joining Time Warner; Murdoch=20
Shares =91Vision for Internet=92; Time for Supreme Court reality TV

EMERGENCY COMMUNICATIONS

A BETTER COMMUNICATIONS SYSTEM FOR EMERGENCY WORKERS
[Commentary] Katrina overwhelmed the nation's complex communications=20
system, raising serious questions about whether federal and local=20
governments need new powers to organize a rapid response by the wireless,=
=20
wire, cable, satellite, and broadcast industries. Moreover, it seems clear=
=20
that first responders ought to have a resilient, mobile wireless data=20
network that they can share. Fixing this is not difficult. There are some=
=20
concrete steps the United States can and should take. The important thing=
=20
to understand is that we know how to do this. The pieces to put together a=
=20
national emergency response system are well understood. They include WiFi=
=20
networks, dedicated spectrum for emergency responders, and standard=20
off-the-shelf technology that enables emergency responders to receive=20
pages, talk to each other, do simple text messaging, transmit photographs,=
=20
and retrieve maps. The basic task is straightforward: every single=20
emergency responder in the United States should be equipped with a simple=
=20
Emergency Transponder (ET) that can receive pages and allow at least voice=
=20
and text communications with other workers. We think such a device could be=
=20
built for as little as $150. It would be a trivial task for the government=
=20
to offer a rebate on the 3.2 million needed devices.
[SOURCE: Center for American Progress, AUTHOR: Reed E. Hundt and Carl Malam=
ud ]
http://www.americanprogress.org/site/pp.asp?c=3DbiJRJ8OVF&b=3D1029179

BILLS WOULD BOOST EMERGENCY COMMUNICATIONS FUNDS
Sen. Debbie Stabenow (D-MI) plans to introduce an amendment today to the=20
Commerce-State-Justice appropriations bill mandating $15 billion for public=
=20
safety communications equipment over 3 years. The amendment will be offered=
=20
when the appropriations bill is on the floor. Sen Stabenow tried but failed=
=20
to get funding for emergency gear in 2003, 2004, 2005 and 2006 Homeland=20
Security Dept. appropriations bills. Last Friday, Sen Barbara Boxer (D-CA)=
=20
introduced a bill that would authorize
$300 million over 5 years for use by state and local agencies to improve or=
=20
replace communications systems. =93The need for interoperable communication=
s=20
has been apparent for over a decade now, but especially since the 2001=20
terrorist attacks,=94 Sen Boxer said in a statement: =93It is all the more=
=20
evident now in the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina.=94 These bills follow=
=20
calls last week for action on digital television transition bills to free=
=20
spectrum for emergency communications. =93Because of delays in the transiti=
on=20
to digital TV the =91date certain=92 deadline Congress set out in law=20
continues to slip,=94 said a letter to House Speaker Hastert (R-IL) from=20
House Minority Leader Pelosi (D-Cal.), House Commerce Committee Chmn.=20
Barton (R-Tex.), Commerce Ranking Member Dingell (D-Mich.), House Telecom=
=20
Subcommittee Chmn. Upton (R-Mich.) and Telecom Subcommittee Ranking Member=
=20
Markey (D-Mass.). =93This spectrum was first promised to America=92s first=
=20
responders in 1997. After years of waiting, this simple step can clear the=
=20
much-needed spectrum for our first responders and instantly improve=20
response and recovery capabilities,=94 the letter said.
[SOURCE: Communications Daily, AUTHOR: Anne Veigle]
(Not available online)
See more on possible DTV legislation below.

WHAT ARE THE LESSONS OF KATRINA?
[Commentary] Lesson five is that the media play a central role. They and=20
the national weather services did a great job of warning Gulf Coast=20
residents that a big one was coming, enabling a million to flee. They were=
=20
at their best, as usual, covering the suffering and destruction. But then=
=20
they became involved in the political debate, as Republicans and Democrats=
=20
tried to outdo each other in assigning blame, with often spurious charges.=
=20
Mayor Nagin's wild estimate of 10,000 deaths was broadcast world-wide. The=
=20
death toll for all the Gulf Coast, when fully tallied, may be well below=20
1,000, judging from the numbers counted so far. The media, however, have a=
=20
natural tendency to make a big story sound even bigger than it is.=20
Politicians and bureaucrats know that the bigger the disaster, the more=20
money is likely to be showered on them. They are being proved right by the=
=20
$60 billion in federal aid envisioned so far. And global media coverage=20
arouses global compassion.
[SOURCE: Wall Street Journal, AUTHOR: George Melloan]
http://online.wsj.com/article/0,,SB112657951035438991,00.html?mod=3Dtoda...
us_opinion
(requires subscription)

A PAPER WITHOUT A CITY
[Commentary] The destruction of New Orleans hasn't stopped the 168-year-old=
=20
Times Picayune from turning out some of the most urgent and personal=20
journalism in America. But there are many outstanding questions concerning=
=20
the paper's future: How does a hometown newspaper write about a city that=
=20
in effect, no longer exists? How long can a newspaper staff, effectively=20
homeless and running on fumes, continue to hold up? Where does a newspaper=
=20
turn for advertising revenue when the city it caters to all of a sudden has=
=20
neither businesses nor subscribers? Can a 168-year old paper, whose initial=
=20
cover price was a 6 1/4 cent Spanish coin, long survive after being reduced=
=20
to what amounts to the country's most tragic metro section? Answers will be=
=20
a while coming.
[SOURCE: AlterNet, AUTHOR: Paul McLeary, CJR Daily]
http://www.alternet.org/mediaculture/25372/
* Biloxi Newspaper Has Largest Press Run Ever
http://www.editorandpublisher.com/eandp/news/article_display.jsp?vnu_con...
t_id=3D1001096817

REBUILT NEW ORLEANS COULD BE CUTTING EDGE
Ugly as she was, Katrina may have given BellSouth a rare opportunity: the=
=20
chance to turn one of the oldest cities in the USA into a showcase for=20
21st-century communications. Assuming New Orleans rises again, a city=20
rebuilt from the ground up could boast the best voice, data and video=20
communications infrastructure in the nation, says Bill Smith, BellSouth's=
=20
chief technology officer. Wired with a state-of-the-art broadband network,=
=20
New Orleans could make vast improvements to health care, education and the=
=20
local emergency communications network. To turn New Orleans into a=20
state-of-the-art showcase, BellSouth would have to replace its 120-year-old=
=20
copper phone wire with sleek fiber-optic lines that have far more capacity.=
=20
Fiber offers mind-bending speeds on the Internet -- 100 megabits per second=
=20
or more. Copper delivers a fraction of that. But if BellSouth can recover=
=20
and repair existing infrastructure, it probably will.
[SOURCE: USAToday, AUTHOR: Leslie Cauley]
http://www.usatoday.com/tech/news/techpolicy/2005-09-11-katrina-communic...
ons-edge_x.htm

KEEP THE LIGHT ON INJUSTICE
MediaChannel has launched a campaign asking readers to help press=20
journalists and news outlets to continue to: 1) Monitor the delivery of=20
relief efforts and funds, and tell us if they are getting to the people=20
most in need. How well are agencies like the Red Cross and the military=20
performing? How much of the money and goods donated are actually reaching=
=20
the victims? 2) Evaluate the process for reconstruction and renewal. The=
=20
people who are most affected must be included in the planning=20
efforts. Citizen journalism must be encouraged to help prevent more=20
injustice. 3) Determine whether the real victims will be compensated for=20
their loss and pain and suffering. 4) Investigate whether the foreign aid=
=20
coming into America is being well-spent. Which organizations, countries and=
=20
agencies are being turned away and why? Who is profiting from this=20
disaster? Let's find out now -- not in five years. 5) Assess who should be=
=20
held accountable. It is time to clean house of all the officials and=20
bureaucrats guilty of criminal neglect and complicity in this shameful=20
performance.
[SOURCE: MediaChannel.org]
http://mediachannel.org/blog/node/934http://mediachannel.org/blog/node/934

BROADCASTING/CABLE

DESPITE KATRINA, INDUSTRY EXPECTS ACTION ON DIGITAL TV TRANSITION
Technology and telecommunications industry officials eager for a fixed date=
=20
for the transition to digital television voiced optimism that Congress=20
would act soon, despite uncertainty related to the recovery from Hurricane=
=20
Katrina. The digital TV language was set to be part of a so-called=20
reconciliation bill, designed to "reconcile" tax and spending initiatives=
=20
with the congressional budget resolution adopted earlier this year. Despite=
=20
some fears early last week that Katrina might sidetrack the budget=20
reconciliation process entirely, technology industry officials said that=20
their preferred route remains the plan by House Energy and Commerce=20
Chairman Joe Barton, R-Texas, to include DTV language in a reconciliation=
=20
bill now delayed until mid-October. Referring to the prospects for the DTV=
=20
transition measure, an aide to one Republican senator said: "I have no=20
doubt that it will happen. If it was neglected [by Senate leaders], many=20
members would be disappointed because many members see the DTV legislation=
=20
as Katrina legislation."
[SOURCE: Technology Daily, AUTHOR: Drew Clark]
http://www.njtelecomupdate.com/lenya/telco/live/tb-XMLR1126554905334.html
Also see BILLS WOULD BOOST EMERGENCY COMMUNICATIONS FUNDS above.

FCC URGES MULTICAST MUST-CARRY -- SOMETIMES
In a report sent to Congress last week, FCC Chairman Kevin Martin and his=
=20
staff endorsed "multicast must-carry" in some situations. The report urged=
=20
Congress
to consider requiring cable carriage of TV stations=92 multiple digital TV=
=20
signals if rules are adopted that restrict the stations from bundling=20
sister cable networks in their retransmission consent negotiations. [Well,=
=20
heck, what's the financial rationale for being a multimedia conglomerate=20
then?] In that scenario, must-carry could help =93maintain a proper balance=
=94=20
between cable operators and broadcasters, the report on the Satellite Home=
=20
Viewer Extension & Reauthorization Act said. Broadcasters =93should be=20
granted full carriage rights for their digital broadcast signals, including=
=20
all free over-the-air digital multicast streams,=94 in cases where=20
=93broadcasters are limited in their ability to accept in-kind compensation=
,=94=20
the report said. Broadcasters, who support multicast must-carry, =93have=20
begun using their retransmission consent negotiations to negotiate carriage=
=20
of their digital signals,=94 the report said. In the same paragraph, it sai=
d=20
the FCC knows of cable industry concerns =93that retransmission consent=20
negotiations frequently involve broadcasters tying carriage of their=20
broadcast signals to carriage of numerous affiliated non-broadcast=20
programming networks.=94
[SOURCE: Communications Daily, AUTHOR: Jonathan Make; Adrianne Kroepsch]
(Not available online)

94 CABLE NETS TO CONGRESS: NO MULTICAST
Ninety-four cable programming networks on Monday asked Congress to deny=20
broadcasters' request that cable operators be forced to carry all digital=
=20
programs that TV stations broadcast. The plea -- from networks that provide=
=20
news and public affairs coverage, religious, Spanish-language and other=20
programming -- comes as Congress nears key votes on digital TV.
[SOURCE: MediaWeek, AUTHOR: Todd Shields]
http://www.mediaweek.com/mw/news/recent_display.jsp?vnu_content_id=3D100...
6781
See text of letter at:
http://www.ncta.com/press/press.cfm?PRid=3D627&showArticles=3Dok

CONSUMER GROUPS CRITICIZE RECORDING INDUSTRY'S NEW ATTEMPT AT CONTENT CONTR=
OLS
As the motion picture industry is trying to persuade lawmakers to resurrect=
=20
the Federal Communications Commission=92s =93broadcast flag=94 content cont=
rols=20
for digital TV, the recording industry is circulating on Capitol Hill a=20
draft resolution and =93fact sheet=94 on digital radio calling on Congress =
to=20
include as well content controls for digital radio. The FCC=92s TV=20
broadcast flag scheme was overturned by the U.S. Appeals Court for the=20
District of Columbia. Public Knowledge and Consumers Union called on=20
Congress to reject the entertainment industry=92s latest attempts to impose=
=20
content controls on digital entertainment. President Gigi B. Sohn said that=
=20
the recording industry =93should be ashamed=94 of its latest attempts to ha=
ve=20
government-sanctioned content controls on digital radio. By seeking content=
=20
controls for digital radio =93the recording industry is trying to take away=
=20
rights that consumers have had for decades.=94 She added: =93I am afraid th=
at=20
it is no coincidence that the industry=92s efforts are taking place at the=
=20
same time that Hollywood is trying to get Congress to codify the TV=20
broadcast flag. Sohn said that both the broadcast flag for digital TV and=
=20
prospective digital radio content controls are =93bad for innovation, bad f=
or=20
consumers and just bad policy.=94
[SOURCE: Public Knowledge Press Release]
http://www.publicknowledge.org/pressroom/releases/20050912-radioflag

PBS STATIONS ELECT PROFESSIONAL AND LAY DIRECTORS TO PBS BOARD OF DIRECTORS
PBS President and CEO, announced the names of the PBS Board members who=20
were elected by PBS member stations in a nationwide vote that took place by=
=20
mail during the month of August. Thomas K. Williams, Alaska Tax Counsel, BP=
=20
Exploration (Alaska), Inc., has been elected to a four-year term as a Lay=
=20
Director representing KAKM/Anchorage. William F. Baker, current Board=20
member and President and CEO, Educational Broadcasting Corporation, and=20
Joseph Widoff, President and CEO, WHRO/Norfolk, Virginia, will each serve=
=20
three years as Professional Directors. Their respective terms will begin at=
=20
the Organizational Meeting of the PBS Board of Directors on October 25,=20
2005. The PBS Board of Directors is responsible for governing and setting=
=20
policy for PBS. The Board comprises 27 members: 13 professional members who=
=20
are member station leaders; nine lay members who represent member stations=
=20
but are not employed by a station; four general directors who are=20
representatives of licensees or the general public; and the PBS president.=
=20
Board members serve without pay. The membership of PBS elects the=20
professional and lay members. The general directors are elected by the=20
Board, which also appoints the President and Chief Executive Officer.
Bios for the new board members are available at the URL below.
[SOURCE: PBS Press Release]
http://www.pbs.org/aboutpbs/news/20050909_boardelection.html

TELECOM

MUNI NETS CAN WORK TO INCUMBENTS' ADVANTAGE
Matt Davis, director of broadband access technologies for Yankee Group,=20
said Thursday in an Web conference called =93=94Like It or Not, Here Comes=
=20
Municipal Broadband,=94 that both telephone companies and cable companies=
=20
could benefit more from working with municipalities who plan to build=20
either fiber optic networks or broadband wireless networks. He thinks=20
telecos should be fighting for fiber build-out, thinking that telecos could=
=20
then offer branded video services over those networks at wholesale prices.=
=20
Cable operators, he offers, should fight for build-out of wireless networks=
=20
which then could be used to serve the small and mid-size businesses that=20
are currently underseved. To date, that advice is resonating more with=20
cable companies than with incumbent telcos.
[SOURCE: Telephony Online, AUTHOR: Carol Wilson]
http://telephonyonline.com/home/news/Yankee_municipal_networks_090905/

PHONE FIRMS TO TAKE ON INTERNET CALLING RIVALS
Traditional telephone companies are likely to fight back as eBay acquires=
=20
Skype Technologies and expands the reach of Internet phone service, experts=
=20
said yesterday. Many competitors will offer their own version of online=20
telephone technology, expand into broadband and television services, and=20
work to limit upstarts such as Skype through regulation. The free Internet=
=20
phone calls offered by Skype and others are "definitely a threat" to=20
traditional telephone companies, said Andy Belt, senior vice president at=
=20
consulting firm Adventis Corp. "If the future of the business is moving=20
toward an all-you-can-eat, download-for-free business model, obviously=20
that's not attractive at all for the Bells." The change in the competitive=
=20
landscape is by no means a death knell for the big phone companies, because=
=20
services like Skype depend on broadband Internet access that most Americans=
=20
can get through only phone and cable companies. Regular phone companies=20
will fight such threats by pushing for increased governmental oversight of=
=20
their online rivals, experts said. "There are people in Washington who are=
=20
experts in killing new companies," said Timothy Wu, a Columbia University=
=20
law professor who specializes in telecommunications. "The [Federal=20
Communications Commission] and others will have to stand firm."
[SOURCE: Washington Post, AUTHOR: Yuki Noguchi and Arshad Mohammed]
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2005/09/12/AR200509...
1683.html
(requires registration)

SURVEY EXPLORES RURAL YOUTH TELECOMMUNICATIONS PREFERENCES
A survey by the National Telecommunications Cooperative Association (NTCA)=
=20
and the Foundation for Rural Service (FRS) shows rural youth are abandoning=
=20
traditional wireline services in favor of wireless ones. Fully two-thirds=
=20
(67%) of survey respondents indicated they currently have a cellular phone,=
=20
and utilize a variety of features on those wireless phones -- including=20
voice calling, text messaging, video gaming, and instant messaging, among=
=20
others. Of those respondents with cellular phones, nearly three-quarters=20
(72%) say the only time they use a wireline phone to place calls is when=20
they are at home -- usually to conserve their monthly allotment of cellular=
=20
minutes. Additionally, 10% indicated they never use a wireline phone.=20
Keeping in touch with parents or guardians was the most commonly cited=20
reason for having a cellular phone -- followed closely by personal safety=
=20
issues and peace of mind. The survey also revealed a number of Internet=20
usage and access preferences among rural youth. While 84% of respondents=20
indicated they have an Internet connection in their home, more than half=20
(55%) report using a traditional dial-up telephone connection. 29% of=20
respondents utilize DSL to connect to the Internet, with 5% citing cable=20
modem usage and 3% citing wireless access. These numbers reflect the=20
dominant role DSL plays in rural broadband infrastructure. The 84% Internet=
=20
connection rate at home for rural youth is slightly higher than the=20
national rate of 68%.
[SOURCE: National Telecommunications Cooperative Association Press Release]
http://www.ntca.org/ka/ka-3.cfm?content_item_id=3D3638&folder_id=3D522

TELSTRA STOCK SALE COULD BE IN JEOPARDY AMID WAR OF WORDS
As Australia's government prepares to privatize Telstra by holding the=20
world's biggest stock sale, Telstra's new American management team is=20
waging an extraordinary -- and risky -- public battle with the government=
=20
over the telecom company's role as an effective monopoly. The government,=
=20
which holds 51.8% of Telstra, wants to sell off its stake and sock away the=
=20
proceeds for future pension obligations, infrastructure work and a variety=
=20
of other needs. Now, as part of the privatization, Australia is trying to=
=20
lessen the company's market dominance with a raft of changes. But Telstra's=
=20
management, led by Chief Executive Solomon Trujillo, has thrown a wrench=20
into the government's plans. Telstra issued a profit warning last week and=
=20
estimated that the proposed regulations "are likely to cost more than 850=
=20
million Australian dollars," or US$658 million, in annual revenue. The=20
Australian Securities and Investment Commission launched an investigation=
=20
into Telstra's compliance with its disclosure obligations.
[SOURCE: Wall Street Journal, AUTHOR: Mary Kissel mary.kissel( at )wsj.com]
http://online.wsj.com/article/0,,SB112655741451538425,00.html?mod=3Dtoda...
us_money_and_investing
(requires subscription)

