FCC admits CableCARD a failure, vows to try something else
The Federal Communications Commission admits that its CableCARD mandate has been an abysmal failure. That doesn't mean it's giving up the fight to encourage set-box innovation; instead, the FCC wants ideas for a new set of rules that will bust open access to video streams from cable and IPTV operators. Call it "Son of CableCARD"... and rest assured, the cable industry ain't gonna like it. If you're curious how an agency like the FCC says something like "total failure," take a look at yesterday's innocuously titled document, "Comment sought on video device innovation." Buried inside that document are these lines: "The Commission's CableCARD rules have resulted in limited success in developing a retail market for navigation devices. Certification for plug-and-play devices is costly and complex." "Limited success" is a bureaucratic euphemism for abject failure, as the FCC made clear during its own November open meeting. During that event, as part of its discussion about the National Broadband Plan, it noted that set-top box innovation had stagnated.