Outcome document arrives before the doors open for the NetMundial conference

[Commentary] Wikileaks has posted a draft outcome document created by the Executive Stakeholder Committee of the NetMundial Internet Governance conference to be held in Brazil April 23 – 24.

Before the first multi-stakeholder invited to attend had taken a seat, the organizer had already decided what principles they were going to agree to and a road map for implementation. The main challenge of the document is this: while the principles may seem reasonable, even laudable, the roadmap for implementation has many challenges and potential hidden agendas. The Internet as a “Human Right”, access to information, free flow of data, freedom of association, expression, privacy, accessibility, etc., all sounds like principles we want to embrace.

And a governance process encouraged to be “open, participatory, multi-stakeholder, technology-neutral, sensitive to human rights and based on principles of transparency, accountability and inclusiveness”, sounds like a good idea we should be able to support. But now I’m wondering who will have the capacity to implement all this pro-free rhetoric?

Most likely, that job would fall to governments around the world. It would be up to them to let us know when we have hit our Internet Governance metric. Many of the items in the leaked outcome document are good aspirational goals. It’s deciding on the path to achieve them that will be the major challenge for the multi-stakeholders engaged in this process. Continuing to seek balance between governments, industry partners, content providers, and the end user will be an ongoing challenge.

[Tews is the Chief Policy Officer at 463 Communications]