QUICKLY

WHAT JOURNALISM CAN LEARN FROM ADVERTISING
[Commentary] 1) Customer insight is critical: News companies must not only=
=20
understand their markets better, but journalists must operate closer to,=20
and in conjunction with, their readers and viewers. 2) The future is=20
fragmented: The much-documented disintegration of mass media -- and the=20
accompanying division of advertising dollars -- continues (and accelerates)=
=20
with the ability of people to create their own media and remix that made by=
=20
others. Successful news organizations will be those that can slice their=20
own products thin enough for their audiences to rearrange them as they=20
choose. 3) Continual change will be the norm: Static, plodding news=20
organizations will lose market share, money and relevance. Dynamic,=20
adaptable organizations will win out. Think Senge, not Patton. The learning=
=20
newsroom, one that can continually educate and reinvent itself in=20
accordance with the world around it, will have the best chances for=20
survival. 4) Brands need stewardship. 5) Consumers need help managing=20
media: It's called editing. Journalists do it well. Now that media have=20
exploded into thousands of remixable slivers, there is value in those who=
=20
can help sort it out. 6) Push boundaries: Journalism is what we do. What=20
form it takes and how we distribute it are secondary. The only journalistic=
=20
rule that matters is to tell the truth (about the news, about our sources,=
=20
about ourselves). Other than the only limitations are self-created,=20
boundaries of tradition, newsroom culture and production. We made them. We=
=20
can get rid of them. 7) Creativity means technology: Digital technology=20
enables news organizations to meet the demands of fractured audiences, to=
=20
empower their journalists to work in more than one dimension, to present=20
news and information in layered, contextual formats and to report, analyze=
=20
and narrate the events of the world in inventive new ways that can connect=
=20
with people for whom traditional media, like newspapers and the sonorous=20
anchor, have no relevance. 8) Big ideas still rule: "Think big. Don't just=
=20
be practitioners of the craft." Tinkering won't get us anywhere. Media has=
=20
exploded. We need to explode the newsroom.
[SOURCE: First Draft, AUTHOR: Tim Porter]
http://www.timporter.com/firstdraft/

TECH FIRMS TALKING UP 'NET NEUTRALITY'
As Congress develops legislation that will rewrite the Telecommunications=
=20
Act of 1996, Internet-based companies such as eBay, Google, Yahoo and=20
IAC/InterActiveCorp have formed a loose coalition pushing for "net=20
neutrality." Such a measure would codify FCC principles laid out in early=
=20
August, which are designed to ensure that companies providing high speed=20
data services =96 such as the Bells or cable firms -- don't discriminate=20
against the content of competitors. In the cable industry, content=20
companies pay cable firms to carry their programming; the fear is that a=20
cable or Bell company could deny access to a Web site if the owners of the=
=20
site did not pay to be carried on the companies=92 high speed network. The=
=20
net neutrality push will face steep obstacles on Capitol Hill. Aides on the=
=20
House Energy and Commerce Committee as well as the Senate Commerce=20
Committee said that while no one opposes the principles of =93net neutralit=
y=94=20
there are huge questions about how such a measure would be written.=20
=93Everyone seems to support of the concept of net neutrality, but when pus=
h=20
comes to shove, and you consider how to put it on paper, members get=20
frozen,=94 said one Senate Commerce committee staff member. =93Because they=
=20
don't want to regulate private networks, and if you aren't going to=20
regulate a private network, then how can you justify net neutrality?=94
[SOURCE: National Journal's Insider Update, AUTHOR: Bara Vaida]
http://www.njtelecomupdate.com/lenya/telco/live/tb-WKNU1115070261210.html

DELAY CHIEF OF STAFF JOINING TIME WARNER
Tim Berry, chief of staff to House Majority Leader Tom Delay, is exiting to=
=20
become a lobbyist for Time Warner. Meanwhile, CBS has named Martin Franks=
=20
to executive VP, planning, policy and government relations, for CBS when it=
=20
splits off from Viacom sometime early next year, establishing Franks as the=
=20
company's top man in Washington going forward.
[SOURCE: Broadcasting&Cable]
http://www.broadcastingcable.com/article/CA6256146?display=3DBreaking+Ne...
referral=3DSUPP
http://www.broadcastingcable.com/article/CA6256067?display=3DBreaking+Ne...
referral=3DSUPP
(free access for Benton's Headlines subscribers)

MURDOCH SHARES 'VISION FOR INTERNET'
Rupert Murdoch has told his senior executives they must find ways to=20
integrate their traditional publishing and broadcasting operations with the=
=20
Internet assets in which News Corporation has invested in recent months. He=
=20
wants different parts of the media conglomerate to start talking more to=20
each other to find more ways of collaborating online.
[SOURCE: Financial Times, AUTHOR: Andrew Edgecliffe-Johnson]
http://news.ft.com/cms/s/64d7e2f6-23ae-11da-b56b-00000e2511c8.html

TIME FOR SUPREME COURT REALITY TV
[Commentary] It is time to allow cameras to show arguments presented before=
=20
the Supreme Court.
[SOURCE: USAToday, AUTHOR:Sandy Grady]
http://www.usatoday.com/printedition/news/20050913/oplede13.art.htm
--------------------------------------------------------------
Communications-related Headlines is a free online news summary service=20
provided by the Benton Foundation (www.benton.org). Posted Monday through=
=20
Friday, this service provides updates on important industry developments,=
=20
policy issues, and other related news events. While the summaries are=20
factually accurate, their often informal tone does not always represent the=
=20
tone of the original articles. Headlines are compiled by Kevin Taglang=20
(headlines( at )benton.org) -- we welcome your comments.
--------------------------------------------------------------

Benton's Communications-related Headlines For Monday September 12, 2005

For upcoming media policy events, see http://www.benton.org/calendar.htm

EMERGENCY COMMUNICATION (AND AFTERMATH)
Why Levee Breaches In New Orleans Were Late-Breaking News
News Media are Heeding a =91Call to Arms'
U.S. won't Ban Media from New Orleans Searches
Broadcasters Seek Better Emergency Alert System
FCC Reminds Stations of Emergency Obligations
An Uncertain Future for Media in New Orleans
Radio Ad Rates Soar in Gulf Coast
Belo Commits to New Orleans
An Anchor Who Reports Disaster News With a Heart on His Sleeve
A Failure To Communicate
Katrina Demonstrates Failure of Spectrum Policy
Tragedy and Telecom
Martin and Copps on Lessons of Katrina
Post-Katrina, Gulf Cable Ops Make Some Progress
not dot gov

TELEVISION/BROADCASTING/CABLE
Public Interest Obligations and the Digital Television Transition
Broadcasters Again Make Case for DTV Multicast Legislation
Cable Launches Fall Must-Carry Offensive
FCC Study Calls for Retrans Status Quo
Cable Uneven With Stevens
Indecent Proposal

JOURNALISM
Less Media Coverage of Confirmation Hearings Expected
Bombs away on Television News
Russia Media Climate Said to Be Chilling

QUICKLY -- Censored News; Teleco Merger News; EBay Agrees to Buy Skype For=
=20
$2.6 Billion; Reaching Latin viewers; Diversity Doesn't Just Happen; CWA=20
Protests CBC Lockout

EMERGENCY COMMUNICATION (AND AFTERMATH)

WHY LEVEE BREACHES IN NEW ORLEANS WERE LATE-BREAKING NEWS
The levee failures that resulted in the flooding of New Orleans apparently=
=20
happened Monday August 29, before Hurricane Katrina hit land. Yet it wasn't=
=20
until Tuesday that most people across the country realized that any levees=
=20
at all had been breached. Did media outlets get it wrong? A look at news=20
reports of the events of Aug. 29 paints a picture of confusion,=20
miscommunication and conflicting information among some government=20
officials and news media. Several major news outlets, including Viacom=20
Inc.'s CBS network and National Public Radio reported the breaking of the=
=20
Industrial Canal and flooding on Monday, although not all of the reports=20
acknowledged the extent of the devastation. The Wall Street Journal=20
reported the Industrial Canal breach but no others. Many reporters, working=
=20
on foot, isolated in higher, drier sections and focused on the survival of=
=20
the city's tourist districts, were unaware of the unfolding disaster in=20
poor neighborhoods of New Orleans. It wasn't until Monday evening that a=20
private helicopter company, Helinet Helicopter Services of Los Angeles,=20
began feeding the first aerial images of New Orleans to Fox News, ABC, NBC,=
=20
CNN and CBS. By early Tuesday morning, most major media had become aware of=
=20
the awful extent of the destruction.
[SOURCE: Wall Street Journal, AUTHOR: Joe Hagan joe.hagan( at )wsj.com and=20
Joseph T. Hallinan joe.hallinan( at )wsj.com]
http://online.wsj.com/article/0,,SB112649152397237699,00.html?mod=3Dtoda...
us_marketplace
(requires subscription)

NEWS MEDIA ARE HEADING 'A CALL TO ARMS'
Americans, usually critical of the media, have given the news coverage of=
=20
Hurricane Katrina a thumbs up, and major outlets are pledging to stay on=20
the story to find out what went wrong with the response to the disaster. A=
=20
Pew Research Center study of 1,000 Americans Sept. 6 and 7 found that 65%=
=20
rated news coverage of the hurricane good or excellent, more favorable than=
=20
the 54% approval rating for 2004 presidential election coverage. Television=
=20
dominated as the main source of information, with cable in the lead: CNN=20
was the main source for 31% of respondents, compared with Fox (22%); local=
=20
news (19%); ABC (14%); NBC (12%); MSNBC (9%) and CBS (8%). Tom Rosenstiel=
=20
of the Project for Excellence in Journalism hopes that many news=20
organizations continue to work the story, =93each one synthesizing and addi=
ng=20
to what others are learning. If only one or two news organizations do it,=
=20
it won't have the same effect.=94 The question is =93how many news=20
organizations have the investigative muscle to handle a story this complex,=
=20
and how many can afford to lose a team for the time it will take to do=20
that, especially in TV,=94 Rosenstiel says. =93I fear the list of news=20
organizations that can do that today is not very long. And sadly, it gets=
=20
shorter if ad sales go down and other news pushes Katrina off our radar=20
screens.=94
[SOURCE: USAToday]
http://www.usatoday.com/printedition/life/20050912/d_mediamix12.art.htm

US WON'T BAN MEDIA FROM NEW ORLEANS SEARCHES
Joint Task Force Katrina "has no plans to bar, impede or prevent news media=
=20
from their news gathering and reporting activities in connection with the=
=20
deceased Hurricane Katrina victim recovery efforts," said Col. Christian E.=
=20
deGraff, representing the task force. U.S. District Court Judge Keith=20
Ellison issued a temporary restraining order Friday against a "zero access"=
=20
policy announced earlier in the day by Army Lt. Gen. Russel Honore, who is=
=20
overseeing the federal relief effort in the city, and Terry Ebbert, the=20
city's homeland security director. In explaining the ban, Ebbert said, "we=
=20
don't think that's proper" to let members of the media view the bodies.
[SOURCE: CNN]
http://www.cnn.com/2005/LAW/09/10/katrina.media/

BROADCASTERS SEEK BETTER EMERGENCY ALERT SYSTEM
The Emergency Alert System was never activated by the White House or by=20
state or local governments during Katrina. In the wake of the 9/11 attacks=
=20
in 2001, WNET New York and a number of partners and government officials=20
began developing a way to use broadcast spectrum dedicated to education=20
(known as Educational Broadband Service, or EBS) as a tool for solving the=
=20
communication problems encountered on 9/11. The system, formerly known as=
=20
Smart Nets but now dubbed GUARD (Geospatially-aware Urban Approaches for=20
Responding to Disasters), relies on small 30-pound antenna/transmission=20
systems placed throughout a town or city and allows a command center to=20
send live video, audio communications and data files with, for example,=20
instructions or floor plans to PDA-type devices. The trials in New York are=
=20
going so well that WNET Director of Digital Convergence Stephen Carol=20
Cahnmann says the developers are considering expanding to another city,=20
perhaps St. Louis.
[SOURCE: Broadcasting&Cable, AUTHOR: Ken Kerschbaumer]
http://www.broadcastingcable.com/article/CA6255755?display=3DNews&referral=
=3DSUPP
(free access for Benton's Headlines subscribers)

FCC REMINDS STATIONS OF EMERGENCY OBLIGATIONS
The FCC Friday cautioned broadcasters covering Hurricane Katrina not to=20
forget to make all their emergency information available to the deaf and=20
hard of hearing. While it saluted the "heroic efforts of all those who have=
=20
worked to protect life and property from the ravages of Hurricane Katrina,=
=20
including those to whom this reminder is directed," it also said that it=20
had received complaints that "some emergency information being provided=20
over television is not being made accessible to individuals who are deaf or=
=20
hard of hearing." Broadcasters aren't required to closed caption all that=
=20
information--the logistics of that would be enormous, particularly for=20
smaller stations--but they have to make sure it is relayed in some=20
accessible form, including crawls or graphics, or something as simple as=20
"handwriting on a blackboard."
[SOURCE: Broadcasting&Cable, AUTHOR: John Eggerton]
http://www.broadcastingcable.com/article/CA6255888?display=3DBreaking+Ne...
referral=3DSUPP
(free access for Benton's Headlines subscribers)
See FCC Reminder:=20
http://hraunfoss.fcc.gov/edocs_public/attachmatch/DA-05-2438A1.pdf
* Stations Oppose Hurricane Coverage Fine
Two TV stations are asking the FCC to rescind or reduce fines for their=20
failure "in three instances lasting a total of 44 seconds," to make=20
emergency information available to hearing impaired listeners during a=20
Florida hurricane last year.
http://www.broadcastingcable.com/article/CA6255617?display=3DBreaking+Ne...
referral=3DSUPP
(free access for Benton's Headlines subscribers)

AN UNCERTAIN FUTURE FOR MEDIA IN NEW ORLEANS
New Orleans media outlets, including The Times-Picayune and seven=20
television stations making up the nation's 43rd-largest media market, have=
=20
been left to contemplate a surreal future of unknown duration in a city=20
devoid of functioning businesses, with no goods to advertise and almost no=
=20
people to buy them. As a plaintive Times-Picayune headline put it Friday,=
=20
"Few Souls Remain in Shell of a City." For the media outlets of New=20
Orleans, the short-term issue has been to find a way to publish and=20
distribute, to get on the air and stay on the air, while simultaneously=20
covering and being caught up in what may be the biggest natural disaster in=
=20
the nation's history. The extent of the physical damage to their plants and=
=20
stations is unclear. Most have been dislocated and their staff members are=
=20
working out of temporary newsrooms and studios around the region, barred by=
=20
flood damage and a lack of electricity from getting back to their desks.=20
The chaos of the short term has obscured the abyss of the long term, which=
=20
is only beginning to emerge. As the news media outlets continue to produce,=
=20
who will be reading them? Who will be watching them? And who will be paying=
=20
for the substantial additional costs of gathering news during the crisis,=
=20
which, for television stations, include expenses like renting helicopters?=
=20
The closest analogy for how advertisers can approach the New Orleans market=
=20
may be World War II, when there was virtually no production of consumer=20
goods like cars and appliances as factories were retooled for military=20
purposes. Many marketers continued to advertise, running patriotic pitches=
=20
to stimulate sales of war bonds or offering uplifting vistas of a rosy=20
postwar life.
[SOURCE: New York Times, AUTHOR: Katharine Seelye]
http://www.nytimes.com/2005/09/12/business/media/12media.html
(requires registration)

RADIO AD RATES SOAR IN GULF COAST
Hurricane Katrina has wreaked havoc with the advertising environment in the=
=20
affected area. Particularly in the days after the storm, when thousands of=
=20
people without power used battery-operated radios to stay informed, radio=
=20
was the best way to reach employees and potential customers. Even as power=
=20
comes back on around the region, just about everybody who didn't have=20
pre-existing contracts is paying more to reach listeners. The spot=20
advertising increases, even on stations that aren't simulcasting, are in=20
the region of 20%-30%, informed people say. Privately, many radio=20
executives say that isn't out of line, given that the number of listeners=
=20
in a market drives rates, and towns like Baton Rouge have seen sizable=20
population increases. Some advertisers, like those with lighthearted ads,=
=20
have been scrambling to pull theirs. Others, like insurers and power=20
companies, have been struggling to get onto the airwaves. And radio sales=
=20
forces around the region are scrambling to stay ahead.
[SOURCE: Wall Street Journal, AUTHOR: Sarah McBride sarah.mcbride( at )wsj.com]
http://online.wsj.com/article/0,,SB112647662677137426,00.html?mod=3Dtoda...
us_marketplace
(requires subscription)

BELO COMMITS TO NEW ORLEANS
Belo Corp is walking a fine line in New Orleans. TV station WWL is one of=
=20
only a few media outlets to survive Huricanne Katrina, but it had to move=
=20
operations to its transmitter site at Louisiana State University. Belo is=
=20
facing incremental cost from such operations and WWL's ongoing news=20
coverage. Belo is withdrawing its financial estimates for the third=20
quarter, following a similar move earlier this week by Hearst-Argyle, owner=
=20
of New Orleans' NBC affiliate WDSU. Belo is also putting on hold plans to=
=20
build a new facility for WWL. It is hard to tell when the area will=20
stabilize and generate consist revenue for the station (and other outlets).=
=20
The company is asking Wall Street analysts and investors to "take a=20
conservative approach" toward the New Orleans advertising market. WWL has=
=20
been a strong contributor to Belo's coffers, with $35 million in revenue=20
last year accounting for 2.3% of the company's revenue. As New Orleans and=
=20
its TV stations rebuild, "WWL's longtime news leadership position in New=20
Orleans, and its singular performance over the past fortnight, constitute a=
=20
valuable competitive advantage that will contribute significantly to the=20
station's ability to rebuild its advertising base as the New Orleans market=
=20
recovers," the company said in a statement.
[SOURCE: Broadcasting&Cable, AUTHOR: Allison Romano]
http://www.broadcastingcable.com/article/CA6255816?display=3DBreaking+Ne...
referral=3DSUPP
(free access for Benton's Headlines subscribers)

