July 2009

Logarithmic Bandwidth Goals For America's National Broadband Strategy

What should the nation's bandwidth goals be? Some say something as low as 25 Mbps is realistic. Others aspire to 1 or 100 Gpbs -- the speeds being deployed today on our nation's fastest research networks. Daily believes we should be trying to achieve 100Mbps by 2015. To use most of today's Internet you need at least 1Mbps. To use all of today's Internet you need 10Mbps, including watching "HD" video on sites like Hulu.com, which requires 7Mbps. And to be able to fully participate in the Internet of just a few years from now, where interactive HD video applications are everywhere, households will need at least 100Mbps. Then looking out further ahead, speeds of 1Gbps, 10Gbps, and 100Gbps line up perfectly with where discussions about future bandwidth goals should be set. So all that seems to be left is to associate this logarithmic growth in broadband capacity with the years we should set as goals for their widespread availability in the US. For 1Mbps, we really need to get that everywhere ASAP. In fact, if we really had our act together, I'd argue that having 1Mbps be universally available should have been a goal set for 2006 or even earlier. For 10Mbps, I'd like to be aggressive and say 2010 but some may see that as being unrealistic given that wireless technologies aren't yet delivering those speeds in the US. If that's the case then we should look at having this benchmark be set for 2011 or 2012 as an intermediary step. For 100Mbps, I didn't pull the 2015 goal out of my hat as striving to become a 100Mbps Nation by then has already been proposed by Sen. Rockefeller.

Boston, "a copper hole in the fiber donut," demands FiOS

Verizon is currently wiring up New York City with fiber optic cables, but Boston mayor Thomas Menino wants to know why FiOS isn't coming to his city anytime soon. Menino has a theory, one that he recently aired during a radio interview: Verizon is retaliating. "They insinuated that we weren't going to get it because of my position on telecommunications," he said. Menino's "position on telecommunications" is that Verizon should pay more money. Specifically, Menino has been trying to change state law so that Verizon has to pay taxes on more of its network equipment that sits on public property. Verizon's FiOS has already been installed in numerous surrounding cities, leaving Boston a "copper hole in the fiber donut," said Boston's Chief Information Officer, William Oates. But despite their density, cities can be expensive to wire. Infrastructure can be hard to access, landlords are finicky about connecting to their buildings, and digging up the streets is tough, dirty work. Verizon is currently bringing FiOS to places like New York City and Washington, DC, but years after the FiOS rollout, neither place is near completion.

Warner Says Virginia's Broadband Maps Put State 'Ahead of the Curve'

Speaking at the Virginia Summit on Broadband Access at the Piedmont Virginia Community College, Sen Mark Warner (D-VA) touted the state's preparation for stimulus funding, through public-private partnerships and fiber builds in rural regions of Virginia, and through its advanced work in broadband mapping. He said the mapping "gives communities a guide to know where there is or is not service available. It's helpful, whether you're applying to the RUS [Rural Utilities Service] or the NTIA [National Telecommunications and Information Administration]." Such activities have put Virginia "ahead of the curve" and "in a good position to take advantage of" broadband stimulus funds.

Larry Strickling Says Now is a 'New Era' for Public Broadband Data from Carriers

Speaking at the Virginia Summit on Broadband Access at the Piedmont Virginia Community College, Larry Strickling, the top official at the National Telecommunications and Information Administration, said that now is "a new era" for broadband data, including public data about carriers that provide high-speed Internet service. He said that he hoped and expected that carriers will allow information about the areas in which they serve to be made publicly available, as they do in Canada. Strickling also said that broadband incumbents that seek to challenge broadband applicants who argue that their areas are "underserved" will have to make such information public - and in the same format as the broadband data collection efforts underway nationwide. "We need the data: I think it is a national imperative in which this data be collected," said Strickling, responding to a question about whether carriers will in fact provide states with the information necessary to create state-level broadband maps.

NCTA Emphasizing Adoption, Training Aspect of Broadband Rollout

The National Cable & Telecommunications Association continues to emphasize the adoption and training side of the broadband rollout. NCTA sent a letter last week in support of the Community College Technology Access Act of 2009, pledging to work for its passage. The bill was introduced in April, but its theme dovetails with NCTA's current push for more broadband training and adoption efforts as part of its grand broadband plan. The bill would provide government funding -- $625 million over the next five years -- to open community colleges to members of the public who want to improve their computer skills.

Broadband stimulus 'underserved' rule becomes more flexible

The federal government's definition of "underserved areas" for purposes of awarding broadband stimulus funds has caused consternation among some applicants - in particular municipal leaders who feel it excludes them from the program. further clarification of these rules may ease some applicants' minds as they prove more flexible than previously thought. The feds have defined "underserved areas" as areas in which: a) at least half of all households lack broadband or b) fewer than 40% of households subscribe to broadband or c) no service provider advertises broadband transmission speeds of at least 3 Mb/s. But that's actually the definition of "underserved." It's up to applicants to define the term "area." Say an applicant wants to bring broadband to three given census blocks - two qualify as underserved, but one doesn't. If, when grouped together into one proposed service "area," they do qualify as "underserved," then a census block that would have been disqualified by itself becomes fair game.

Broadband - so what? Here's what

[Commentary] While President Barack Obama and Congress have made clear how important broadband is to our nation by putting $7.2 billion in stimulus funding behind broadband initiatives, there still seems to be a perception gap among many non-adopter citizens. In short, there is a lack of understanding of the value broadband connectivity can bring to their lives. If the perception is that high-speed access is about iTunes and iPods, then public education should become part of public policy as it relates to stimulus funding on broadband networks. It's critical to get everyone in the U.S. connected to high-speed Internet as soon as possible. When citizens aren't online, our nation's resources - our entrepreneurial spirit and innovative minds - are not being leveraged. It's time now to connect the dots on the demonstrated payoffs, so that Americans clearly know what opportunities are in store as a result of broadband adoption. So what? It's our future.

AT&T's 4chan Block Raises Issue of Network Neutrality

It appears some of AT&T's broadband customers across the United States were intentionally blocked from accessing the infamous forum 4chan over the weekend. The message board's founder Christopher "Moot" Poole encouraged 4chan users to contact AT&T to complain. The 4chan black out lasted for about 12 hours. AT&T claims it did so because of a denial of service attack originating from IP addresses connected to a 4chan server. unWired, also had to temporarily block 4chan because of what unWired described to Broadband Reports as "relentless ACK scan reports." Even if it turns out the ISPs' decisions were legitimate, the appearance of censorship raises the contentious issue of network neutrality -- the belief that ISPs should not be allowed to block or slow down traffic to any Website.

CDT Privacy Recommendations for the Google Book Search Settlement

A report analyzing the privacy risks associated with the proposed expansion of Google Book Search. The report urges Google to commit to a strong privacy regime for the new service in advance of the settlement fairness hearing this fall. The tentative settlement between Google and publishers, the result of a copyright infringement lawsuit, would dramatically alter the way the public obtains and interacts with books. The report asks the court to approve the settlement but to retain oversight in order to monitor implementation of a privacy plan.

Advocacy groups, individuals get into the government data game

When the Office of Management and Budget announced last spring that it would set up a repository of government data feeds, called Data.gov, a number of other sites appeared aiming to duplicate or even improve on the work that the General Services Administration was doing to create the service. Such duplication of effort might not be a bad thing. Federal Chief Information Officer Vivek Kundra has said that by making agency data available, the government could enlist the public in helping to solve our country's most pressing problems.