AN ANCHOR WHO REPORTS DISASTER NEWS WITH A HEART ON HIS SLEEVE
CNN cable news host Anderson Cooper has dressed down officials in=20
interviews with polite righteous indignation in behalf of hurricane=20
victims. At least twice he choked up on air, once abruptly stopping his=20
commentary about lost homes and waving away the camera as he looked about=
=20
to burst into tears. Mr. Cooper's Sept. 1 interview with Senator Mary L.=20
Landrieu, Democrat of Louisiana, marked a turning point in the tone of=20
hurricane coverage as he snapped when she began thanking federal officials=
=20
for their recovery efforts. "Excuse me, Senator, I'm sorry for=20
interrupting," Mr. Cooper interjected. "I haven't heard that, because, for=
=20
the last four days, I've been seeing dead bodies in the streets here in=20
Mississippi. And to listen to politicians thanking each other and=20
complimenting each other, you know, I got to tell you, there are a lot of=
=20
people here who are very upset, and very angry, and very frustrated. "And=
=20
when they hear politicians slap -- you know, thanking one another, it just,=
=20
you know, it kind of cuts them the wrong way right now, because literally=
=20
there was a body on the streets of this town yesterday being eaten by rats=
=20
because this woman had been laying in the street for 48 hours." His=20
comments pushed right up to the line between tough questioning and=20
confrontational advocacy journalism, but viewers responded.
[SOURCE: New York Times, AUTHOR: Elizabeth Jensen]
http://www.nytimes.com/2005/09/12/arts/television/12coop.html
(requires registration)

A FAILURE TO COMMUNICATE
A massive breakdown in communications after Hurricane Katrina hit the Gulf=
=20
Coast -- nearly four years after the devastating mishaps following 9/11 --=
=20
has brought the issue of emergency communications into the spotlight on=20
Capitol Hill. Washington has started to assess the system failures exposed=
=20
by the government=92s delayed response to Katrina. The ability of police an=
d=20
firefighters to better communicate during emergencies has been one of the=
=20
major motivations for the DTV transition because some of the spectrum to be=
=20
reclaimed from broadcasters=97almost certainly now sometime in 2009 -- is t=
o=20
go toward wireless services for first responders. The issue is sure to come=
=20
up at DTV-transition hearings in the House and Senate Commerce Committees=
=20
this month and at the FCC meeting on Thursday.
[SOURCE: Broadcasting&Cable, AUTHOR: John Eggerton]
http://www.broadcastingcable.com/article/CA6255754.html?display=3DNews&r...
rral=3DSUPP
(free access for Benton's Headlines subscribers)

KATRINA DEMONSTRATES FAILURE OF CURRENT U.S. SPECTRUM POLICY
In recent days the press has extensively covered the telecommunications=20
breakdown in New Orleans and the attempts of telephone, cable, and=20
broadcast companies to reinstate service and help disaster victims. What=
=20
has not been covered as extensively in the media is the lack of=20
communications at dozens of rural Louisiana shelters and the efforts of=20
Wireless Internet Service Providers (WISPs), which use unlicensed spectrum,=
=20
to address this problem. As New Orleans is being evacuated, thousands of=20
evacuees are streaming out into the countryside where churches and=20
communities have set up shelters to take care of them. Unfortunately, many=
=20
of these shelters lack telecommunications service. Responding to this=20
need, dozens of rural WISPs have poured into rural Louisiana to help=20
out. As Congress moves digital TV legislation to free up spectrum for=20
broadband telecommunications, the lack of telecommunications services in=20
the wake of Katrina has moved front and center. Much of the freed up=20
broadcast spectrum could be converted to broadband use. The broadcast=20
industry has been fighting tooth and nail to prevent this from happening in=
=20
a timely fashion. Most press attention has focused on the industry's=20
effort to delay giving back the channels Congress loaned to transition=20
digital TV. Less well known is that the industry has also been fighting to=
=20
keep as many as possible of the unused TV channels ("guard bands" between=
=20
the currently used channels) for their own future use. For example, a=20
video being distributed on Capitol Hill (www.mstv.org/static.html) argues=
=20
that complete havoc will be created if unlicensed broadband devices are=20
allowed in the unused TV channels. The FCC has initiated a rulemaking=20
(Docket 04-186) to require these channels to be opened up for unlicensed=20
broadband use. The broadcasters are now lobbying Congress to kill this=20
rulemaking. Said Ed Thomas, former FCC Chief Engineer responsible for the=
=20
FCC's rulemaking, "I strongly urge Congress to direct the Commission as the=
=20
expert government agency to bring this proceeding to a conclusion. A golden=
=20
opportunity exists to extend the social and economic benefits of broadband=
=20
to all Americans. I urge Congress and the FCC not to be persuaded by the=20
invalid self-serving claims of a few."
[SOURCE: New America Foundation press release]
http://www.newamerica.net/index.cfm?pg=3Dsec_home&secID=3D3
* Fact Sheet: Myths Regarding Unlicensed Use of the TV Band White Space
http://www.newamerica.net/Download_Docs/pdfs/Doc_File_2550_1.pdf
* Statement of Ed Thomas, former FCC Chief Engineer, can be found at:=20
http://www.newamerica.net/Download_Docs/pdfs/Doc_File_2547_1.pdf

TRAGEDY AND TELECOM
[Commentary] With respect to its effect on infrastructure, Katrina gave=20
much more notice of impending disaster than the September 11 attacks. And=
=20
yet, when the hurricane hit land, we saw -- four years after 9/11 -- the=20
same meltdown of service, but this time over 90,000 square miles. When our=
=20
citizens found themselves drowning in their own homes or, three days later,=
=20
still marooned on their rooftops, they had no way to call and no one to=20
call for help. It turns out we have developed a budding broadband system=20
that, in times of disaster, doesn't work as well, interrupts more easily,=
=20
and comes back on line later than the good old copper-wire system. And=20
"emergency preparedness" apparently doesn't mean that in an emergency you=
=20
can actually dial 911. The 1996 Telecom Act has taken our country exactly=
=20
where we wanted it to. But thanks to the extreme nonregulatory bias of the=
=20
current government (and despite its having had four years to learn from the=
=20
9/11 horror), it's clear the Bush Administration, the Federal=20
Communications Commission, the Federal Emergency Management Agency, and the=
=20
Homeland Security Dept. have thrown the baby out with the bath water when=
=20
it comes to telecom emergency preparedness. And if you happen to live in=20
flood-ravaged New Orleans, this particular metaphor is simply too painful=
=20
to ponder. So should the devastated 90,000 square miles end up, after some=
=20
federal subsidy, with state-of-the-art broadband and wireless=20
communications when the rebuilding is finished? You bet they should. And=20
because having these capabilities will greatly hasten economic and=20
employment recovery, some government backing of this effort is entirely=20
appropriate.
[SOURCE: BusinessWeek, AUTHOR: Leo Hindery Jr.]
http://www.businessweek.com/bwdaily/dnflash/sep2005/nf20050912_8022.htm?...
n=3Dtc

MARTIN AND COPPS ON LESSONS OF KATRINA
Last week, FCC Chairman Kevin Martin and Commissioner Michael Copps visited=
=20
communities in the Gulf State region affected by Hurricane Katrina. They=
=20
witnessed first hand the impact of the storm on the residents and the=20
region's telecommunications infrastructure. Chairman Martin and=20
Commissioner Copps stated: "We are encouraged that in the aftermath of=20
Hurricane Katrina carriers are working day and night to speed the=20
restoration of service in Gulf State communities. We salute the Herculean=
=20
efforts of their employees-many of whom have experienced terrible personal=
=20
loss and property damage in this tragic storm. We are committed to doing=
=20
everything within our power to aid these extraordinary recovery=20
efforts. In the days ahead, the challenge will be facilitating service=20
restoration. But in the long term, we will need to learn from this event=
=20
and work together to improve the reliability, survivability, and security=
=20
of our nation's telecommunications networks." On Thursday, September 15,=20
2005, the Commission will hold an Open Meeting that will focus on the=20
effects of Hurricane Katrina on communications services in the Gulf Coast=
=20
states.
[SOURCE: Federal Communications Commission]
http://hraunfoss.fcc.gov/edocs_public/attachmatch/DOC-260931A1.doc

POST-KATRINA, GULF CABLE OPS MAKE SOME PROGRESS
Cable operators in the most ravaged areas in Hurricane Katrina=92s path are=
=20
slowly gaining access to their properties and making progress in accounting=
=20
for local employees.
[SOURCE: Multichannel News, AUTHOR: Linda Haugsted]
http://www.multichannel.com/article/CA6255903.html
(requires subscription)

NOT DOT GOV
As authorities scrambled in the wake of Katrina, media technology was being=
=20
harnessed by ordinary citizens to assist the displaced. With no official=20
mandate, central organizing principle, or pay, Internet users compiled=20
lists, message boards, and lists of lists and message boards. BuzzMachine=
=20
blogger Jeff Jarvis tells Bob about Recovery 2.0, an effort to consolidate=
=20
the relief efforts and prepare better for the future.
[SOURCE: OnTheMedia]
http://www.onthemedia.org/stream/ram.py?file=3Dotm/otm090905d.mp3

TELEVISION/BROADCASTING/CABLE

LEGAL CENTER SENDS LETTER TO HILL REGARDING PUBLIC INTEREST OBLIGATIONS AND=
=20
DIGITAL TELEVISION TRANSITION
The Campaign Legal Center's Media Policy Program, Common Cause, the Media=
=20
Access Project, the New America Foundation and the Office of Communication=
=20
of the United Church of Christ sent a letter last week to leaders of the=20
House and Senate Commerce Committees urging them to "ensure that public=20
interest obligations are at the core of the upcoming debate about the=20
future of television, especially in light of critical decisions you are=20
facing regarding multicasting must-carry." The organizations write, "Taking=
=20
this opportunity to define public interest obligations in the digital age=
=20
is critical because even in the current analog scheme, most broadcasters do=
=20
not fulfill their most basic pledge to serve the American viewers." The=20
groups also support strong disclosure requirements since they "would give=
=20
the FCC more complete and accurate information to make better policy, as=20
well as provide viewers with information about the programming being aired=
=20
in their communities."
[SOURCE: Campaign Legal Center , Media Policy Program]
http://www.campaignlegalcenter.org/press-1766.html

BROADCASTERS AGAIN MAKE CASE FOR DTV MULTICAST LEGISLATION
Nearly 100 broadcasters from across the country converged on Capitol Hill=
=20
last week, meeting with members on both the House and Senate Commerce=20
Committees to educate them on the importance of crafting pro-consumer=20
legislation that ensures cable companies carry broadcasters' multicast=20
stations. During the second DTV Fly-In event this summer, NAB's grassroots=
=20
representatives presented a compelling case for providing viewers with=20
access to more local news, weather, sports, additional public affairs=20
programming and foreign language programming. It is critical that NAB's=20
message gets through and that Congress passes a multicasting mandate that=
=20
prevents the cable gatekeepers from thwarting viewer access to more local=
=20
program choices.
[SOURCE: National Association of Broadcasters]
(Not available online)

CABLE LAUNCHES FALL MUST-CARRY OFFENSIVE
In the weeks ahead, Congress is expected to put a formal end to analog TV,=
=20
forcing broadcasters to rely solely on digital transmission, starting as=20
soon as 2009. While simple-sounding in the abstract, the effort to complete=
=20
a digital transition, now in its eighth (8th!) year, has triggered the most=
=20
acrimonious policy dispute between cable and broadcasting since the run-up=
=20
to passage of the 1992 Cable Act. The two camps are at odds over carriage=
=20
of DTV signals. When a TV station today elects mandatory cable carriage,=20
the cable system is required to carry just one programming service per=20
station. Over cable=92s objections, broadcasters want the carriage=20
requirement expanded to include as many free digital programming streams=20
that can technologically fit within a 6-MHz channel. The NCTA and the=20
National Association of Broadcasters are going all out to win. Pointed ads=
=20
have been running in Capitol Hill newspapers, tough-sounding e-mails have=
=20
been flooding inboxes and executives from both sides have been buzzing=20
congressional offices to ply influential lawmakers with their latest=20
economic studies and legal analyses.
[SOURCE: Multichannel News, AUTHOR: Ted Hearn]
http://www.multichannel.com/article/CA6255827.html?display=3DPolicy
(requires subscription)

FCC STUDY CALLS FOR RETRANS STATUS QUO
In a report to Congress released Friday, the Federal Communications=20
Commission declined to recommend changing laws that allow TV stations to=20
bargain for cable carriage despite MSO concerns about hardball tactics=20
employed by the major broadcast networks. The retransmission-consent law,=
=20
passed in 1992, is largely working as intended, meaning that =93the local=
=20
television broadcaster and the [pay TV distributor] negotiate in the=20
context of a level playing field in which the failure to resolve local=20
broadcast-carriage disputes through the retransmission-consent process=20
potentially is detrimental to each side,=94 the FCC concluded in the 43-pag=
e=20
report.
[SOURCE: Multichannel News, AUTHOR: Ted Hearn]
http://www.multichannel.com/article/CA6255858.html?display=3DBreaking+News
(requires subscription)
See FCC's Report to Congress on Retransmission Consent:
http://hraunfoss.fcc.gov/edocs_public/attachmatch/DOC-260936A1.doc

CABLE UNEVEN WITH STEVENS
Sen. Ted Stevens (R-Alaska), the chair of the Commerce Committee, has=20
concluded that a major PR campaign pointing out how easy it is for parents=
=20
to block cable channels does not adequately address the issue of indecency=
=20
in cable programming. That means the $250 million =93Cable Puts You in=20
Control=94 campaign is failing in one of its key objectives: mollifying=20
critics on Capitol Hill. What comes next is unclear, but it could be bad=20
news for cable executives trying to keep government out of their=20
programming decisions. Sen Stevens has yet to disclose what steps he'll=20
take=97whether to mandate a family-friendly programming tier or simply writ=
e=20
cable programming into indecency law that now affects only broadcasters.=20
The ball is in his court since the House already passed its version of=20
indecency legislation, boosting fines but leaving cable unscathed.
[SOURCE: MediaWeek, AUTHOR: Todd Shields]
http://www.mediaweek.com/mw/news/recent_display.jsp?vnu_content_id=3D100...
6027

INDECENT PROPOSAL
[Commentary] The Center for Creative Voices in Media was stumping last week=
=20
in favor of government regulations to combat indecency. The Center released=
=20
a report that found a link between big media and programming that loads of=
=20
people like and some don't. We agree that big media has gotten too big, but=
=20
that is not an excuse to limit free speech. It is unwise to ever use some=
=20
peoples' dislike of some kinds of speech to invite the government to=20
regulate it. Period.
[SOURCE: Broadcasting&Cable, AUTHOR: Editorial Staff]
http://www.broadcastingcable.com/article/CA6255868?display=3DOpinion&ref...
al=3DSUPP
(free access for Benton's Headlines subscribers)
See the CCVM rport at:=20
http://www.creativevoices.us/cgi-upload/news/news_article/FINALReport090...
.pdf

JOURNALISM

LESS MEDIA COVERAGE OF CONFIRMATION HEARINGS EXPECTED
When the Senate confirmation hearings for Judge John Roberts begin this=20
morning, the cable news networks plan to dip in and out after carrying some=
=20
opening statements. The far more dramatic pictures of flood-ravaged New=20
Orleans and Biloxi, Miss., will continue to dominate the on-air coverage,=
=20
and the uproar over the administration's handling of the disaster has=20
greatly eclipsed Roberts in the print media. Had there been no hurricane,=
=20
the battle over the next chief justice would be the media's top story=20
instead of a sidebar. While PBS, Court TV and C-SPAN3 will carry the=20
hearings live, arguments about strict constructionism and legal precedents=
=20
will simply have trouble competing with a catastrophe that most likely=20
killed thousands. Some newspapers last week led with the president's=20
decision, after William Rehnquist's death, to name Roberts to succeed him=
=20
instead of Sandra Day O'Connor, but that took a back seat to Katrina on the=
=20
network newscasts and quickly faded. A key factor in dampening coverage of=
=20
the Roberts hearings is the apparent lack of suspense about the outcome.=20
With most of the 55 Republican senators, and some Democratic ones, voicing=
=20
support for the appellate judge, a media consensus formed early that he was=
=20
a shoo-in. But even if the vote were a cliffhanger, the story would still=
=20
have trouble competing with the worst natural disaster in American history.
[SOURCE: Washington Post, AUTHOR: Howard Kurtz]
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2005/09/11/AR200509...
1526.html
(requires registration)

BOMBS AWAY ON TELEVISION NEWS
[Commentary] When this nation's founding fathers set out on their=20
experiment in democratic governance, one of their most revolutionary ideas=
=20
was that political power would be moderated not only by checks and balances=
=20
built into the government, but by a free and independent press that would=
=20
provide knowledge to the public and warn of pending dangers. As James=20
Madison bluntly observed, "A popular government without popular=20
information, or the means of securing it, is but a prelude to a farce or=20
tragedy, perhaps both." It is increasingly difficult to discern the vision=
=20
of Madison in broadcast news today, even though most of it comes over=20
airwaves owned by the public and licensed to commercial outlets for a few=
=20
hundred dollars a year. If avoiding "dark" becomes the criterion for=20
broadcast news, how will Americans learn about such stories as New Orleans=
=20
and Iraq, never mind Sierra Leone, Kosovo, the melting polar ice cap or the=
=20
dying oceans? If only perky, upbeat stories and shows make it onto the air,=
=20
who will inform the public and play the watchdog role? As the media get=20
increasingly ratings-driven and profit-hungry, fewer and fewer news=20
division executives support serious journalism. The result is that too many=
=20
excellent broadcast journalists now feel discouraged, debased and=20
disgusted. The reality is that it is increasingly less realistic to expect=
=20
commercial broadcast outlets to effectively serve two masters: the public=
=20
interest and corporate bottom line.
[SOURCE: Los Angeles Times, AUTHOR: Orville Schell, UC Berkeley's Graduate=
=20
School of Journalism]
http://www.latimes.com/news/printedition/opinion/la-oe-schell12sep12,1,3...
785.story?coll=3Dla-news-comment
(requires registration)

RUSSIAN MEDIA CLIMATE SAID TO BE CHILLING
Human rights leaders say that in President Vladimir V. Putin's Russia,=20
journalists increasingly face a campaign of intimidation by the authorities=
=20
and corrupt business interests. The New York-based Committee to Protect=20
Journalists complained in July that "Russia's poor press climate is=20
declining at an alarming rate." Twelve journalists have been slain since=20
2000. The number of criminal cases against journalists, accusing them of=20
libel and insulting public officials, is increasing, in addition to the=20
6,000 to 8,000 civil defamation cases filed every year in which the burden=
=20
of proof is on the accused, said Oleg Panfilov, head of the Moscow-based=20
Center for Journalism in Extreme Situations.
[SOURCE: Los Angeles Times, AUTHOR:Kim Murphy]
http://www.latimes.com/news/printedition/asection/la-fg-press12sep12,1,2...
887.story?coll=3Dla-news-a_section
(requires registration)

QUICKLY

Project Censored presents the 10 biggest stories the mainstream media=20
ignored over the past year
List includes: #7. Journalists face unprecedented dangers to life and=20
livelihood; #4. Surveillance society quietly moves in; #3. Another year of=
=20
distorted election coverage and 1. Bush administration moves to eliminate=
=20
open government.
[SOURCE: San Francisco Bay Guardian, AUTHOR: Camille Tiara camille( at )sfbg.com]
http://www.sfbg.com/39/49/cover_censored.html

TELECO MERGER NEWS
FCC Chairman Kevin Martin has told staff to prepare a draft order approving=
=20
the SBC-AT&T and Verizon-MCI mergers, Precursor Advisors, a financial=20
research firm, said Fri. in a report. Chairman Martin plans to seek=20
approval from the politically split 2-2 Commission without waiting for=20
confirmations of new Commissioners that
would give him a Republican majority. The draft order could circulate among=
=20
other Commissioners as soon as mid-Sept. and be approved as early as Oct.
[SOURCE: Communications Daily]
(Not available online)

EBAY AGREES TO BUY SKYPE
EBay said this morning it will acquire Luxembourg-based Skype Technologies=
=20
SA for $2.6 billion, split evenly between cash and eBay stock. Skype is a=
=20
privately-held Internet communications company with 54 million customers=20
around the globe. EBay, which has been seeking to enhance its core=20
e-commerce business while venturing into a fast-growing segment of the=20
communications field, has been expanding geographically but, besides a=20
handful of small acquisitions, hasn't ventured much outside the=20
online-auction business. The purchase of Skype represents a big step in a=
=20
new direction, causing concern among many investors.
[SOURCE: Wall Street Journal, AUTHOR: Stephen Wisnefski and Desiree Hanford]
http://online.wsj.com/article/0,,SB112651960619337861,00.html?mod=3Dhome...
ats_news_us
(requires subscription)
* EBay to buy Skype
http://today.reuters.com/news/newsArticle.aspx?type=3DtechnologyNews&sto...
D=3D2005-09-12T104538Z_01_HO227963_RTRIDST_0_TECH-SKYPE-EBAY-DC.XML

ENGLISH? SPANISH? WHICH IS BEST TO REACH LATIN VIEWERS?
Answers to those questions will help allocate the billions in ad revenues=
=20
that are targeted toward America=92s largest and fastest-growing ethnic=20
group. Unfortunately, they also tend to trigger some very divisive=20
political and cultural debates over immigration and the future of U.S. cult=
ure.
[SOURCE: Broadcasting&Cable, AUTHOR: George Winslow]
http://www.broadcastingcable.com/article/CA6255761.html?display=3DSpecia...
eport&referral=3DSUPP
(free access for Benton's Headlines subscribers)

DIVERSITY DOESN'T JUST HAPPEN
[Commentary] Real diversity requires a commitment to change, and concrete=
=20
actions.
[SOURCE: Broadcasting&Cable, AUTHOR: Debbie Smith, Walter Kaitz Foundation]
http://www.broadcastingcable.com/article/CA6255867?display=3DOpinion&ref...
al=3DSUPP
(free access for Benton's Headlines subscribers)

CWA PROTESTS CBC LOCKOUT
Today marks the 29th day of a Canadian Broadcasting Corp lockout of=20
Canadian Communications Workers of America members. So US CWA members plan=
=20
protests at the Canadian embassy in Washington today to show their=20
solidarity. For news on the lockout, check out=20
http://cbcunplugged.blogware.com/blog
[SOURCE: Broadcasting&Cable, AUTHOR: John Eggerton]
http://www.broadcastingcable.com/article/CA6255852?display=3DBreaking+Ne...
referral=3DSUPP
(free access for Benton's Headlines subscribers)
--------------------------------------------------------------
Communications-related Headlines is a free online news summary service=20
provided by the Benton Foundation (www.benton.org). Posted Monday through=
=20
Friday, this service provides updates on important industry developments,=
=20
policy issues, and other related news events. While the summaries are=20
factually accurate, their often informal tone does not always represent the=
=20
tone of the original articles. Headlines are compiled by Kevin Taglang=20
(headlines( at )benton.org) -- we welcome your comments.
--------------------------------------------------------------

Benton's Communications-related Headlines For Friday September 9, 2005

For upcoming media policy events, see http://www.benton.org/calendar.htm

EMERGENCY COMMUNICATIONS
Media Groups: FEMA Censoring Death
Media Moguls, not Looters, Killed Katrina=92s Truth Tellers
Benefit Not Intended to 'Shelter' Politics
The Radio Station That Could, and Did, and Still Does, Help
Official Blocks Radio Station For Hurricane Evacuees
Feingold Asks TV Networks to Provide Airtime for Hurricane Survivo=
rs
Wireless Networks Give Voice To Evacuees
Displaced Students Turn to Internet
After Katrina: Congressman Slams Comms Funding
At Center of Crisis, City Officials Faced Struggle to Keep in Touch
FCC Assigns Emergency Telephone Numbers in
Response to Relief/Restoration Efforts

BROADCASTING/CABLE
FCC Commissioner Lauds Findings Of Media Indecency Study
Texas Cable Sues Over State Franchises
Telco TV Expected to Surge

INTERNET
Is the Internet the Public Utility of the Future?
Illinois Governor Creates Broadband Deployment Council
E-sales Tax Debate to Resume this Fall
News Corporation, With IGN in Its Stable, Backs Up Promise to
Be Bigger Web Player
U.S. Sues Realtors, Claims Web Rules Limit Discounting
Plan by 13 Nations Urges Open Technology Standards

QUICKLY -- Cable Ownership Proceeding Extended; SBC-AT&T Merger Review=20
Clock Stopped; Hearing Aid Compatibility Requirements for Wireless=20
Carriers; China Telecom Blocks Internet Phone Service; Intellectual Property

EMERGENCY COMMUNICATIONS

MEDIA GROUPS: FEMA CENSORING DEATH
When the Federal Emergency Management Agency asked the media not to take=20
pictures of those killed by Hurricane Katrina and its aftermath, they were=
=20
censoring a key part of the disaster story, free speech watchdogs said on=
=20
Wednesday. Newspapers, television outlets and Web sites have featured=20
pictures of shrouded corpses and makeshift graves in New Orleans. But on=20
Tuesday, FEMA refused to take reporters and photographers along on boats=20
seeking victims in flooded areas, saying they would take up valuable space=
=20
need in the recovery effort and asked them not to take pictures of the=20
dead. FEMA's policy of excluding media from recovery expeditions in New=20
Orleans is "an invitation to chaos," according to Tom Rosenstiel, director=
=20
of the Project for Excellence in Journalism.
[SOURCE: Reuters, AUTHOR: Deborah Zabarenko]
http://today.reuters.com/news/NewsArticle.aspx?type=3DtopNews&storyID=3D...
5-09-07T202009Z_01_SPI773106_RTRIDST_0_NEWS-CENSORSHIP-DC.XML
* Media provide forums for administration officials and conservatives to=20
spread falsehoods about hurricane relief efforts
Media Matters for America reports that Bush Administration officials and=20
conservative commentators have repeatedly used the national media to spread=
=20
misinformation about the federal government's widely criticized response to=
=20
the devastation caused by Hurricane Katrina.
http://mediamatters.org/items/200509080002
* Where is media outrage over purported government attempts to restrict=20
Katrina coverage?
http://mediamatters.org/items/200509080025
* Katrina Timeline
http://www.thinkprogress.org/katrina-timeline

MEDIA MOGULS, NOT LOOTERS, KILLED KATRINA'S TRUTH TELLERS
[Commentary] For the first 120 hours after Hurricane Katrina, TV=20
journalists were let off their leashes by their mogul owners, the result of=
=20
a rare conjoining of flawless timing (summer=92s biggest vacation week) and=
=20
foulest tragedy (America=92s worst natural disaster). The depth of their=20
reporting, unashamed to show their outrage, bested almost anything written=
=20
by the most talented and experienced newspaper reporters. And the rawness=
=20
of that televised despair spurred a still-new generation of Internet blogs=
=20
and Web magazines to abandon their potty-mouthed snarking for long enough=
=20
to start snarling at the proliferation of government lies and lying liars=
=20
who tell them. All of a sudden, broadcasters, and the Web media who shadow=
=20
them, narrated disturbing images of the poor, the minority, the aged, the=
=20
sick and the dead, and discussed complex issues like poverty, race, class,=
=20
infirmity and ecology, that never make it on the air =97 in this Swift=20
Boat/gay marriage/Michael Jackson media-sideshow era. But the truth telling=
=20
soon turned to backslapping. Lost amid all the self-congratulation by=20
broadcasters once the crisis point had been passed was the fact that TV=20
journalists went back to business-as-usual by the weekend. Their choke=20
chains had been yanked by no-longer-inattentive parent-company bosses who,=
=20
fearful of any FCC regulatory fallout from fingering FEMA and the Bush=20
Administration, decided yet again to sacrifice community need for corporate=
=20
greed. Now comes the real test of pathos vs. profit: whether the TV=20
newscasters will spend the fresh reservoir of truth and trust earned with=
=20
the public to challenge FEMA=92s attempt to perpetrate a campaign of mass=
=20
deception.
[SOURCE: LA Weekly, AUTHOR: Nikke Finke]
http://www.laweekly.com/ink/05/42/deadline-finke.php

BENEFIT NOT INTENDED TO 'SHELTER' POLITICS
While the executive producer of Friday night=92s Hurricane Katrina benefit=
=20
concert, Shelter From The Storm: A Concert For The Gulf Coast, says the=20
show will only edit out of a star=92s comments if they contain obscenities,=
a=20
30-second delay does give individual networks the chance to edit out any=20
political asides on the order of Kanye West=92s appearance on last week=92s=
NBC=20
telethon. In that show, West went off script to criticize the government's=
=20
relief effort and said President George W. Bush didn't care about black=20
people. NBC left the comments in. West is also slated for an appearance on=
=20
the Friday broadcast. Joel Gallen said Thursday the show will be aired on a=
=20
30-second delay that is =93standard=94 for these types of broadcasts. =93Th=
e=20
delay is not to be used and will not be used for any of those kind of=20
remarks,=94 he said, referring to politically-charged commentary, though he=
=20
doesn't expect there to be any. =93It=92s purely for the accidental obsceni=
ty=20
or things like that that are normal that networks normally take precautions=
=20
for all live broadcasts.=94
[SOURCE: Broadcasting&Cable, AUTHOR: Ben Grossman]
http://www.broadcastingcable.com/article/CA6255498?display=3DBreaking+Ne...
referral=3DSUPP
(free access for Benton's Headlines subscribers)

THE RADIO STATION THAT COULD, AND DID, AND STILL DOES, HELP
With many of their worst fears now fact, the people in and around New=20
Orleans have needed to communicate with one another: to seek or offer help,=
=20
to criticize this agency or praise that one, to vent, cry, reassure or just=
=20
find comfort in the soothing radio voice of someone who has shared their=20
loss. Some people might find escape through a country-music station, or=20
affirmation from a local Christian station that suggests that the Sodom=20
known as New Orleans got what it deserved. But most people here are=20
listening to the United Radio Broadcasters of New Orleans, a=20
round-the-clock radio program born of the hurricane, which is broadcast=20
over several stations to cast a radio-wave net that holds New Orleans toget=
her.
[SOURCE: New York Times, AUTHOR: Dan Barry]
http://www.nytimes.com/2005/09/09/national/nationalspecial/09radios.html
(requires registration)

OFFICIAL BLOCKS RADIO STATION FOR HURRICANE EVACUEES
A low-power radio station for evacuees from Hurricane Katrina that was=20
prepared to launch Wednesday at the Houston Astrodome likely will not go on=
=20
the air because of a denial by the "incident commander" at the stadium,=20
radio volunteers said. The station was granted a temporary FCC license and=
=20
had support from the Texas governor's office, as well as city officials.=20
But R.W. Royall, incident commander of the joint information committee=20
responsible for emergency operations at the Astrodome complex, denied the=
=20
radio volunteers' efforts to launch the station. Because Royall's denial=20
did not specify reasons, "I can only speculate as to what they found=20
particularly worrisome," said Jim Ellinger, who heads Austin Airwaves, a=20
nonprofit community radio group in Austin, Texas, involved in the=20
project. Gloria Roemer, another emergency official at the center, said the=
=20
Astrodome could not the spare the electricity. Ellinger said he could=20
operate the station on battery power, but Roemer insisted that the denial=
=20
is final. According to Ellinger, Roemer said, "Only [Federal Emergency=20
Management Agency Director Michael] Brown or President Bush can override"=
=20
Royall's decision.
[SOURCE: Technology Daily, AUTHOR: Drew Clark]
http://www.njtelecomupdate.com/lenya/telco/live/tb-TBYX1126212496014.html

FEINGOLD ASKS TELEVISION NETWORKS TO PROVIDE AIRTIME FOR HURRICANE=20
SURVIVORS IN SEARCH OF LOVED ONES
In a letter to the five major broadcast television networks (ABC, CBS, CNN,=
=20
FOX, and NBC), US Senator Russ Feingold (D-WI) on Thursday asked each of=20
them to provide airtime to the survivors of Hurricane Katrina who are=20
spread out across the country in relief staging areas. In the letter,=20
Feingold said that while there have been many success stories of families=
=20
being brought back together by the news media and others after being=20
displaced by the hurricane, many survivors "still carry the heavy burden of=
=20
not knowing the whereabouts of loved ones, especially loved ones." While=20
there have been efforts by reporters, through the Internet, to connect=20
Hurricane survivors "the effort to bring families back together might be=20
well served by having the news networks dedicate a substantial block of=20
air-time... so that those survivors who are in search of loved ones could=
=20
both let their voice be heard and tune in to a particular network at a=20
specific time to connect with family members through telephone hotlines at=
=20
the various staging areas."
URL includes text of letter.
[SOURCE: TruthOut press release]
http://www.truthout.org/docs_2005/090805G.shtml

WIRELESS NETWORKS GIVE VOICE TO EVACUEES
With few reliable communications systems in place, people and companies=20
from around the country are converging on the Gulf Coast region to create=
=20
improvised networks that give survivors and emergency personnel ways to=20
talk and coordinate efforts. For example, a band of volunteer techies are=
=20
stitching together wireless networks at shelters across northeastern=20
Louisiana using radio transmitters mounted on such items as a grain silo=20
and a water tower. While local telephone and wireless networks are slowly=
=20
coming back, they remain spotty or nonexistent in some places, and fire,=20
police and other rescue personnel have complained about the lack of a=20
unified emergency communications system. To meet the needs of evacuees in=
=20
Jackson (MS), America Online has parked an 18-wheel truck at the=20
Mississippi State Fairgrounds, a major shelter, with a satellite dish on=20
top and 20 computers with Internet access inside. At the Houston Astrodome,=
=20
volunteers have obtained a Federal Communications Commission license to set=
=20
up a low-power radio station and are now struggling to get permission from=
=20
local officials to broadcast to evacuees inside the stadium.
[SOURCE: Washington Post 9/8, AUTHOR: Arshad Mohammed]
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2005/09/08/AR200509...
2058.html
(requires registration)
* Wireless tech to be deployed for Katrina
http://www.mercurynews.com/mld/mercurynews/business/technology/12594999.htm
* Wireless Broadband Rises to Challenge Land Lines
http://www.latimes.com/business/printedition/la-fi-wireless9sep09,1,6524...
.story?coll=3Dla-headlines-pe-business
(requires registration)

DISPLACED STUDENTS TURN TO INTERNET
The dislocation of students caused by Hurricane Katrina is fueling interest=
=20
in online learning. Universities, for-profit companies and public school=20
systems are scrambling to use the Internet to teach the 75,000 to 100,000=
=20
college students and 135,000 elementary and high-school students displaced=
=20
by Katrina in greater New Orleans alone. This week, in response to the=20
hurricane, the Department of Education said it would urge states to relax=
=20
teacher-certification regulations and other rules to help more children get=
=20
schooling through the Internet. Distance-education advocates are pushing to=
=20
include increased funding for online efforts in emergency legislation=20
before Congress. At the same time, if the efforts are to take off, some=20
states and localities may still need legislative approval to pay the=20
far-flung organizations that could offer online programs in homes and=20
shelters. Meanwhile, the Bush Administration is supporting legislation=20
pending in Congress that would scrap a requirement that colleges offer at=
=20
least half their instruction face to face and not through distance learning=
=20
to receive federal funding. That rule had been adopted in part because of=
=20
concern about low-quality "correspondence courses" and potential for fraud.
[SOURCE: Wall Street Journal, AUTHOR: John Hechinger john.hechinger( at )wsj.com=
=20
and Daniel Golden dan.golden( at )wsj.com]
http://online.wsj.com/article/0,,SB112622247296335918,00.html?mod=3Dtoda...
us_page_one
(requires subscription)

AFTER KATRINA: CONGRESSMAN SLAMS COMMS FUNDING
Rep. Bart Stupak (D-MI) late yesterday called on the White House to fund=20
and implement an interoperable, inter-agency communication network for=20
first responders in the wake of Hurricane Katrina, which devastated the=20
Gulf Coast region of the United States. In a letter to President George W.=
=20
Bush, Rep Stupak cited widely reported communications-system breakdowns and=
=20
inadequacies among military personnel and other emergency service workers=
=20
as one of many reasons for his demand. While costs for full=20
interoperability are estimated at $18 billion, Rep Stupak charged that, for=
=20
the second year in a row, the President's budget =93completely zeros out=94=
=20
specific funding for interoperability. Rep Stupak touted the Public Safety=
=20
Interoperability Implementation Act (H.R.1323) that he reintroduced last=20
March to establish the Public Safety Communications Trust Fund. After an=20
initial three-year grant program, monies for the trust fund would come from=
=20
future sales of spectrum, and grants would be allocated to eligible=20
entities, with multi-year grants available to help ensure that agencies can=
=20
make long-term plans without having to worry about funding from one year to=
=20
the next. Congress currently is considering legislation to sell spectrum=20
valued at between $10 billion to $20 billion.
[SOURCE: TelecomWeb]
http://www.telecomweb.com/news/1126120006.htm

AT CENTER OF CRISIS, CITY OFFICIALS FACED STRUGGLE TO KEEP IN TOUCH
A look at how the emergency communications plan of the city of New Orleans=
=20
failed during Katrina and the aftermath -- and how city officials coped.
[SOURCE: Wall Street Journal, AUTHOR: Christopher Rhoads=20
christopher.rhoads( at )wsj.com]
http://online.wsj.com/article/0,,SB112623219825036218,00.html?mod=3Dtoda...
us_page_one
(requires subscription)

FCC ASSIGNS EMERGENCY TELEPHONE NUMBERS IN RESPONSE TO HURRICANE KATRINA=20
RELIEF AND RESTORATION EFFORTS
On Thursday the FCC announced contact information numbers for FCC offices=
=20
providing emergency telecommunications service authorizations and other=20
relief in order to facilitate reconstruction efforts by telecommunications=
=20
providers affected by the devastation caused by Hurricane Katrina.
[SOURCE: Federal Communications Commission]
http://hraunfoss.fcc.gov/edocs_public/attachmatch/DOC-260902A1.doc

BROADCASTING/CABLE

FCC COMMISSIONER LAUDS FINDINGS OF MEDIA INDECENCY STUDY
FCC Commissioner Michael Copps applauded a new study released by media=20
watchdogs that links media consolidation and broadcast radio=20
indecency. Copps asked rhetorically: "As media conglomerates grow ever=20
larger, as control moves away from local communities, as the big companies=
=20
focus so much of their programming on one or two particular demographics,=
=20
doesn't it stand to reason that community standards may go by the boards?"=
=20
The report, "Ownership Concentration and Indecency in Broadcasting: Is=20
There a Link?," suggests that media concentration resulting from passage of=
=20
the Telecommunications Act of 1996 has triggered a rise in indecency.=20
Backers of the report, including the Center for Creative Voices in Media=20
and Free Press, oppose stiffer fines for indecency, arguing that such=20
penalties stifle creative expression. Instead, they want policymakers to=20
impose stricter limits on media ownership, which they say would address=20
indecency concerns.
[SOURCE: Technology Daily, AUTHOR: David Hatch]
http://www.njtelecomupdate.com/lenya/telco/live/tb-OCOD1126212741116.html
See full report at:
http://www.creativevoices.us/cgi-upload/news/news_article/FINALReport090...
.pdf

TEXAS CABLE SUES OVER STATE FRANCHISES
The ink had hardly dried on a new telcom law -- Governor Rick Perry had=20
signed it Wednesday -- when the Texas Cable & Telecommunications=20
Association (TCTA) filed suit against it. The law encourages broadband=20
competition by allowing new entrants to get statewide video franchises=20
rather than have to seek them from individual cities and towns, as cable=20
has been required to do. The cable industry is arguing that sparing the=20
telcos the regulatory hoops cable has had to jump through is unfair and=20
that whatever regulatory breaks the phone companies are given should apply=
=20
to cable, too. In its suit, TCTA argued that not holding the Bells to the=
=20
same franchise process is discriminatory and will allow=20
red-lining--"dividing communities into the 'haves' and 'have nots' of=20
advanced technologies by not serving areas with lower return on investment.
[SOURCE: Broadcasting&Cable, AUTHOR: John Eggerton]
http://www.broadcastingcable.com/article/CA6255488?display=3DBreaking+Ne...
referral=3DSUPP
http://www.multichannel.com/article/CA6255486.html?display=3DBreaking+Ne...
referral=3DSUPP
(free access for Benton's Headlines subscribers)

TELECO TV EXPECTED TO SURGE
Worldwide adoption of IP-based TV is expected to grow significantly in=20
coming years, though the U.S. will only be a bit player in the market,=20
according to researchers from In-Stat. The market research firm predicts 32=
=20
million subscribers will be watching TV provided by telecommunications=20
providers in 2009, up from 1.6 million at the end of 2004. IPTV is expected=
=20
to provide the foundation for a new industry of premium services by=20
telephone providers and for consumers. With television as the basic=20
service, telcos can sell extensions, such as video on demand (VoD), digital=
=20
video recording (DVR) and interactive TV.
[SOURCE: InternetNews, AUTHOR: Jim Wagner]
http://www.internetnews.com/infra/article.php/3532371http://www.internetn=
ews.com/infra/article.php/3532371
What is IPTV? See=20
http://inews.webopedia.com/TERM/I/Internet_protocol_television.html

INTERNET

IS THE INTERNET THE PUBLIC UTILITY OF THE FUTURE
Media reform advocates maintain that the Internet is a necessary utility,=
=20
and as such, should be available at an affordable cost. But many people=20
living in the United States face geographic and financial barriers to high=
=20
speed Internet -- putting them at a distinct disadvantage in today's=20
digitized world. As Roberto Lovato writes in In These Times, "[C]ontrol=20
over and access to broadband connectivity is defining global, regional and=
=20
individual success."
[SOURCE: Utne Reader, AUTHOR: Rose Miller]
http://www.utne.com/webwatch/2005_215/news/11785-1.htmlhttp://www.utne.co=
m/webwatch/2005_215/news/11785-1.html

ILLINOIS GOVERNOR CREATES BROADBAND DEPLOYMENT COUNCIL
Under Executive Order, Governor Rod R. Blagojevich today announced the=20
creation of the Broadband Deployment Council to improve high-speed Internet=
=20
access for all Illinois residents. According to a 2004 Pew Research=20
report, only 10-percent of rural Americans have high-speed Internet access=
=20
in their homes, about one-third the rate of non-rural Americans. Expanding=
=20
access to critical technology and its related benefits has been a priority=
=20
of the Blagojevich administration. The Executive order comes as the latest=
=20
action in a widespread effort to bring technology into the heart of=20
Illinois communities. Other key efforts include the grassroots program=20
known as Eliminate the Digital Divide. The Eliminate the Digital Divide=20
program provides funding to local community technology centers in=20
low-income communities to provide technology skills training and access to=
=20
computers and the Internet. Since technology literacy today is a necessity=
=20
to competing for and succeeding in well-paying jobs, this program teaches=
=20
essential skills to people whom often lack access to important educational=
=20
opportunities that will help prepare them for a 21st Century job. Lt.=20
Governor Pat Quinn will serve as Chairman of the Broadband Deployment=20
Council. As Lt. Governor, Quinn has worked to help bridge the digital=20
divide through various Governor=92s Rural Affairs Council initiatives, and=
=20
most recently, by providing two $20,000 Wireless Main Street grants to the=
=20
communities of Mt. Vernon and Quincy.
[SOURCE: State of Illinois press release]
http://www.illinois.gov/PressReleases/ShowPressRelease.cfm?SubjectID=3D3...
cNum=3D4289

E-SALES TAX DEBATE TO RESUME THIS FALL
State officials plan to revive this fall their push to force Internet and=
=20
mail-order vendors to collect sales taxes from their out-of-state=20
customers. On Oct. 1, 13 states will officially launch reformed systems=20
that pledge compliance with the Streamlined Sales Tax Agreement, first=20
devised in 2002 by a committee of state tax officials and billed as a way=
=20
to make tax administration simpler and more uniform. Five more states have=
=20
passed laws that, over the next two years, will bring them into compliance=
=20
with the agreement. Compliance with the system won't change the fact that=
=20
tax collection remains voluntary for companies without a physical presence=
=20
in the states where their orders originate, thanks to a 1992 Supreme Court=
=20
decision. But project backers say they hope the streamlined system, even=20
with voluntary compliance, would attract participation from multistate=20
companies that say the current tax system is too complicated.
[SOURCE: C-Net|News.com, AUTHOR: Anne Broache]
http://news.com.com/E-sales+tax+debate+to+resume+this+fall/2100-1028_3-5...
343.html?tag=3Dnefd.lede

NEWS CORPORATION, WITH IGN IN ITS STABLE, BACKS UP PROMISE TO BE BIGGER WEB=
=20
PLAYER
The News Corporation has been giving new meaning to the term e-commerce:=20
the company has been on an online buying spree, spending nearly $1.5=20
billion on three Internet companies in just the last seven weeks. Its=20
swiftness in agreeing to pay $650 million to buy IGN Entertainment, an=20
Internet game and entertainment site, in a deal announced yesterday,=20
underscored just how serious - one of his executives says "obsessed" -- the=
=20
chairman, Rupert Murdoch, is about replicating in cyberspace the kind of=20
power he has in media arenas like British newspapers, Hollywood and cable=
=20
television news. When the deals close, traffic across all of News=20
Corporation's Internet properties -- which include the Web sites of dozens=
=20
of newspapers and scores of TV stations it owns - will have increased to=20
nearly 70 million unique monthly users from fewer than 25 million.=20
According to Merrill Lynch, the estimated 12 billion monthly page views=20
News Corporation will generate with IGN will rank it fourth among all=20
companies online, behind Yahoo, Time Warner and MSN, but ahead of eBay and=
=20
Google. The company's challenge now, said News Corp President Peter=20
Chernin, is figuring out how to integrate its new online businesses with=20
one another as well as the huge amount of content the company owns and=20
produces.
[SOURCE: New York Times, AUTHOR: Richard Siklos]
http://www.nytimes.com/2005/09/09/business/media/09online.html
(requires registration)

US SUES REALTORS, CLAIMS WEB RULES LIMIT DISCOUNTING
The Justice Department challenged the nation's dominant real-estate trade=
=20
group in a lawsuit that could lower costs of buying and selling homes. The=
=20
federal antitrust suit, filed in U.S. District Court in Chicago against the=
=20
National Association of Realtors, targets the group's bylaws, which allow=
=20
members to withhold online listings from other brokers in a local market.=
=20
The government charges that the rules illegally could restrict discounting=
=20
and disadvantage Internet competitors.
[SOURCE: Wall Street Journal, AUTHOR: James R. Hagerty bob.hagerty( at )wsj.com]
http://online.wsj.com/article/0,,SB112622387990535977,00.html?mod=3Dtoda...
us_page_one
(requires subscription)
* Realtors sued over Web listing access
http://www.usatoday.com/printedition/money/20050909/narsuit.art.htm

CHINA TELECOM BLOCKS INTERNET PHONE SERVICE
China Telecom, the country's largest fixed-line phone carrier, has started=
=20
blocking access to Skype, a popular Internet telephone service that is=20
threatening its long-distance revenue, according to local media reports and=
=20
Internet postings. China routinely blocks access to Web sites on=20
politically sensitive subjects such as the banned Falun Gong spiritual=20
movement and the 1989 crackdown at Tiananmen Square that left hundreds=20
dead. But blockage of sites for purely economic reasons is much less common.
[SOURCE: Reuters, AUTHOR: Doug Young]
http://today.reuters.com/news/newsArticleSearch.aspx?storyID=3D83147+09-...
-2005+RTRS&srch=3Dchina+telecom

PLANS BY 13 NATIONS URGES OPEN TECHNOLOGY STANDARDS
In a report to be presented at the World Bank today, a group that includes=
=20
senior government officials from 13 countries will urge nations to adopt=20
open-information technology standards as a vital step to accelerate=20
economic growth, efficiency and innovation. The 33-page report is a road=20
map for creating national policies on open technology standards, and comes=
=20
at a time when several countries -- and some state governments -- are=20
pursuing plans to reduce their dependence on proprietary software makers,=
=20
notably Microsoft, by using more free, open-source software. The project,=
=20
begun by the Berkman Center for Internet and Society at the Harvard Law=20
School, gathered government officials from China, India, Thailand, Denmark,=
=20
Jordan, Brazil and elsewhere at a three-day meeting in Silicon Valley in=20
February to discuss technology standards and economic development. The=20
meeting was followed by e-mail exchanges, conference calls and postings on=
=20
a shared Web site. The group defines an open standard as technology that is=
=20
not owned by a single company and is openly published. Still, there is a=20
huge debate in industry and among policy makers about how far openness=20
should go. The report makes clear that government policy should "mandate=20
technology choice, not software development models."
[SOURCE: New York Times, AUTHOR: Steve Lohr]
http://www.nytimes.com/2005/09/09/technology/09open.html
(requires registration)

QUICKLY

CABLE OWNERSHIP PROCEEDING EXTENDED
The FCC has extended the date for filing reply comments in The Commission's=
=20
Cable Horizontal and Vertical Ownership Limits (MM Docket No. 92-264) to=
=20
September 23, 2005.
[SOURCE: Federal Communications Commission]
http://hraunfoss.fcc.gov/edocs_public/attachmatch/DA-05-2425A1.doc

SBC-AT&T MERGER REVIEW CLOCK STOPPED
On September 6, 2005, SBC Communications and AT&T filed an ex parte letter=
=20
in WC Docket No. 05-65 containing more information about their proposed=20
merger. Although September 7 was day 180 of the Commission's informal time=
=20
clock for consideration of this transaction, the Applicants have now=20
requested that the agency "stop the clock" and extend the time for its=20
consideration. In the interest of ensuring sound analysis of the record,=
=20
the FCC has stopped the clock on consideration of the merger. The clock=20
will be stopped until October 13, 2005.
[SOURCE: Federal Communications Commission]
http://hraunfoss.fcc.gov/edocs_public/attachmatch/DA-05-2426A1.doc

FCC PROVIDES TEMPORARY RELIEF FROM HEARING AID COMPATIBILITY REQUIREMENTS=
=20
FOR WIRELESS CARRIERS
In an order released Thursday, the Federal Communications Commission (FCC)=
=20
provided temporary, conditional relief from certain hearing aid=20
compatibility requirements for carriers and manufacturers that offer=20
dual-band digital wireless handsets that use the GSM air interface in both=
=20
the 850 MHz cellular and 1900 MHz broadband PCS bands. The FCC's hearing=
=20
aid compatibility rules require that, by September 16, 2005, wireless=20
handset manufacturers must offer to carriers - and that wireless carriers=
=20
and service providers must offer to their customers - at least two hearing=
=20
aid-compatible handsets per air interface. In addition, nationwide (Tier=
=20
I) wireless carriers must offer, per air interface, four hearing=20
aid-compatible digital wireless handset models, or 25% of the total number=
=20
of digital wireless handset models offered by the carrier nationwide must=
=20
be hearing aid compatible, by September 16, 2005. The FCC adopted=20
the recommendation of a technical group that focuses on hearing aid=20
compatibility in wireless GSM handsets and includes representatives from=20
the wireless industry, as well as the hearing aid industry and hearing=20
disabled community. The Commission ruled that, until August 1, 2006, it=20
will base the hearing aid compatibility compliance rating of dual-mode GSM=
=20
handsets on their operation in the 1900 MHz band only.
[SOURCE: Federal Communications Commission]
http://hraunfoss.fcc.gov/edocs_public/attachmatch/DOC-260920A1.doc

Intellectual Property: Improvements Needed to Better Manage Patent Office=
=20
Automation and Address Workforce Challenges
Testimony by Anu K. Mittal, director, science and technology issues, and=20
Linda D. Koontz, director, information management issues, before the=20
Subcommittee on Courts, the Internet, and Intellectual Property, House=20
Committee on the Judiciary. GAO-05-1008T
[SOURCE: Government Accountability Office, AUTHOR: Anu K. Mittal & Linda D.=
=20
Koontz]
http://www.gao.gov/cgi-bin/getrpt?GAO-05-1008T
Highlights - http://www.gao.gov/highlights/d051008thigh.pdf
--------------------------------------------------------------
Communications-related Headlines is a free online news summary service=20
provided by the Benton Foundation (www.benton.org). Posted Monday through=
=20
Friday, this service provides updates on important industry developments,=
=20
policy issues, and other related news events. While the summaries are=20
factually accurate, their often informal tone does not always represent the=
=20
tone of the original articles. Headlines are compiled by Kevin Taglang=20
(headlines( at )benton.org) -- we welcome your comments.
--------------------------------------------------------------

Benton's Communications-related Headlines For Thursday September 8, 2005

For upcoming media policy events, see http://www.benton.org/calendar.htm

EMERGENCY COMMUNICATIONS
After Katrina, Communications Still Hobbled
Gulf Region Infrastructure Slowly Revives
BellSouth Exec Says Katrina Caused Unprecedented Damage to Facilities
Gulf Coast Regulators Face Tough Telecom Issues in Katrina's Wake
FCC, Congress Urge Wireless Industry to Keep Service On For Hurricane Vict=
ims
Live From the Astrodome, a Radio Station for Evacuees
Small WISPs Help Hurricane Victims
Media Hurricane
Online Scams Solicit Katrina Donations, Risk Identity Theft

TELEVISION
Citing Katrina, Experts Step Up Push For Digital TV Transition
Barton Says Committee Won't Make Sept. 16 DTV Deadline
NCTA: We'll Fight vs. Multicast Must-Carry
Consumer Groups Oppose =93Multicast Must Carry=94
Must-Carry Fights Smut-Carry, Says NRB
Texas OKs Statewide Cable Franchises
PBS Stands for Pork
Liquor and TV Advertising

OWNERSHIP
Study Ties Indecency to Consolidation of Media
Web Buying Spree for Big Media
EBay May Buy Web Phone Firm In Strategy Shift

INTERNATIONAL
Controversy dogs Telstra stake sale
In Japan Campaign, Web Goes Silent

EMERGENCY COMMUNICATIONS

AFTER KATRINA, COMMUNICATIONS STILL HOBBLED
Since the Hurricane Katrina, government officials and communications=20
vendors have been working nonstop to repair damaged public-safety systems,=
=20
with their efforts sometimes bordering on the heroic. Volunteers drove=20
vehicles packed with communications equipment from as far away as Florida=
=20
within hours after the storm passed to help some of the hardest hit areas.=
=20
Of the 17 public-safety systems being tracked by Motorola eight were "up=20
and running" yesterday morning. The company listed seven others, including=
=20
the one serving the Louisiana State Police, as "marginal" and wasn't able=
=20
to make contact with two others. The communications failures left many=20
fire, ambulance and police officers with no way to communicate with their=
=20
headquarters or each other at a time when thousands needed rescue and=20
lawlessness was rampant. At one point in New Orleans, hundreds of police=20
officers were trying to communicate on two radio channels on a backup=20
system, forcing most of them to wait for minutes to get their messages=20
through. Public-safety officials and vendors say they've already begun to=
=20
think about how to improve emergency communications. But past efforts to=20
improve networks after disasters like Sept. 11 have fallen short of goals.=
=20
"After every single calamity we see the exact same thing," says Reed Hundt,=
=20
former chairman of the Federal Communications Commission.
[SOURCE: Wall Street Journal, AUTHOR: Peter Grant peter.grant( at )wsj.com and=
=20
Christopher Rhoads christopher.rhoads( at )wsj.com]
http://online.wsj.com/article/0,,SB112613389036634560,00.html?mod=3Dtoda...
us_marketplace
(requires subscription)

GULF REGION INFRASTRUCTURE SLOWLY REVIVES
Key parts of the Gulf Coast's transportation systems, communications and=20
energy production remain out of service for the foreseeable future. More=20
than 1 million telephone lines and about 30 percent of cell phone towers in=
=20
the affected region remain out of service. Louisiana officials yesterday=20
began dealing with cell phone systems in Baton Rouge that are overloaded=20
with traffic from evacuees who have reached the state's capital. "It's=20
choked," Louisiana Public Service Commissioner James M. "Jimmy" Field said=
=20
of the cellular network. "We are trying to work out something to make sure=
=20
emergency calls can get through." Even for the companies that successfully=
=20
navigated all the downed infrastructure, the use of generators, satellite=
=20
phones and rerouted shipments may exact new costs. "Businesses are going to=
=20
be able to get around all these disruptions, but it won't be cheap," said=
=20
Peter Morici, an economist at the University of Maryland business school.
[SOURCE: Washington Post, AUTHOR: Neil Irwin and Sara Kehaulani Goo]
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2005/09/07/AR200509...
2099.html
(requires registration)

BELLSOUTH EXEC SAYS KATRINA CAUSED UNPRECEDENTED DAMAGE TO FACILITIES
In the first of what will probably be many Congressional hearings on=20
Hurricane Katrina, Rep. Fred Upton, R-Mich., who chairs the Commerce=20
Committee's Telecommunications and the Internet Subcommittee, raised=20
concerns about the ability of emergency rescue personnel to communicate=20
with each other. "Clearly that is not an acceptable situation," responded=
=20
Kenneth Moran, director of the homeland security office in the FCC=20
Enforcement Bureau. "Effective communications for emergency responders is a=
=20
priority for the commission." But he blamed the communications problems=20
partly on other factors, such as power outages and battery shortages. He=20
said security concerns prevented rescuers from replenishing some supplies.=
=20
A BellSouth executive praised the FCC and other agencies for waiving=20
restrictions to make it easier for BellSouth to rebuild. He also asked=20
lawmakers to help BellSouth secure access to capital that it will need to=
=20
finance repairs. The FCC's Moran said the storm disrupted phone service to=
=20
3 million customers. Of 41 broadcast radio stations in the New Orleans=20
area, only four remained on the air after Katrina. A week after the=20
hurricane, more than 1 million phone customers still did not have service,=
=20
30 percent of cellular sites were down, and 50 to 100 TV and radio stations=
=20
were dark.
[SOURCE: Technology Daily, AUTHOR: David Hatch]
http://www.njtelecomupdate.com/lenya/telco/live/tb-LNHH1126125165356.html
* Statement of Kenneth Moran, FCC
http://hraunfoss.fcc.gov/edocs_public/attachmatch/DOC-260895A1.pdf
* Fifty to 100 Stations Still Off Air
[SOURCE: Broadcasting&Cable, AUTHOR: John Eggerton]
http://www.broadcastingcable.com/article/CA6254917?display=3DBreaking+Ne...
referral=3DSUPP
(free access for Benton's Headlines subscribers)
* New Orleans Station Gets Boost From Paxson
WDSU, a Hearst-Argyle-owned NBC affiliate, was knocked off the air by=20
Hurricane Katrina, but it is now back, broadcasting on Paxson stations in=
=20
New Orleans and Houston.
[SOURCE: Broadcasting&Cable, AUTHOR: ]
http://www.broadcastingcable.com/article/CA6255184?display=3DBreaking+Ne...
referral=3DSUPP
(free access for Benton's Headlines subscribers)

GULF COAST REGULATORS FACE TOUGH ISSUES IN KATRINA'S WAKE
State telecom regulators in Louisiana, Mississippi and Alabama are=20
returning to work and face tough decisions: 1) Whether to waive service=20
quality standards such as for timely installations and repairs be waived=20
until carriers complete restoration of service and replacement of destroyed=
=20
facilities; 2) Whether to allow regulated carriers a temporary local rate=
=20
increase or surcharge to enable them to recover the extraordinary and=20
unexpected costs the storm caused; 3) Whether to let carriers restore=20
networks to pre-storm condition, or encourage them toward wholesale=20
replacement of older wires, cables and switches with the latest in fiber=20
and digital technologies; and 4) How to use state regulation to facilitate=
=20
electronic communications among emergency responders and prevent breakdowns.
[SOURCE: Communications Daily, AUTHOR: Herb Kirchhoff]
(Not available online)

FCC, CONGRESS URGE WIRELESS INDUSTRY TO KEEP SERVICE ON FOR HURRICANE VICTI=
MS
The FCC and members of Congress urged the wireless industry to maintain=20
service to Hurricane Katrina victims who can't pay their bills. The FCC=20
gave wireless service licensees with hurricane-affected customers until=20
today (Sept. 8) to submit a report verifying =93compliance with the standar=
d=20
industry practice of maintaining service to people displaced by Hurricane=
=20
Katrina despite failure to pay bills.=94 Reports should describe the grace=
=20
period or other relief licensees are providing, the agency said. =93Hurrica=
ne=20
Katrina displaced hundreds of thousands of residents of Louisiana,=20
Mississippi and Alabama, and many thousands of these customers rely on=20
their wireless service during this difficult time to remain in touch with=
=20
loved ones,=94 the FCC said Wed. It said affected residents can't pay their=
=20
bills for many reasons. For example, it said, the U.S. Post Office isn't=20
operating throughout the affected areas, commercial power isn't available=
=20
everywhere and communications networks, including Internet for online bill=
=20
payment, aren't at pre-hurricane capabilities.
[SOURCE: Communications Daily, AUTHOR: Susan Polyakova]
(Not available online)
* Facilitating Restoration of Wireless Facilities in Areas Impacted by=20
Hurricane Katrina
http://hraunfoss.fcc.gov/edocs_public/attachmatch/DA-05-2427A1.doc
* Maintaining Wireless Service for Consumers Affected by Hurricane Katrina
http://hraunfoss.fcc.gov/edocs_public/attachmatch/DA-05-2421A1.doc

LIVE FROM THE ASTRODOME, A RADIO STATION FOR EVACUEES
Federal regulators have authorized an unusual radio station to serve the=20
estimated 10,000 evacuees living in the Houston Astrodome, part of an=20
effort to fill the information void left by Hurricane Katrina's disruption=
=20
of communications services along the Gulf Coast. The Federal Communications=
=20
Commission over the weekend granted Houston relief volunteers and media=20
organizers permission to build a 30-watt radio station inside the=20
Astrodome. Government and industry officials said it was the first time=20
they could recall that a domestic radio station had been set up primarily=
=20
to keep victims of a U.S. disaster informed. They predicted that the=20
station would improve communications for residents, who rely mostly on=20
bulletin board postings and word of mouth for news about jobs, missing=20
relatives, housing and child care.
[SOURCE: Los Angeles Times, AUTHOR: Jube Shiver Jr]
http://www.latimes.com/news/printedition/asection/la-na-radio8sep08,1,25...
20.story?coll=3Dla-news-a_section
(requires registration)
* Broadcasters Offer Portable TVs to First Responders in Hurricane Katrina=
=20
Relief Efforts
The National Association of Broadcasters is partnering with Louisiana and=
=20
Mississippi broadcasters to distribute 1,300 battery-operated handheld=20
television sets to public safety officials assisting with Hurricane Katrina=
=20
relief efforts.
[SOURCE: National Association of Broadcasters press release]
http://www.nab.org/newsroom/pressrel/Releases/090705_HurricaneKatrina_TV...
dsets.htm

SMALL WISPs HELP HURRICANE VICTIMS
Stepping to the plate, hundreds of small wireless ISPs are helping Gulf=20
Coast residents caught in Hurricane
Katrina. The Part 15 Organization (Part-15.org) -- one of the biggest WISP=
=20
groups -- met Fri. with FCC officials
via teleconference to discuss how to utilize WISPs better, and got the=20
necessary clearances Tues. night. The FCC has designated Part-15.org as a=
=20
single point of contact, responsible for gathering
information the Commission needs to coordinate WISP efforts with the Red=20
Cross, FEMA and others,
[SOURCE: Communications Daily, AUTHOR: Susan Polyakova]
(Not available online)

MEDIA HURRICANE
[Commentary] The magnitude of the Hurricane Katrina disaster and the=20
media's astonished--and astonishingly vigorous-- response puts in=20
perspective how hard it has generally become, in this country, to deliver=
=20
the unadorned, unapologetic truth. Indeed, for at least as long as George=
=20
Bush has been in office, the great unspoken challenge for mainstream=20
journalists has been to do one's job while keeping one's job.
[SOURCE: AlterNet, AUTHOR: Russ Baker, TomPaine.com]
http://www.alternet.org/mediaculture/25158/

ONLINE SCAMS SOLICIT KATRINA DONATIONS, RISK IDENTITY THEFT
Thousands of domain names containing "hurricane," "Katrina" or "Hurricane=
=20
Katrina" have popped up on the Internet, and millions of people are=20
receiving email soliciting donations for hurricane victims. But authorities=
=20
and Internet security experts warn that some of these Web sites may be=20
scams intended to trick people into handing over money and identity=20
information or download viruses onto their computers. The Federal Bureau of=
=20
Investigation has identified at least a dozen potential Katrina-related=20
Internet frauds that it is investigating -- and the agency expects the=20
number to increase in coming days.
[SOURCE: Wall Street Journal, AUTHOR: Li Yuan li.yuan( at )wsj.com]
http://online.wsj.com/article/0,,SB112614471129734872,00.html?mod=3Dtoda...
us_marketplace
(requires subscription)

TELEVISION

CITING KATRINA, EXPERTS STEP UP PUSH FOR DIGITAL TV TRANSITION
Given that many of the problems Hurricane Katrina emergency workers have=20
encountered are due to an ineffective communications system, a panel of=20
experts suggested that it would be unwise for Congress to delay action on=
=20
the transition from analog to digital television. When broadcasters make=20
the transition to digital signals, it will free more spectrum for use by=20
public safety agencies in communicating across jurisdictions. Digital=20
television "is about public safety, it's about the emergency response and=
=20
it's about Katrina," Cheryl Leanza, principal legislative council for the=
=20
National League of Cities, told a Capitol Hill luncheon sponsored by the=20
New America Foundation. "The idea that we would set aside this issue ... is=
=20
a little mystifying," she declared.
[SOURCE: Technology Daily, AUTHOR: Chloe Albanesius]
http://www.njtelecomupdate.com/lenya/telco/live/tb-VXPM1126125619410.html

BARTON SAYS COMMITTEE WON'T MAKE SEPT 16 DTV DEADLINE
House Commerce Committee Chairman Joe Barton (R-TX) hopes to put DTV=20
legislation on a =93fast track=94 behind concerns about interoperability du=
ring=20
Hurricane Katrina, but the crisis will make it impossible to meet the Sept.=
=20
16 budget reconciliation deadline that would include a DTV measure. He made=
=20
his comments after a full-day hearing on the impact of the hurricane=20
focusing mainly on oil prices and emergency response times. The committee=
=20
put together a discussion draft in May and a mark-up is expected to be=20
scheduled for some time in the next 2 weeks.
[SOURCE: Communications Daily, AUTHOR: Anne Veigle, Tania Panczyk-Collins]
(Not available online)

NCTA: WE'LL FIGHT VS MULTICAST MUST-CARRY
Big cable vowed Wednesday to fight broadcasters=92 plea for Congress to for=
ce=20
cable operators to carry any digital program a TV station broadcasts. =93Th=
e=20
point is, it=92s just not right,=94 said Kyle McSlarrow, President of the=
=20
National Cable & Telecommunications Association. In the same vein, the NCTA=
=20
will begin a lobbying campaign against the designated hitter rule and=20
low-fat ice cream. McSlarrow said forcing carriage of the six digital=20
channels that broadcasters can send would deny others space on increasingly=
=20
crowded cable systems. He said such a requirement would violate=20
constitutional guarantees against government-compelled speech, and against=
=20
government takings of private property. McSlarrow said he's no fan of=20
artificial turf either.
[SOURCE: MediaWeek, AUTHOR: Todd Shields]
http://www.mediaweek.com/mw/news/recent_display.jsp?vnu_content_id=3D100...
6074
* Cable Lobbyist Calls 'Multicasting' A 'Taking' Of Private Property
http://www.njtelecomupdate.com/lenya/telco/live/tb-QPAS1126124018268.html

CONSUMER GROUPS OPPOSE "MULTICAST MUST CARRY"
Consumers Union, the Consumer Federation of America, Free Press, and the=20
Center for Digital Democracy urged Congress to reject any proposals that=20
would require automatic cable distribution of every channel local=20
broadcasters choose to provide following the digital television transition,=
=20
known as =93multicast must carry.=94 In letters to the House and Senate=20
Commerce Committees, the groups wrote, =93=85there exists no compelling pub=
lic=20
policy reason at this time to extend this requirement to all digital=20
channels, nor is there a significant consumer benefit of doing so=85 A=20
decision on multicast must-carry is premature and should not be made before=
=20
a thorough consideration of viewpoint diversity, consumer benefit, and=20
policies that will increase access to diverse content through technologies=
=20
that use the public airwaves.=94 The groups argue that the dominant=20
broadcasters would only see their already significant megaphone amplified=
=20
under multicast must-carry, creating the very outcome that Congress has=20
sought to avoid when it rejected FCC=92s broadcast ownership rules=97the=20
expansion of the reach of dominant media voices.
[SOURCE: Consumers Union Press Release]
http://www.hearusnow.org/other/newsroom/tvradiocable/cuopposesmulticastm...
carry/
* Consumer Groups Oppose Multicast Must-Carry
http://www.broadcastingcable.com/article/CA6255046?display=3DBreaking+Ne...
referral=3DSUPP
(free access for Benton's Headlines subscribers)
* Consumer Groups Fight Multicast Must-Carry
http://www.multichannel.com/article/CA6255182.html?display=3DBreaking+News
(requires subscription)

MUST-CARRY FIGHTS SMUT-CARRY, SAYS NRB
Religious Broadcasters have come up with a new argument for requiring cable=
=20
to carry all of the channels broadcasters can fit into their digital=20
spectrum allotment: At least they won't be cable channels. That dimension,=
=20
they argued in a letter to House Speaker Dennis Hastert, is that their=20
stations could be bumped in favor of cable channels that "will not be=20
subject to federal indecency standards."
[SOURCE: Broadcasting&Cable, AUTHOR: John Eggerton]
http://www.broadcastingcable.com/article/CA6254415?display=3DBreaking+Ne...
referral=3DSUPP
(free access for Benton's Headlines subscribers)

TEXAS OKs STATEWIDE CABLE FRANCHISES
As expected, Texas Gov. Rick Perry has signed the bill, passed in a special=
=20
legislative session, which authorizes statewide franchises for competitive=
=20
cable franchises. The wide-ranging telecommunications bill also deregulates=
=20
some of the wire-line services of the incumbent local providers, including=
=20
SBC Communications and Verizon Communications,. And the bill promotes the=
=20
deployment of broadband over power lines.
[SOURCE: Multichannel News, AUTHOR: Linda Haugsted]
http://www.multichannel.com/article/CA6255082.html?display=3DBreaking+News
* Texas Opens Door to Cable Competitors
http://www.mediaweek.com/mw/news/recent_display.jsp?vnu_content_id=3D100...
6376
(both stories require subscription)

PBS STANDS FOR PORK
[Commentary] When the House of Representatives restored $100 million to the=
=20
budget of the Corporation for Public Broadcasting, bringing its annual=20
appropriation up to $400 million, there were no headlines in the Post, New=
=20
York Times or other media about wasting taxpayer dollars on "pork." In the=
=20
classic sense, however, spending on public broadcasting qualifies as pork.=
=20
It represents members of Congress returning money to their districts, in=20
the form of grants to local public TV and radio stations.
[SOURCE: Accuracy in Media, AUTHOR: Cliff Kincaid]
http://www.aim.org/media_monitor/3975_0_2_0_C/

LIQUOR AND TV ADVERTISING
For virtually all mainstream advertisers, television has for decades been=
=20
the medium that matters most, whether broadcast or cable, local or=20
national, stations or networks. The abilities of TV to bring a sales spiel=
=20
to life with sight, sound and motion - and to reach large numbers of=20
consumers quickly and frequently - have been invaluable in generating=20
demand for products from fluoride toothpaste to light beer. But Under=20
voluntary policies that dated to the beginning of radio and television,=20
distilled spirits remained off those media. Indeed, it has been brewers'=20
access to television as an advertising medium that distillers have deemed=
=20
the biggest reason for their loss of market share and so-called buzz to=20
beer brands, particularly among consumers aged 21 to 34. But in 1996, after=
=20
Seagram began defying the bans, they were lifted, although the biggest=20
broadcast TV networks - ABC, CBS, Fox, NBC, UPN and WB - continue to refuse=
=20
to run liquor commercials. So the distillers have cobbled together an=20
informal web of national cable networks, local cable systems and local=20
broadcast stations to run their commercials. Among the more than two dozen=
=20
cable networks that take liquor spots are BET, Bravo, CNN, CMT, Comedy=20
Central, Discovery Channel, FX, Fox Sports Network, OLN, Spike TV, Golf=20
Channel, Sci-Fi Channel, USA and VH1.
[SOURCE: New York Times, AUTHOR: Stuart Elliott]
http://www.nytimes.com/2005/09/08/business/media/08adco.html
(requires registration)

OWNERSHIP

STUDY TIES INDECENCY TO CONSOLIDATION OF MEDIA
The consolidation of the broadcast industry over the last decade may have=
=20
increased indecent programming on the nation's airwaves, according to a new=
=20
report by the Center for Creative Voices in Media and Fordham University.=
=20
According to the report, as leading broadcasters such as Clear Channel=20
Communications and Viacom Inc.'s Infinity Broadcasting have bought more=20
stations, they have frequently replaced local programming with shock jocks=
=20
such as Howard Stern and Bubba the Love Sponge, who are prone to vulgarity.=
=20
Those programming decisions may have lured more young listeners, the ones=
=20
that advertisers most covet, while also saving the companies money. But=20
that may have led to an increase in indecency complaints, according to the=
=20
report, which is to be released today. From 2000 to 2003, the report found,=
=20
the nation's four largest radio companies racked up 96% of the fines handed=
=20
out by the Federal Communications Commission, while their stations=20
accounted for only about half of the country's listening audience. The=20
study suggests that instead of relying on stiffer fines, regulators seeking=
=20
to rein in indecency would be better off breaking up large broadcast groups.
[SOURCE: Los Angeles Times, AUTHOR: Sallie Hofmeister]
http://www.latimes.com/business/printedition/la-fi-indecent8sep08,1,2409...
.story?coll=3Dla-headlines-pe-business
(requires registration)
For more on release of the report, see:
http://www.creativevoices.us/php-bin/news/showArticle.php?id=3D135&PHPSE...
D=3Dd3b061b92e55ba728d9c4d35be013930

WEB BUYING SPREE FOR BIG MEDIA
[Commentary] About.com is among the many Web properties that traditional=20
media companies have snapped up this year as they scramble to cash in on=20
the second big Internet advertising boom. While Internet ads claim a small=
=20
slice of the overall ad pie -- generating not quite $10 billion in the=20
United States last year, less than 5 percent of all ad revenue -- the=20
online dollars grew more than 30 percent, much faster than off-line. In=20
response, traditional media companies have been making some startling moves.
[SOURCE: Washington Post, AUTHOR: Leslie Walker]
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2005/09/07/AR200509...
2178.html
(requires registration)
* News Corp. to Pay $650 Million For Operator of Web Game Sites
http://online.wsj.com/article/0,,SB112614765764734958,00.html?mod=3Dtoda...
us_marketplace

EBAY MAY BUY WEB PHONE FIRM IN STRATEGY SHIFT
EBay is in talks to acquire Internet-telephony company Skype Technologies=
=20
SA for $2 billion to $3 billion, in a deal that would represent a dramatic=
=20
shift in strategy for the world's largest online auction site.=20
Luxembourg-based Skype, whose software allows consumers to make free=20
telephone calls around the world using Internet technology, has been in=20
active discussions with other technology companies, and none has led to a=
=20
deal. But the emergence of eBay as a suitor reveals a lot about the auction=
=20
leader's growth prospects and strategy. While still dominating its field,=
=20
eBay's core business is maturing, and the company is searching for new=20
product categories and international markets. The company has made a steady=
=20
string of acquisitions and investments over the last year and a half to=20
enter markets such as rental-property listings, online classified-ad=20
listings and comparison shopping.
[SOURCE: Wall Street Journal, AUTHOR: Mylene Mangalindan=20
mylene.mangalindan( at )wsj.com and Dennis K. Berman dennis.berman( at )wsj.com]
http://online.wsj.com/article/0,,SB112615385922335028,00.html?mod=3Dtoda...
us_page_one
(requires subscription)

INTERNATIONAL

CONTROVERSY DOGS TELSTRA STAKE SALE
Controversy engulfing the Australian government=92s plans to sell its=20
remaining 51.8 per cent stake in Telstra, the country's largest=20
telecommunications company, widened on Wednesday as legislation enabling=20
the sale was presented to Australian parliament and an official=20
investigation into possible violations of stock market rules by Telstra=20
executives began.
[SOURCE: Financial Times, AUTHOR:]
http://news.ft.com/cms/s/0eb5bbca-1fb5-11da-853a-00000e2511c8.html
(requires subscription)

IN JAPAN CAMPAIGN, WEB GOES SILENT
As political candidates campaign feverishly before the Japanese elections=
=20
Sunday, an antiquated law that effectively bans the use of the Internet is=
=20
causing confusion, bickering and finger-pointing. The law, which dates to=
=20
1955, limits candidates' direct written communication with constituents to=
=20
postcards and pamphlets. This means politicians and their parties are=20
prohibited from sending emails or updating their Web sites during the=20
official 12-day campaign period. But many candidates are finding it=20
increasingly difficult to accommodate the law as the Internet gains=20
importance as a source of political information. Struggling to stay within=
=20
the rules, politicians have shut down their Weblogs or hired lawyers to=20
advise them on what they can and can't post. Political parties, meanwhile,=
=20
are seizing the opportunity to point fingers at rivals they accuse of using=
=20
the Internet in illegal ways.
[SOURCE: Wall Street Journal, AUTHOR: Ginny Parker Woods=20
ginny.parker( at )wsj.com]
http://online.wsj.com/article/0,,SB112612187732634311,00.html?mod=3Dtoda...
us_page_one
(requires subscription)
--------------------------------------------------------------
Communications-related Headlines is a free online news summary service=20
provided by the Benton Foundation (www.benton.org). Posted Monday through=
=20
Friday, this service provides updates on important industry developments,=
=20
policy issues, and other related news events. While the summaries are=20
factually accurate, their often informal tone does not always represent the=
=20
tone of the original articles. Headlines are compiled by Kevin Taglang=20
(headlines( at )benton.org) -- we welcome your comments.
--------------------------------------------------------------

Benton's Communications-related Headlines For Wednesday September 7, 2005

For upcoming media policy events, see http://www.benton.org/calendar.htm

EMERGENCY COMMUNICATIONS
TV Forces a Collective Responsibility
The Bigotry of Low Expectations
The Unasked Question
Hill To Deal With Katrina Communications
New Orleans Stations Improvise
Volunteers and Astrodome Resident Families Build Emergency Radio Station
Help For Storm-Affected Broadcasters
How Public Broadcasters are Faring after Katrina
Katrina Costs Cable Millions as Billing Stops
Joint Statement from FCC Commissioners
Technology: Free Phones, Buses, Web Assistance
The Web and Hurricane Katrina

TELEVISION
Hurricane Unearths Feud Between Broadcasters, Cable
NCTA: Multicasting Could Cost Billions
Stevens Stalls DTV Until Relief Package in Place
GAO Releases Report on Information Campaign Regarding DTV Transition
Accounting for Taste (V-chip & indecency)
What Does Fall Hold for TV News?

OWNERSHIP
FCC: Winter of Discontent
Consolidation/Smut Connection Asserted
The Wall Street Journal at Sea
Murdoch calls New Web Summit (no, you are not invited)
Magazines: The Global Carveout

QUICKLY -- Chief justice nominee carries slim record on tech; News Junkies=
=20
find Wikipedia more than Encyclopedia; Things to hate about cable news;=20
Court cases don't scare file swappers; Dot Triple X; DVR Penetration Slows;=
=20
Digital Gamers Reduce TV Viewing

EMERGENCY COMMUNICATIONS

TV FORCES A COLLECTIVE RESPONSIBILITY
[Commentary] you already can sense a shift in TV's approach as newscasts=20
move from the on-the-fly immediacy of those emotional early reports, which=
=20
left viewers so shocked and chagrined, to carefully planned televised=20
events. Reporters now share the scene with stars: Katie Couric co-anchored=
=20
NBC's Today show Tuesday morning from a flooded New Orleans street; Diane=
=20
Sawyer led a Good Morning America town meeting from a shelter in=20
Donaldsonville, La.; Oprah Winfrey did her show on the scene. Soon the=20
stars will depart, other stories will push their way to the fore, and much=
=20
of the coverage will consist of studio-bound anchors and commentators=20
talking over video. Clearly, the story of the destruction of New Orleans is=
=20
not over. But as the story shifts from what happened to why it happened,=20
other news outlets will take over. In-depth analysis is not television's=20
strong point; policy debates do not respond well to TV's dramatic=20
storytelling technique -- one that tends to stress sentiment over context=
=20
and emphasize individual suffering over collective impact. Yet no matter=20
how it covers the debate to come, there's no question the debate itself has=
=20
been framed by television's coverage and might not even exist without it.=
=20
When disaster struck, TV's newscasters did what they do best: They showed=
=20
us what was happening as it happened, a service we too often take for=20
granted. Television made it impossible for government officials to say the=
=20
situation was under control; we could see that it wasn't. Television made=
=20
it impossible for government officials to say they couldn't get into New=20
Orleans to help You cannot fix what you refuse to see. Television showed us=
=20
the damage done by Katrina and forced us to examine our collective=20
responsibility for the sorrow and pity that followed. That public service=
=20
will resound long after the cameras move on.
[SOURCE: USAToday, AUTHOR: Robert Bianco]
http://www.usatoday.com/printedition/life/20050907/d_topstrip07.art.htm

THE BIGOTRY OF LOW EXPECTATIONS
[Commentary] All along Hurricane Katrina's Evacuation Belt, in cities from=
=20
Houston to Baton Rouge to Leesville, Louisiana, the exact same rumors are=
=20
spreading faster than red ants at a picnic. The refugees from the United=20
States' worst-ever natural disaster, it is repeatedly said, are bringing=20
with them the worst of New Orleans' now-notorious lawlessness: looting,=20
armed carjacking, and even the rape of children. "By Thursday," the Chicago=
=20
Tribune's Howard Witt reported, "local TV and radio stations in Baton=20
Rouge...were breezily passing along reports of cars being hijacked at=20
gunpoint by New Orleans refugees, riots breaking out in the shelters set up=
=20
in Baton Rouge to house the displaced, and guns and knives being seized."=
=20
The only problem--none of the reports were true. As Katrina wiped out New=
=20
Orleans' communications infrastructure, and while key federal officials=20
repeatedly expressed less knowledge than cable television reporters,=20
panicky rumors quickly rushed in to fill the void. Many of them have shared=
=20
the exact same theme -- unspeakable urban ultra-violence, perpetuated by=20
the overwhelmingly black population.
[SOURCE: AlterNet, AUTHOR: Matt Welch, Reason]
http://www.alternet.org/story/25116/

THE UNASKED QUESTION
Early in the week, discussions began online about the way much of the TV=20
coverage of Katrina's impact was ignoring obvious questions of race and=20
class. On Wednesday, Slate media critic Jack Shafer accused TV news of=20
skirting one of the most visually clear aspects of the story =AD- that blac=
ks=20
in New Orleans were more directly hurt than whites. Mark Jurkowitz, media=
=20
analyst for the Boston Phoenix speaks about the questions left largely=20
unasked and unanswered.
http://www.onthemedia.org/stream/ram.py?file=3Dotm/otm090205a.mp3

HILL TO DEAL WITH KATRINA COMMUNICATIONS
Look for the communications problems of first responders in New Orleans to=
=20
come up even before the DTV hard-date hearings expected in the House and=20
Senate in the next week or two. For its part, the House Commerce Committee=
=20
is planning to delay or reschedule an 11 a.m. hearing on Medicaid Wednesday=
=20
in favor of a Katrina-related hearing where Chairman Joe Barton (R-TX) is=
=20
expected to bring up the issue of emergency communications. A witness list=
=20
has not been finalized, but one source said an FCC speaker has been lined=
=20
up. According to a Senate source, the Homeland Security Committee's hearing=
=20
next week is expected to include a review of public safety communications.=
=20
Senate Commerce Committee Chairman Ted Steven (R-Alaska) is also a member=
=20
of that committee.
[SOURCE: Broadcasting&Cable, AUTHOR: John Eggerton]
http://www.broadcastingcable.com/article/CA6254402?display=3DBreaking+Ne...
referral=3DSUPP
(free access for Benton's Headlines subscribers)

NEW ORLEANS STATIONS IMPROVISE
Broadcast stations of New Orleans have to be creative to get back on the=20
air. One station is moving operations to a sister station in Mobile,=20
Alabama. Another has moved to Jackson, Mississippi. WWL never lost its=20
signal, though it had to abandon its French Quarter studios. The station=20
has been broadcasting from Louisiana State University and an emergency=20
studio at its transmitter site, with the Louisiana Public Broadcasting=20
station carrying the signal. WWL is also simulcasting its coverage online.=
=20
Spanish-language KGLA AM has put out an urgent call for advertisers so that=
=20
it can remain on the air. The station is broadcasting warnings to the=20
Hispanic community, but it has no income. For any good Samaritan=20
advertisers in the area, the station is owned by Crocodile Broadcasting, a=
=20
minority-owned company headed by Ernesto Schweikert=20
(ernesto_s( at )tropical1540.com).
[SOURCE: Broadcasting&Cable, AUTHOR: Allison Romano/John Eggerton]
http://www.broadcastingcable.com/article/CA6254373?display=3DBreaking+Ne...
referral=3DSUPP
New Orleans Radio Needs Advertisers
http://www.broadcastingcable.com/article/CA6254216?display=3DBreaking+Ne...
referral=3DSUPP
(free access for Benton's Headlines subscribers)

VOLUNTEERS AND ASTRODOME RESIDENT FAMILIES BUILD EMERGENCY RADIO STATION
Relief volunteers and Independent Media organizers in Houston, Texas, in=20
collaboration with residents displaced by Hurricane Katrina, have gotten=20
permission from the Federal Communications Commission and the City of=20
Houston, Texas to build a 30 watt radio station to serve the people and=20
families currently living at the Houston Astrodome and adjacent=20
buildings. But a lack of final permission from officials at the Astrodome=
=20
is keeping the station from going on the air. The radio volunteers, led by=
=20
a community media publishing group called Houston Indymedia, are working=20
with volunteer professional engineers and technicians from all over the=20
United States to get this station on the air. The FCC acted on Saturday to=
=20
approve the station, and quickly, the City of Houston gave the project a=20
letter of official support. The Prometheus Radio Project, a not-for-profit=
=20
organization that builds Low Power FM radio stations all around the United=
=20
States, has worked throughout the weekend to facilitate the legal and=20
timely launch of this radio station.
To donate to the Houston project, please call the Prometheus Radio Project=
=20
at 215-727-9620, or visit them online at http://www.prometheusradio.org, or=
=20
visit http://houston.indymedia.org.
[SOURCE: Prometheus Radio Project press release]
http://www.prometheusradio.org/katrina_ten_thousand_radios_release.doc

HELP FOR STORM-AFFECTED BROADCASTERS
The Broadcasters=92 Foundation, which quietly exists to give aid to=20
broadcasters or their families who have fallen on hard times, is looking=20
for ways to help the broadcasters hit hard by Hurricane Katrina. The=20
foundation has an endowment of $1.5 million and has given ~1.6 million in=
=20
aid since 1995. Helping Katrina victims is its biggest effort since the=20
organization was founded in 1942. There could be 100-200 broadcasters who=
=20
were severely impacted by the hurricane.
[SOURCE: Broadcasting&Cable, AUTHOR: P.J. Bednarski]
http://www.broadcastingcable.com/article/CA6254205?display=3DBreaking+Ne...
referral=3DSUPP
(free access for Benton's Headlines subscribers)

HOW PUBCASTERS ARE FARING AFTER KATRINA
Current is offering an online resource on Katrina's impact on public=20
broadcasters, relief offered from the Corporation for Public Broadcasting=
=20
and the response from National Public Radio.
[SOURCE: Current, AUTHOR: Karen Everhart, Jeremy Egner and Mike Janssen]
http://www.current.org/katrina.shtml

KATRINA COSTS CABLE MILLIONS AS BILLING STOPS
Cable operators -- which stopped billing some subscribers affected by=20
Hurricane Katrina -- likely will lose
tens or hundreds of millions of dollars in revenue, plus the cost of=20
restoring operations, analysts said. Cable One
and Cox are among Gulf Coast cable operators that suspended billing in=20
disaster areas, firm officials said Tuesday.
Comcast is issuing credits =93case by case=94 and area by area, a spokesman=
said.
[SOURCE: Communications Daily, AUTHOR: Jonathan Make]
(Not available online)

JOINT STATEMENT FROM FCC COMMISSIONERS
In addition to its other tragic consequences - including tremendous loss of=
=20
life and widespread property damage - Hurricane Katrina severely shook the=
=20
communications network in the Gulf Coast and restoring all these links will=
=20
be as challenging a communication mission as we have ever=20
confronted. Dedicated employees from wireline, wireless, broadcast, cable,=
=20
and satellite companies are working around the clock to restore=20
communications services to millions of customers. We commend the rapid=20
response we have witnessed from all segments of the communications=20
industry. We know that the industry, like those of us at the Commission,=
=20
is sparing no effort in restoring service to the Gulf Coast. The Commission=
=20
has been in continual contact with the industry and has taken prompt=20
action, where necessary, to provide regulatory relief to facilitate=20
restoration efforts. For example, the Commission has created opportunities=
=20
for providers to deploy alternative means of communication in the affected=
=20
region. We have also assisted in performing coordination activities=20
between the industry and federal emergency authorities as appropriate. We=
=20
will continue doing everything within our power to ensure the vitality of=
=20
the nation's communications network. We are confident that all service=20
providers will do the same. Our deepest thanks go out to the thousands of=
=20
communications company employees who, at great sacrifice, have been working=
=20
nonstop for the past week to repair the communications infrastructure that=
=20
is relied upon by the entire nation. And, above all, our thoughts and=20
prayers are with the countless victims of this tragedy and their families.
[SOURCE: Federal Communications Commission]
http://hraunfoss.fcc.gov/edocs_public/attachmatch/DOC-260871A1.doc

TECHNOLOGY: FREE PHONES, BUSES, WEB ASSISTANCE
With power and telephone service down in the hardest-hit areas of the Gulf=
=20
Coast, communications gear for rescue workers is one major need. Tech and=
=20
telecom companies are digging through their warehouses and sending=20
everything from batteries to buses to the area. In addition, SBC=20
Communications set up 1,000 free telephones in the Houston Astrodome, where=
=20
many evacuees are living. Lenovo is donating about 1,800 computers and Dell=
=20
1,000 =97 many to shelters. Intel is helping coordinate wireless data cente=
rs=20
in the Astrodome and plans to buy additional computers. Cingular Wireless=
=20
and T-Mobile were allowing hurricane victims to make free phone calls from=
=20
their retail stores. T-Mobile is also offering its wireless Internet=20
service for free in Louisiana, Alabama and Mississippi.
[SOURCE: USAToday, AUTHOR: Michelle Kessler]
http://www.usatoday.com/printedition/money/20050907/tech07.art.htm

THE WEB AND HURRICANE KATRINA
* Blogs Provide Storm Evacuees With Neighborhood-Specific News
As the world's news media show the big picture of the devastation left by=
=20
Hurricane Katrina, some Web sites are finding ways to provide specific=20
information to those hungry for details about their homes and local landmar=
ks.
[SOURCE: Washington Post, AUTHOR: Yuki Noguchi]
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2005/09/06/AR200509...
1995.html
(requires registration)
* Internet helps reunite survivors
http://www.usatoday.com/printedition/news/20050907/a_missing07.art.htm
* Internet is bulletin board for Katrina victims
http://today.reuters.com/news/newsArticle.aspx?type=3DinternetNews&storyID=
=3D2005-09-04T200203Z_01_BAU472051_RTRIDST_0_NET-INTERNET-DC.XML
* Nearly 100,000 seek family on Katrina site-Red Cross
http://today.reuters.com/news/newsArticle.aspx?type=3DinternetNews&storyID=
=3D2005-09-06T135302Z_01_MCC649531_RTRIDST_0_NET-FAMILIES-DC.XML
* Katrina children seeking parents shown on Web site
http://today.reuters.com/news/newsArticle.aspx?type=3DinternetNews&storyID=
=3D2005-09-06T143717Z_01_ROB600012_RTRIDST_0_NET-CHILDREN-DC.XML

TELEVISION

HURRICANE UNEARTHS FEUD BETWEEN BROADCASTERS, CABLE
Broadcasters and cable industry lobbyists announced multimillion-dollar=20
efforts to help victims of Hurricane Katrina -- and then argued about how=
=20
the disaster's lessons should affect a key policy issue dividing the=20
industries. NAB had planned the lobbying blitz before the onslaught of=20
Katrina -- but, in its discussions with lawmakers, broadcasters planned to=
=20
use the hurricane as evidence of the importance of multicasting, NAB=20
spokesman Dennis Wharton said. Wharton said Cox Communications, the cable=
=20
operator in New Orleans, failed to carry NBC's Weather Plus, a free=20
multicast channel aired on the digital spectrum of NBC affiliates. Cable=20
operators must air only the primary signal, and the FCC has twice rejected=
=20
NAB's efforts for mandatory "multicast must-carry." Said Wharton, "This=20
demonstrates that in New Orleans, there can be real value to having a=20
24-hour weather channel." "To suggest that the other broadcasters that were=
=20
carried by cable, or any of the national cable networks, were not providing=
=20
more-than-adequate, 24-hour consistent coverage of this hurricane is=20
completely ridiculous," countered NCTA spokesman Brian Dietz.
[SOURCE: Technology Daily, AUTHOR: Drew Clark]
http://www.njtelecomupdate.com/lenya/telco/live/tb-VSHI1126039336581.html

NCTA: MULTICASTING COULD COST BILLIONS
Forcing multicast must-carry on cable operators could cost the federal=20
government billions of dollars if courts found that the carriage obligation=
=20
was an unconstitutional seizure of private property, the National Cable &=
=20
Telecommunications Association said in a letter Tuesday to Congress. The=20
NCTA is hoping that Congress will pass legislation this fall that ends the=
=20
transition to digital broadcasting without expanding cable=92s carriage=20
obligations. Meanwhile, broadcasters have made multicast must-carry a=20
legislative priority.
[SOURCE: Multichannel News, AUTHOR: Ted Hearn]
http://www.multichannel.com/article/CA6254374.html?display=3DBreaking+News
(requires subscription)
See NCTA's letter to Congress:=20
http://www.ncta.com/press/press.cfm?PRid=3D623&showArticles=3Dok

STEVENS STALLS DTV UNTIL RELIEF PACKAGE IN PLACE
Senate Commerce Committee Chairman Ted Stevens (R-Alaska) has put digital=
=20
television transition legislation on hold until the Senate acts on a=20
Hurricane Katrina relief package. The committee will be eyeing a =93whole=
=20
series=94 of steps, including =93how we can buoy up communications in disas=
ters=20
of this size,=94 Sen Stevens said. Leaders in the Senate will meet today to=
=20
discuss what a possible relief package will look like. The Commerce=20
Committee has jurisdiction over such issues as communications, global=20
warming, energy prices and economic matters. Meanwhile, the House Commerce=
=20
Committee said it has no intention of slowing digital TV legislation. That=
=20
committee will begin discussing the impact of Katrina today with testimony=
=20
expected from the Federal Communications Commission and BellSouth. Congress=
=20
is unlikely to meet the Sept. 16 reconciliation deadline, leading many to=
=20
predict an extension of that deadline.
[SOURCE: Communications Daily, AUTHOR: Anne Veigle]
(Not available online)

DIGITAL TELEVISION TRANSITION: ISSUES RELATED TO AN INFORMATION CAMPAIGN=20
REGARDING THE TRANSITION
The Government Accountability Office spoke with television industry=20
executives government officials, telecommunications experts, and=20
representatives from industry trade and consumer groups about the=20
transition to digital television. In a report released Tuesday, GAO=20
provides 1) stakeholder views on Americans=92 knowledge of the DTV=20
transition, 2) stakeholder views on how government and industry might most=
=20
effectively communicate critical DTV information, and 3) information on=20
efforts by Germany and the United Kingdom to inform their citizens about=20
the DTV transitions taking place in those countries. Many stakeholders=20
believe that Americans do not fully understand the digital TV transition=20
and see advertising as the best way to rectify this situation. (GAO-05-940R)
[SOURCE: Government Accountability Office]
http://www.gao.gov/cgi-bin/getrpt?GAO-05-940R

ACCOUNTING FOR TASTE
Remember the V-chip? It=92s an electronic circuit that can be used to filte=
r=20
out shows you deem offensive. Recently a group of media companies banded=
=20
together to better publicize the device, which seems awfully altruistic.=20
After all, why would CBS want to help us block out CSI? The answer: they=
=20
hope to show that parents are better arbiters of taste than Uncle Sam, who=
=20
appears to be gearing up to clamp down on decency standards. Salon=92s=20
Michael Scherer says that FCC Chairman Kevin Martin is among those leading=
=20
the charge.
http://www.onthemedia.org/stream/ram.py?file=3Dotm/otm090205c.mp3

WHAT DOES FALL HOLD FOR TV NEWS?
As television network news divisions went into overdrive last week to cover=
=20
the unrelenting aftermath of Hurricane Katrina, scrambling to provide daily=
=20
necessities to their crews on the ground and assemble special reports that=
=20
lifted news ratings at all three networks, behind-the-scenes broadcasters=
=20
were contending with another challenging reality: Their news operations=20
face potentially drastic changes this fall, and no one is sure of the=20
direction things will take. It's a time of soul-searching and open=20
questions about the future at all three networks -- even top-ranked NBC,=20
where News president Neal Shapiro, who began negotiating his departure last=
=20
spring, is stepping down from his post.
[SOURCE: Los Angeles Times, AUTHOR: Matea Gold]
http://www.calendarlive.com/tv/cl-et-anchors5sep05,0,6352077.story

OWNERSHIP

FCC: WINTER OF DISCONNECT
The Federal Communications Commission's four-year campaign to deregulate=20
the media industry has frozen to a halt, trapped in the pack-ice of=20
politics and negative publicity. That has left industry players once=20
hopeful of a major climate change on the issue to hunker down until the=20
impasse over media mergers is broken. Telecommunications regulators have=20
been struggling to revise federal broadcast ownership rules since 2001,=20
when the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit struck=
=20
down revisions issued by the FCC two years earlier for not going far enough=
=20
in revamping the Telecommunications Act of 1996. The agency's job got even=
=20
murkier when another appeals court in Philadelphia last summer struck down=
=20
the subsequent regulatory rewrite for going too far. For now, broadcasters=
=20
remain barred in all but the biggest markets from operating two-station=20
"duopolies." They also are forbidden from buying a TV station in cities and=
=20
towns where they already own a daily newspaper. Proponents of consolidation=
=20
say existing restrictions on media mergers are inhibiting investment and=20
growth in the industry. These critics favor allowing a large round of=20
consolidation, leaving a half-dozen or so large companies. With capital to=
=20
spend on emerging technologies and programming, these media giants could=20
roll out new services, such as "datacasting" to PDAs and high-definition=20
TV, and broaden their revenues. Although FCC Chairman Kevin Martin has=20
pledged to jump-start the media ownership rewrite, Democratic commissioners=
=20
Copps and Jonathan Adelstein have pressured him to conduct a lengthy round=
=20
of public hearings on the issue around the U.S. and to commission a series=
=20
of in-depth economic studies on the impact of consolidation on programming=
=20
diversity, independent station owners and other topics.
[SOURCE: TheDeal.com, AUTHOR: Bill McConnell]
http://www.thedeal.com/NASApp/cs/ContentServer?pagename=3DTheDeal/TDDArt...
e/TDStandardArticle&bn=3Dnewsby%2FMEDIAPUBLISHING.gif&c=3DTDDArticle&cid=3D=
1125016629280

CONSOLIDATION/SMUT CONNECTION ASSERTED
The Center for Creative Voices in Media's Executive Director Jonathan=20
Rintels and FCC Commissioner Michael Copps are getting together Sept. 8 at=
=20
the Press Club in Washington to unveil a report the center says "offers=20
compelling evidence of a link between media consolidation and indecency."
[SOURCE: Broadcasting&Cable, AUTHOR: John Eggerton]
http://www.broadcastingcable.com/article/CA6254379?display=3DBreaking+Ne...
referral=3DSUPP
(free access for Benton's Headlines subscribers)
* PTC Crows Hilton Ads Were a Bust
http://www.broadcastingcable.com/article/CA6254188?display=3DBreaking+Ne...
referral=3DSUPP
(free access for Benton's Headlines subscribers)

THE WALL STREET JOURNAL AT SEA
The great chronicler and champion of capitalism has become a poor example=
=20
of it. No major media company has suffered a string of bad luck and=20
management missteps that quite compares to the recent bum run of Dow Jones,=
=20
the company that owns the Journal. Over the past five years, its stock has=
=20
plummeted 45 percent=97trailing the New York Times Company and the S&P=20
average by 25 percentage points. Where it once aspired to conquer the=20
global market, this spring it shrunk its European and Asian editions into=
=20
tabloids, a step many consider a prelude to their euthanizing. The domestic=
=20
situation is less grim, but only a bit. With ads scarce, it often publishes=
=20
waiflike editions of the Journal. In five years, there have been four heads=
=20
of ad sales. a substantial offer could spur a sale. For all its troubles,=
=20
the Journal remains quite a prize, and there are many potential suitors who=
=20
could fire up a bidding war. Michael Bloomberg has salivated over Dow Jones=
=20
in the past, although his company likely won't make a major move as long as=
=20
he=92s ruling in absentia. Arthur Sulzberger Jr. doesn't have such=20
restraints. Two years ago, The New Yorker reported that he sent the=20
Bancrofts a letter, via Hammer, announcing the New York Times Company=92s=
=20
interest in a deal. Hammer and Kann rebuffed Sulzberger without even asking=
=20
the Bancrofts first. But nobody really quibbled with the logic of the=20
rejection. =93The Bancrofts worry that the Wall Street Journal and the Time=
s=20
are natural competitors,=94 says a source close to the family. They would=
=20
never abide the two Gray Ladies shacking up together, because they can't=20
see the Journal receiving the attention it deserves within the Times=20
company. Don Graham and the Washington Post are far more natural buyers.=20
But the most obvious buyer might be Rupert Murdoch.
[SOURCE: New York Magazine, AUTHOR: Franklin Foer]
http://newyorkmetro.com/nymetro/news/media/features/12899/
(long article)

MURDOCH CALLS NEW WEB SUMMIT
Rupert Murdoch has summoned his most senior executives for the second=20
summit in seven months on News Corporation's Internet strategy. The=20
broadcasting and publishing group=92s executive committee will gather this=
=20
weekend. The summit comes as Mr Murdoch received an important show of=20
support on Tuesday from Prince Alwaleed bin Talal=92s Kingdom Holding=20
Company. The Saudi prince, a long-time shareholder, converted his=20
non-voting shares in News Corp to a 5.46 per cent stake of the voting=20
shares and said he might buy more =93if the situation warrants.=94 Since th=
e=20
first gathering in February, Mr Murdoch has spent $580m on buying Intermix,=
=20
which operates social networking site My-Space.com, and bought Scout Media,=
=20
a sports website company. He is reported to have held talks to buy Blinkx,=
=20
a video search engine.
[SOURCE: Financial Times, AUTHOR: Andrew Edgecliffe-Johnson]
http://news.ft.com/cms/s/d21bd7d0-1efb-11da-94d5-00000e2511c8.html
(requires subscription)

MAGAZINES: THE GLOBAL CARVEOUT
Magazine publishing mergers and acquisitions may reduce the number of=20
global players. Hachette, Hearst and Time are expected to be among the=20
survivors. VNU is "almost certain" to sell off its U.S. business media=20
unit, which publishes Billboard, Adweek and Hollywood Reporter. "The=20
question everyone's asking is how do you grow in a saturated market," says=
=20
Mark Edmiston, a managing director at investment bank boutique AdMedia=20
Partners, of what's driving global consolidation. "The answer is you=20
can't." It's not lost on Edmiston that, with few exceptions, U.S.=20
publishers are the last of their brethren to address this question. And=20
that they're getting to it now stems not from global unity but economic=20
necessity: The enviable growth that defined our domestic publishing market=
=20
for decades is, simply, no more.
[SOURCE: TheDeal.com, AUTHOR: Richard Morgan]
http://www.thedeal.com/NASApp/cs/ContentServer?pagename=3DTheDeal/TDDArt...
e/TDStandardArticle&bn=3Dnewsby%2FMEDIAPUBLISHING.gif&c=3DTDDArticle&cid=3D=
1125016628798

QUICKLY

CHIEF JUSTICE NOMINEE CARRIERS SLIM RECORD ON TECH
On Monday, Sept. 12, John Roberts will begin facing questions from the=20
Senate Judiciary Committee in hearings widely expected to result in his=20
confirmation as Chief Justice. The Electronic Frontier Foundation has=20
suggested that Roberts may be prone to yielding authority to federal=20
agencies in questions of technology. The organization has expressed hope=20
that he would act cautiously before expanding regulatory power. In a 2003=
=20
case, Roberts wrote an opinion for the court that upheld a Federal=20
Communications Commission order setting a deadline by which all televisions=
=20
with a display size of 13 inches or greater and certain other VCRs and DVD=
=20
players had to possess a tuner capable of receiving digital TV signals.=20
Roberts also participated on a three-judge panel in 2003 that ultimately=20
decided a noteworthy spat between Verizon Internet Services and the=20
Recording Industry Association of America. The court ruled that the=20
recording industry couldn't continue its practice of subpoenaing Internet=
=20
service providers like Verizon for the names of alleged illegal file=20
swappers without first obtaining a judge's consent.
[SOURCE: C-Net|News.com, AUTHOR: Anne Broache]
http://news.com.com/Chief+justice+nominee+carries+slim+record+on+tech/21...
1028_3-5851480.html?tag=3Dnefd.top

NEWS JUNKIES FIND WIKIPEDIA MORE THAN ENCYCLOPEDIA
The Wikipedia, which has surged this year to become the most popular=20
reference site on the Web, is fast overtaking several major news sites as=
=20
the place where people swarm for context on breaking events. Traffic to the=
=20
multilingual network of sites has grown 154 percent over the past year,=20
according to research firm Hitwise. At current growth rates, it is set to=
=20
overtake The New York Times on the Web, the Drudge Report and other news=20
sites. But the rising status of the site as the Web's intellectual=20
demilitarized zone, the favored place people look for background on an=20
issue or to settle a polemical dispute, also poses challenges for the=20
volunteer ethic that gave it rise.
[SOURCE: Reuters, AUTHOR: Eric Auchard]
http://today.reuters.com/news/newsArticle.aspx?type=3DtechnologyNews&sto...
D=3D2005-09-06T211135Z_01_ROB676217_RTRIDST_0_TECH-BIZFEATURE-WIKIPEDIA-DC.=
XML

NEWS YOU CAN LOSE
Things to hate about cable TV news: 1) musical emotional cues, 2) undated=
=20
video footage, 3) conspicuous lack of maps illustrating where the camera=20
and reporters are when reporting, 4) the fundamental dishonesty of 24/7=20
coverage, 5) the opportunism of Fox News Channel's Geraldo Rivera, 6) the=
=20
absence of context and continuity, 7) the lack of input from knowledgeable=
=20
outsiders, and 8) the absence of self-criticism.
[SOURCE: Slate, AUTHOR: Jack Shafer]
http://www.slate.com/id/2125683/

COURT CASES DON'T SCARE MUSIC FILE SWAPPERS AWAY
Despite two huge court losses for file-sharing firms, unauthorized online=
=20
song and movie swapping is at an all-time peak.
[SOURCE: USAToday, AUTHOR: Jefferson Graham]
http://www.usatoday.com/printedition/money/20050907/filesharing07.art.htm

DOT TRIPLE X
What's in a name? For the Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and=20
Numbers (ICANN), domain names are the way to organize a chaotic global=20
Internet. But when ICANN proposed a .XXX domain for adult-content, it=20
sparked a political fight. Those debating the new .XXX suffix are an uneasy=
=20
alliance of pornographers, the Christian right, conservative countries and=
=20
the U.S. government. Brooke speaks to Bret Fausett, a lawyer and advisor to=
=20
ICANN, about how names can hurt you.
http://www.onthemedia.org/stream/ram.py?file=3Dotm/otm090205d.mp3

DVR PENETRATION SLOWS
Digital video recorder (DVR) penetration has slowed, and new data from the=
=20
biggest suppliers suggests that future growth may not accelerate as=20
anticipated. DVRs have made network executives weak in the knees, given=20
their easy-to-use ad-skipping functionality. Originally the product of=20
pioneers like TiVo (which added just 40,000 subscribers in second quarter),=
=20
increasingly major cable and satellite providers have been offering their=
=20
customers DVR subscriptions. Yet unlike the adoption of previous hot=20
entertainment technologies which saw popularity explosions, like the Web or=
=20
DVDs, Magna Global predicts that in most markets, DVRs adoption will surge=
=20
at first and then lose considerable steam. One reason that adoption has=20
been less than spectacular, says Magna, is that DVRs are simply difficult=
=20
to market -- either because consumers don't 'get' DVRs or just don't seen=
=20
the technology as being compelling. Magna also contends that vendors'=20
strategy to charge a premium for DVR service limits its potential.
[SOURCE: MediaWeek, AUTHOR: Mike Shields]
http://www.mediaweek.com/mw/news/recent_display.jsp?vnu_content_id=3D100...
5227

DIGITAL GAMERS REDUCE TV VIEWING FURTHER
During the last year, America's hard-core game players have shifted four=20
more hours of their weekly TV-watching time to online activities, according=
=20
to a new survey by Ziff David Media Game Group. The study, "Digital Gaming=
=20
in America," also reports that the number of hard-core game-playing=20
households increased by 900,000 from 18.9 million to 19.8 million over the=
=20
same year's time.
[SOURCE: AgAge, AUTHOR: Kris Oser]
http://adage.com/news.cms?newsId=3D45987
--------------------------------------------------------------
Communications-related Headlines is a free online news summary service=20
provided by the Benton Foundation (www.benton.org). Posted Monday through=
=20
Friday, this service provides updates on important industry developments,=
=20
policy issues, and other related news events. While the summaries are=20
factually accurate, their often informal tone does not always represent the=
=20
tone of the original articles. Headlines are compiled by Kevin Taglang=20
(headlines( at )benton.org) -- we welcome your comments.
--------------------------------------------------------------